News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by shiohime on Saturday November 20, 2021 @02:08PM (#29290893)
I someday hope that people realize what you can do with single issue tokens beyond simply having a link to cloud storage. You can create products that utilize this same behavior, but also leverage proof of ownership to create actual unique applications. With even just an ounce of developer ingenuity, you can use NFTs as an access token to whatever service you wish to provide.

I put together a collection that is both art + access to an interactive service that relies on ownership of a token. The right-click download picture is completely meaningless as the true power is simply proof of ownership of the piece, having a copy of the image means nothing if you don't own the token and you will be denied access to the service. I guess it's a completely new concept in a lot of ways and not many people have yet implemented this to scale but it's a fascinating concept to me personally.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Saturday November 20, 2021 @02:53PM (#29291301)
> The right-click download picture is completely meaningless as the true power is simply proof of ownership of the piece, having a copy of the image means nothing if you don't own the token and you will be denied access to the service.

Sure, fine. Why do I care? I can use said copy on any other service I want. If your argument is "ah yes, but someone out there believes that's not as valuable because it ignores their 'ownership'", and you can't see why that isn't persuasive, then I really am not sure we share enough of the same reality to discuss this rationally.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by shiohime on Saturday November 20, 2021 @03:11PM (#29291452)
I don't think you are understanding at all what I am saying lol.

I have a program, think of it as a traditional web app, that has a backend that validates whether you own the asset prior to granting access.

You can't use any copy of the png to interact with other services, since there is only *one* service that allows for the interactive capabilities, and it requires ownership of the token to access. Hell, you could even take it a step further, take the png and make a forge of a token from my collection. You still won't be able to access the service with a forged token with the exact same metadata and image, because it will easily be able to detect it is not part of my collection.

All you would have is a PNG. Not access to the actual services that are only possible via ownership. I could extend my project and create a plethora of services that are only accessible to people who own one of the NFTs from my collection, and that is what I intend to do.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Saturday November 20, 2021 @03:23PM (#29291532)
> You can't use any copy of the png to interact with other services, since there is only one service that allows for the interactive capabilities, and it requires ownership of the token to access.

This makes no sense. Given any possible interaction you could have with a PNG some other service can replicate it. They could choose to do so with alternative NFTs pointing to the same PNGs, or just let you use any PNG at your leisure.

Let's give the benefit of the doubt and say your service is utterly unique. That you have somehow invented some kind of super-magic software that does something super incredible with PNGs that no one else can manage, and you've decided that NFTs are the way to determine who can and cannot use the service. What exactly is your reasoning to use NFTs in this way instead of traditional authentication mechanisms? Because the only one I can think of is capitalizing off the NFT hype.

Please, convince me that NFTs as a technology have some inherent value instead of all their value being derived from a collective delusion and FOMO. I'm aching to hear a good, concrete usecase for the technology that simply cannot be done better without it.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by _gf4m on Saturday November 20, 2021 @03:44PM (#29291674)
It's pretty simple really. You just seem to have a fundamental misunderstanding of what an NFT actually is. It is simply a single issue token. The current implementation is nearly 100% for art purposes, in that they are tokens that point to cloud storage. As a developer I can create whatever services I want, based off of a determined, finite collection of single issue tokens. The token can do whatever the developer of the token wants it to do, and grant access to whatever services they want it to have access.

If I was to implement this with traditional web infrastructure, it would increase the scope of my project by likely 2-3 times. I am a single developer, and yeah I may have like a decade of experience at this point, but utilizing this instead of integrating traditional payment and authentication services, as well as traditional database services, dramatically decreases the scope of my project. Seriously, it would probably not be a feasible project for me alone if I stuck to traditional infra. It is empowering me, as a solo developer, to create something unique that I hope people find some enjoyment out of.

Let me be very straightforward here - I have spent the past 4 months working full time creating interactive generative art, that I 100% absolutely never would do so, unless there are economic incentives. This is an independent venture, I'm running it as my first business venture outside of the traditional corporate world, and I want to create something unique. I am planning on charging a very fair price for mint, basically only enough that if my full collection is minted and I do nothing else, then I would extend the amount of time I have until I have to go back to the corporate grind from about 6 months from now to about a year. I'm not creating a collection and charging like $500 per piece, I am targetting like $20.

Just because there is a ton of hype in the technology and people are making get quick rich schemes left and right with really low effort collections, please don't rule out the tech entirely.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Saturday November 20, 2021 @05:47PM (#29292514)
> It's pretty simple really. You just seem to have a fundamental misunderstanding of what an NFT actually is.

