News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Is AMD ROCm? by VHRanger on Thursday November 25, 2021 @01:01PM (#29343441)
It's something that has very little uptake because it's not supported on mainline GPUs?

I want to use it for compute on something like a rx 6800 and to my knowledge can't

Re:What Is AMD ROCm? by rjzzleep on Thursday November 25, 2021 @01:11PM (#29343547)
I was going to post exactly the same. And if you look at the github issues of their project you will see that very often it looks outsourced support teams comment on these issues with the standard: we will discuss this internally and get back to you kind of response that enterprises twitter support usually gives.

Not really what you expect from quality engineering. At the end of the day these kind of companies don't understand the value of development and engineering clients as customers.

It's unfortunate really.

EDIT: here's an example:

   ROCmSupport commented on Feb 22 •

   Hi @powderluv
   Thanks for reaching us. I can not comment on RDNA2  support right now.
   We are working on adding a few more new hardware into ROCm environment.
   Please stay tuned via our documentation.
   Thank you.
   
   @ROCmSupport ROCmSupport closed this on Feb 22 

https://github.com/RadeonOpenCompute/ROCm/issues/1390#issuec...
Re:What Is AMD ROCm? by dylan604 on Thursday November 25, 2021 @02:17PM (#29344099)
Sounds like a race from support staff to see how many tickets they can close to make themselves look good for the PM at the next review
Re:What Is AMD ROCm? by nicolaslem on Thursday November 25, 2021 @01:26PM (#29343663)
On the other hand AMD has a fraction of the engineering resources Intel and Nvidia have. They need to make some choice and looking back at the last few years it seems that their choice to focus their efforts on hardware and gaming paid off.
Re:What Is AMD ROCm? by to11mtm on Thursday November 25, 2021 @01:45PM (#29343820)
ATI/AMD has always had finicky drivers and engineering decisions IMO.

I guess on the plus side they at least have a more open driver than NVidia (AFAIK nouveau doesn't get any support from them, at least AMD tries to maintain their open source driver on some level.)

And yet, every time I've tried an ATI/AMD Card, the driver experience even in windows has been pretty off-putting, and while I suppose we are finally at a point where one is less likely to be impacted by their issues with 768p overscan on TVs, I wonder what zany quirk they'll come up with next.

Re:What Is AMD ROCm? by ahartmetz on Thursday November 25, 2021 @08:46PM (#29346815)
> AMD tries to maintain their open source driver on some level.

I think you somehow mistyped "AMD has open source drivers of absofuckinglutely excellent quality supporting hardware of the last ten years or so". No really, they are great. For graphics, that is.

Re:What Is AMD ROCm? by dagmx on Thursday November 25, 2021 @02:17PM (#29344104)
On the flip side, I think that they haven't focused on a compelling compute story means that anyone doing anything other than pure gaming is better served by an Nvidia card.
Re:What Is AMD ROCm? by edgyquant on Thursday November 25, 2021 @07:03PM (#29346246)
Yeah I bought an AMD card a few years when they released the new architecture to support them. I ended up grabbing an nvidia card because I don’t play many games but I want to be able to run tensorflow etc but after a year AMD still had little support for any machine learning.
Re:What Is AMD ROCm? by jagger27 on Thursday November 25, 2021 @06:45PM (#29346142)
This is why I'm excited about Intel getting into the market.
Re:What Is AMD ROCm? by jacquesm on Thursday November 25, 2021 @10:11PM (#29347195)
That's not a valid reason to close a ticket. You close a ticket because the matter is resolved. We work with an internal rule with respect to comments on documents: if you open it the default is that you are going to be the one to close it when you are satisfied your concerns have been addressed. This sometimes gets overruled but that definitely isn't the norm.
Re:What Is AMD ROCm? by slavik81 on Thursday November 25, 2021 @02:04PM (#29343992)
It's not officially supported, but I think it would work if you installed the official ROCm 4.5 packages. The RX 6800 is listed as gfx1030 [1], which has been shipping in most libraries since ROCm 4.2. I've heard there were a few bugs, but I've been using it for months without encountering any issues myself.

(I work for AMD on ROCm. All opinions are my own.)

[1]: https://llvm.org/docs/AMDGPUUsage.html#processors

Re:What Is AMD ROCm? by techdragon on Thursday November 25, 2021 @03:05PM (#29344528)
Can you please emphasise to your management chain how important the need for less terrible support and developer relations vis GitHub is. They can close support questions but basically anything in these repos gets closed as fast as possible even feature requests and other things that should be left open.

