News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Carbon Taxes Work by roenxi on Friday November 26, 2021 @06:46AM (#29349357)
> For example, look at what happened in France with the fuel tax rise which lead to the “gilets jaunes” protests.

I think people actually underestimate the effect of a carbon tax. The tax has to be extreme enough that it changes behaviour in the real wold, and something like 70-80% of energy comes from fossil fuels.

If people aren't near to rioting because their lifestyle is being forced to change then the tax isn't doing anything. It isn't going to look like cheerful.

Re:Why Carbon Taxes Work by yunohn on Friday November 26, 2021 @06:49AM (#29349392)
I understand your viewpoint, but if you tax the common man such that they are unable to travel to work in the only car they can afford - the world will stop functioning.

I often wonder why the elites don’t understand what their mistreatment of the proletariat will lead to…

Re:Why Carbon Taxes Work by gefhfff on Friday November 26, 2021 @07:05AM (#29349502)
Or they'll just move closer to work, or will implement Home Office, or will demand public transport (which can be combined with bicycles), or will drive electric (car, ebike, electric scooter/motor cycles) or will drive as groups instead of individuals, or a dividend will implemented making this scenario unlikely in the first place while still enabling carbon taxes.
Re:Why Carbon Taxes Work by yunohn on Friday November 26, 2021 @07:10AM (#29349537)
> they'll just move closer to work

This is often way more expensive than paying for heating.

> will implement Home Office

This only works for well paying IT jobs. Not the working class that actually physically work at factories, stores, restaurants, hospitals, etc etc that are underpaid and hit the most by taxes.

> will demand public transport

Demands are cool and everything, but you can’t sit around jobless for 1-2 decades waiting for laws to pass and municipalities to build out the transport infrastructure.

> will drive electric

Very few cities have the infrastructure for this. Once that’s fixed, carbon taxation would work better.

> drive as groups instead of individuals

This already happens in Europe, but people are still wage slaves. It changes nothing.

Re:Why Carbon Taxes Work by gefhfff on Friday November 26, 2021 @07:14AM (#29349559)
Another option: get work nearby.

Some jobs will also get pay raises if there is demand for them, but people can't afford to take them.

Working remote doesn't work just for IT, and I didn't claim everything works for everybody. And incrementally increased taxation will allow for planning.

Poor people have a low enough foot print to profit with a dividend anyways.

The real problem with carbon taxing is that it must be realized globally

Re:Why Carbon Taxes Work by yunohn on Friday November 26, 2021 @07:18AM (#29349588)
I’ve lived in the USA, EU, and Asia. Very very rarely can you get a job near your housing (suburbs) - residential vs commercial areas are intentionally zoned against this. Getting housing near your work (city center) is much easier, due to mixed zoning, but obviously way more expensive.

> profit with a dividend anyways

See, the thing is, there are no carbon dividends yet. We do have lots of carbon-like taxes (in the EU and elsewhere) though. So, there’s only loss, no gain.

Re:Why Carbon Taxes Work by gefhfff on Friday November 26, 2021 @07:35AM (#29349693)
So you have found things to be changed (back). Same goes for shops having centralized a lot especially in the US at it seems, while local shops are much more bicycle or even foot friendly.

Generally, there is no silver bullet, but there are a lot of possible solutions as you can see. And I am sure I didn't include most of them

> See, the thing is, there are no carbon dividends yet. We do have lots of carbon-like taxes (in the EU and elsewhere) though. So, there’s only loss, no gain.

Well, what not is ...

Re:Why Carbon Taxes Work by yunohn on Friday November 26, 2021 @07:43AM (#29349752)
> Generally, there is no silver bullet

I’m not ascribing to a perfection mindset. Just pointing out the ridiculousness of the elites telling others how to live their lives, while simultaneously finding ways to further suppress them.

“We could have an ideal world, if you just stopped doing everything that enables your survival. Me? I just make/support the rules - despite them not materially affecting me.”

Re:Why Carbon Taxes Work by ajuc on Friday November 26, 2021 @06:53AM (#29349418)
If you don't stop global warming - it's not going to be pretty either. And taxing rich, while a good idea - won't solve the problem, because there's so few of them that it won't matter, nevermind how exuberant they CO2 emissions are.

So basically choose your poison or hope for magic tech to appear soon.

Re:Why Carbon Taxes Work by yunohn on Friday November 26, 2021 @07:02AM (#29349473)
> because there's so few of them that it won't matter

What do you mean?? Literally, you could redistribute billionaire/millionaire wealth and it would be more useful than taxing the average person tens/hundreds of euros more, when they can barely afford to survive.

In fact, ongoing taxation that reduces the loopholes that elites get away with, would be even more beneficial.

