News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Constitutional Convention is closer than you think (2019) by prepend on Sunday November 28, 2021 @08:39PM (#29375314)
I would not trust the present day to create a viable constitution. It would likely be dominated by whatever party is in charge to perpetuate their specific platform rather than to establish principle based rules.

The original constitution is really kind of amazing at how well it’s functioned. It has flaws, obviously, but seems really effective.

Re:A Constitutional Convention is closer than you think (2019) by rootusrootus on Sunday November 28, 2021 @09:03PM (#29375478)
On the other hand, modern countries who once used the US Constitution as a starting point for their own version no longer do, because ours is stuck two centuries back and there is no reason to believe we have the ability to change that.
Re:A Constitutional Convention is closer than you think (2019) by zamadatix on Sunday November 28, 2021 @09:44PM (#29375755)
1865-1965 saw more than 1 amendment per decade which was a pretty good clip IMO, churning enough that the 21st was to repeal the 18th for example. It has only really been the last 50 years it slowed down with the long proposed and relatively minor 27th amendment catching a second wind of state approvals. Not the longest dry spell either, the early 1800s also had a 50ish year void.
Re:A Constitutional Convention is closer than you think (2019) by dragonwriter on Monday November 29, 2021 @11:11AM (#29381481)
> 1865-1965 saw more than 1 amendment per decade

No, it didn't. It averaged more than one per decade, which isn't the same thing.

In that period you had the post-Civil War Amendments (3, between 1865 and 1870), more than 40 years with nothing, another burst from 1913-1920 (3 amendments), a burst in 1933 (2 amendments), one by itself in 1951, and then a flurry overlapping the end of the period from 1961-1971 (4 amendments, 2 each before and after your 1965 cutoff).

And, just to be complete, after that you’ve got one solitary amendment in 1992 (the last of the 11 that have passed of the 12 proposed together as the Bill of Rights) and nothing since.

> Not the longest dry spell either, the early 1800s also had a 50ish year void.

61 from the 12th Amendment, the last of the fairly immediate post-Constitution ones, in 1804 to the 13th, the first of the post-Civil War ones, in 1865.

Re:A Constitutional Convention is closer than you think (2019) by zamadatix on Monday November 29, 2021 @01:43PM (#29383488)
Yes meant to say averaged more than, good catch.

1865 to 1965 was just to show a 100 year period were activity stayed hot to not say there weren't amendments before or after. In regards to the 2 after '65 cutoff they are still older than the 50 year claim (the 26th as of this year) so I didn't feel the need to mention them, only noting the 27th which as you mentioned passed in '92.

If one is interested in an exact list of amendment ratification dates rather than a summary that it has been slow for the last 50 but quite busy since it was made https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_amendments_to_the_Unit... is probably a more apt resource.

Re:A Constitutional Convention is closer than you think (2019) by dragonwriter on Monday November 29, 2021 @03:57PM (#29385192)
> 1865 to 1965 was just to show a 100 year period were activity stayed hot

But it wasn't a 100 year period where activity stayed hot. It was a 106 year period (stretching to 1971) starting with a 5 year period where activity was hot, followed by a 43 year period of complete inactivity, and them some brief periods of sporadic activity, ending with a the single most active decade since the 1790s.

A 100 year period where activity stayed hot is a complete misrepresentation.

Re:A Constitutional Convention is closer than you think (2019) by readflaggedcomm on Sunday November 28, 2021 @11:39PM (#29376432)
That sounds like a feature rather than a bug.
Re:A Constitutional Convention is closer than you think (2019) by rootusrootus on Monday November 29, 2021 @10:45AM (#29381124)
Certainly there are different perspectives. I think many people don't trust that we have the ability to change the Constitution to suit modern American culture without ruining it. But it's also arguable that we could do much to clarify modern interpretation of principles that aren't as obvious given the dramatic shift in technology between 1789 and today.
Re:A Constitutional Convention is closer than you think (2019) by vzcx on Sunday November 28, 2021 @09:27PM (#29375645)
I'll take a crack at it. How about a two-person consularship with a red consul and a blue consul? Together they wield full executive control, but nothing happens unless both agree on a particular action. Would you ratify?
Re:A Constitutional Convention is closer than you think (2019) by erect_mom on Sunday November 28, 2021 @09:59PM (#29375853)
Why do you guys keep dreaming up there bizarre forms of government when the parliamentary system exists and works well enough…
Re:A Constitutional Convention is closer than you think (2019) by davemp on Sunday November 28, 2021 @10:26PM (#29376035)
What happens when one person dies suddenly?
Re:A Constitutional Convention is closer than you think (2019) by unclenoriega on Sunday November 28, 2021 @10:40PM (#29376113)
The appropriate vice-consul takes over, presumably.
Re:A Constitutional Convention is closer than you think (2019) by markdown on Sunday November 28, 2021 @08:51PM (#29375392)
Those flaws are pretty massive though. Legalising slavery and letting anyone and his dog own guns? That barbaric and doesn't belong in any constitution in 2021.
Re:A Constitutional Convention is closer than you think (2019) by prepend on Sunday November 28, 2021 @10:37PM (#29376100)
Slavery should have been outlawed, but the gun bit isn’t so bad, I think.

