1. Until June it was impossible for a developer to issue a refund to an angry customer - Apple simply did not allow developers to do that, despite the app store being around for 13 years. This has led to untold frustration among developers - angry customers email us, leave horrible reviews, leave screeds on social media about how we “won’t” refund them, when in actually Apple reserved that right only for Apple support agents. Literally - if you forgot to cancel your Calm or Headspace subscription, neither Calm nor Headspace could give you a refund. You had to call Apple. That’s insane and leads to horrible customer experiences. (I can send you actual emails we got blasting us for this, and us pleading with them to contact Apple because we literally can’t do anything to help them).
2. You may love the Apple subscription experience, but we shouldn’t be letting Apple decide what experiences we do and don’t have online (within reason). For instance: Apple doesn’t allow subscriptions priced at less than $0.99. Why not? What if I had a product that i wanted to sell for $0.50 a month? Why should Apple get to decide that that’s not high enough? There are many examples of things like this.
3. I think we should grapple with the ideas and arguments of the author, when in this case or others, and not focus on the pedigree of the publication they write for
I’d pay $0.50 more.
I just had the unpleasant experience of canceling a non-Apple controlled service. It sucked. Pages and pages of “are you sure you want to cancel” dark patterns.
You guys did this to yourselves with absolutely shitty customer experience. Could not care less if Apple makes things harder for you. Do not care if I pay more.
App store is classic rent-seeking; it's also an economic force. So, we've pulled our app, but I'm long $AAPL
Shouldn’t Apple’s IAP actually be able to compete on its merits (like the better experience that we both prefer!) rather than arbitrary platform lock-in?
If, faced with actual competition, users and/or developers do not chose Apple IAP, wouldn’t this signal to Apple that they need to do better and improve their service?
Remove the centralization of apple driving the policy, then again to get rid of the centralization of developers choosing
Yes, users know how to shop around. That's how they buy cars, groceries, gas, computers, cellphones, etc.
The problem is that on iOS apps are forbidden from telling their users that this is an option.
It's not much of a fair market if one of the items have been removed from the shelves and you have to specifically ask for it and the price.
Is it fair if Spotify and Netflix are charged a 30% tax on Apple's platforms when Apple's services arent?
To be fair, this isn't a very apt analogy.
A better one would be to liken Apple to a smart fridge...
- Is it ok for Apple to say "only products bought through our smart fridge's grocery app can be stored in this fridge" ? --> probably not
- Is it ok for Apple to take a cut when the consumer purchases through the smart fridge's app directly? --> IMO clearly yes
- Should Apple be required to warn you that it'd be cheaper to buy the same brand of milk from a grocery store 10min walk away? --> IMO clearly no
Right now Apple prohibits developers from being transparent about what the users choices are. I think it is wrong that developers are not allowed to explain the rules to its own users.
Apple should compete on the product itself, not technicalities and obfuscation. There should be pressures on Apple to lower prices for what it charges.
Ah yes. "The market".
People forget that before Appstore mobile apps were distributed through stores controlled by mobile operators. With "store tax" at 70% or higher.
Then Apple came along and decided to take only 30%. It turns out that this (and superior phones) is exactly what users prefer.
But wait, now it's somehow not the proper "market", there's some other "proper market" that must make it right.
What would an acceptable solution to letting both styles compete? (would it be controlled by the phone's settings and the end user can change how they manage their subscriptions? Is it at the app level?)
Google, Nintendo, Sony, Microsoft all wish their app stores could be as lucrative as Apple’s, and most of these are trying to do exactly what Apple is doing.
What other product exists that is able to take such a large revenue cut from 3rd party product enhancers? Is this possible outside of software? Don’t see why Apple would give that up unless they were forced to.
The market segment that would have to resist would be the app developers themselves, but no individual app is attractive enough to do that. Even Microsoft attempted to keep Office products off iOS for quite some time. The cat is out of the bag at this point. Ironically, it seems as long as Google/Android still commands a significant market share, it's unlikely to be viewed by the courts as a monopoly. That just means Google will try harder to become like Apple, but they're going to have an even harder time back-tracking the path they've gone down.
The thing about Apple is not only have they prevented in-app payment processing, they have also prevented side-loading. This combination makes the App store so powerful. Probably some of the reason why they don't support PWAs well etc...
From the Epic decision it sounds like the courts may be inclined to allow 3rd party in-app payment processing as long as Apple still gets a cut. It's debatable which would be "worse" for end-users -- allowing them to side-load or allowing 3rd party in-app payment processing. It's probably less debatable about which one Apple prefers.
