News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by waffle_ss on Monday August 22, 2011 @01:59PM (#2913365)
I pay for Netflix and Hulu Plus streaming (the latter of which still comes with ads). If it's not on there, I feel like I've done my due diligence and have no ethical dilemma with pirating.
Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by biot on Monday August 22, 2011 @02:16PM (#2913428)
I have a simpler standard: if the price being asked for digital content is less than or equal to the value I expect to receive, I'll purchase it. If it isn't and I can't find a legitimate lower price then I won't get the digital content.

I have no problems rewarding businesses (or individuals) which produce content of value to me. If it's not of sufficient value that I'd pay for it, why would I watch it anyways?

Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by absconditus on Monday August 22, 2011 @02:03PM (#2913380)
Viewing videos is not a necessity. It is possible not to watch something at all.
Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by jrockway on Monday August 22, 2011 @02:12PM (#2913416)
When you pirate something, you're sending the message that you want the content. Whey you don't watch something, the producers can't be sure if it's because it's simply not to your taste, or that you just don't like the mandatory delivery mechanism. Network middlemen aren't interested in "alternate" distribution mechanisms, but the people that actually want get paid for producing content are. Every time you pirate something, the world is one step closer to one where you can just visit a TV show's website, pay $1, and download this week's episode. Let's get there faster.

And anyway, is it even piracy when it was already broadcast into your house? (Anyone can watch Fox for free with a big enough antenna.) I can pay someone to clean my house; why can't I pay someone to videotape my TV shows?

Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by danielsoneg on Monday August 22, 2011 @02:44PM (#2913551)
> When you pirate something, you're sending the message that you want the content.

That, I think, is an undervalued point here - Piracy as a signaling mechanism is, I think, why an awful lot of what's currently out there for digital delivery (Hulu, especially) exists.

The industry's still not entirely sure what a viable market model looks like - that's part of the reason why Fox pulled their 8-day move. Bittorrent's shown people will do it for free, Hulu's shown more people will do it if it's easier even if they have to watch ads, Netflix has shown people will pay for it (though recently they've shown the selection needs to be bigger), but nobody's hit the magic bullet that both consumers and industry will accept yet.

In the mean time, piracy is certainly a valuable signal for the industry that demand exists - it's just that the price and mechanisms aren't right yet. (I'm sure the content producers feel the same way /s)

Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by rick888 on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @01:13AM (#2915434)
"In the mean time, piracy is certainly a valuable signal for the industry that demand exists - it's just that the price and mechanisms aren't right yet. (I'm sure the content producers feel the same way /s)"

If you can get a show in HD quality, very fast, without commercials, and at no cost..nothing will compete with it that costs money.

Content producers shouldn't have to consider pirates the competition.

At this rate, the answer will be a forced monthly fee/tax through all of the major Internet providers.

Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by nitrogen on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @06:10AM (#2916012)
The present article suggests the opposite, if you replace "costs money" with "has ads". Else, why did piracy rates drop significantly when Hulu was launched, and spike again as shows were pulled?

Also as counterexample, lots of people pay for Netflix.

Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by jeffool on Monday August 22, 2011 @03:37PM (#2913764)
There's a startup for that. Saw it here on HN: http://www.bamboom.com
Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by ryanklee on Monday August 22, 2011 @03:02PM (#2913639)
I read an excellent argument against this idea not too long ago in an HN comment. I wish I could track it down because I am going to do an awful job paraphrasing it, but it basically amounts to this:

To ask someone not to participate in media (watch videos) is tantamount to asking someone not to participate in culture. Cultural participation is a basic human need: people will go to great lengths, will in fact in despotic, tyrannical, totalitarian or fascistic regimes go so far as to actually risk their own lives and the lives of their loved ones to participate in unsanctioned culture. Whether the sanction comes by way of money or by way of politics, it is no matter.

The idea that "not watching the videos" is somehow an option ignores this basic (desperate) human need to participate in culture. It's not going to happen. Media existed before money and before despots. Media is what happens when a culture expresses itself. People are going to watch Jerry Springer, The Sopranos, and listen to Lady Gaga and listen to Woodie Guthrie, money or no (though when payment is convenient, we all know what happens). They will in fact lay down their lives to do so if the circumstances demand it. If that's the case, (and we often find ourselves praising the bravery of such individuals in those cases), then it doesn't seem to me to make any sense to become moralistically reversed when the matter isn't of death but of a few measly dollars.

Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by psyklic on Monday August 22, 2011 @03:32PM (#2913746)
Of course "not watching the videos" is an option. You decide your own culture. What if your friends don't watch TV? Then, you won't feel a need to view a show immediately upon release -- I certainly don't.

All of your friends could go to a $100/mo gym. Sure, you would have a "need" to participate in this culture. But, "not going to the gym" is perfectly acceptable too. After all, your friends may like you for more than your gym membership! Or, you could find new friends. Or, you could make up an excuse. It's not the end of the world.

Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by ryanklee on Monday August 22, 2011 @03:45PM (#2913798)
"You decide your own culture."

This is a very narrow view of culture. If culture is simply any given activity, then yes, you decide your own culture. But if culture is simply any given activity, then we are talking about two different things. One can either go to the gym or not go to the gym and still be a part of the general culture in which one exists and be conversant in that culture. But one cannot abstain from all media and still be a part of that culture. We refer to such individuals as deprived, unfortunate, uneducated idiots. We in fact expect people to be conversant in culture through familiarity with available media. We say, "It is your responsibility to know yourself and know the world." One can do neither except via engagement with media. If there is a bureaucratic or fiscal or political lock-down on culture, we cannot say, "Well, too bad for those individuals, they'll just have to suffer their existence as deprived, unfortunate, uneducated, idiots." Yes, it is not that bad for anyone in the U.S. Yes, we are saturated with media. And, no, no one is suffering to any real extent because of the 8-day FOX hold on Hulu releases. But that's hardly the issue when someone says, "You don't like the price? Go eat worms." People have a right to watch Jerry Springer without paying a dime for it. Which isn't to say that one shouldn't charge a dime.

Edit: I said "U.S." above, but I really mean any culture for whom Hulu is not just a gibberish word.

Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by psyklic on Monday August 22, 2011 @04:46PM (#2914046)
Yes, but the aspects of the culture you're expected to know is purely dependent on your circle of friends. If you choose to hang out with entrepreneurs, your knowledge of the latest TV shows is irrelevant, and perhaps even looked down upon :)

So on that note, people should have to pay to watch Jerry Springer, if that's what the content producer wants.

I do not gain or lose anything (aside from my time) from watching or not watching Jerry Springer, or any other TV show. Perhaps I am lucky that none of my friends watch TV, but TV is a luxury. If you want to be part of a group whose "culture" involves watching the latest TV shows, joining expensive gyms, or even starting companies, then that is your choice. The value you gain from paying for these activities is in part feeling more connected to your friends, feeling part of a privileged group, or just personal satisfaction. Clearly, there is no inherent "need" to watch any TV show.

Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by nitrogen on Monday August 22, 2011 @05:53PM (#2914292)
...TV is a luxury.

How convenient it is that media companies can perpetually turn last year's luxury into today's necessity, yet when their opponents use the same argument against them, they feel free to roll back the clock and declare everything beyond basic caloric sustenance a luxury once again.

Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by absconditus on Monday August 22, 2011 @06:52PM (#2914500)
There is a middle ground: watch some videos and not others. Having access to every television show and movie made is not the key to a good life.
Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by ryanklee on Monday August 22, 2011 @07:08PM (#2914542)
This is not an argument about what or what doesn't constitute a good or healthy life; it is an argument about what is an acceptable barrier to cultural access and about the kind of moralizing that goes on around supposed breaches of property rights, where such (non)property includes such things as story, song, meaning, thought, abstraction and explanation, i.e. culture. You can't inject such things into people's lives and expect to keep control of them without resorting to really horrible treatment of your fellow human beings.
Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by DasIch on Monday August 22, 2011 @04:12PM (#2913915)
In this case piracy doesn't affect the willingness to buy the product and it also doesn't hurt the producer, in fact the producer may still make a profit through merchandise and a satisfied viewer may provide free advertisment.

I don't see how this could possibly be ethically wrong.

Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by steverb on Monday August 22, 2011 @02:10PM (#2913410)
Do you have something useful to say, or do you just like moralizing at people?
Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by coconutrandom on Monday August 22, 2011 @02:16PM (#2913430)
Do you?
Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by nitrogen on Monday August 22, 2011 @06:00PM (#2914323)
Regardless of the ethical justifications, and even if you have an ostensible legal right to be watching a show (e.g. you have a cable subscription and you recorded the show with your DVR), their watchdogs will still send DMCA notices to your ISP if you happen upon a file they are watching.
Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by protomyth on Monday August 22, 2011 @02:51PM (#2913588)
If the creator is only selling it on his/her website or on iTunes / Amazon, do you pay or pirate?
Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by chc on Monday August 22, 2011 @08:20PM (#2914756)
That would be a question of marketing for most people, I imagine.
Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by protomyth on Monday August 22, 2011 @11:15PM (#2915187)
No, it's a question of respect. How can people expect the GPL to be honored when they won't honor the wishes of others in regard to their works?
Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by chc on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @04:16AM (#2915817)
I don't see how what you said has to do with what I said.

You: If the author sold the work on his site, would you buy it there or pirate it?

Me: I guess that depends on if people know to find it there.

You: That's so disrespectful!

What's the connection?

Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by sid0 on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @03:25AM (#2915713)
The tacit assumption you're making is that all wishes should command equal respect. They shouldn't. If the wishes of a creator include his creation not being available to buy where I live, well then, fuck his wishes.
Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by mikeryan on Monday August 22, 2011 @02:40PM (#2913534)
I pay for Netflix and Hulu Plus streaming (the latter of which still comes with ads). If it's not on there, I feel like I've done my due diligence and have no ethical dilemma with pirating.

I tried to find a $200 Porsche, but couldn't so I had no problem stealing one.

Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by bdhe on Monday August 22, 2011 @02:51PM (#2913595)
I tried to find a $200 Porsche, but couldn't so I had no problem stealing one.

At first glance this might seem a fine refutation of the earlier point, but upon deeper inspection, it falls back on the fallacy that digital data is analogous to tangible property. By stealing a Porsche (whatever be your motivation) you are denying another person the right to his car. However, the same is untrue of pirating.

I am firmly of the belief that until we abandon the false and forced analogies and treat digital data and IP as something new, something that requires us to work out ethics and moral of afresh, we'll be stuck in this rut of old business models forcing new technology to fit into their mold and the consumers suffering because of bureaucracy.

I'll go further and state that the precise reason why Movie Studios and Recording Labels seemingly don't want to innovate and adopt new technologies to their benefit is precisely because of this thinking that immediately clouds all other possible arguments (oh, and maybe the people in charge of making decisions have got to the top because of their understanding of old technologies and therefore have little incentive to abandon that and embrace newer ways of doing business) /rant

Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by hugh3 on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @01:08AM (#2915421)
I am firmly of the belief that until we abandon the false and forced analogies and treat digital data and IP as something new, something that requires us to work out ethics and moral of afresh, we'll be stuck in this rut of old business models forcing new technology to fit into their mold and the consumers suffering because of bureaucracy.

It's not analogous to stealing a Porsche, but it's not analogous to nothing either.

There's nothing particularly novel about it, people have been stealing services in ways that don't directly deprive anyone else for... well, quite some time. They've been sneaking into theaters, sneaking onto buses, and otherwise dishonestly using services that the honest people pay for, and which couldn't exist without them. It's just the old free rider problem.

Morally there's nothing "new" about it. And it's not particularly difficult to work out the answer to a question about "is it morally acceptable to sneak into a non-full movie theater?" The only question is whether you're prepared to behave immorally to save a few bucks.

Personally I value my self-respect a bit higher than that.

Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by drivingmenuts on Monday August 22, 2011 @03:01PM (#2913636)
The studios are terrified because the moment someone figures out an effective metric, they're toast. Physical unit sales are easy - one CD sold, X dollars received, with corresponding breakdown to show what value they actually add (lying about their value-add is another thing entirely). One digital download - it's not so clear.
Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by klipt on Monday August 22, 2011 @07:28PM (#2914612)
Steam makes tons of cash from (relatively) cheap digital downloads. The studios are just way behind.

(In fact Steam probably makes most of their money from sales where hoarder-type personalities buy hundreds of games they never even play.)

Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by sp332 on Monday August 22, 2011 @03:11PM (#2913677)
Ooh, a car analogy! Here's mine: I went to a car dealer and offered to pay for a copy of a car. But he wouldn't sell me one, so I found someone else who had the same kind of car and made a copy of theirs instead.
Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by chopsueyar on Monday August 22, 2011 @06:42PM (#2914461)
You have a Porsche replicator?

Awesome!

Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by lhnn on Monday August 22, 2011 @02:53PM (#2913605)
Analogies between digital and physical items regarding piracy are always fallacies.

His point is that if he CAN'T pay for it, having no avenue to give them revenue, then it doesn't hurt the content creator for the OP to consume the video for free.

Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by goatforce5 on Monday August 22, 2011 @03:27PM (#2913727)
You've deprived the content creator (well, a distributor) the chance to make money from you consuming the content at some point in the future.

eg, Fox will let you watch their content on Hulu 8 days after broadcast. But you don't want to wait 8 days, so you go pirate it. Fox makes no money.

If you'd waited the 8 days, Fox would show it to you via Hulu, and show you some ads, and they and Hulu would have made some money.

Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by DasIch on Monday August 22, 2011 @04:20PM (#2913952)
When was the last time you talked to your friends about that episode that was broadcasted eight days ago? In case of media time is a very important aspect of the product that has a significant value.
Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by goatforce5 on Monday August 22, 2011 @04:57PM (#2914088)
I was just talking to someone about Tom Goes to the Mayor, which is a few years old, and The Adam and Joe Show that is over 10 years old.
Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by chopsueyar on Monday August 22, 2011 @06:47PM (#2914478)
He isn't paying Hulu per episode watched, only per month. Fox and Hulu still get their money.

But, by your logic, purchasing any non-expiring stored media, such as a DVD, would deprive "the content creator (well, a distributor) the chance to make money from you consuming the content at some point in the future."

Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by goatforce5 on Monday August 22, 2011 @07:38PM (#2914643)
>He isn't paying Hulu per episode watched, only per month. Fox and Hulu still get their money.

...if Fox gets a cut of the Hulu subscription cost regardless of whether that individual watches any Fox content during the subscription period or not.

> But, by your logic, purchasing any non-expiring stored media, such as a DVD, would deprive "the content creator (well, a distributor) the chance to make money from you consuming the content at some point in the future."

Yes. But they've made your money off your consumption of that content at some point in time.

Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by chopsueyar on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @09:52AM (#2916524)
As Fox did in the Hulu circumstance.
Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by sp332 on Monday August 22, 2011 @03:46PM (#2913804)
Right, if I actually interacted with a distributor in any way, you might make a case that I owe them something. But the whole point is, that I have no interaction with the distributor, so I don't owe them anything. I'm not using their services, so I don't pay them for those services.
Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by goatforce5 on Monday August 22, 2011 @04:56PM (#2914082)
The content creator typically sells some or all rights to their content to a distributor. Often it's that money that allows the content to be made in the first place, and if the distributors weren't there you wouldn't have the same range as content as is available today.

The distributor is a very important part of the creation process at the moment.

Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by sp332 on Monday August 22, 2011 @05:09PM (#2914121)
And if distributors had anything to sell me that I wanted, maybe I would give them some money for it. But they don't sell anything I want to buy, and that's why I'm not giving them any money.
Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by goatforce5 on Monday August 22, 2011 @07:41PM (#2914660)
You don't want to buy it because you don't like the price they want to charge for the thing you want to consume, or you don't want to buy it because you have no interest in the product they're offering?
Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by sp332 on Monday August 22, 2011 @09:17PM (#2914905)
The day after a show airs on FOX, I can't buy it from FOX for any price.
Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by alanfalcon on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @06:35AM (#2916057)
Actually, they do offer it (on Fox.com and Hulu.com) the next day to people who prove they are current Dish customers. They're surely extracting some money from Dish for this arrangement (the way ESPN 3 does from some ISPs), and they created a situation where you can indirectly pay for access to the cotent the next day (assuming Dish is available to you in your part of the world).
Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by goatforce5 on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @07:22AM (#2916145)
The way i'm reading it it's free to watch the next day on Hulu for existing Dish subscribers, or you can watch it on Hulu the next day if you're a Hulu Plus subscriber:

http://www.hulu.com/support/article/20362238

Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by gscott on Monday August 22, 2011 @04:00PM (#2913881)
I mail them $1 every time I pirate one of their shows, so my conscious is clear.
Re:Fox’s 8-Day Delay on Hulu Triggers Piracy Surge by absconditus on Monday August 22, 2011 @06:57PM (#2914510)
He hardly exhausted all avenues. He listed two avenues which cost a total of about $20 per month. Does anyone really believe that we will ever have access to all movies and television shows for $20 per month?