Re:Why Carbon Taxes Work by roenxi on Friday November 26, 2021 @07:10AM (#29349536)
Wealth is numbers on a page. Chop fossil fuel use in half (picking a random ratio) and there physically isn't a way for everyone to maintain their lifestyle. They have to travel less, receive less goods and spend less on heating and cooling.

There may not be a way to make that burden fall on the rich. I'm not sure what percentage of a society's energy is spent on maintaining the lifestyles of the wealthy but it wouldn't be weird if it is low in absolute terms.

Re:Why Carbon Taxes Work by yunohn on Friday November 26, 2021 @07:11AM (#29349544)
> I'm not sure what percentage of a society's energy is spent on maintaining the lifestyles of the wealthy but it wouldn't be weird if it is low in absolute terms.

I think this is patently false; but even more generally, wealthier people and “developed” countries are the biggest polluters.

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2020/sep/21/worlds-r...

Re:Why Carbon Taxes Work by roenxi on Friday November 26, 2021 @07:33AM (#29349678)
The global 1% are, by definition, around 80 million people (more than the population of most countries). As the article points out, earning more than around $100,000. They aren't billionaires.

I suppose they might be millionaires since around 9% of the US are millionaires [0]. That isn't a very exclusive club these days. A tax that knocks the lifestyle of that many people down to something like what an individual with a <$100k income experiences is going to be look radical.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_the_numbe...

Re:Why Carbon Taxes Work by yunohn on Friday November 26, 2021 @07:45AM (#29349770)
> A tax that knocks the lifestyle of that many people down to something like what an individual with a <$100k income experiences is going to be look radical.

Why shouldn’t it be radical? Why should the %-ers get to pollute and live lavish lifestyles, while enforcing frugality and poverty on the remaining 90-99%?

Re:Why Carbon Taxes Work by ajuc on Friday November 26, 2021 @08:07AM (#29349916)
> What do you mean?? Literally, you could redistribute billionaire/millionaire wealth and it would be more useful than taxing the average person tens/hundreds of euros more, when they can barely afford to survive.

Most of that wealth is stocks of companies that only exist because they serve needs of billions of people that are not rich. If you redistribute the wealth (so - who owns the stocks) - you don't change the emissions because the needs of billions of people are still there (in fact - you will probably increase net emissions because now more people have money to spend) and companies will continue to try to satisfy these needs to earn money. And emit CO2 while doing so.

If you want to reduce the emissions you have to stop these needs from being satisfied (or invent magic tech). Redistribution of wealth (while reasonable for other reasons) - won't help with global warming.

Side effect of cutting CO2 emissions is that these companies lose big percent of their value, so wealth of everybody drops, but that's the least of our problems.

Another thing is - significant part of the world is just now achieving living standards considered bare minimum in the west. That's more than billion people that will double their CO2 emissions soon. If you cut the 15% of emissions caused by top 1% to 0 - it doesn't matter because at the same time 20% or 30% of world population is increasing their emissions by 100%.

We have 2 issues - life is unfair (and to fix that we need to tax the rich), and global warming (and to fix that we need to tax CO2 emissions, no matter who cause them). The end result will be that everybody but the poor people in 3rd world countries will significantly lower their living standards.

What will actually happen is probably that we just tax CO2, so everybody living standards will drop. Or we do nothing and we all suffer the climate crisis, mass imigrations, starvations, wars etc.

Re:Why Carbon Taxes Work by gefhfff on Friday November 26, 2021 @07:11AM (#29349540)
That taxation is redistributing wealth (supporting climate change).

Reducing loopholes won't reduce carbon emissions. Internalizing the cost will, so I can't even imagine how this would be more beneficial. So, just do both

Re:Why Carbon Taxes Work by gefhfff on Friday November 26, 2021 @07:07AM (#29349512)
1% (richest) = 15% emissions, so much for that

But carbon tax (ideally with a dividend) catches this anyways

Re:Why Carbon Taxes Work by tonyedgecombe on Friday November 26, 2021 @07:00AM (#29349467)
On the other hand if you can't get the common man out of their polluting activities then you aren't going to solve the problem.
Re:Why Carbon Taxes Work by yunohn on Friday November 26, 2021 @07:20AM (#29349602)
> common man out of their polluting activities

The common man is definitely less polluting than the average HNer - HN represents the upper % of the upper middle class. So really, the way you frame your reply makes me think you haven’t thought through the impact on your own polluting lifestyle.

Re:Why Carbon Taxes Work by tonyedgecombe on Friday November 26, 2021 @07:39AM (#29349714)
>The common man is definitely less polluting than the average HNer - HN represents the upper % of the upper middle class.

The common man in the developed world is still part of the problem.

>So really, the way you frame your reply makes me think you haven’t thought through the impact on your own polluting lifestyle.

You are jumping to an incorrect conclusion there. I've been thinking about it for decades which is why I don't fly nor own a car. My spending (hence consumption) is around the poverty line for my country.