But I think, at the time, slavery was still legal in most of the world so while it would have been right to outlaw it, it’s understandable how it was allowed. And the amendments outlawing it actually show how the constitution works as ideas change over time.

If Americans change their opinion on guns then that could change as well. But I don’t think that will happen in 34 states.

Re:A Constitutional Convention is closer than you think (2019) by threatofrain on Sunday November 28, 2021 @10:49PM (#29376164)
> And the amendments outlawing it actually show how the constitution works as ideas change over time.

The amendment to end slavery happened on the backbone of killing several hundred thousand Americans. The compromise between two sides was to shoot people until one side agreed.

Re:A Constitutional Convention is closer than you think (2019) by markdown on Monday November 29, 2021 @01:29AM (#29377013)
> The amendment to end slavery

This didn't happen, and the constitution still explicitly allows slavery.

Re:A Constitutional Convention is closer than you think (2019) by prepend on Monday November 29, 2021 @09:31AM (#29380255)
I think the civil war was independent of the constitution and it would have occurred regardless of whatever the legal structure was.
Re:A Constitutional Convention is closer than you think (2019) by threatofrain on Monday November 29, 2021 @01:29PM (#29383310)
The southern states were required to ratify the 14th Amendment as a condition of having any federal representation, and it nullified a prior Supreme Court ruling on the Constitution. The 15th Amendment was specifically designed to counter anticipation of tactics to dodge the 14th Amendment.

You were just talking about how the 14th Amendment reflects how the Constitution adapts to the changing values of a nation. Yes, after one side shoots the other side into agreement, and after 750,000 lives ended. Then the victor decided the outcome of history.

One can only imagine how the course of the Constitution would have been "independent" to the course of the Civil War if the northern states had lost.

Re:A Constitutional Convention is closer than you think (2019) by prepend on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @06:22AM (#29390990)
What I meant was that slavery was a big divide in the US. This was not caused by the constitution. I think any founding documents would have had the same effect: massive bloodshed to force part of the country to stop slavery.

When I say independent of the constitution, I mean that no matter what legal foundational framework, I think we would have had the civil war to end slavery. Even if we had the magma carta or whatever.

Re:A Constitutional Convention is closer than you think (2019) by markdown on Monday November 29, 2021 @01:25AM (#29376990)
The amendments didn't outlaw slavery, and the US constitution still explicitly allows slavery.
Re:A Constitutional Convention is closer than you think (2019) by prepend on Monday November 29, 2021 @09:33AM (#29380273)
I think they did based on my reading of the 13th amendment “ Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction.”
Re:A Constitutional Convention is closer than you think (2019) by markdown on Monday November 29, 2021 @10:01PM (#29388426)
> except as a punishment

Anyone convicted of a crime in the US can be turned into a slave as punishment, and that happens every day. US prisons are filled with slaves right this minute.

https://www.aljazeera.com/opinions/2017/9/9/slavery-in-the-u...

https://www.npr.org/transcripts/884989263

Re:A Constitutional Convention is closer than you think (2019) by prepend on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @06:26AM (#29391015)
Technically I think you’re correct, but it’s a different form of slavery that isn’t nearly as bad as the slavery that was eliminated by the 13th amendment.

For example, the children of prisoners aren’t owned property to be sold and traded.

Re:A Constitutional Convention is closer than you think (2019) by dragonwriter on Monday November 29, 2021 @11:16AM (#29381559)
> I think they did based on my reading of the 13th amendment

They didn't, and you quote the part that makes that clear:

“except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted”

A whole lot of current social issues can be traced back to things rooted in the way penal slavery, and targeted over-criminalization and policing to supply bodies for penal slavery, immediately replaced chattel slavery with the 13th Amendment.

Re:A Constitutional Convention is closer than you think (2019) by prepend on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @06:25AM (#29391012)
When I mean slavery, I mean chattel slavery.

I don’t think imprisonment is slavery. There are many problems with the US prison system and it needs a lot of work to reform and correct. But at least it’s not chattel slavery.

Equating the two is not very helpful to the discussion because it distracts from a conversation about slavery by equating two different, but slightly similar topics.

Re:A Constitutional Convention is closer than you think (2019) by dragonwriter on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @06:41AM (#29391088)
> I don’t think imprisonment is slavery

Imprisonment is not slavery.

