News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by stevebmark on Monday November 08, 2021 @04:26PM (#29154494)
From the outside, it looks like Jony Ive was only able to get away with the damaging push to flat design after Steve Jobs died, and since Ive has left Apple, beautiful skeuomorphic gradients, lighting, embosses, drop shadows, and photo-real elements, have started to return. His legacy is a deep stain on the design industry that we are only now beginning to recover from. The loss of accessibility and beauty from only using flat design has set us back a long way.
Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by Osmium on Monday November 08, 2021 @04:56PM (#29154765)
> His legacy is a deep stain on the design industry

This is a rather extreme statement. A person's career can be long and complex, involve many projects, not all of which will be successful. We all learn.

From the outside, it seems that Jony Ive was successful in a lot of endeavors, was successful in creating a disciplined design culture, and yes, sometimes, went too far (it seems) but even that kind of exploration can be useful for how it informs future work.

Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by petilon on Monday November 08, 2021 @06:21PM (#29155641)
Let's consider Jony's performance on software design first. This is what some prominent people have said about iOS 7, which was the first flat-design iOS: The Verge wrote in their review: "iOS 7 isn't harder to use, just less obvious. That's a momentous change: iOS used to be so obvious."

In iOS 7 basic usability features such as making buttons look like buttons are now stuffed under Accessibility options. About this, Tumblr co-founder Marco Arment wrote: "If iOS 8 can’t remove any of these options, it's a design failure." (And iOS 8 didn't.)

Michael Heilemann, Interface Director at Squarespace wrote, "when I look at [iOS 7 beta] I see anti-patterns and basic mistakes that should have been caught on the whiteboard before anyone even began thinking about coding it." And famed blogger John Gruber said this about iOS 7: "my guess is that [Steve Jobs] would not have supported this direction."

And what about Jony's other responsibility, industrial design? The iPod, iPhone, iPad, MacBook Air and other Apple products from Jobs era are all amazingly well designed and breathtakingly beautiful. But these products weren't designed by Jony Ive all by himself. He designed them under Steve Jobs's guidance and direction. Steve was the tastemaker. Apple's post-Steve products are nowhere near as well-designed.

Consider iPhone 5c, for example, which was the first post-Steve-Jobs design. The colors were horrid, and when you add those Crocs-like cases it looks more like a Fisher-Price toy than like a device an executive would want to be seen holding. Then they released some ads for the 5c, and I kid you not, one of the ads had sounds of bleating farm animals. (It was titled "Every color has a story", published on tumblr.) That the 5c didn't do well in the market shouldn't surprise anyone.

Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by kergonath on Monday November 08, 2021 @08:59PM (#29156812)
It all is debatable. Apple regularly backtracked after having gone too far in one direction. See e.g. the dialling back of translucency after OS X 10.1, and of brushed metal after Panther. The break in iOS 7 was extreme, but the same people whining about Ive were whining about skeumorphism a couple of months before.

Jobs had good taste, but was not infallible either. And he could not have designed a computer if his life depended on it. Saying that Ive has nothing to do with the iMac, iPod, iPhone, Cube, PowerBooks and MacBooks is very myopic, to beat the least.

Looking back, Apple kept being Apple and not much changed when Jobs died. Well, the keynotes are less interesting now. But product development does not look too different. Occasional mistakes are still made, and occasionally fixed. It was so before both Ive and Jobs, and it will still be that way after them.

Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by saagarjha on Monday November 08, 2021 @09:54PM (#29157182)
You’re seeing what you want to see. Ive tried many things throughout his career, from colorful transparent plastic all the way to deep black metal. iPhone 5c was perhaps the most comfortable iPhone iPhone to hold, and it came it a variety of bright colors that Apple overcorrected for afterwards and only recently has started to embrace again. Its poor sales were likely due to its high perceived price and lack of features, rather than its design.
Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by birdyrooster on Monday November 08, 2021 @07:29PM (#29156202)
Don’t forget the cavernous spaceship with acoustics and privacy issues that has caused many an engineer to loathe working in it. That was his design too.
Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by GhettoComputers on Monday November 08, 2021 @08:09PM (#29156474)
I completely agree. His exit signaled the return of flat screens rather than the terrible curved glass edges, slippery corners and the mess of designing for design’s sake. I don’t know if he was responsible for the butterfly keyboard but I wouldn’t be surprised.
Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by Andrew_nenakhov on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @12:48AM (#29158186)
I'm mostly and android user, but ios7+ flat design with translucency is way better than the old ways. Just remember, how ugly the stock buttons were! Whenever I see screenshots of old apple interfaces it makes me want to throw up.
Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by GrifMD on Monday November 08, 2021 @08:08PM (#29156464)
I really liked the iPhone 5c's design. The colors were fun, and the case options weren't super bland. The 5 was there to fill in the need for more traditional iPhone design, but the 5c felt like a little throwback to when phones were a little more fun and weird.
Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by quartesixte on Monday November 08, 2021 @10:05PM (#29157241)
Also back to the fun colors of the iPod’s later years.

