So much this. Here in NL, my heating bill is 70% tax and 30% gas charges (not exaggerating).
The government claims to do this to encourage installation of better insulation and other energy saving measures - however, as a renter (like the vast majority of NL is), I can’t do anything about this and just pay the exorbitant heating bill (1). I have no option but to use gas, and even if I move to a (rare) neighborhood with city heating, they’ll charge me the same amount (2).
(1) https://www.dutchnews.nl/news/2021/09/as-gas-bills-rise-more...
(2) https://www.dutchnews.nl/news/2021/11/homes-with-district-he...
Additionally, while I don't know the numbers of renters vs. buyers, I do know that the vast majority of renters in NL live in social housing, which means the government has some leverage there to get the housing corporations to lower gas use.
> social housing, which means the government has some leverage
I’m not sure if you’ve seen social housing, or even the average rental in places like The Hague. They are definitely not maintained well - insulation or otherwise.
Whatever the gov “could” do, isn’t being done. Other than high taxes.
https://www.iamexpat.nl/housing/real-estate-news/urgent-call...
Admittedly, there are some rentals with bills included. But if gas was very expensive, few landlords would offer it.
I can’t tell if this is serious? You’re saying that the gov policy’s effect should be the common man freezing during winter? I don’t know anyone who runs their heating for shits and giggles.
> Admittedly, there are some rentals with bills included
I’ve seen very few (<10%) of rentals that come with utilities included. It wouldn’t make sense either, I’d rather pay for my usage. Not the upper limit of usage that the landlord is accounting for while determining rent.
Heating isn't a binary thing - we want people to minimise their use of gas within reason.
Most people I know could turn their heating down a couple of degrees and put on a warmer jumper, some thermal underwear, or sit with a hot water bottle whilst at their desk if working from home. I've managed to save >30% of my households gas usage in this way.
Yes, there are people on the poverty line who already use their heating at a minimal level. And at risk elderly people. This problem is best solved with subsidies to these specific groups, rather than gas that is too cheap for everyone relative to its environmental impacts.
This view (that a sizable portion of people can reasonably turn down their heat) is substantiated by UK government research, see e.g. https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/...
For instance, there are lots of people heating rooms they don't even use, and heating their whole house overnight.
That’s good for you! I fully support educating families that are indeed superfluously running heating.
However, I would also like the exorbitant taxes to go towards actually fixing insulation/heating, or investigating/penalising landlords that don’t fix the overpriced rentals they provide.
> the rich will be relatively unaffected and can continue polluting
If the tax revenue is spent on cleanup/offsetting/etc. then that doesn't matter. That's the point of the tax.
In fact, if the tax is set slightly higher than the net cleanup cost, that (a) acts as a disincentive (rather than just 'cost of doing business'), and (b) we would want the rich to pollute even more, since they would be paying to clean up more than just their own mess.
For comparison: I take care to avoid making a mess at home, since it would take me a lot of time and effort clean up. The rich can just throw money at cleaners. Now imagine that some Global Cleaners Union sets the price-per-hour of cleaning to cover 61 minutes of work; those extra minutes are aggregated and spent on charitable activities. In such a situation, we would want the rich to make more mess.
> Such a regressive tax, levied on basic things like energy, fuel etc. that are fundamental to normal life seems incredibly likely to trigger political unrest as we saw in France.
This is mentioned in the article:
> In the UK, carbon dioxide emissions are less than six tonnes per person per year, plus two or three tonnes more to reflect the carbon footprint of imported goods. A £100/tonne tax that covered those emissions would raise the cost of living by just over £2 a day, and cover more than 5 per cent of UK tax revenue. That’s not nothing: the government would be wise to send everyone a monthly lump sum in compensation.
For example, giving out gas burning stoves to replace wood burning ones in a developing country can generate offsets. But who's to say we accurately forecast the chopped wood demand that was reduced by the program, and the gas demand that was increased by the program? Can we say 100% the recipients were not going to purchase these stoves themselves in their future? All incentives go to biasing the assumptions and printing as many offset certificates as possible.
To actually clean up we would need Direct Air Capture. The cost is 100+x higher than the usual cost of carbon offsets, and supply is very limited. The DAC industry would need to grow to a similar size (in terms of tonnes of product produced) as our current fossil fuel industry. But the output product, such as carbonate rock, would be useless, unlike fossil fuels. Its only use would be how it removed carbon from the air. I don't see anybody paying for that.
