> With families building up savings during pandemic and increasingly working from home, demand for property is on the rise...
Return to office, taking deferred vacations, etc. winds down the savings.
> labour shortages, global supply chain bottlenecks
won't last forever.
So there's downside demand-side risk and upside supply-side risks, with identical underlying causal triggering conditions (end of pandemic). Oh, and how long can central banks hold off on rate increases?
The risk of a violent crash has less to do with the probability of a rapid post-pandemic renormalization and more to do with the tight causal links between the risks of upside supply and downside demand. Less like "crash will definitely happen" and more like "X_1, ..., X_n all have unknown but likely highly correlated probabilities, so if one happens they all happen and if you get X_1, ..., X_n all at once there'll definitely be a crash"
I think.
Houses were only sold en masse due to a prescribed flowchart: borrower couldnt pay, bank takes house, bank doesnt want actual houses so bank sells house, bank already earned enough on interest to sell house at a loss, bank can also take losses and list property for lower to sell faster, bank found out it couldn't take losses.
This isnt happening right now. The overleverage isnt in real estate. Everyone is looking in the wrong direction just because price go up.
There's a good chance that, in the coming years, labor and materials prices will fall such that builders will start construction on too many homes. But that's a while away. material prices are falling, but they are still elevated. And houses take a while to build -- four months minimum, nine+ more typical. So even if overbuilding started today, there's still a good year or so before that stuff comes on the market.
In these situations, I'm a big believer in contrarian outcomes. Because if a large number of people think some event will occur, then they act in a way which gives them the best outcome should that event occur. The popular trend right now is to speculate a housing collapse. Thus, I think most people are going to put off buying at "elevated" prices for a few years, until it becomes crystal clear that they were wrong.
My prediction: House prices will be like the stock market circa 2016. Everyone will be predicting a collapse "any time now" while prices soar at a crazy pace and continue to do so for a decade.
Price action is sentiment. Words are hot air. People are NOT speculating on a housing collapse. Exactly the opposite.
Prices demonstrate the attitudes of people who are buying houses. I'm concerned with the attitudes of people who are not buying houses. Why aren't they buying houses? Because they think the are going to fall in the near future. Why do I think that? Because this is a popular sentiment expressed by normal people on social media.
Yes, it's wholly unscientific of me to use Reddit and Facebook as a barometer of society, but I'm not a professional economist, just another rando on the internet making bad predictions.
That's fair.
> Why aren't they buying houses?
I think a lot of people are buying.
> Because they think the are going to fall in the near future.
One major reason people with massive hoards of cash aren't buy is uncertainty around WFH. "Where to buy? Depends. Let's see how this whole return to office thing goes..."
> Yes, it's wholly unscientific of me to use Reddit and Facebook as a barometer of society, but I'm not a professional economist, just another rando on the internet making bad predictions.
Aren't we all :)
My experience is that there are a lot of people looking to buy a house, there's just no houses to buy. I bought a house earlier in the year and put an offer in the day it went on the market, and I was still only one of several offers they got that day. I also have a friend who's looking at houses right now and it seems to be basically the same, houses are getting multiple offers and selling within a few days of going on the market, and anything that doesn't sell that fast isn't worth buying.
The good question is probably "Why aren't people selling?", but I'm not sure that's actually the issue. Google suggests at least as many homes will sell this year as last year, which leads me to believe there must be more buyers than normal.
Petite investors. I saw somewhere on another thread speculation that a crash could come from prospective land lords not being able to make their properties affordable. That seems possible.
Is there a reason to assume there are more people attempting this than normal? I would think this is the worst time to attempt that since the prices are so high. You may very well be right, but it feels like we're going full circle since presumably those 'investors' think the prices are going to continue to go up or else they wouldn't be buying...
Oh, another important point: they aren't necessarily buying investment properties! They might be buying their padnemic/wfh home and then not selling their already paid off starter home/condo
How broad is the market relative to society? Could say 3% of people investing tons of money, while 97% are not, create the same result we are seeing today?
One is active, the other passive
The ECB is talking about Germany, France and the Netherlands, where the average home is an apartment in a shared building. Going on anecdata from my surroundings, those take at least two years from project for sale to finished and ready for use.
That coupled with limited place and an already existing housing shortage and growing prices, it will IMHO take much longer than a year for the current shortage to be corrected.
Housing starts aren't necessarily responding to demand, because yeah, nobody wants to over-build and contribute to a default. Plus there are other factors that impact housing starts in most high-cost areas (i.e. availability of land to build on.)
I don't see a pop, yet I'm not certain prices will soar. People will typically shop based on 'what they can afford' and that usually means monthly payment; as rates went low, it was easier to bump up the ask price; the best way to put it is, if rates drop from 4% to 3%, you can finance around 10% more money over 30y with the same overall monthly payment.
I do think there might be some 'bumps' in the road, but ironically, many of the people 'waiting' will probably end up pulling us out of the bumps (or, maybe, causing another surge.) I think overall the most likely scenario is we'll see some periods of paused growth or slight decline.
Worth throwing out there, at least in US the housing market typically cools down a bit over the winter, so take any news of decreases in volume with a grain of salt.
Tract builders target 100 days to complete a home from ground up. The permitting, zoning, and land acquisition is the slowest part, but once all of the paperwork is done, they can pump out entire neighborhoods in a couple years max.
