News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An “incident” with the James Webb Space Telescope has occ... by thuccess129 on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @09:30AM (#29318193)
Engineers at heart wouldn't let a single point of failure in in the design of it to let a pin drop unexpectedly. Is the vehicle insured for a do-over should it fail to launch unspectacularly and land in the water?
Re:An “incident” with the James Webb Space Telescope has occ... by shantara on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @09:48AM (#29318387)
After watching an official JWST video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uUAvXYW5bmI, they seem almost proud of having several hundred of single points of failure and an immensely complex deployment process that takes several weeks and must work perfectly. I don't know what engineer could be proud of coming up with a design like that.
Re:An “incident” with the James Webb Space Telescope has occ... by Out_of_Characte on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @10:08AM (#29318646)
Single points of failure are inevitable. engineers could always make a copy of the entire design but that would double the costs and you would still be left with unknown points of failure that the telescope double would have.

The solar shield is like rolling out five layers of tightly packed tinfoil from several points without tearing. Claiming that you would do away with single points of failure if you were the one designing it is too easy to say on HN

Re:An “incident” with the James Webb Space Telescope has occ... by depaya on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @10:37AM (#29319035)
Any idiot can build a bridge that stands, but it takes an engineer to build a bridge that barely stands.
Re:An “incident” with the James Webb Space Telescope has occ... by shantara on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @10:16AM (#29318750)
I'm not arguing you could completely go away with single points of failure when designing a spacecraft while being limited by the payload mass and volume. But the whole JWST unfolding sequence looks like a way too risky gamble to me. Maybe, it was worthwhile to sacrifice some of the scientific payload mass to add more redundancies into the solar shield design and increase the chances the telescope would be able to reach the beginning of its observation process.

There's also the whole "what if we could avoid mass and volume constraints" tangent, that was discussed in the yesterday's Starship article, but it's more of a theoretical consideration for now.

Re:An “incident” with the James Webb Space Telescope has occ... by jdmichal on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @11:09AM (#29319480)
Honestly, I thought the same about the whole Perseverance landing sequence on Mars. But now it's done, and the rover is running around doing its thing.

So, what I learned is that single points of failure on initial deployment -- which by definition only has to run once -- is a drastically different cost vs risk calculation than something that happens during normal operations.

Re:An “incident” with the James Webb Space Telescope has occ... by idlewords on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @11:46AM (#29320004)
The unfolding sequence looked complicated to me, too, and then I remembered I am just a guy online.

You are right that a magical rocket could solve many of NASAs problems (just launch ten Webbs and use the ones that don't work as sunshades for the rest!) but I think NASA is being pretty practical in not waiting for one to be invented.

Re:An “incident” with the James Webb Space Telescope has occ... by dylan604 on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @10:16AM (#29318759)
>entire design but that would double the costs

What was the original budget for JWST? Where's it at now? From your assessment and the numbers, it sounds like there's not just double but triple redundancy now.

Re:An “incident” with the James Webb Space Telescope has occ... by ZeikJT on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @02:02AM (#29327583)
In 1996 when it was a proposed idea the estimated cost was 500 million USD and the proposed launch was 2007. But the design kept getting more and more lofty and the project got more and more complex. The initial estimate was a bit off, it has cost about 9.6 billion USD so far.

Still though, if everything works and we learn more about the universe, I think it'll have been worth it.

Re:An “incident” with the James Webb Space Telescope has occ... by NikolaeVarius on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @09:58AM (#29318520)
Its a machine that is extremely mass limited, has many different groups of people influencing different systems, and is extremely complex.

If the HARD requirement is "you have this much mass and volume to make a thing to a particular confidence score" you make the damn thing and hope you are on the correct side of the dice.

No single engineer gives a shit about the entire system because no single person is equipped with the human ability of comprehending each individual part that has whatever confidence rating that is required.

Re:An “incident” with the James Webb Space Telescope has occ... by spaetzleesser on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @01:33PM (#29321365)
Makes me wonder if the future is in launching things in parts and assembling things in space. This probably has its own set of problems though.
Re:An “incident” with the James Webb Space Telescope has occ... by sgtnoodle on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:43PM (#29323928)
That would be pretty cool if it could be done inside a pressurized workspace. Humans could do the work of massive cranes.
Re:An “incident” with the James Webb Space Telescope has occ... by alanbernstein on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @10:26AM (#29318885)
If I skipped reading the first clause in your comment, I would definitely think you were talking about modern software systems. Plenty of pride there.

(Ok, "weeks" isn't quite applicable in that case... Unless you're counting the time for updates to propagate through all upstream dependencies.)

Re:An “incident” with the James Webb Space Telescope has occ... by shlurpy on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @01:16PM (#29321123)
The mass constraint in space engineering is a real killer, unfortunately. I doubt they want so many single points of failure, but I also understand it can be effectively impossible to add redundancy within mass window.
Re:An “incident” with the James Webb Space Telescope has occ... by spaetzleesser on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @01:35PM (#29321395)
These people aren’t dumb. I am pretty sure they went through a lot of options before settling on a design. Keep in mind that a lot of space devices are outdated by the time they are being deployed.
Re:An “incident” with the James Webb Space Telescope has occ... by mdoms on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @01:10PM (#29321057)
Very aggravating to hear them use units like "thousandths of an inch thick" and "feet of cables". Does NASA really still work with imperial units of measure?
Re:An “incident” with the James Webb Space Telescope has occ... by idlewords on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @11:43AM (#29319970)
The question is what engineer could be proud of finding a solution within such difficult constraints, and the answer is a really good bunch of engineers.
Re:An “incident” with the James Webb Space Telescope has occ... by Enginerrrd on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @11:00AM (#29319329)
In many systems, yes, that's to be avoided. However, the space industry as a whole is so tightly constrained that it's a necessary evil to eliminate redundancy and even reduce safety factors below ideal.
Re:An “incident” with the James Webb Space Telescope has occ... by edgyquant on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @09:41AM (#29318314)
With how long it’s been planned a do-over would involve a new telescope I’d think.
Re:An “incident” with the James Webb Space Telescope has occ... by scrooched_moose on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @09:57AM (#29318510)
I'd imagine there were redundant systems that caught it, but it still caused a significant shift in load distribution and possibly the satellite to drop some distance which would impart an acceleration load.
Re:An “incident” with the James Webb Space Telescope has occ... by dylan604 on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @10:19AM (#29318788)
I wonder how much shock the system is going to take to use a persuasion tool (aka mallet) to release it from this "redundant" system you imagine. My imagination is much less prolific and see it wedged in at an angle in a way not imagined by the deigners.
Re:An “incident” with the James Webb Space Telescope has occ... by willis936 on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @11:06AM (#29319419)
10 Bn USD projects are not insured.
Re:An “incident” with the James Webb Space Telescope has occ... by bumby on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @08:59PM (#29326171)
Almost no government space project is insured. The govt is self-insured, generally. Which incidentally, means private space companies are effectively out-sourcing much of their govt contract risk to the taxpayer