News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by unicornporn on Sunday November 14, 2021 @01:49PM (#29219470)
Oh, great timing. Just ended a conversation with some friends who had bought a dishwasher. The display for these new machines had been removed, so the only way to tell when the machine was really finished was to... Guess what? Download an app! I suppose I don't need to tell you all the permissions it asked for...
Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by Waterluvian on Sunday November 14, 2021 @01:56PM (#29219528)
Someone can make an absolute killing by creating an entire brand of “dumb” appliances that Just Work. Make them sensible quality, modern, entirely offline.
Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by bnjemian on Sunday November 14, 2021 @02:09PM (#29219647)
100% agree, I've been saying this for years. I've joked with friends that I'd call it Dumb Inc. It's (mostly) in jest, but I think there's a real mismatch of expectations with a lot of modern appliances with respect to what a consumer needs and what companies use to try and differentiate their products from the competition.

In evolutionary biology, there's this idea that "evolution is stingy" – in most cases, a species doesn't have substantially more capability than it needs to survive (human brains are an often cited exception). I kind of expect that, outside of a computer, most product design should be err on the side of being stingy too. If I buy a toaster, I don't need it to be wi-fi connected so it can send me a text notification when the toast is done. I say this satirically, but I genuinely wouldn't be surprised if one existed. Frackin' toasters.

Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by JasonFruit on Sunday November 14, 2021 @03:15PM (#29220239)
It didn't take me long to find your smart toaster. You can't use SMS, though; have to install the app.

https://www.engadget.com/2017-01-04-griffin-connects-your-to...

Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by bojangleslover on Sunday November 14, 2021 @06:47PM (#29221898)
Can't make this shit up!
Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by unicornporn on Sunday November 14, 2021 @04:57PM (#29221118)
> 100% agree, I've been saying this for years. I've joked with friends that I'd call it Dumb Inc.

The problem is that — in a not so distant future, where every company makes a large slice of its profit from selling user data — Dumb Inc. products will be a lot more expensive than the competition. As people in general are not technically competent to assess the consequences of their digital actions, they will chose the cheaper option. So, perhaps Dumb Inc. won't have mass market appeal, but I guess it could still sell to the techo elite. :)

Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by bnjemian on Sunday November 14, 2021 @07:18PM (#29222075)
Maybe – but I think this assumes that general consumers will forever be unsophisticated with respect to their privacy. That may be the case, but I think it's a bold to claim to make. In my mind, that claim goes against the current trend towards more privacy.

I also highly doubt that a manufacturer of smart products would pass a "we profit off your data" discount down to consumers. Better they pocket the additional profit and then market it as a convenience for the consumer, which I think is precisely what's happening right now.

Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by GoodbyeMrChips on Monday November 15, 2021 @04:00AM (#29225264)
> future, where every company makes a large slice of its profit from selling user data

Which is why we have the GDPR to prevent this dystopian shite!

The only people on HN who object to the GDPR are those whos scummy business model exploits user data (and those who don't realise GDPR popups only need to exist because advertisers must now ask permission to use your personal data; and so they should!).

Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by perl4ever on Sunday November 14, 2021 @07:41PM (#29222221)
But that's not how evolution works, is it? If living creatures didn't have more capability than they need to survive, they would necessarily go extinct the minute the environment changed.

Also, as I wrote in my other comment, there are "dumb" appliances on the market - the fact that most people won't search for them is exactly what makes them rare.

Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by sircastor on Sunday November 14, 2021 @03:38PM (#29220434)
I think privacy advocates think that there’s this massive untapped market of single-issue consumers who would gladly spend the extra money for this kind of thing.

I don’t think it’s there. I’d be willing to bet appliances are already a commoditized market and the margins are already painfully thin. “Absolute killing” it would not be.

Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by staticautomatic on Sunday November 14, 2021 @03:52PM (#29220564)
I doubt the appliance companies have researched it, and I say that as a product/marketing researcher.
Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by gaganyaan on Sunday November 14, 2021 @06:07PM (#29221642)
It's not just about privacy, it's also about durability and repairability.
Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by LegitShady on Sunday November 14, 2021 @02:08PM (#29219635)
they'll make a lot less of 'an absolute killing' than the devices and apps that spy on you through your phone and generate a constant revenue stream after the initial purpose.

That's why dumb devices are getting harder and harder to find. It's much easier to take advantage of users and steal their data with 'smart' devices.

Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by Waterluvian on Sunday November 14, 2021 @02:17PM (#29219728)
It’s a curve. What you’re saying is a true to a certain point. After that point the smart devices have created a sufficient market for dumb devices.
Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by LegitShady on Sunday November 14, 2021 @02:23PM (#29219785)
it depends on how much those dumb devices cost. many people are price sensitive and unaware of the privacy concerns, and the less business you have the more expensive each unit is to make, etc.

Dumb TVs are the same thing. Hard to find, and surprisingly expensive for the feature set when you do find them.

I don't currently own a TV but if there was a decent dumb TV that was decently affordable and wasn't garbage I might buy one to watch movies on.

