Or obviously an ETF, or obviously a mutual fund, or obviously a market maker, or obviously The Fed.
There is literally a 1-1 attempt at mimicking the current financial system under the label "DeFi".
The problem is that the vast majority of the participants don't care about this. They care about 720,687% APY as of this posting on things like this, which anyone should realize is nonsense:
That's $100 to $3 billion in two years.
Good luck with that.
The parent comment is pointing out that this looks like it meets the same definition as those other things and needs to follow the same laws, no matter how much people like it, want it, think it's better than what's it's "replacing"
Your dollar yield will be the token yield minus the change in token price.
Perhaps they should be more transparent about this, because I can end homelessness in the United States right now with $100 based on their reported APY.
The only people who are attracted to this misinformation are amateur investors, and I fear that is the whole point.
But this is my point, it takes an understanding of finance and an understanding of what’s actually happening with these smart contracts. Retail will get slaughtered.
Perhaps the best part of the Green Bay Packers is that the reason they only publicly offer “stock” every 10 years or so, is they have to obtain permission from the NFL and the NFL’s official position is that the NFL must restrict the Packers public offerings because it is a “competitive advantage” over every other team backed by billionaires.
> But Packers stock does give holders the right to vote/elect a certain number of directors to the board.
The toy stock certificates they give out to the fans that buy them have no voting rights whatsoever. Or any kind of rights at all. It's basically just some packers memorabilia.
> Nearly every 10 years they raise funds through a “public offering” of “stock” amounting to hundreds of millions of dollars.
what on earth. they do not raise "hundreds of millions of dollars".
Here is the Packers 2012 Public Offering Document: https://shareholder.broadridge.com/pdf/gbp/offering_document...
see page 7 for the voting rights
> On each matter submitted to a vote of the shareholders of the Corporation, the holders of outstanding shares of Common Stock are entitled to one vote per share. Among other things, shareholders vote annually to elect members of the Corporation’s Board of Directors.
In terms of the amount the public offering document includes the price $250 per stock and the range 250,000-888,000 shares. These offerings historically sell out in minutes. I could pull the most recent SEC no action letter to confirm the amounts sold, but I don’t think it’s necessary at this point.
The public offering document speaks for itself and I quoted it, so what’s overblown about the description? If you think it’s fraudulent launch your complaint with the SEC instead of arguing on HN about it and prove your intellectual superiority.
Your comments could have some credibility if you provided any information or made any point. Unfortunately you're instead saying nothing and just adding noise to an otherwise interesting discussion.
If you work with the SEC on the governance of Green Bay Packers securities, it’s alarming how loose you are with facts. I suspect “work with the SEC” boils down to got coffee for your lawyer while you were in the room, because you’re saying some plainly false things that even Wikipedia, that bastion of truth, quickly proves wrong.
Source: Shareholder.
Every other team is owned through a business organization, but no one refers to those organizations as the owner, they refer to the private individual billionaires (ie no one says the Kraft Group is the owner of the Patriots, they refer to Robert Kraft as the owner. Or Mark Cuban is the owner of the Dallas Mavericks). No one would argue in good faith they are not the owners.
Your personal attacks are sad, FYI I am a lawyer.
The official stock website [2] also says the following about the voting rights.
“Q: How many votes will I receive for purchasing Common Stock?
A: You will have one vote for each share of Common Stock you purchase.”
I’m not sure what those votes actually count for, but they at least exist.
[0]: https://www.packers.com/community/shareholders [1]: https://www.nbc15.com/2021/11/25/packers-stock-sale-nets-mor... [2]: https://packersstock.com/faq
>Common stock does not constitute an investment in “stock” in the common sense of the term. Purchasers should not purchase common stock with the purpose of making a profit.
> You cannot sell, assign or otherwise transfer shares of Common Stock to a third party, except that you may transfer shares to an “immediate family” member by gift or in the event of death. “Immediate family” is defined as the spouse, children, mother, father, brothers, sisters, or any lineal descendent of a shareholder.
> Shareholders don't receive any power in the organization aside from an invitation to an annual shareholder's meeting with voting rights to issues decided at the meeting. The stock also pays no dividends to shareholders.
This thing is like buying a Packers jacket and trying to say you own some of the team...
Ownership is just a bunch of rights. In any case, why not securitize a sports team?
If this DAO did give its members ownership rights, then obviously it would be a security and their raise would be a regulated public offering, unless it met an exemption. That is an idea baked into my original comment, where I simply say “maybe” as to 3 and it is dependent on the rights the DAO conveys.