Source on the carbonate rock and scale of DAC industry: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal...
Info on offsets accounting: https://www.climatechangenews.com/2020/12/11/10-myths-net-ze...
I agree that the wood->gas stove example creates perverse incentives. It can certainly be a good investment, but the costs/risks/rewards need to be distributed to the appropriate stakeholders. In this example, I could imagine a setup like:
- Country levies a flat tax on carbon emissions
- Country pays out a flat/progressive dividend, to prevent the carbon tax making the poor worse off
- We can imagine the above balance out, such that person A with a wood-burning stove doesn't notice any cost difference
- Person A now has an incentive to switch to a gas-powered stove (reducing their tax without affecting their dividend)
- Person A can purchase such a gas-burning stove using a loan, paid for by their dividend saving (with some dividend left over to incentivise the switch)
Such a setup would be essentially the same as giving away gas-burning stoves, but the incentive structure is different: the 'potential future emissions' question has to be answered by the people who stand to gain. In the above example, Person A knows how much they spend on wood fuel (including tax); they decide whether a particular gas-stove loan is worth taking; and they gain the dividend savings during and after the loan's repaid.
I'm always iffy when it comes to loans for the most economically vulnerable; but the state can still play a role, by reducing predatory lending practices, etc.
> To actually clean up we would need Direct Air Capture. The cost is 100+x higher than the usual cost of carbon offsets, and supply is very limited.
Whenever I see such schemes I always like to see what happens if we incrementally simplify the setup. For example, we might start with:
- Extract oil -> burn oil -> synthesise carbonate rock (DAC) -> bury carbonate rock
If we use a different DAC system, we can synthesis hydrocarbons instead of carbonate rock:
- Extract oil -> burn oil -> synthesise oil (DAC) -> bury oil
The burning and DAC steps cancel out, saving money and energy:
- Extract oil -> bury oil
The extraction of fossil oil cancels out with the burying of (fossil or synthetic) oil:
- Do nothing
In other words, the simplest, cheapest form of carbon capture is to leave the oil in the ground. In that sense, DAC has two roles:
- Cancel out the burning we've already done
- Decouple energy usage from energy availability, e.g. if some remote location is great for hydro/geothermal/etc., but there's no local demand, we could use that energy for DAC. However, the majority of the time it would be even more efficient to just run electricity cables (e.g. HVDC).
I think people actually underestimate the effect of a carbon tax. The tax has to be extreme enough that it changes behaviour in the real wold, and something like 70-80% of energy comes from fossil fuels.
If people aren't near to rioting because their lifestyle is being forced to change then the tax isn't doing anything. It isn't going to look like cheerful.
I often wonder why the elites don’t understand what their mistreatment of the proletariat will lead to…
This is often way more expensive than paying for heating.
> will implement Home Office
This only works for well paying IT jobs. Not the working class that actually physically work at factories, stores, restaurants, hospitals, etc etc that are underpaid and hit the most by taxes.
> will demand public transport
Demands are cool and everything, but you can’t sit around jobless for 1-2 decades waiting for laws to pass and municipalities to build out the transport infrastructure.
> will drive electric
Very few cities have the infrastructure for this. Once that’s fixed, carbon taxation would work better.
> drive as groups instead of individuals
This already happens in Europe, but people are still wage slaves. It changes nothing.
Some jobs will also get pay raises if there is demand for them, but people can't afford to take them.
Working remote doesn't work just for IT, and I didn't claim everything works for everybody. And incrementally increased taxation will allow for planning.
Poor people have a low enough foot print to profit with a dividend anyways.
The real problem with carbon taxing is that it must be realized globally
> profit with a dividend anyways
See, the thing is, there are no carbon dividends yet. We do have lots of carbon-like taxes (in the EU and elsewhere) though. So, there’s only loss, no gain.
Generally, there is no silver bullet, but there are a lot of possible solutions as you can see. And I am sure I didn't include most of them
> See, the thing is, there are no carbon dividends yet. We do have lots of carbon-like taxes (in the EU and elsewhere) though. So, there’s only loss, no gain.
Well, what not is ...
I’m not ascribing to a perfection mindset. Just pointing out the ridiculousness of the elites telling others how to live their lives, while simultaneously finding ways to further suppress them.
“We could have an ideal world, if you just stopped doing everything that enables your survival. Me? I just make/support the rules - despite them not materially affecting me.”
