Re:A Constitutional Convention is closer than you think (2019)
by prepend on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @06:22AM
(#29390990)
What I meant was that slavery was a big divide in the US. This was not caused by the constitution. I think any founding documents would have had the same effect: massive bloodshed to force part of the country to stop slavery.
When I say independent of the constitution, I mean that no matter what legal foundational framework, I think we would have had the civil war to end slavery. Even if we had the magma carta or whatever.
You were just talking about how the 14th Amendment reflects how the Constitution adapts to the changing values of a nation. Yes, after one side shoots the other side into agreement, and after 750,000 lives ended. Then the victor decided the outcome of history.
One can only imagine how the course of the Constitution would have been "independent" to the course of the Civil War if the northern states had lost.