Also on the front page

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29218381

Vizio makes more money spying on people who buy TVs than TVs themselves

Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by hunter2_ on Sunday November 14, 2021 @02:54PM (#29220054)
Could run a shadow vlan/tablet/etc. where you do absolutely nothing personal and just use it as a UI for the subsidized IoT devices. Obviously this is serious effort right now for most people, so a mass-market shim that makes it easy for all could be a successful niche.

People love the integration of a single thing in their pocket, but maybe some are getting privacy-conscious enough to have two. Think of it like a TV remote that floats around your coffee table.

Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by thebean11 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @04:29PM (#29220910)
Needing to go get the tablet from the laundry room cause you want to make toast is also abysmal UX..
Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by jdeibele on Sunday November 14, 2021 @10:17PM (#29223260)
My brother-in-law bought a Speed Queen washer because it has relatively primitive technology. As I understand it, they're aimed more at commercial users or users who want to fix their machines themselves. https://speedqueen.com/
Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by yumraj on Sunday November 14, 2021 @06:08PM (#29221649)
The problem is a certain % of HN readers and so on will but those, even pay a premium.

But the rest of the population just wants smart appliances and Nest or other smart thermostats, Ring/other key hole cameras, Alexa/other smart devices and Facebook/Instagram/TikTok/…

So, unfortunately it’s not going to be a very successful business because the dumb masses have been brainwashed into accepting these smart devices.

I think Framework would be a good test. If they are successful it may imply that there is a large enough market, otherwise all bets are off.

Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by emptyparadise on Sunday November 14, 2021 @07:33PM (#29222161)
Do people really want this stuff or are they forced to use it? When your options are either buying this IoT thing or not buying the thing at all, what can you do?
Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by yumraj on Sunday November 14, 2021 @09:48PM (#29223076)
I don't think anyone is forced to buy an Amazon Eco speaker, a Google Home or an Apple Homepod. Given that people are buying these tells me that some people want it and are willing to sacrifice privacy.

Similarly, a lot of people are willing to buy a Tesla despite all the monitoring that that car does. And so on.

So, it is obvious that a certain percentage of people don't care about privacy. Now, what is dangerous is that a substantial percentage of these people are so called tech-savvy and even people in the tech industry. So, if they don't care despite them being able to understand the privacy issues, the general population which looks at these people for buying advice is certainly not going to care.

Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by userbinator on Sunday November 14, 2021 @06:32PM (#29221806)
There's actually a pretty large market in used appliances that have been refurbished with all-new wear parts (seals, bushings, etc.) I don't think the manufacturers want to create dishwashers and other appliances that last decades anymore.
Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by mindslight on Sunday November 14, 2021 @06:46PM (#29221891)
Care to elaborate? I've got a dream of someday making an aftermarket appliance control board that could be retrofitted into different types of appliances, offering smart features - Free firmware, Free app, automation, etc (obviously without all the surveillance/lockin bullshit). I'd love to hear what else is already out there.
Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by perl4ever on Sunday November 14, 2021 @07:39PM (#29222202)
The fact that you are here, making this comment, as if there weren't any, proves there's no great market opportunity. Few people will seek out such things; instead they will continue to complain about how there aren't any.

I'm not making a general comment; I bought a washer and dryer for the first time in my life a couple years ago, GE branded, and they have no wifi, bluetooth, or even any kind of electronic display.

As it happens, I got them more for their dimensions fitting the space I had than anything else, as GE hasn't had the greatest reputation for reliability in recent years. But so far, they work fine.

Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by 01100011 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @02:13PM (#29219685)
Personally I think I prefer devices which offload the UI to a smartphone. I was thinking of something like this years ago where you could use something like Bluetooth to push a web UI so devices like thermostats would no longer need to have a shitty UI for things like programming schedules.

Unfortunately in this case the greed of the manufacturer hoping to monetize their UI has ruined an otherwise decent idea(although the device really should function on some basic level without a phone).

Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by MBCook on Sunday November 14, 2021 @02:48PM (#29220000)
What happens in two or three years when they decide to stop updating the app and it no longer works on your phone?

They couldn’t bother since there was no recurring revenue stream so you just have to buy a new dishwasher?

Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by 34679 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @03:20PM (#29220286)
I believe the other person was talking about having the devices serve up webpage UIs, so you wouldn't need their specific app, just a browser. A lot of makers do this with their 3D printers and CNC machines, as it avoids the cost and hassle of installing a display on the machine.

Two of the more popular ones, for those interested:

octoprint.org

cnc.js.org

Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by MBCook on Sunday November 14, 2021 @05:33PM (#29221386)
You’re right. They were. My mistake.

Personally I don’t like those either. I’ve experienced it with printers (which can only be configured initially via USB and some app), 3D printers (configured by putting an SD card in your computer), and other gizmos. They’re all a pain to deal with, especially if your WiFi details change or their IP does.

Some others expect you to connect to THEIR Wi-Fi network instead. Which is also a complete pain.