So basically choose your poison or hope for magic tech to appear soon.
What do you mean?? Literally, you could redistribute billionaire/millionaire wealth and it would be more useful than taxing the average person tens/hundreds of euros more, when they can barely afford to survive.
In fact, ongoing taxation that reduces the loopholes that elites get away with, would be even more beneficial.
There may not be a way to make that burden fall on the rich. I'm not sure what percentage of a society's energy is spent on maintaining the lifestyles of the wealthy but it wouldn't be weird if it is low in absolute terms.
I think this is patently false; but even more generally, wealthier people and “developed” countries are the biggest polluters.
https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2020/sep/21/worlds-r...
I suppose they might be millionaires since around 9% of the US are millionaires [0]. That isn't a very exclusive club these days. A tax that knocks the lifestyle of that many people down to something like what an individual with a <$100k income experiences is going to be look radical.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_the_numbe...
Why shouldn’t it be radical? Why should the %-ers get to pollute and live lavish lifestyles, while enforcing frugality and poverty on the remaining 90-99%?
Most of that wealth is stocks of companies that only exist because they serve needs of billions of people that are not rich. If you redistribute the wealth (so - who owns the stocks) - you don't change the emissions because the needs of billions of people are still there (in fact - you will probably increase net emissions because now more people have money to spend) and companies will continue to try to satisfy these needs to earn money. And emit CO2 while doing so.
If you want to reduce the emissions you have to stop these needs from being satisfied (or invent magic tech). Redistribution of wealth (while reasonable for other reasons) - won't help with global warming.
Side effect of cutting CO2 emissions is that these companies lose big percent of their value, so wealth of everybody drops, but that's the least of our problems.
Another thing is - significant part of the world is just now achieving living standards considered bare minimum in the west. That's more than billion people that will double their CO2 emissions soon. If you cut the 15% of emissions caused by top 1% to 0 - it doesn't matter because at the same time 20% or 30% of world population is increasing their emissions by 100%.
We have 2 issues - life is unfair (and to fix that we need to tax the rich), and global warming (and to fix that we need to tax CO2 emissions, no matter who cause them). The end result will be that everybody but the poor people in 3rd world countries will significantly lower their living standards.
What will actually happen is probably that we just tax CO2, so everybody living standards will drop. Or we do nothing and we all suffer the climate crisis, mass imigrations, starvations, wars etc.
Reducing loopholes won't reduce carbon emissions. Internalizing the cost will, so I can't even imagine how this would be more beneficial. So, just do both
But carbon tax (ideally with a dividend) catches this anyways
The common man is definitely less polluting than the average HNer - HN represents the upper % of the upper middle class. So really, the way you frame your reply makes me think you haven’t thought through the impact on your own polluting lifestyle.
The common man in the developed world is still part of the problem.
>So really, the way you frame your reply makes me think you haven’t thought through the impact on your own polluting lifestyle.
You are jumping to an incorrect conclusion there. I've been thinking about it for decades which is why I don't fly nor own a car. My spending (hence consumption) is around the poverty line for my country.
The purpose of a CO2 tax is reduce emissions and a lot of emissions are not caused by luxury products and services but simple stuff like growing food or driving to work.
Increasing the price of fuel to the point where people switch to biking to work would be very successful from a climate standpoint but extremely unpopular.
Private jets use ridiculous amounts of fuel.
The middle class will drive while the poor take the bus.
It's not as regressive as you'd think.
This can also be offset with tax rebates for those on lower incomes.
Politically the problem is that the wealthy will use every lobbying, legal and propaganda tool to shift the burden off their backs.
Except in most of America, where the poor have to drive as well, and spend a much higher percentage of their income on cars. Evidently most don't mind or are even supportive, because it supposedly buys them freedom (From what? Disposable income?).
I think this is patently false; but even more generally, wealthier people and “developed” countries are the biggest polluters.
(https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2020/sep/21/worlds-r...)
For example, look at what happened in France with the fuel tax rise which lead to the “gilets jaunes” protests.
If people need to get to work and heat their homes etc. then putting a tax on all of that will hit them hard while the rich will be relatively unaffected and can continue polluting. A simple flat tax on CO2 emissions, while far easier to implement, would be regressive compared to one that scaled with your personal emissions or something.
Such a regressive tax, levied on basic things like energy, fuel etc. that are fundamental to normal life seems incredibly likely to trigger political unrest as we saw in France.