Personally I don’t like those either. I’ve experienced it with printers (which can only be configured initially via USB and some app), 3D printers (configured by putting an SD card in your computer), and other gizmos. They’re all a pain to deal with, especially if your WiFi details change or their IP does.
Some others expect you to connect to THEIR Wi-Fi network instead. Which is also a complete pain.
I don’t mind having an app to make the device more useful, but it needs to have enough controls on the front to use the thing and preferably reconfigure the Wi-Fi if necessary.
> Something simple, like a subset of bluetooth, with easy discoverability
Sounds like a security vulnerability waiting to happen. I can image every 3D printer in range printing a dildo.Heck, we've even seen that model simply to use goods you've purchased, as with digital restrictions malignant books, music, videos, and games, where the restrictions-management servers were discontinued and access to the goods (bads) bought requiring them became useless.
Though there is still the prospect of broken or insecure applications. Depending on the specific use case, that might or might not be an issue.
Though there's the casino whose network was hacked through a fish tank:
http://www.businessinsider.com/hackers-stole-a-casinos-datab...
Two of the more popular ones, for those interested:
octoprint.org
cnc.js.org