Penal slavery was very much a thing in much of the US for quite a while after the civil war (the federal government has since taken statutory and administrative steps to eliminate it, and may or may not have generally succeeded depending on exactly how you bound the term, but previously penal slavery in the US differed from chattel slavery only in that it had (often extremely corrupt) criminal conviction as an entry gate. And while penal slavery itself has been mitigated and arguably eliminated as a deliberate state practice (rather than an aberrant corruption of individual officials) subsequently (though still Constitutionally permitted) a whole lot of the over-criminalization and police and correctional culture built originally around the institution remains.

Re:A Constitutional Convention is closer than you think (2019) by jdpedrie on Sunday November 28, 2021 @08:57PM (#29375435)
Those two things are in no way comparable.
Re:A Constitutional Convention is closer than you think (2019) by tomrod on Sunday November 28, 2021 @09:19PM (#29375591)
But they are, as both are no longer necessary in a civil, functioning society. Consider Europe, much of Asia, which have been able to achieve democracy, stability, and little need for open carry or slavery.

Now, one has a lot of open supporters (gun rights exceeding the US second amendment, in that the regulated militia component gets left out).

Re:A Constitutional Convention is closer than you think (2019) by harpersealtako on Monday November 29, 2021 @02:34PM (#29384142)
1) A more fair interpretation of the pro-gun argument would be that firearm rights are designed to guarantee long-term stability and democracy. The current stability of a small amount of relatively young democracies in Europe and Asia that do not have gun rights does not debunk the claim that gun rights protect against tyranny over the long term.

2) Considering the EXTREMELY violent, turbulent history of the last 100-150 years of governance (democratic and otherwise) in Europe and Asia, I don't think this is the strong argument you think it is.

Re:A Constitutional Convention is closer than you think (2019) by FpUser on Sunday November 28, 2021 @09:20PM (#29375600)
I am very much against slavery even as a punishment. I think it is a shame that the US allows it in such form.

Guns, I am not so sure. There are numerous benefits to be able to own guns besides protection.

Re:A Constitutional Convention is closer than you think (2019) by fuckcensorship on Sunday November 28, 2021 @09:10PM (#29375532)
> Legalising slavery

The original constitution did not address slavery until the passing of the thirteenth amendment in 1865 which made it illegal except as punishment for a convicted crime.

Re:A Constitutional Convention is closer than you think (2019) by bryanrasmussen on Sunday November 28, 2021 @09:20PM (#29375593)
https://www.britannica.com/topic/three-fifths-compromise

it's true that the word slavery is not used, but if you talk about free people and then note that there are not free people and make political rules for how those non free people should be counted, then in a slave holding society it becomes somewhat obvious who you're talking about.

Re:A Constitutional Convention is closer than you think (2019) by mcny on Sunday November 28, 2021 @09:41PM (#29375739)
» which made it illegal except as punishment for a convicted crime

It is time to revise this in my opinion. Just because I am in prison does not mean you can require me to work. If you can't afford to feed, clothe, house, and provide necessary medical services, release me. The fact that the state of Texas can deny air conditioning to inmates (when the temperature is ought to be enough for the US to require Texas to release all inmates in those conditions. How can states that are arguably in direct violation of basic human rights still have representation in the union is beyond me.

» Refusing to install air conditioning is a matter not just of short-term cost savings, but of appearing tough on crime. State and local governments go to astonishing lengths to avoid installing air conditioning in prisons. In 2016, Louisiana spent over $1 million in legal bills in an attempt to avoid installing air conditioning on death row, an amount four times higher than the actual cost of installing air conditioning, according to an expert witness. Similarly, in 2014, the people of Jefferson Parish, LA only voted to build a new jail after local leaders promised there would be no air conditioning.

https://www.prisonpolicy.org/blog/2019/06/18/air-conditionin...

It isn't just Texas. Prisoners throughout the country are malnourished and starving. It costs way too much to make a phone call so much so that public libraries offer assistance with phone calls.

Democracy should not mean tyranny of the majority. I don't understand how this is controversial. If states and local governments are in violation of the constitution, they should automatically lose representation in the union.

Re:A Constitutional Convention is closer than you think (2019) by dignan on Sunday November 28, 2021 @09:21PM (#29375610)
Article 1, Section 9 specifically prevented slavery from being abolished until 1808. The three-fifths compromise (Article 1, Section 2) also addressed slavery. The word never appears, but there are plenty of euphemistic references.
Re:A Constitutional Convention is closer than you think (2019) by markdown on Monday November 29, 2021 @01:26AM (#29376997)
The result being that in 2021, slavery is still legal in the US. That's beyond abhorrent.