There are houses for cheaper, but they tend to be in less desirable locations. Same in America, there just happens to be way more “less desirable” places. Lots of land in the 90 minute commute radius.
In my experience Germans tend to outright dismiss options that are less than ideal, always searching for the eierlegende Wollmilchsau.
German houses are not, on average, 1.2 million euro.
How do we check? I just went Immobilienscout and tried a random small city "Tübingen" which has a population of only 80k:https://www.immobilienscout24.de/Suche/de/baden-wuerttemberg...
Looking at these prices, €1.2M seems like a good ballpark number.
Tübingen is an infamously expensive outlier. Most average costs for houses I saw online are around 250-400k€. My own hometown, Ulm (not too far from Tübingen, and a bit larger) has Houses around 500-600k in good positions (although 1mio+ houses exist as well).
On a square meter basis, there are maps like this: https://www.immowelt.de/immobilienpreise/deutschland/hauspre... giving an average of 2.6k€/m² (Tübingen being around 5k€/m²)
Taking Cambridge, MA as an example (though it's certainly more expensive than average) - median house is ~1.4M in 2018 (probably higher now), and median _household_ income is ~75K USD per year - for Cambridge, giving a multiplier of something like 20x (household income, not counting taxes - not individual)
5.4 times that is about 200k. Avery’s Dutch houses are now 400k (and growing 10%+ y/y). So there’s definitely a gap, but more like 2x than 10x.
This still means the median person can’t afford to live in the city center one of the big cities, but rural areas can be relatively affordable.
Yes, a few things. For one, Germany isn't the richest in Europe. But that's besides the point.
Typically price to income measures not prices per person, but per household. After all, the average house isn't lived in by one person. particularly homes that are bought (average buyer is a family, or an investor renting to multiple people), leading to an income that's the sum of typically at least two adults.
Second, these figures are virtually always pre-tax.
Third, these figures often reference to price to income of buyers, depending on the study. The average income in the Netherlands for example is about 37k leading, 5.4x would for example get you to 200k. But the average income includes unemployed, students, retirees, disabled etc. The average salary of working individuals (i.e. the home-buying population) is substantially higher, particularly if you filter out the population which is eligible for cheap subsidised social housing (about 1/3rd of all housing stock in the Netherlands). At that point you get to >50k salaries, with families of two earners often bringing in 100k and able to afford 540k homes at price to income levels of 5.4x.
Fourth, interest rates in certain EU countries is substantially lower than in the US. I just bought a house at sub 1.5% rates (Netherlands), about half of what you see in the US. Denmark had negative rates, I believe. This pushes up the max mortgage / home price to higher figures than the US, at the same monthly fees (and thus same affordability). In that sense it's not any cheaper per se, once you figure in that the US has more expensive financing costs than some EU countries, including Germany.
Fifth, the average buyer isn't a 25 year old fresh from college with a new job, but instead actually 45 years old. In fact, the average buyer isn't a first-time buyer, but has bought and sold a home before and has some equity, some savings, a retirement fund, perhaps a small inheritance from his parents, buying with a partner in the same situation. In other words, people are typically bringing in quite a bit of equity and are able to afford more than they can borrow.
A more meaningful difference is what individuals do not have to pay for in Germany.
They realized they speak with an American so they tried to adjust.
People are using after tax income in Europe because it's easier to assess the purchasing power.
Good job putting labels on people you know nothing about though.
This is a tax on the income of workers which almost no one in the UK even realises exists.
The “gross” salary number is post this tax.
As of 2019, there were 8 Europan OECD countries with higher average wages.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_average_w...
For example, in 2018, 45 single super-rich germans possessed the same amount of wealth as the poorest 50% of germans [0]. Using the median of distributed wealth would not express that, and if you cut off outliers by looking at percentiles and then averaging would also not express that.
[0]: https://www.spiegel.de/wirtschaft/soziales/vermoegen-45-supe...
But houses there are also very expensive. Basically unaffordable if you don't get help from either a second high income or money from parents etc.
Also, parent said it is the richest in EU which of total value (GDP) is correct, but by GDP per capita isn't. But, Switzerland isn't first on the list either if you take GDP per capita because that spot is taken by Luxemburg. (Which is 27th on the GDP list)
But parents point still stand, on a median income it is really hard to find a proper place in Europe.
Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Financial_and_social_rankings_...
So his point kinda stands.
a. Are not incomes for just a single-wage earner, they include the combined income for a household (of 2.53 people on average)
b. Are referred to in pre-tax figures, not post-tax.
c. Are not just wage income, but include non-wage income like dividends, capital gains, small business income, fed/state/local government transfers, etc.
d. Are using the median, not the average (mean).
[1] says median household income is apparently 4.8k€/month, so around 58k€/year (before tax). Average housing prices seem to be between 250k and 400k (couldn't find a good source). That would be 4.3~6.9 ratio. (edit: Quality of this estimate is probably still low.)
Personally, I believe (affordability of) average housing prices to be a very useless statistic, due to the extreme regional and local variation in housing prices (and incomes). But maybe I am wrong about that and it is a good indicator.
[1] https://de.statista.com/statistik/daten/studie/261850/umfrag...
The average house price seems to be € 376 000 [2]
That means 13 years worth of salary which is kind of much.
As to why is this the case I see two reasons but I am sure there are more:
Houses in Europe are built with better standards and built to last more. You can pass the house to your kids, no problem. It will be in very good shape and probably worth more than you've paid for it.
The biggest issue is land. Europe is small and crowded and it becomes more crowded due to increasing migration. So the land is scarce. Also many EUsians like to live in the city, close to center if possible in contrast with USians which might be glad to live in suburbia. US has good roads uniting the suburbs with the city and the price of gas is small. US is a vast place so land is not exactly a problem.
Another issue is socialist policies (even from the CDU) which means high taxation, resulting in lower incomes and less investments in developing real estate.
[1] https://housinganywhere.com/Germany/average-salaries-in-germ...
[2] https://www.iamexpat.de/housing/real-estate-news/where-can-y...
Land might be somewhat scarce, but that isn't the huge cost driving point. The problem is the process by which land is assigned for building - there is a lot of land which just cannot be used for building. New building areas are sometimes opened, but always trailing the demand, keeping the price up. Also, the density of new buildings could be higher. It is grotesqe that in an area with lacking housing new single homes get approved. Also, why are cities allowed to approve additional office buildings without ensuring that the housing capacity is extended for all those new office workers? Easy way to enforce that would be mixed use buildings, where you have a comparable work and living capacity.
In Germany, which is the richest country in Europe, the average working person earns €2000 (after taxes) per month, so €24000 per year. Times 5.4 that is €129600. You can only dream about buying a house for that price here. The price of a house is ten times that. Even if it is not in a big city.
Am I missing something?