News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020) by rtkwe on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:08AM (#29162702)
Except it seems he forgot to invert the question of "How would I design an absolutely depressing and dangerous place to live?" then came up with that design.
Re:Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020) by shwoopdiwoop on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:21AM (#29162869)
Except all the outrage came from people who never lived in his buildings, and the ones who did gave it overwhelmingly great reviews.
Re:Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020) by rtkwe on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:41AM (#29163183)
Are you talking about the U of Michigan graduate dorms? Those seem like a vastly different design and people have some thoughts on the whole windowless thing from COVID when they couldn't use the suite's common area.

For starters the units are much smaller and each suite of rooms has it's own little semi-public area instead of being a completely windowless block like his new design. The difference between the two is vast.

https://detroit.cbslocal.com/2021/11/03/heres-what-its-like-...

https://i.redd.it/81yfb7wkxby51.jpg

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=__cfVWiAxSU

Re:Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020) by csdvrx on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @12:24PM (#29164488)
> the whole windowless thing from COVID when they couldn't use the suite's common area.

Here's a daring thought: maybe the problem isn't the windowless bedroom by itself, but the idea that it's acceptable to lock people inside their own residence, or even to forbid people to use the common areas of their own residence.

Re:Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020) by rtkwe on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @12:50PM (#29164865)
That's largely tangential from the issues with the UCSB dorm and there were complaints well before the COVID lockdowns so we shouldn't get mired in the unrelated morass of the pandemic response.
Re:Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020) by hinkley on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:45AM (#29164004)
I'd like to hear more from sam0x17 (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29163439) on this topic.

I think OP has confirmation bias. Lots of armchair criticism != only armchair criticism. I've lived in plenty of buildings that don't rate a rant and yet I would never live in again. And I've had friends who've lived in worse and I was so glad when they moved so I didn't have to visit their old shithole. Are we gatekeeping complaints from visitors?

Re:Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020) by mitchdoogle on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:43AM (#29163204)
The reviews I saw all painted the lack if windows as a major negative. Something worth tolerating because of the building's central location. The residents who had to stay there during the pandemic, when communal areas were not so utilized, were even more critical, describing it as "depressing"
Re:Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020) by jquery on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:58AM (#29163432)
Rave reviews? It seems low quality paid reviews are worth every penny.

https://www.reddit.com/r/UCSantaBarbara/comments/qkmp5h/i_wa...

Re:Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020) by adewinter on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:23AM (#29162902)
The building has not yet been built.
Re:Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020) by nisegami on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:28AM (#29162965)
This is not his first time designing dorms: https://housing.umich.edu/residence-hall/munger/
Re:Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020) by rtkwe on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:53AM (#29163362)
The difference between Munger Hall [2] and the new UCSB dorm [1] is vast. For starters you go from a 7 person common room being your nearest real light to a 60-70 person common room being your nearest indoor natural light. The Michigan dorm has a fraction of the people living in it total, larger rooms and amenities that would be hard to include in the UCSB simply because there's so many more people in that doom.

You expect a quality difference between graduate apartments and undergraduate dorms but saying one is well received (with complaints about the lack of windows and lights in the bedrooms btw) so this different design must also be secretly ok is stretching things.

[1] https://static.dezeen.com/uploads/2021/11/munger-hall-univer... [2] https://i.redd.it/81yfb7wkxby51.jpg

Re:Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020) by woodruffw on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:28AM (#29162968)
The building is apparently in the same mould as a highly-rated[1] one already in use at the University of Michigan. The people (graduate students?) who live there seem to like it more than any other campus housing option.

[1]: https://www.veryapt.com/Apartments-L7646-ann-arbor-central-c...

Re:Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020) by chaosite on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:36AM (#29163096)
It is not in the same mould at all. Reposting my previous comment:

OK, I found an article with a floorplan[1]. This thing is not at all comparable to the Michigan dorms. Recall, in the Michigan dorms you have an apartment housing 7 people with a spacious, well-lit living room (6 windows, but the count isn't important.) Sure, you don't have a window in your bedroom, and that sucks, but to see the sun you just go through that one door.

But in this proposed building? Look at that insane floor plan[2]! It looks like a maze! If you're in one of those inner rooms, you exit your bedroom (no windows) into your apartment's common area (no windows), exit that to a long corridor that eventually leads to your "House's" common area, which finally has windows. But is the opposite way from the building's exit.

Yeah this thing is insane.

[1] https://www.dezeen.com/2021/11/02/architect-resigns-grotesqu... [2] https://static.dezeen.com/uploads/2021/11/munger-hall-univer...

Re:Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020) by hinkley on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @12:00PM (#29164203)
I wonder if the rendering is a lie, or there are a small number of bedrooms that have private windows in them?

I think the main mistakes here are that he made the building bilaterally symmetrical and it should instead be along four quadrants. Additionally, there should be an atrium in the center providing additional windows for the middle of the building.

That many students sharing a single TV every evening is not going to work out, and if you want a 'study space' (which is psychologically healthy and strategic), you'll have to do it in the main entertainment area or leave the building.

Each 'house' at this size should have 2 public areas, and there should probably be one house at each corner, and one at each face, rather than 4 corners and 2 on the same face.