People keep saying this, but I'm pretty sure I know what it is. But what I'm asking is: what in god's name is it actually good for, other than scams?

> Just because there is a ton of hype in the technology and people are making get quick rich schemes left and right with really low effort collections, please don't rule out the tech entirely.

But this is precisely what you're doing with it too! Your service is just creating generative art and minting an NFT for it, from what I can tell, with the sole intention of convincing people to pay for the NFT so you can make money. From the sounds of it, the NFT is just the authentication token, perhaps signing some set of parameters that determine the "unique" generative algorithm that the user "bought". Sure, fine, whatever, but you could have done that with boring old certificates and a database. What value, other than NFT hype, did putting it on a decentralized trustless blockchain do for you?

People keep trying to sell this as some revolutionary technology and I just don't see it.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by shiohime on Saturday November 20, 2021 @05:54PM (#29292549)
The best way I can describe my project to you is the difference between owning a room and owning a picture of a room. You cannot enter the room, only see it from a static angle based on the picture.

This is the fundamental difference between what my project can do and what a static image does. My service does not interact with the PNG, it interacts with the space that my program generated, and took a picture of. The user can connect their wallet, select their art, and explore the "room" generated with it.

To do this in web2 infra, like I said, is a much more complicated problem and would involve probably non-user friendly DRM. It's simply a different technology, and really if you don't understand it I hope there are more projects out there that come out in the next year that change your mind.

You can write off my project as a get rich quick scheme, but that is from a point of ignorance from someone that probably hasn't tried to create something on their own and market it. I'm creating a project, charging a very reasonable price, for interactive art. I don't really care about your opinion on if you think I'm trying to make money for providing a product.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Saturday November 20, 2021 @06:03PM (#29292599)
> The best way I can describe my project to you is the difference between owning a room and owning a picture of a room. You cannot enter the room, only see it from a static angle based on the picture.

You already said this, and as I mentioned you do not need, nor can I see why anyone would want, a decentralized trustless blockchain-backed token for this.

> To do this in web2 infra, like I said, is a much more complicated problem and would involve probably non-user friendly DRM.

No it wouldn't, it just requires certificates and maybe accounts if you want a backup in case people lose their certificates. Or you could use the accounts without the certificates. Millions and millions of services provide "access to a virtual room" or the equivalent already today without ever touching a blockchain.

Besides which, what are you describing if not Digital Rights Management? Don't pretend that NFTs aren't the same damn artificial scarcity nonsense in a hip new garb.

> You can write off my project as a get rich quick scheme, but that is from a point of ignorance from someone that probably hasn't tried to create something on their own and market it.

I have, and I wasn't any good at it, but that's irrelevant. The point is that the only reason you seem to want to use an NFT is so you can get paid for it, presumably because NFTs are hip and sexy and traditional infrastructure doing the same thing for millions of online services isn't. You're praying on people falling for the hype.

You have not explained specifically in what ways an NFT gives you a better ability to do what you're doing than traditional solutions, other than to simply assert that it does.

> I don't really care about your opinion on if you think I'm trying to make money for providing a product.

I don't bemoan people trying to make money on a product. But I do, in fact, look down on people trying to take advantage of a hype bubble and push FOMO by pretending like it is some kind of revolution.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by shiohime on Saturday November 20, 2021 @06:12PM (#29292647)
Really man, if you think that me charging $20 for a unique product that you actually don't know anything about other than the few sentences I've explained here to you is preying on people, I don't care to bother discussing this any further. You're entitled to your opinions of course, but do note that I'm trying to provide a creative art project that would have been much more of a pain in the ass to create in web 2.

Please, just believe me when I say that I'm an engineer that is exploring the space to try and do something independent and something I personally find cool. If I wanted to make money quick, I would have made a shitty PFP apes collection 3 months ago and charged half an ETH per mint. I decided to try and create a unique product, and also explore an emerging space.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by verdverm on Saturday November 20, 2021 @02:14PM (#29290934)
So is the NFT acting like a password to the service? Do you have a way to revoke access in this scheme? (For example an abusive user)

How would NFT access work for a service which requires monthly or usage based billing? (As this seems like a one time payment currently)

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by shiohime on Saturday November 20, 2021 @02:16PM (#29290949)
Not quite. It acts as an access token, in about the purest sense, kind of like an auth token in traditional webapps. I could revoke access by blacklisting the NFT if I really, really wanted to I suppose, but I don't in this specific service I've built, as there would be no reason whatsoever for me to revoke access to the interactive capabilities of my art from someone that purchased it, and never would implement such a thing.