From the developer side of things, if 3rd party in-app payments are allowed and Apple still gets a cut what was gained? If Apple is forced to allow side-loading, you better believe they're going to make enabling that feature seem as scary and obscure as possible to the end-user.
Now if you file a chargeback against Apple or Google, your account with that company will almost certainly be permanently disabled, based on what I've heard from users who have done it. This is a significant setback for consumer protections, and makes it less advisable to concentrate your digital identity into either of these companies' services. However, as inconvenient as it may be to get banned from having an account with Apple/Google, it shouldn't blacklist you from using your card at any gas stations or online stores, assuming that you aren't using Apple/Google payment processing.
That being said you’d have to be purchasing from shady merchants quite a lot and using lots of chargebacks (and presumably losing them) to be blanketed.
Needless to say I don’t shop at that store anymore.
If you haven’t seen it, it’s because you’ve never read the App Store agreement. They have a table in the PDF that lists out every single price you can charge. $0.99, $1.99, $2.99, … , $999.99. Per country too. Want to charge $1.49? Sorry, it’s not on the table of prices. It’s just absurd.
Yes, in a Supermarket, they will advertise your product on your behave. But customer dont run to Kraft Heinz, Johnson & Johnson, Procter & Gamble or Coca Cola for refund. They go straight to the store they bought it with. Or a better analogy would be tools ( multi usage ) rather than consumables. Consumer buying a tool will still return their tools to Home Depot rather than making complain about the tools maker not doing refund. But with Software that is not the case. Nearly all software are treated as "services" by consumer whether they are charged with subscription or not. And customer will act the same if they bought a services from Walmart. Let say Disney+ or Netflix. They will go to Disney and Netflix to complain or refund, not Walmart.
I think this distinction is quite profound ( to me at least ). Because we often use the product analogy with Software and Subscription. We even have a term SaaS ( Software as Services ) when in fact nearly all software are in some way treated as services by consumers. And of course Software developer have long thought of it as services due to its constantly updating nature.
So this mismatch, between how App Store operate, how Apps are priced and how consumer behaves with software seems to be fundamentally wrong.
Similarly, people buying from the app store BnL don’t go back to the app store to find the developer web site and go there to look up a support phone number to ask a human if they can please cancel by physically mailing a certified letter somewhere (how you cancel most first party subscriptions). They go to the subscriptions settings and cancel.
I’d argue that is indeed exactly like Heinz vs. Walmart or whatever.
I want to cancel in one tap for any subscription. I do not want to go through shitty, abusive retention flows.
Two questions:
1. Are you fine (edit) as a consumer (/edit) paying 30% more for this, especially when you are just trading data collection from the App maker to Apple?
2. Wouldn't you rather that everyone had this protection, and not depend on the mercy of corporates for this?
I absolutely am not fine allowing Apple to charge 30% extra, especially when other payment processors only charge around 2 to 5%. And Apple forcing themselves as a middle man is more of a concern here as they have more potential to exploit me commercially, using my data, than some non-BigTech app maker. The 2nd question is more pertinent to all of us as consumers - thanks to Indian laws and regulation, I can easily unsubscribe to any service, and that protects me from exploitation both from Apple and any unscrupulous service. That is what we should all be working towards (more consumer rights). Any support for Apple on this is totally misguided - if they genuinely cared about your rights here, they wouldn't be gauging 30% of you in in-apps payment, without even telling you that money goes to Apple.
There is a difference between trusting a single company to run all your transactions through them and giving your card out to the 20+ places you subscribe to.
I trust Apple (and Google) on data security several orders of magnitude more than any generic publisher. While I may not like the privacy part, at least they tend to hold it better than any other generic app.
Several years ago there was a company similar to this called UltimateGameCard - they were a neutral third party not associated with any publisher that strictly handled paid-in-store prepaid value PINs that collected no personal information and were partnered with dozens to hundreds of game publishers, and supported hundreds of different major games (and several software publishers).
They were available in almost every store, and using them required no privacy violations. Explicitly, their largest customer base were minors (like me at the time), and not collecting PII or even name made it great and a first choice for them.
The low incidence of fraud and inability to chargeback the company (cash only in hand; and you could still dispute the game publisher via the prepaid company to get value added back) resulted in extremely low fees, to the point where games would give you bonus value if you chose this instead of a credit card or other. They had contracts with basically every major publisher - Club Penguin, Runescape, Everquest, etc, and your funds were good almost every game you'd play.
