News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by sb057 on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @11:50PM (#29009342)
Money is largely controlled by a small group of investors and central banks. [citation needed]
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by pcwalton on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @11:52PM (#29009354)
The difference is that traditional money is up front about that fact and doesn't use decentralization as a selling point.
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by anonporridge on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @02:09AM (#29010042)
There seems to be a weird perception that decentralization means that there won't be inequality of power in the system.

That's not what it means.

Decentralization simply means that there is no central power that can make unilateral decisions about the system like a government can with its currency.

This explicit decentralization of power is what people are excited about, because it means any change to the system requires a supermajority of consent and there are no central points of attack that power hungry fascists can target and take over.

Centralization can be incredibly efficient, but also incredibly fragile.

Bitcoin is the anti fragile monetary system.

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by bradwood on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @03:35AM (#29010531)
You nailed it. Bitcoin is not some kind of panacea that will make everyone rich. It's just money that cannot be fucked with by central bankers, governments, dictators or anyone else for that matter.

That's it.

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by evilos on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @03:58AM (#29010653)
Can't it still be fucked with via regulation? eg China banning it outright etc.
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by IAmGraydon on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @06:08AM (#29011286)
Yep. That’s the thing that crypto supporters just seem to ignore: it requires an infrastructure that is owned and controlled by a higher power. Namely, the internet. In the end, the government has the power to easily shut this entire thing down. It only exists because they let it.
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by glenvdb on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @07:14AM (#29011672)
You think they're going to shutdown the Internet to kill Bitcoin?

Even if they did, once the Internet was back up and running what would stop the Bitcoin network from continuing where it left off?

There's thousands of people around the world running their own Bitcoin nodes, many also protected behind Tor [1]. In what realistic way could governments shut it down globally?

They could go for centralised custodial businesses like the exchanges, but that doesn't stop the Bitcoin network itself. Also there are decentralised exchanges like Bisq that can't be shutdown.

"Yes (you will not find a solution to political problems in cryptography.), but we can win a major battle in the arms race and gain a new territory of freedom for several years.

Governments are good at cutting off the heads of a centrally controlled networks like Napster, but pure P2P networks like Gnutella and Tor seem to be holding their own." — Satoshi Nakamoto

"A lot of people automatically dismiss e-currency as a lost cause because of all the companies that failed since the 1990’s. I hope it’s obvious it was only the centrally controlled nature of those systems that doomed them. I think this is the first time we’re trying a decentralized, non-trust-based system." — Satoshi Nakamoto

1. https://bitnodes.io/dashboard/

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by IAmGraydon on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @08:45AM (#29012557)
No, I’m not talking about shutting down the internet. I’m talking about filtering its traffic. I also did not say they would do this. I said that they could do it and have the power to do it. My point is that if the US Govt really wants crypto to go away, it will.
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by christophilus on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @07:28AM (#29011768)
Not sure about the rest of the world, but if the US shut down it’s internet, we’d have an entirely new government in the next election, if not sooner.
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by hnbad on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @05:11AM (#29010995)
Well, unless you can exert sufficient influence on the system itself from outside. Ask Tor how the whole "anonymity is guaranteed by decentralization" thing works out when individual actors control the majority of the nodes involved. To say nothing about rubber-hose cryptanalysis or simply banning crypto currencies an seizing assets.

It also doesn't really matter if the person fucking with a resource is a state or an extremely rich individual or a company, except for ideological reasons. Diamonds (even natural ones) are fairly abundant and largely worthless but that doesn't stop De Beers from selling them at ridiculously inflated prices because they hold enough of a monopoly to be able to create artificial scarcity (and spend a lot of money on marketing to distinguish their "product" from the cheaper but higher quality artificial alternative).

That crypto currencies aren't subject to the power hierarchies of the institutions you name in the exact same way as state-backed currencies doesn't mean they are not impacted by real world power hierarchies at all -- nor at least less so. Literally the only thing guaranteeing the "value" of anything is (state) violence. The reason you can charge ten bucks for a fancy cup of coffee is that if I drink without paying, you can call the cops.

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by timeon on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @05:24AM (#29011074)
Isn't the article arguing otherwise?
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by tshaddox on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @12:35AM (#29009583)
Well and also the government doesn’t need to have a “selling point” because of the whole being the government thing.
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by nickpinkston on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @12:07AM (#29009438)
100% this
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by KennyBlanken on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @01:51AM (#29009985)
This sort of comment adds nothing of value whatsoever to the discussion.
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by glenvdb on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @07:17AM (#29011696)
Well... neither does your's, or this one for that matter.
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by nuerow on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @01:51AM (#29009987)
> Money is largely controlled by a small group of investors and central banks. [citation needed]

There are an estimated 40 trillion dollars in circulation alone. The US government debt is currently close to 30 trillion dollars.

The world's richest person has an estimated value of around 180 billion dollars, less than 1% of the US debt alone. I'm talking about projected value, not cash.

In contrast, it was already reported that a mere 100 individuals control around 13% of BTC's coins, and 1000 users control around 40%.

https://www.businessinsider.com/bitcoin-whales-the-key-facts...

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by yc12340 on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @03:23AM (#29010462)
So you are saying, that US government controls such staggering amount of money, that even it's debt (denominated in it's own currency) is several orders of magnitude bigger than total worth of the richest person in the world? And that person is also many orders of magnitude richer than a mean citizen?!

Suddenly, Bitcoin does not sound so centralized in comparison...

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by kolinko on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @02:26AM (#29010129)
You need to compare the relative numbers. Bitcoin is being held by 1000x fewer people than the US dollar.

If 100 people control 13% of Bitcoin, then the question is how much Dollar top 100,000 people hold.

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by tonfa on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @02:44AM (#29010248)
But by design Bitcoin doesn't dilute or expand through balance sheet, so in a BTC maximalist world, those 100 people still hold roughly the same fraction, right?
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by Synaesthesia on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @01:34AM (#29009890)
Yes it is. But bitcoin has an even greater degree of inequality, way beyond. Almost all the bitcoin is in the hands of a few thousand people.
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by zeepzeep on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @01:40AM (#29009927)
Sadly crypto currencies do not solve the problem of money distribution. (It's not the problem of the money, it's how we as society use it)
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by JohnJamesRambo on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @01:42AM (#29009936)
You can change that today by buying some. It’s an all you can eat buffet at $61,000 and those thousands will gladly sell you some.
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by arcticbull on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @02:14AM (#29010069)
You're going to love my Herbalife supplements.
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by 2pEXgD0fZ5cF on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @05:35AM (#29011124)
I'd say the main takeaway is that the narrative of "crypto currencies decentralize money and transfer the power and control from banks/rich people to the people" is just complete bullsh*.