I don’t mind having an app to make the device more useful, but it needs to have enough controls on the front to use the thing and preferably reconfigure the Wi-Fi if necessary.

Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by 01100011 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @11:18PM (#29223644)
At the time I was considering it, I figured there should be a dedicated protocol for serving things like this. Something simple, like a subset of bluetooth, with easy discoverability. Sort of like NFC perhaps. Something that you can implement with minimal software and hardware support. Obviously you risk the protocol dying and devices becoming bricks. I'm not sure how you avoid that.
Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by dotancohen on Monday November 15, 2021 @03:11AM (#29224981)

  > Something simple, like a subset of bluetooth, with easy discoverability
Sounds like a security vulnerability waiting to happen. I can image every 3D printer in range printing a dildo.
Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by dredmorbius on Sunday November 14, 2021 @08:06PM (#29222402)
And when the webpage is no longer updated?

Heck, we've even seen that model simply to use goods you've purchased, as with digital restrictions malignant books, music, videos, and games, where the restrictions-management servers were discontinued and access to the goods (bads) bought requiring them became useless.

Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by mitchdoogle on Monday November 15, 2021 @12:38AM (#29224106)
The device itself is serving up the webpage. It doesn't get updated. It's connected to the network and you visit the ip address or whatever
Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by dredmorbius on Monday November 15, 2021 @02:16AM (#29224689)
Ah, got it.

Though there is still the prospect of broken or insecure applications. Depending on the specific use case, that might or might not be an issue.

Though there's the casino whose network was hacked through a fish tank:

http://www.businessinsider.com/hackers-stole-a-casinos-datab...

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16844462

Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by mitchdoogle on Monday November 15, 2021 @12:41AM (#29224128)
3d printers and CNC machines almost always involve using a computer anyway and good chance they are physically connected. Not the case with my washing machine or toaster
Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by JasonFruit on Sunday November 14, 2021 @03:16PM (#29220246)
Or if Apple decides their devices can be .08mm thinner without Bluetooth?
Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by msrenee on Sunday November 14, 2021 @05:02PM (#29221148)
Then how would they sell their headphones?
Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by taneq on Sunday November 14, 2021 @06:48PM (#29221903)
New incompatible protocol, duh! :P
Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by nicbou on Sunday November 14, 2021 @04:56PM (#29221112)
I'm not a big fan of this. If I want to see a device's status, I look at it. Or in the case of certain devices, I listen for a specific hum. This requires no setup and no maintenance. I can check the status of my washing machine, as can anyone else in the house.
Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by JohnFen on Sunday November 14, 2021 @09:42PM (#29223033)
I agree. Having to use a computer to check the status of a machine is very inconvenient compared to just looking at the machine.
Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by JohnFen on Sunday November 14, 2021 @09:40PM (#29223020)
> Personally I think I prefer devices which offload the UI to a smartphone.

In concept, I agree. As you mention, in practice, the apps used nearly always collect data about you and the use of your devices to send back to the mothership.

That makes their use unacceptable to me. Requiring the use of a smartphone app is a showstopper.

But even if that wasn't the case, it seems odd to require me to provide a device of my own in order to use a machine. There are a lot of people who don't own a smartphone at all (and I will join their ranks once my current one dies). Why exclude that part of the market?

Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by npteljes on Monday November 15, 2021 @07:06AM (#29226428)
This could be great, if the interfaces were to adhere to some standard. Like, if there was a single web server on a chip thingie which would expose http endpoints, and even that could be replaced with something else, because the signals that it sends on the wires are also documented.

But of course, this lessens the control of the manufacturers, and increases the control of the users. So it won't happen until it's up to the manufacturers.

Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by nitwit005 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @05:19PM (#29221267)
It's innevitable it will ho wrong though. Apple or Google bans the app, millions of dollars of hardware bricked.
Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by thaumasiotes on Sunday November 14, 2021 @04:46PM (#29221045)
> The display for these new machines had been removed, so the only way to tell when the machine was really finished was to... Guess what?

Welll....

The display on my dishwasher technically exists. It is set on the top face of the panel, facing up into the counter, so it cannot be seen when the dishwasher is closed.

I'm not sure who thought of this, but it must have been approved by multiple people to appear on a real, already-manufactured dishwasher. Every one of those people was apparently terrible at their job.

Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by treis on Sunday November 14, 2021 @05:00PM (#29221137)
Mine is like that. Looks better, IMHO. There's a red light that's projected on the ground to tell you if it is running or not.
Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by jay3ss on Sunday November 14, 2021 @05:05PM (#29221166)
This is an awful, consumer hostile trend. I have a Bose sound bar that requires an app, account, and internet and blue tooth connection just to change the settings. Luckily it has a remote so I can use it without any of those things, but it can only change the volume and power the device on/off. I only kept it because the sound is good and it was a gift.
Re:There may be a steep privacy cost if you park here by evenw on Sunday November 14, 2021 @06:39PM (#29221841)
The default "happy path" for new Samsung televisions is to be set up through an app. A mandatory step is to allow background location tracking permissions.