Edit - For the other cases you added to your original post, I've thought about the subscription problem some and have ideas but it's outside of the scope of my current project, but I think it is a solvable problem with some underlying changes to token mechanics.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by verdverm on Saturday November 20, 2021 @03:25PM (#29291543)
Sounds more like the NFT is a ticket for entry to an experience.

How does this work if a person makes a unique wallet for this NFT and then shares the private key? Does that essentially break the exclusivity mechanics?

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by shiohime on Saturday November 20, 2021 @03:57PM (#29291773)
Yeah, that is how I am envisioning it as well. It is a ticket to services I've already created, and services I intend to create in the future.

And sure, a user could create a shared wallet and let others see the interactive capabilities of the art in that wallet. Personally I wouldn't mind if someone wanted to do this, my collection will have X number of unique pieces, each of them are a completely different generative piece. So, yeah, you could buy a piece, put it in a shared wallet, and share it with your friends. Up to the purchasers of the piece to do what they want with it :)

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by NicoJuicy on Saturday November 20, 2021 @02:13PM (#29290926)
The digital piece can disappear when you still have the ownership and there's still nothing the owner can do about it.
Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by shiohime on Saturday November 20, 2021 @02:20PM (#29290994)
In my case, if arweave allows for digital pieces to disappear from the web, then that means they've likely failed as a project considering they've positioned themselves to be a permaweb.

However, interestingly if you leverage the token ownership for access, in my collection's case, even if the static image is wiped for whatever reason, they could still access the interactive service and see their art, and interact with it.

This of course has the assumption that I'm continuing to host my service indefinitely, which I know is a problem with my current implementation. I am planning to recreate my APIs as onchain programs, and migrate my app to be hosted on arweave. If it works the way I think it does and arweave doesn't fail as a project (which I don't think they will), then I'm hoping that I can have a service that is permanently accessible. I have yet to test that hypothesis of course.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by NicoJuicy on Saturday November 20, 2021 @02:39PM (#29291187)
And how can the "buyer" verify if the creation has unlimited "lifetime"?

If the original creator can even delete the artwork, the owner is never sure.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by shiohime on Saturday November 20, 2021 @02:47PM (#29291254)
That's a fair question, and really I think it comes down to degrees of trust. As you say, ultimately I as the creator of the tokens could possibly utilize my update authority to change some of the underlying metadata for the token. The only real reason I can think of that I'd do it for this project is bugfixes if there is something botched in the metadata for specific tokens.

I don't quite know the extent of power that I could leverage as a creator over data on arweave. It's not ever crossed my mind as to why I'd possibly want to alter that.

At the end of the day you have to have some degree of trust with most services you interact with, and I think this would be no different. Maybe I as a creator could eliminate this ability to update anything on arweave after the initial upload by changing the update authority to a wallet that is programmatically created from an onchain program, and off of the Ed25519 curve. If I am able to do something like that, then it would be impossible to access the wallet since it doesn't have a valid private key, and maybe then it's truly immutable?

It's a problem I actually haven't thought of until now. But there's probably something I could do along those lines.

Honestly if something like that works then it might be a generalizable solution to the problem you're suggesting.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by NicoJuicy on Saturday November 20, 2021 @02:51PM (#29291285)
But trust is currently easy online. I can initiate a chargeback through traditional currencies.

Bought source is available for download as soon as I buy something. So i have it in my possession on my drive when eg. Envato deletes the assets because of copyright infringement.

Also, i frequently visit https://rekt.news/ and trust seems to be far-fetched. Even the auditors sometimes keep the 0-days to themselves.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by shiohime on Saturday November 20, 2021 @03:09PM (#29291433)
Yeah, it's true that chargeback is not possible in the same way in cryptocurrencies, so there is just an inherent risk vector there.

I think it would be possible, and likely, that there could be a marketplace / service specifically for high-end art, that could have built in functionality that explicitly makes their pieces immutable.

But really I do think it kind of comes with the territory in some ways, when it comes to refunds. I think for instance I could create a service that allows for refunds on the initial sale from me as a provider, however if you buy something from the secondhand market, you wouldn't be able to receive a refund from me as a producer, you'd have to work with the secondhand market / user you bought it from personally.

It's possible to create trustworthy products and platforms I think. But yeah, right now there exists no easy mechanism to get a chargeback, nor do I think there likely will ever be such a thing on most chains, as chargebacks rely on centralization (banks) to transfer funds to your account.

Also thanks for sharing that link, I've never heard of the site and it's pretty interesting.

Re:TheNFTBay: Fake, but Worth Discussing by throwaway1777 on Saturday November 20, 2021 @02:14PM (#29290937)
it’s not really a new concept, just a better implementation.