All this brushed silver/gold/black bores me. I am very glad Apple has decided to embrace colors once again.

Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by hadlock on Monday November 08, 2021 @06:38PM (#29155784)
Johnny Ive pushed design deeply into "lowest common denominator" territory, to the point that I've seen a lot of features flat out cut from products simply because the UI/UX team couldn't make enough white space on the screen to hold them all. Ives did not invent "more white space is better" but he certainly embraced it and helped push out complexity at all costs in the name of usability.
Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by simonklitj on Monday November 08, 2021 @04:38PM (#29154611)
I disagree with you, I think it was a much needed reboot to the concept of design, and the future will be all the brighter for it. Accessibility is more on everyone’s mind today than ever before, and I think skeumorphism’s accessibility was more of a side effect than an intended effect.

I’ll gladly be proven wrong though, but design wise I’d absolutely hate to go back to pre 2012.

Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by mc32 on Monday November 08, 2021 @05:45PM (#29155288)
But often times flat design lacks hints or affordances which is the opposite of accessibility.
Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by Retric on Monday November 08, 2021 @07:07PM (#29156040)
I am just glad flat designs look really dated. Skeuomorphic accessibility was very much an early design goal, the issue is it lived so far past it’s origin that people forgot why it was built that way in the first place.
Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by petilon on Monday November 08, 2021 @06:16PM (#29155595)
> Jony Ive was only able to get away with the damaging push to flat design after Steve Jobs died

Sadly, true.

> and since Ive has left Apple, beautiful skeuomorphic gradients, lighting, embosses, drop shadows, and photo-real elements, have started to return.

Not really. Where have you seen this return? It hasn't, not in any significant way. The damage Ive did seems more or less permanent.

Jony Ive is only part of the problem. The other problems is hatred towards Scott Forstall. Since Scott was a proponent of skeuomorphism, one way remaining Apple execs stuck it to Forestall is by losing skeuomorphism, and then opening deriding skeuomorphism during the reveal of iOS7.

Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by hyperpallium2 on Monday November 08, 2021 @06:23PM (#29155662)
I humbly await the Second Coming of Forstall to resurrect Apple and rescue it from bankrupcty!

it may be a while

Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by stevebmark on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @12:04PM (#29164266)
The iMessage mac desktop icon, the Preview icon using real 3d elements, System Preferences keeping beautiful 3d icons, are all giving me hope that we can back out of this nightmare.

> Sadly, true.

Any additional context you can give here?

Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by voldacar on Monday November 08, 2021 @05:56PM (#29155414)
There is something deeply antihuman about flat design. It's hard to describe exactly how, because it sounds silly when it comes out of your mouth, but I really believe this is true on some deep, pre-verbal level. They make me feel mentally and spiritually harmed somehow.
Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by stevebmark on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @12:00PM (#29164204)
Humans see in 3d, and we use 3d cues from the world around us to assess everything. Taking these cues out of design is absolutely antihuman. And we know it's bad, especially for older populations, where nothing looks like a button or clickable, so folks click on things until something works.
Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by ChrisClark on Monday November 08, 2021 @04:53PM (#29154739)
A deep stain? No, I wish everything remained flat, it is exactly what design of software should be. (I can also state my opinion as fact)

But seriously, I do really love flat design. Though I do agree with some of the arguments against it.

A more varied design landscape is always better though.

Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by krisrm on Monday November 08, 2021 @06:45PM (#29155855)
In your opinion, what would be an example of a "beautiful skeuomorphic gradient"?

I don't use Apple software (or hardware) much, but I recall a certain stitched-leather user interface for iCal that really put me off skeuomorphism in User Interfaces.

Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by phendrenad2 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @01:36AM (#29158449)
A nice story with a bow on top, but it doesn't match reality. Flat design started at Google and spread to Microsoft and eventually Apple. It was simply the style, and now the trends are starting to change. We'll go through a 3D glossy "aqua" phase for the next 10 years, then we'll go back to brutalist flat design. And we'll have no choice but to follow the UI designers into whatever obsession they're on time after time.
Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by applgo443 on Monday November 08, 2021 @04:49PM (#29154705)
What's the problem with flat design? I love that!
Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by baq on Monday November 08, 2021 @05:27PM (#29155099)
It’s ok if you have two eyes, two hands and/or a well lit room.

Apple TV remote is possibly the worst remote ever made.

Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by dtgriscom on Monday November 08, 2021 @05:46PM (#29155295)
This. I forever struggle to persuade my remote to do what I want it to. That touch-sensitive panel is a complete PIA, and just navigating across a rectangular array of icons is fraught with detours.

If I were paranoid, I'd say it was designed to force people to use the voice-recognition system, which gives better user data.

Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by deeblering4 on Monday November 08, 2021 @06:13PM (#29155584)
It really is. You can’t even wake the remote from sleep without sending a keypress to the TV. And the trackpad is difficult to use accurately. Totally over engineered for no benefit.
Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by notJim on Monday November 08, 2021 @06:27PM (#29155690)
That remote is awful, but isn't usually what I've heard people refer to as flat design. Flat design tends to refer to the more simplistic software UIs that have been in fashion over the last few years.
Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by ibero on Monday November 08, 2021 @05:39PM (#29155220)
just to clear it up:

“flat design” is a reference or common term to a graphical design style that followed skeuomorphism, not a term used for the industrial design aspect.

Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by holistio on Monday November 08, 2021 @06:01PM (#29155466)
I guess you are referring to the previous generation.

The newest is really good, in fact I think it's the best remote I've ever used.

Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by ChrisMarshallNY on Monday November 08, 2021 @06:26PM (#29155689)
> Apple TV remote is possibly the worst remote ever made.

Yup. It's awful. I shelled out the bucks for the new one, and have found it to be worlds different.

Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by tomxor on Monday November 08, 2021 @05:47PM (#29155299)
You may love the way it looks... but no one being honest with themselves loves the way it functions, UI is visually functional, a functionality that happens in your brain, like legibility - flat UI has very poor "legibility" if compared to something like 3d embossed win95 UI where every identification and anticipation is painfully obvious to the point that it's effortless. It's familiarity is also learned in a very short space of time; whereas flat UI continues to elude even advanced users and remains ambiguous with high cognitive load - you might not realise why, but it will feel slow, and uncomfortable for each new front end you encounter.

Designers don't like this fact because that embossed 3d look is considered ugly, but it's intuitively and obviously true.

Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by SahAssar on Monday November 08, 2021 @06:06PM (#29155520)
I think all of your points are true for badly made UIs, regardless of if they are flat or not. I like flat UIs, partially because they look and behave like digital things instead of trying to resemble something else and partially just because they usually (entirely subjectively) look better. We have a deeper well of inspiration to draw from for non-flat and more experience with them (so it's easier to make them "better") but I don't think anyone can say they are inherently "better".
Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by GhettoComputers on Monday November 08, 2021 @08:19PM (#29156530)
They’re better for accessibility for anyone less interested in learning the new technological design UIs to have their programs function, people that just want to look at something and get how it works without a manual or googling it. The functionally has never improved because of flat designs, ever.
Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by secondcoming on Monday November 08, 2021 @05:54PM (#29155395)
Eliminating the 3.5mm jack was a step too far!
Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by hn_throwaway_99 on Monday November 08, 2021 @04:46PM (#29154682)
I mean, in fairness, the design outlined in TFA is an intricate, 3D, embossed design, so maybe Ive himself is off the "simple and flat" train ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by ThomPete on Monday November 08, 2021 @07:36PM (#29156254)
Flat design was never about flat design but about layers and animation. The idea was to get rid of the fake 3d and instead use layered animation to create the depth.
Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by jasonvorhe on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @03:15AM (#29159028)
Ive would've left Apple way earlier, if someone hadn't convinced him to stay. iirc he moved to London a couple of years ago and everyone was curious if he was still interested in Apple. I'm sure they lured him to stay with the new Apple HQ.