I'd rather be an asset owner than a revolutionary in that case, though, because it's always easier to play defense than offense. The vast majority of non-billionaires can sit tight and not be explicitly targeted, but starving revolutionaries have to fight for survival. Assets can be rebuilt, but death is permanent.
I wouldn't hold my breath on that one - something like 95% of governors are also property investors.
I could believe an argument based on causal links of supply & demand, but I'm skeptical that they'll operate in the direction you suggest. To my eye: remote work was a spring that's been ready to burst since about 2014 but needed the pandemic to catalyze it; we're not going back to offices; home offices are going to become very desirable; savings (in the form of financial assets, at least) are increasing because of inflation; and supply chain bottlenecks are not normalizing anytime soon.
2021-2008 = 13 < 20.
There were a lot geopolitical papers written then about the unipolar world and how we'd reached the end of history and liberal democracy had won. To the extent that people imagined threats to U.S. dominance, they usually envisioned state actors like Russia or China. Few people predicted the rise of international terrorism, widespread state failures, mass migrations, and internal destabilization of states.
There were a fair number of commentators who said that the Internet was a fad and we'd go back to calling up businesses when we got tired of webpages. The dot-com boom was a bona-fide bubble - it burst, severely - and yet it also wasn't. I predicted the Amazon would go out of business in 2001 when their stock was down 90% in a year; it now owns retail, and is worth 50x that.
People wondered how the hell a website for throwing virtual sheep at one another was worth $15B in 2007. It's now worth $942B, and blamed for taking down governments.
We just had a page at the top of HN about someone's 2011 prediction that Bitcoin would fail. It did, for all the reasons they listed, and yet is still worth 20,000x what it was going for then. It's also had some 60-70% declines in that process.
The general lesson I take from these is that life is a whole lot more random and absurd than a lot of people think it is. A lot of people who lose everything in bubbles are right about the direction of the trend (oftentimes on a subconscious level), but wrong about magnitude and timing. I see a lot of people asking whether today's housing situation is like 2008, and to my eye the fundamental forces are nothing alike. But 2005-2008 might have been the bubble before the trend, which sets up the causal forces leading to a genuine housing shortage now.
Or summarized: first things seem impossible, then they seem obvious.
Prices in certain regions will just. keep. going. up. Maybe with dips here or there.
But there's also a lot of speculation happening in down-market junk.
Given current inflation expectations (and reality) the ECB will probably come under a lot of pressure to start raising rates.
The French are already trying to play down inflation to try and avoid the above scenario I'm guessing
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-11-18/don-t-pan...
In a vacuum.
It's cheaper and has been for many years..
The argument is that when interest rates go up, you refinance at a fixed rate while you can afford it, or sell stocks to payoff a larger portion of you morgage.
That strategy certainly has issue, because stocks will probably crash a bit when interest rates go up.
On the flip side, interest rates will go up slowly, so you might be able to refinance to fixed rate -- the hard part is doing this before it's too expensive. As it'll always be more expensive than sticking with your variable rate.
[1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2019/02/14/adjustabl...
It doesn't have to be a lot. It might only require a little underutilized housing to cause a price drop, depending on how inelastic the market is. If that is indeed the case, then the high-price situation would be fairly fragile, and worthy of being called a "bubble", even if it reflects a current shortage.
What there isn't yet is unsold housing.
On a random drive through a residential area, I'll see an occasional vacant lot or house with its lights perpetually off, but the vast majority of houses seem to be actively lived in. By contrast, I know lots of people that want houses but can't afford them. Either they're living with parents, or raising a family in a condo/apartment that's too small for them, or they've got roommates, or they're doubled/tripled up in a unit with extended family. If prices went down, they'd jump at a chance to buy, but they can't make it work right now.
For a bubble to burst, there'd need to be more vacant units being held as investment properties than there are persons/households that are bunking with people they'd rather not be with. I'm unconvinced this is the case; it certainly seems counter to my experience.
What central banks and feds need to think about is, if they raise rates to combat high inflation, will the higher rates induce a coma in the borrowing market, thus overcorrecting the market into a high supply/low demand situation.
While your argument is logically sound, it's not the whole picture
The whole picture is complex. Anyone who predicts it correctly stands to make a lot of money.
So stagflation, with the prices going up but down in real terms.
That seems to be the best case scenario, the way to reduce overinflated asset prices without causing a panic.
And I'm pretty sure central bankers are currently dreaming of pulling this off, but it seems the market is much more aware of inflation than it was in the 70s, so I'm not sure it's more than a dream.
We already have enough housing to house everyone in the US (including the homeless) with ease. Where are we going to draw the line in the name of investment and speculation?
"With families building up savings during pandemic and increasingly working from home, demand for property is on the rise..."
"Construction cannot keep up with demand and the residential market is especially hot"
"Despite the recovery in residential construction, labour shortages, global supply chain bottlenecks and input price increases are weighing on the construction sector’s ability to expand housing supply, which is putting upward pressure on house prices"
All of those are indicative of a housing shortage, not a bubble. For the bubble to burst, a lot of underutilized housing would need to come onto the market at once, into an environment where demand is dropping. If supply is tightening and demand is expanding, that's a recipe for continued price increases, not drops.
I suspect people are saying "bubble will burst" because it's going up faster than it has in recent memory, but there's nothing special about today's prices. If supply is low and demand is high tomorrow, there's a new price equilibrium that's higher than today.