Re:Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020) by CalChris on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:46AM (#29163257)
The Munger Graduate Residences do not have a CostCo for a penthouse.
Re:Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020) by d23 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:27AM (#29162949)
There was a similarly designed building someone linked to in a previous thread that had rave reviews pre-Covid.
Re:Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020) by milesskorpen on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:28AM (#29162966)
There is a smaller version of it at UMich: https://www.mlive.com/news/ann-arbor/2015/07/heres_your_firs...
Re:Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020) by rtkwe on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:10AM (#29163597)
Smaller with fewer people sharing a common space and better amenities. The differences between the two designs are vast. Also a lot of people complain about the lack of windows in the rooms but give it a positive review because of amenities. I've talked more about the differences in other comments I won't rehash.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29163183

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29163362

Re:Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020) by jquery on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:33AM (#29163050)
I wouldn’t describe “you’ll get used to lack of windows” as rave reviews. It looks suspiciously like the reviews were farmed out, the english is atrocious and the reviews are very generic.
Re:Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020) by nostromo on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:48AM (#29163287)
It looks like it was designed in Prison Architect.
Re:Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020) by hindsightbias on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:31AM (#29163016)
If we’re going to need people to populate austere environments lile Mars, we’re going to need people used to living without windows.

Works for the Navy.

Re:Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020) by dymk on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:33AM (#29163046)
This is housing for undergrads on sunny coastal California, not the navy
Re:Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020) by busterarm on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:50AM (#29163322)
We're always just one declared war away from changing that.

Your life's circumstances can change at a moment's notice. You could fall and have a devastating brain injury. Being comfortable with your circumstances can mostly only come from within.

Re:Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020) by bagels on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:13AM (#29163639)
Bad things can happen, therefore, we should not discourage bad things from happening?
Re:Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020) by busterarm on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:20AM (#29163725)
Having a windowless bedroom isn't some terrible tragedy that happens to you. It's a minor inconvenience and bit of adversity that is temporary. Probably about 20% of all of the people that I know who moved to New York to pursue their dreams lived for at least a year in an illegal windowless-bedroom shared apartment (they exist because there is demand for cheap housing).

Young people need to be challenged with small bits of adversity from time to time to overcome instead of being coddled and incapable of dealing with real, adult problems by themselves.

I say this as someone who had to drop out of college and become homeless before really getting on my feet in my mid-20s. So many of my peers bitch and moan and live NEET lifestyles as they're pushing 40 because their parents and society promised them the world after college and they never learned that nothing is achieved without hard work.

Re:Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020) by dymk on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:35AM (#29163898)
This is a good example of pointless suffering and self flagellation
Re:Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020) by busterarm on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @12:04PM (#29164262)
"suffering".

We're talking about UCSB students here.

It's a school where wealthy, well-connected parents and administrators collude to skirt the rules to get their children admitted. It's a school where wealthy Chinese nationals send their children, because admissions is less competitive than the Chinese university admissions process and offers a better chance for their children.

It's ranked 5th out of all public universities. None of those kids are suffering and I would suggest you reevaluate what suffering is.

Re:Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020) by mitchdoogle on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:39AM (#29163130)
Mars? That's your best argument? We're on Earth, so let's design for Earth.
Re:Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020) by busterarm on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:09AM (#29163593)
Not Mars. "like Mars". The conversation is really about austere environments.

Given current trends, Earth is likely to be full of austere living conditions in the future. Do you want to learn how to survive now or have to scramble to figure it out when it happens?

Re:Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020) by hindsightbias on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @12:19PM (#29164436)
HN was pretty enthusiastic about pod housing/hotels back in the day. Hip solution for affordable urban housing. All these tiny home homeless neighborhoods aren't much more than a closet even if they have a tiny window usually covered with foil or cardboard.
Re:Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020) by mattnewton on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:48AM (#29163289)
The navy pays people to live like that; the university is charging people. Not sure this is comparable.
Re:Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020) by busterarm on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:54AM (#29163367)
If the education were worth a damn, people would be climbing over each other to get into those dorms.

The juice not being worth the squeeze is not the dorms' fault.

Re:Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020) by rtkwe on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:35AM (#29163905)
The goal when designing something isn't to be as shitty as will be tolerated. And people are doing lots to get these educations... going massively in debt seems like a pretty strong indicator that people want the education I'd say.
Re:Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020) by busterarm on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @12:16PM (#29164379)
Correlation != Causation.

American kids go massively into debt because their parents, their legislators and their universities have largely failed them. Kids aren't given a proper financial education before making the biggest financial decision of their lives. Laws were written to make student debt the most secure form of debt ever for lenders. Schools flush with public money have done nothing but increase the costs of education in ways that are often hardly visible or impactful for their students.

American students get an incredibly poor ROI for their education on average. Pick your degree wisely.

Re:Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020) by rtkwe on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @09:07AM (#29174754)
> Correlation != Causation.

So people not clamoring to live in a shit windowless shoebox of a dorm might not reflect on the quality of the education?

Re:Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020) by busterarm on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @10:23AM (#29175572)
Students will deal with it for the eduation.

I'm aware of a far less prestigious school where when they ran out of dorms they converted an abandoned super 8 motel for 3 years and the building was absolutely filthy and in terrible shape (it needed a new roof) and it was still full of students.

Re:Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020) by dangerwill on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:49AM (#29163307)
How about you trial this first and then come back to us? Might find that there is a reason for shore leave in the Navy