They generally respected both sides of the market: you, a 12 year old, could ask customer service if you were genuinely ripped off or accidentally claimed too much value at a specific publisher but didn't use it yet, and they would treat you like an adult. The game publisher could refund the value if you didn't spend it yet, and not be hit with any form of chargeback or dispute fee or any increase in fees at all. And since it was paid in cash, if you were lying about it or just upset you failed your loot box gamble, you got nothing back. It was also more or less publisher contract based so random IAP trash couldn't just sign up and take money - all the big names were on this.
I would love a system like this again.
Regarding #2, we didn't depend on the mercy of corporates in the PC world. I saw firsthand how annoying it is to debug my parent's computer repeatedly when random apps get installed or terms of service overstep. For less tech aware consumers this is almost certainly a win in terms of privacy and general experience.
I do not want any kind of retention, I do not want to be messaged in any way, just stop renewal. I do not want to call in, live chat, give a reason, etc.
I think that would be great, except many companies care more about holding on to users than the user itself.
But i think it's a great idea, it could even be listed as a feature/badge when signing up.
[X] Easy one-click cancellation.
It’s currently 6 taps to cancel a single subscription in Apple and 2 taps extra for each service you want to cancel right after. I love knowing that I don’t have to figure out what magical incantation I have to do to cancel any/every service I sign up for.
Also, those numbers aren't as great if you count typing a url in your tap count.
I’d be amazed if the game publisher would have cared at all. No amount of future loyalty to the one game would have offset the cost of the refund. Same is not true for Apple or Nintendo.
Businesses have cost cut and devalued support so much that it's not worth having a relationship with them. They only want a sales relationship and you're on your own when it comes to support.
What does having a relationship with them get me as a customer?
Spoken like someone who has never tried to cancel anything where they had a direct relationship with the publisher
As an individual, I would rather buy a newspaper subscription from Apple instead of paying for a 13 week subscription from the paper directly, billed monthly.
As an enterprise, I don’t want to be stuck dealing with a mercurial and pain the ass middleman like Apple for anything significant to my business. I have the market power to get terms from a company like Adobe or whatever, but with Apple, we get a very polite “Fuck you, we’re Apple, you are not Apple. Be thankful we are selling our beautiful things to you.”
The reasons why I can’t stand Apple for B2B are why they are delightful to Spooky23, the individual consumer.
Their experience is better when they signed up, mostly due to Apple's integrated API and enforcing standards.
Their experience is much worse when they have dispute. Because no user think of themselves as Apple's customers. They are using your App or Services. Telling them to go to Apple doesn't solve their problem.
If the experience is truly better, and if Apple owns every single transaction and relationship. Why is it the developers gets the blame every time when there is a problem while Apple sitting their enjoying their 15% to 30% commission?
Apple is muddling rent-seeking, developer tooling, support, discovery, distribution and services all into that 15-30%. And they happily dance around that one of these stance every time they are questioned.
So odds are subscribe through apple has better experience.
You, as a dev, may offer better, for sure. But the user cannot count on that.
I'd say the same thing. Much prefer dealing with individual app developers. I go out of my way to purchase through them over Apple. It's far more secure for me as a consumer to go through individual app developers than through Apple.
What if a person would sign up to a dating site under two separate names - would the App Store out them somehow?
RevenueCat had a decent explanation for this considering this is their main product:
https://www.revenuecat.com/blog/managing-cross-platform-subs...
Disclaimer: not at all associated with revenuecat, just in the process of evaluating their product myself.
> “The user experience is much worse,” a marketing executive from one company told me. “When you buy with the developer, they have a relationship with you ... when you buy from Apple: sorry, you’re Apple’s customer, not ours, and if you have a problem with a subscription … we can’t really help them.”
Now interview a real user of subscriptions instead of a brand marketing executive and ask them if the user experience is worse.
PS. Even when not confronted with such a piece, remember that Forbes is no longer the business journalism folks may have grown up with. For the past decade, it’s a blogging platform for independent contributors:
> Each contributor flies solo with his own blog. He is responsible for conceiving and creating the content, ensuring its accuracy and building an engaged, loyal readership. Forbes provides the technology and compensates some of the contributors, but otherwise, like all entrepreneurs, contributors are left to sink or swim on their own.
https://www.poynter.org/reporting-editing/2012/what-the-forb...