As to why not securitize a sports team, that would be great and a DAO would be a potential vehicle for that, but a DAO wouldn’t be needed either. From a practical point of view, the reason we don’t see billionaire owners IPOing their team and reaping the financial windfall of an IPO is because the NFL, NBA, MLB don’t allow it. The leagues maintain very tight controls on who may own teams. For example a few years back there was a owner of a major - billion dollar plus - team that made some racially charged statements to the media and the league forced the owner to sell the team. Again the NFL even controls when the Packers can raise funds by issuing stock. Nothing prevents the leagues from changing their policy, but historically the leagues don’t like giving up control.
More recently Wyoming passed a law creating a “DAO LLC” which is pretty novel and allows “algorithmic management” of the LLC. The only entity I am aware of that has used it is CityDAO LLC, you can look them up and review their Articles on the Wyoming Secretary of State website. I’m not overly familiar with them but understand they are experimenting with owning a parcel of land.
Hypothetically say there were a DAO that got sued, without a legal entity it is a very real legal risk all participants of the DAO could be jointly and severally liable (which could include personal liability above beyond the DAO funds). Legally the concept of a DAO LLC is giant, because it creates a legal mechanism to shield participants of a DAO from personal liability.
I have a trademark application from March that has been approved by the USPTO examining attorney and been published (~10 more days left of publication), then I will set up a Wyoming DAO LLC and assign the DAO the trademark (I think it will be the first registered trademark owed by a DAO). It’s very simple, minimal risk of liability (unlike property) and I think will provide a solid legal framework moving forward (almost like an anti-troll mechanism for IP). It’s a real problem in the space, just as an example there have been bad-faith actors filing trademark applications for Doge and Dogecoin, which if left unchecked could lead to all sorts of legal problems.
My takeaway is that what makes DAO LLC unique is that it allows for "algorithmic management".
I'm familiar with LLC management, where there are owners, wondering what advantage the algorithmic aspect adds. I'll go read up on CityDAO. Congrats on the upcoming project)!
Indeed, one with no water or access to water, or anything else.
For good or ill, a common pattern is (1) someone just does it. (2) it attracts regulatory oversight/action/whatnot (3) regulation becomes actually functional.(3.5) the incumbent now has advantage. PayPal, Uber, etc.
What's the alternative? Ban it? Create a framework regulating something that does not exist?
All that said, crypto-ish ownership of a sports team isn't a bad idea.
In the past, this meant that exchanges won't list the token to trade (or delist, with traders panic selling before the delisting events), as any asset notified as being a security requires a broker-dealer to trade it ONLY IF it is registered. But for the past 2 years, centralized exchanges aren't involved in the liquidity. The network has innovated a way to incentivize liquidity with a fundamentally different model of exchange called AMMs (automated market markers, the acronym tells you nothing about why it is different though, but thats the term to look up). AMMs let people pool liquidity onchain and there is practically zero consequence anymore from SEC action - with regard to globally accessible liquidity. And sure, maybe the numerous liquidity providers can be sanctioned but they don't care, it is extremely easy to mix your legitimate funds with Tornado Cash and come out the other side and make a liquidity pool anonymously with mixed funds. It is up the regulator to figure out who to sanction and in this case the mixer's use isn't criminal and the clean funds on the ensuing anonymous side are only a civil issue. Also, even if you want to argue the cat and mouse game favoring the government's omnipotence, liquidity can be burned making that liquidity permanent no matter what happens to the human. I would actually argue a significant bullish thesis is based on how many assets are intentionally burned in liquidity pool bearer shares. Its pretty much perfect right now (with room for improvement in the liquidity pool technology). Between permissionless AMMs and permissionless bridges, and 3 trillion USD already within the crypto ecosystem outside of exchanges, its just not really the same game as it was 3 years ago.
The SEC regulates the intermediaries and now those intermediaries have been disintermediated.
The company bit of the equation has not been disintermediated. In fact, that's the whole point of this transaction: to create a publicly traded company.
> Probably? Why else would they be buying a team for?
Teams are money sinks. The reason to buy a team is political power. To the extend that the state will turn a blind eye or two (see ^2). A totally random example[1], less random examples: Juventus, AC Milan, Olympiacos[^2] and countless others.
Just pointing the obvious, I agree that this transaction should be regulated, all I'm saying is that (3) is not _necessarily real_ in this or other cases.