I doubt they have the funding to meaningfully impact the overall hardware and software support matrix but if they could just make the GitHub repo feel less like I’m back in my days working at a call centre raising tickets to a second level support team in a foreign country who’s only business KPI was tickets closed per day.

Re:What Is AMD ROCm? by slavik81 on Thursday November 25, 2021 @03:24PM (#29344692)
I agree with you. The communication between AMD and the community has been less than ideal.

I think it's worth noting, though, it's not always as bad as the example in the sibling comment. The RadeonOpenCompute/ROCm repo catches a lot of questions about big features and the future direction of the project. Those are particularly difficult to answer as an engineer. As much as I'd like to, I can't make a product announcement in a GitHub issue.

If you have a specific technical problem and you open an issue on the repo for the corresponding component, you'll probably have a better experience. Some teams are more responsive than others, but that will at least maximize your odds of successful resolution.

Re:What Is AMD ROCm? by dogma1138 on Thursday November 25, 2021 @01:25PM (#29343657)
It’s worst because it has no intermediate state there is no guarantee for forward compatibility (backward compatibility is also kinda broken). Shipping anything with HIP will be a pain.

With CUDA you simply target a specific CUDA version and there is full forward and backwards compatibility on any hardware that supports that version.

Re:What Is AMD ROCm? by bubblethink on Thursday November 25, 2021 @01:41PM (#29343785)
AMD is much smaller in comparison, and their main focus with ROCM is to get pytorch and tensorflow to work with enterprise GPUs. Everything else is long tail in terms of scale.
Re:What Is AMD ROCm? by Gigachad on Thursday November 25, 2021 @11:33PM (#29347502)
This doesn't mean anything to potential customers. If I was in the market for GPU compute, nvidia is the only real option. AMD has had some PR person commenting on github that they have "big news coming very soon" for navi users but it's been over a year now and still no news.
Re:What Is AMD ROCm? by vardump on Thursday November 25, 2021 @05:18PM (#29345488)
Sadly this is why I (and many others) keep begrudgingly choosing Nvidia cards instead.

Once the developers are familiar with CUDA, what are the chances you'd choose ROCm for deployment? Yeah, not great.

Consumer cards' ROCm support is strategic.

Re:What Is AMD ROCm? by enos_feedler on Thursday November 25, 2021 @08:40PM (#29346786)
If this is the goal they are better off working with Google on MLIR since they are also focusing on hw acceleration of pytorch and tensorflow code
Re:What Is AMD ROCm? by zwaps on Thursday November 25, 2021 @08:23PM (#29346695)
AMD's support - not just for new or old GPUs, but in terms of all sorts of compatibility changes, usability parity and regressions is staggeringly bad.

Given that compute is important, and many people use their GPUs for compute of some sort, I simply can not understand how that part is so poorly executed on the part of AMD that, in terms of actual application, you might call it entirely absent.

I mean, this is a company that produces compute cards, which supposedly someone in the world must buy and use... but who? Why? I have never seen anyone, and for good reason. And it seems like AMD just... doesn't care?

Like, it's just not a part of their organizational strategy... Compute is on the powerpoint slides, but... no one (can) use it?

It's been going on for years now and I don't get it.

Re:What Is AMD ROCm? by jacquesm on Thursday November 25, 2021 @10:12PM (#29347203)
Especially not with NVidia leaving the front door wide open with their licensing terms and other oversights. But as long as AMD doesn't care enough NVidia will grow and become more and more entrenched. It would take a small miracle to displace them by now.
Re:What Is AMD ROCm? by a_bonobo on Thursday November 25, 2021 @09:43PM (#29347052)
I tink the main workhorse supercomputer GPUs are not out yet.

They announced the MI200 GPU with 128GB of memory, two supercomputers (Setonix, Frontier) are suppose to include them but both will only be launched next year https://www.tomshardware.com/news/setonix-supercomputer-mi20...

Re:What Is AMD ROCm? by touisteur on Friday November 26, 2021 @03:05AM (#29348295)
Also announced very recently the MI250 with 47 FP32 TFLOPS? Just the morning before the GTC keynote? NVIDIA Lovelace is supposed to be in 2022 (I think?) so it's a good time to ship GPGPU HW but wait and see if AMD can ship them, at what prices, and if their library ecosystem (not even thinking rocm or hip... But even blas, miopen would be enough to start...) has full optimized support.
Re:What Is AMD ROCm? by sorenjan on Thursday November 25, 2021 @01:19PM (#29343625)
There's also no Windows support, so you cant use it to make consumer programs, or on your gaming rig without dual boot. It's made for data centers with bespoke software, not really for distribution.