My dad worked on a couple of standards, and while he wasn't paid by the standards body he didn't work for free. He was employed at a company and the company paid him his salary. Working on those standards was just another part of his day job.
If I donate food to a food bank, would it be fair for someone else to say “That food wasn’t donated for free! A store got paid for that food!” No, of course not.
See also: https://satwcomic.com/every-time
That's exactly my point. The standard _organization_ gets the work for free, but the standard _writers_ are almost always paid for their work and aren't working for free. The original comment made it sound like the standard writers where somehow being exploited or where donating their time to the standard organization.
In your analogy the writer is the food store, and the company is the person that bought the food to donate.
No, I read it as pointing out that ISO does not need to be paid in order to pay its contributors, since ISO does not pay its contributors. The point was about ISO, not its contributors.
It's basically all a wastage, because an electronic record keeping and content management system can be cheaply administered, rather than as an organization.
And? If the authors didn't think they got any benefits—or rather, the companies employing the authors and paying them—didn't think they got any benefit, then they wouldn't make the work on ISO standards part of their job.
Just because the benefit is non-financial does not mean there is no benefit.
People have recognized that having common standards is a general benefit to society. For a history of this see Engineering Rules: Global Standard Setting Since 1880 by Craig Murphy and JoAnne Yates (ISBN 9781421440033):
* https://jhupbooks.press.jhu.edu/title/engineering-rules
ISO has bills and overhead to cover, just like anyone else. Just because some of its work is covered by 'donated' effort doesn't mean all of it can.
(I wouldn't object to having ISO standards being freely available, it's just that I can see some reasons for why they are not.)
Whether the author needs that money or not is not the point, you would surely feel angry at the pricing, and would wish the author had put it on his website instead (where you could grab it for free), Amazon had priced it more fairly (paying for shipping and some overhead is fine but not $50), or the book had been authored by some GitHub organization in the open.
Not if the author agreed to this arrangement ahead of time.
I'm not against the standards being freely available if it can be arranged, I just find it slightly annoying that many people seem to be acting like ISO is some moustache-twirling, evil mega-corp that is exploiting the workers because it charges a fee currently.
I'm sure the few people that work directly for ISO aren't feeling particularly exploited. neither are the standards authors - at least when I was doing it everyone was a well-paid engineer who enjoyed the travel and the work.
the issue is that the role of standards is best fulfilled by making them as widely available as possible. and its really not clear from an economic perspective what value ISO as an organization independent of its contributors is providing.
the IETF has a pretty reasonable track record technically, and there was never any notion about charging for standards access.
I think the burden of proof here is on ISO to show that the negative impacts of restricting distribution have any positive aspects at all.
edit: you know what, forget that. I'm pretty sure their primary cost is billing and IP enforcement. since they owe their privileged position to international treaty..its very difficult to perceive ISO as anything other than parasitic.
2020 annual report, finances:
* https://www.iso.org/ar2020.html#section-finances
* https://www.iso.org/annual-reports.html
Expenditures were 35M CHF, income was 40M CHF, for a net result of 5M CHF. "Royalties received from members selling ISO standards" was 12M CHF.
If they can make up that money elsewhere then they could stop charging.
* the ISO needs to pay the bills
* part of their income is charging for standards
* the folks that work to together to write the standards agree not to ask for a cut of the proceeds of the sale
* some folks want ISO standards to be free
2020 annual report, finances:
* https://www.iso.org/ar2020.html#section-finances
* https://www.iso.org/annual-reports.html
Expenditures were 35M CHF, income was 40M CHF, for a net result of 5M CHF. "Royalties received from members selling ISO standards" was 12M CHF.
If the ISO can make up that money elsewhere then they could stop charging.
Authors get paid a small royalty; publishers set the price and get most of the scratch
this is a nonsense claim - in almost all cases they’re paid by their employers.
Yes, the writer is typically employed by a relevant company. They're not working for free. But the body from which you must buy the standard is getting it for free.
This is exactly the same problem academia is facing. The big journal companies charge huge amounts for access to journals, but don't pay for their production. That's funded by universities.
In both cases, the bodies collating these documents are rent seekers making far more money than their services are worth.
The standards body _is_ its members. It's not practically a separate company - it's a vehicle for the members.
For details, check out their 2020 financials page: https://www.iso.org/ar2020.html#section-finances
I am only highlighting how proceeds from the sale of ISO standards are not being distributed to ISO members, including national standardization bodies, nor any contributors.
I'd hope that country ISO members would push for their membership fees to cover for distribution of standards for free (even if it meant increasing those fees) — that'd be a much more sensible approach IMHO. Or they could optimize slightly not to need those royalty fees in the first place.
To add insult to injury, some of those "employers" actually pay further fees to standardization bodies.
And? If the authors didn't think they got any benefits—or rather, the companies employing the authors and paying them—didn't think they got any benefit, then they wouldn't make the work on ISO standards part of their job.
Just because the benefit is non-financial does no mean there is not benefit.
People have recognized that having common standards is a general benefit to society. For a history of this see Engineering Rules: Global Standard Setting Since 1880 by Craig Murphy and JoAnne Yates (ISBN 9781421440033):
* https://jhupbooks.press.jhu.edu/title/engineering-rules
ISO has bills and overhead to cover, just like anyone else. Just because some of its work is covered by 'donated' effort doesn't mean all of it can.
(I wouldn't object to having ISO standards being freely available, it's just that I can see some reasons for why they are not.)
I guess what we perceive differently is how much work is "donated": I'd say most of it is (which does not make your statement untrue, but "some" implies a lesser part of it).
Nobody is doubting the need for common standards and the need to pay for them: this is why there are membership fees, and ISO has collected half of its revenue on those — https://www.iso.org/ar2020.html#section-finances. IMHO, it should optimize in a way to make its entire operations possible on that revenue (if that involves increasing fees or becoming more frugal is up to them).
I'm not against the standards being freely available if it can be arranged, I just find it slightly annoying that many people seem to be acting like ISO is some moustache-twirling, evil mega-corp that is exploiting the workers because it charges a fee currently.
Nobody is acting as if they are exploiting anyone, but many are unaware of the situation above. Whether one finds that fair is up to everyone individually, but perhaps you can allow that finding it unfair is a reasonable viewpoint as well?
Isn’t this normal in life? Most people are paid salaries or contracts for a job, not a proportion of sales.
An engineer at Google is paid to build an advert system but they don’t get a proportion of the advert fees.
> some of those "employers" actually pay further fees
Why have you put employers in scare quotes? Do you doubt they’re employing anyone?
And they don’t have to put anyone on the committee writing the standard if they don’t want to.
The company may have employees that write the standard, that's immaterial. You're equating "Author" with "Employee" rather than "Company"
It's not supposed to be a money-making opportunity.
Or they could become more frugal. Eg. simply by removing the overhead of managing *sale" of electronic documents, they could optimize at least a little bit.
Membership fees are stable, yet royalties are fluctuating. As a non-profit, they've got to end the year on 0, so they'll always spend whatever they earn.
My trick is to, for technical stuff, look for working groups and their mailing lists or other collaborative spaces, which are sometimes in the public, and get the latest working draft that they put out before it was turned into an official standard.
That's how I learned C in-depth in my high school days from the C9X (became C99 :)) draft standard.
Edit: clarify that ISO is not paying for the work being done on the standard, instead of that "writers usually do all the work for free".