To say that it was Steve Jobs keeping him from having too much unrestricted impact on the product is not a convincing argument. Sure, he took over software design as well but skeumorphism, gradients and huge shadows were often heavily criticized before it was cool to hate on a minimalistic flat design.

Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by Angostura on Monday November 08, 2021 @07:03PM (#29156009)
From looking at Apple and this project. I suspect that Ive is quite good at delivering to the client's brief.
Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by brailsafe on Monday November 08, 2021 @06:03PM (#29155481)
> skeuomorphic gradients

Come on. These were an awful trend.

Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by petilon on Monday November 08, 2021 @06:26PM (#29155682)
It wasn't.

EVERYTHING beautiful is skeuomorphic. The page turn in iBooks, page curl in maps, cover flow, the shred animation in older versions of Passbook, the date picker (all in iOS 6), rotating settings gear (when updating iOS 6), the Time Machine interface in older versions of OS X, photo borders and shadows in older versions of iWorks documents, etc.

This is not surprising, because our sense of beauty comes from the physical world.

So what is the problem with skeuomorphism?

Tech enthusiasts would like their phones to look like something from the future, not something from the past. But ordinary everyday people prefer for it to look like things they are already familiar with, or can relate to.

Tech enthusiasts worry that the skeuomorphism was getting totally out of hand, particularly where the UI metaphor started limiting functionality (e.g. an address database that's limited to what a Rolodex can do, rather than exploiting what is possible with a computer). But this is not really true. For example, iBooks has instant search, something only possible with a computer.

Some people point out that many skeuomorphic elements reference things that a large part of Apple's audience hasn't used in a long time, if ever. True, but here's the thing: It doesn't matter whether the user has ever seen a reel-to-reel tape. What matters is whether the visuals depict a physical object that the user can model in his mind. If it is too abstract (that's the opposite of physical) then non-tech-enthusiast users will find it hard to intuit.

Some people say skeuomorphism looks tacky. This is partly true. Skeuomorphism is hard to do. When done poorly it does look tacky. But when done well it looks very beautiful.

By removing all skeuomorphism Apple threw the baby out with the bathwater.

Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by notJim on Monday November 08, 2021 @06:29PM (#29155707)
> EVERYTHING beautiful is skeuomorphic

I don't think you can make any kind of categorical statement like this about a topic as subjective as beauty. Maybe you only find skeuomorphic things beautiful, but some of us disagree.

Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by stevebmark on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @12:02PM (#29164227)
I take it you haven't seen the new iMessage mac desktop icon. You may also be misinterpreting this as two color gradients that also came from the poisoning of flat design.
Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by didip on Monday November 08, 2021 @07:11PM (#29156074)
ugh... I loath the skeuomorphic design.

A bunch of engineering effort spent just to make digital products looked like the old physical products they killed.

Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by GhettoComputers on Monday November 08, 2021 @08:16PM (#29156516)
Why get a retina screen to display what like design limitations of low resolution screens? Why do you loathe them? It’s for ease of use, in iOS 6 the notes app that looks like notes or the newsstand app that looks like a news stand it was easy to understand. What does the photos app look like now? A bunch of circular colors to mean what exactly? What about the news app? Used to be a bunch of geometric shapes, now it’s a square slanted candy stripe.
Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by zeroimpl on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:25AM (#29162123)
The actual content (eg pictures, videos and text) all look better on a retina screen. I don’t think people buy retina screens so that the UI elements look prettier.
Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by GhettoComputers on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:49AM (#29162445)
That might not be why, but the UI elements looks worst, the apps are unified under uglier UI, and by the logic of content it was an unnecessary design change with less accessibility, more complications to make boring UI that needs explanation and all for no benefit to the user. Just look at the iOS 7 news stand icon or the one that’s a red candy cane stripe versus the iOS 6 news stand icon. Who designed the photos icon and what’s it represent if not just designing for design’s sake? He made it minimalist, harder to use, and forced every iOS UI to congregate under a more flawed design. Pretty elements that highlighted the Retina display’s capabilities in the are now replaced by uglier boring design that was probably a practical scaling solution for ease of designing unified UI that was more developed friendly and less user friendly.
Re:Jony Ive’s first major design since leaving Apple by kumarvvr on Monday November 08, 2021 @08:39PM (#29156670)
How is it that in a land on Nokia N95 and the likes, introducing the iPhone was not revolutionary?

You are cutting short and focusing on the design of the software (which I am sure Ive had a limited say in) while ignoring decades of excellent design work.