Because me sending random cash to the federal government does absolutely nothing, and higher taxes can pay for actual programs. There's a huge difference between exempting yourself from a new mandate you enforce on everyone else, and simply waiting for a universal mandate before acting yourself.
Libraries, fire stations, universal K-12 education? Certainly imperfect, but def benefit from coordination. Health care too - a lack of universal coordination makes life difficult.
On the private sector side, many companies are great examples of coordination payoffs (I trade entrepreneurial risk/reward for consistent benefits).
Why though? If you found out that many members of MADD had installed these devices would it change your opinion on requiring it for everyone else? If you found that someone campaigning for higher tax rates actually did make generous contributions, would it change your opinion on raising the rates? Somehow I suspect not, in fact I would hope you wouldn't be so easily swayed! So then we've not pushed the argument forward at all, just taken a detour down an irrelevant cul-de-sac in the hopes of finding a gotcha.
At least I would respect the argument. Right now I see too many people proposing the use of force to achieve something they don't believe in enough to do themselves.
Which really just means 'no.' So like I said, just a big waste of time, the argument for or against these drunk-driving systems is about whether the good for society is worth the cost not about who's making the argument or whether you respect them.
I don’t own a car, so no. But a bike is my primary means of traffic. Do I get no say in traffic safety that impacts me?
> Person saying taxes should be higher for everyone -- what's stopping them from paying more right now?
I also do this. California allows tax payers to pay taxes to a couple dozen special funds. I usually kick in extra for the rape kit tests and coastal preservation funds.
BTW, arguing bothsideism is one of the least effective ways to analyze policy. Focus on the specifics. Even though I support this mandate, one of the downsides is it costs $80/month to keep ignition locks calibrated. How does the federal government plan to make this equitable?
I write this as someone who has both been hit by a drunk bike rider and unintentionally hurt in a bar fight that wasn’t even involving me.
See all the morality crusaders who are also secretly sexting teenagers
However, I can with zero hypocrisy argue that everyone should have to do this before being allowed on the road, including myself. We can't tell who needs to have these installed, so we have to specify "everybody" for it to be effective. That would cover myself, which is annoying, but I would still gain a benefit from it would decrease my chances of someone else crashing into me while drunk.
And, I should not need to tell you this, but what is stopping me from paying higher taxes right now is that that is not a thing you can do. There is no voluntary tax payment.
They have the opportunity to get one person closer to "everybody" but choose not to, so instead they choose to use the government to force people to do this.
You argue that the marginal benefit of you doing it on your own is too little for you to do it. Then you propose using force to add up a whole lot of "too littles" to make into something.
>If I do not drink and drive, why would I pay money to install a system to detect if I drink and drive? I would be throwing money out the window for zero gain.
And they propose to make millions of people waste this money when they don't believe in it enough to do it for themselves.
No, I argue that the benefit is zero, since I do not drive drunk, and the device will prevent exactly zero instances of drunk driving.
> And they propose to make millions of people waste this money when they don't believe in it enough to do it for themselves.
Please re-read my post. I explained the reasoning there already. The point is that:
a) We do not know who needs to have this installed.
b) That means the only way for it to be effective is to make everyone install it.
c) However, I know that I am not one of those who needs it installed, therefore, there is zero benefit to me installing it on my own.
All of this is perfectly non-hypocritical.
“I’ll believe in Climate Change when people stop flying in private jets”
“People can always pay more taxes on their own.”
“People should give up fossil fuels if they believe in climate change “
Sounds like you’ve bought into how we play politics.
When we discuss inflation it’s:“Remember Jimmy Carter”
No one ever discusses the Fed, etc and the causes of inflation.
Oh well, at least try not to be part of the problem and understand that it’s mostly about manipulating people emotionally
Source please.
Even if what you are saying is true, are you claiming that installing these devices on the cars of people who routinely drive drunk would not save lives?
Source - me. I'm sure. Please read carefully.
Also, it's not like they've presented large scale trials of this working.
> Even if what you are saying is true, are you claiming that installing these devices on the cars of people who routinely drive drunk would not save lives?
Am I claiming that? The discussion is about putting devices on all cars, not repeat offenders, so no.
Classy.
> Am I claiming that? The discussion is about putting devices on all cars, not repeat offenders, so no.
And yet, "cars of repeat offenders" is a subset of "all cars".
Now, I think cameras in our cars is something I hate and will fight against for other reasons, but your whole "do it yourself before mandating others" is a bad faith argument that makes no sense and is only used to distract from practical solutions in many areas.
And we already have systems for putting these systems in people's cars after they drive drunk. This new system is specifically targeting people who haven't been caught driving drunk. As such, MADD and Congress are absolutely in the targeted demographic for this bill. Frankly, given how often congresspeople get caught driving drunk, they should be probably be the first group to get them.
I would be utterly stunned if Congress isn't somehow exempt though. They'll leave a loophole for themselves, probably via not requiring the sensors to be retrofitted on imported cars or similar.
Of course I understand what it's like when you've been reigning in frustration and then it boils over, but still—we all need to take responsibility not for venting that into the threads here.
https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
Edit: you've unfortunately been breaking the site guidelines like this multiple times recently. Can you please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and take the intended spirit of the site more to heart? It's not ok to lash out at others, call names, go on the attack, etc., just because they're wrong or you feel they are. That doesn't help anyone.
No, I absolutely don't think they need it. Nor do I need it. But the discussion is about putting it in cars for everyone. They think I need to have a more expensive car, but they don't want to make their own cars more expensive until they can mandate that I do as well.
> "do it yourself before mandating others" is a bad faith argument
It's not a bad faith argument, and I've tried to live my life like this. One major consideration when I left the military is that as I moved up in rank I was going to have to enforce rules that I wouldn't actually follow myself.
People are very quick to use the force of law on others.
> Your stupid ass ideology is harming your ability to view the world practically. I'll keep my ideology, thank you. Leadership isn't about driving the people before me.
I was in the military when Congress banned smoking in much of the military and other federal buildings but exempted themselves.
Person saying taxes should be higher for everyone -- what's stopping them from paying more right now?
If it's a step I haven't already taken myself, I can't even conceive of mandating that everyone do it before I start, but that's just too alien a concept it seems.
In a similar bit of hypocrisy, I feel the same way about drinking underage and the number of people who are perfectly ok ramping up punishments for the same "crimes" they themselves committed -- it's just the timeline in a different direction now.