[^1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joan_Laporta#Political_activit...
[^2]: https://newrepublic.com/article/159252/noor-one-vampire-ship...
And for your Barcelona example, it isn't a good one. It's a fan owned club, the president is elected and isn't an owner and can't really invest in it bar some special cases.
Umm no. I have the expectation of loss but am putting a small amount money to insure myself against the emotional distress of if I missed a big mooning opportunity. The default expectation is that the money is all lost.
So no, it's not a security.
If you invest $100 with the expectation that it will be lost with 99% probability, and that it will become $100,000 with 1% probability, you are expecting a profit of $901.
That is an "expectation of profit" my friend.
No, it would be stupid to "expect" a profit of $901 because there is no scenario in which you would gain $901. You would either have -$100 or +$100000 and never +$901 in your stated scenario.*
In your case since there is a 99% probability of -$100, my "expectation" would be -$100 and if "surprise" of $100000 happens that is "surprise", not part of the "expectation".
* I realize there is a term called "expectation value" and I hate that term with a passion because in any distribution that doesn't roughly resemble a bell curve it would be stupid to "expect" the mean value. Statistics like the mean are not a good way to establish a strategy for a game that you only get to play once.
GGP said "you are expecting a profit of $901" -- I'm not, personally. I'm "expecting" -$100. How about we take a bet? I'll expect -$100, you expect $901. If I win you give me $100, if you win I give you $100, and if neither of us wins we split the $100K. Deal?
This is a game theory problem, NOT a statistics problem. In my case the utility of losing -$100 is zero, the utility of gaining $100K is very positive, the utility of missing out on the $100K is extremely negative.
Calculating utility, or the expected value, is entirely statistics.
"Expected value" and its derivatives is a specific term, with a specific calculation. You can't just throw around words and expect others to understand you don't mean the actual definition when you say them.
I don't know about you but if you have a coin labeled 0 and 1 and flip it it would be mind-bogglingly stupid to expect a 0.5 out of this coin. Just like if you have a coin labeled A and C it would be stupid to expect a B to come out of it. You'd be better off picking either A or C and expecting that instead.
No statistics class I took said that a coin with sides A and C can give you a B, or that you could "expect" 0.5 from a bimodal distribution with a delta function at 0 and a delta function at 1. The mean value may be 0.5 but it's not something you would expect to actually happen; if you wanted to maximize the probability that your prediction is correct you'd be better off picking 0 or 1.
It’s like having a huge argument about a physics problem claiming “force” isn’t mass times acceleration because nobody is “forcing” you to do anything.
Back to your 0 or 1 example. 0.5 is the meaningful value to know over any kind of large sampling because that is what matters for “expected value”. It tells me what I should expect overall if I play 1000 times.
What you want is called the “mode”. Given a single instance of an event, what is the most frequent value.
I already know that.
My point is it's shitty terminology, even though it's somehow become a standard.
Stats 101 also does NOT tell you to "expect" the expected value to happen.
GGGGGP however seems to actually use the value to formulate a strategy, and that's where I'm pointing out that this entire formulation of using stats to approach this problem is flawed. You don't have enough chances at the game such that the mean is a meaningful number to consider.
That's also why I always refer to it as the mean even if other people call it "expected value". I hate the term with a passion and I will not yield to the wise guys who wrote the books.
Honestly I'd rather not have this discussion in English because this isn't a problem in many other languages. In many languages mean is not called "expected" anything.
While ongoing profit from the investment itself is nice it's not legally required. For example, stock in Uber is a regulated security, even though Uber has a history of losses and is not expected to be profitable in the near or distant future, if ever.
Similarly, loss companies were once frequently sold to savvy investors needing losses to offset their taxable earnings from other sources, and those investments were similarly regulated securities even though there was clearly no expectation of profits.
Yes, more or less. Or call it an insecurity, I don't care, whatever is needed so the SEC can stay out of this.
https://www.investopedia.com/terms/h/howey-test.asp
>1. An investment of money
check
>2. In a common enterprise
check
>3. With the expectation of profit
Probably? Why else would they be buying a team for?
>4. To be derived from the efforts of others3
check.
edit: I took a look at their "Flightpaper", and in it they acknowledged that some parts of it might pass the Howey Test, and they recognize the possibility of regulatory oversight
>This funding model requires extensive SEC regulation oversight.
However, they're pretty light on details on whether it would actually be approved by the SEC or not. Also by the looks of it they haven't registered with the SEC right now, but they're already raising funds?