News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by belval on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @04:37PM (#29005936)
Net income up 68%, that's terrifying high for a company that size. Good job everyone at Alphabet/Google.
Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by dekhn on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @04:46PM (#29006047)
There's a part of Chaos Monkey where the author describes driving past Google on a weekend and seeing empty parking lots while Facebook's were full (this was during Google Plus). He concluded that Google no longer had a fire in the belly and facebook was going to overcome it, not just in social mindshare, but ad revenue.

Conditions changed.

Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by nostrademons on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @04:54PM (#29006114)
The dirty secret of tech is that markets matter more than effort or smarts. If you have product/market fit and a decent technological lead in a market that is large and growing, you will do better than a company that does not have PMF or a good market, regardless of how hard you work. (This explains so much about Oracle.) Social media mentions are probably a better sign of how well you'll do than full parking lots.

I'd bet that Google & Facebook's current run-up is largely driven by inflation and higher ad prices. FB even said as much in a recent earnings call. Jerome Powell did more for their business than any employee up through the CEO did.

Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by dekhn on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @06:05PM (#29006951)
Google's revenue growth came at least in part by creating two new markets that it has control over: youtube ads and mobile ads. In both areas, Google was able to couple a rapidly growing product with new ad space that it auctioned. I doubt most people appreciate quite how effective Youtube and Google Play are at delivering ads to users and money to Google. It's not just inflation and higher prices- it's a massive growth of the market.
Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by gitfan86 on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @05:14PM (#29006330)
markets and moats matter. Anyone can get revenue selling tomatoes, the problem with tomato farming is that there is no moat, you will not be able to sell at a price much higher than the next farmer down the street.

If there were 100 good search engines the price for advertising would be 90% lower

Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by jsnell on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @05:23PM (#29006455)
> If there were 100 good search engines the price for advertising would be 90% lower

Why do you think that? The revenue is determined by the number of searches showing ads, the click-through rate, and the cost per click. The total across all companies would clearly not change for the first two metrics. Would the cost per click change? Given it's determined by an auction, I don't see how it could change. If you have an incentive to bid $1 on an ad on a single site with 100x traffic, you'd be equally willing to bid $1 on each of 100 separate sites with 1x traffic.

Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by gitfan86 on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @06:31PM (#29007208)
If competition existed company A would offer a better product than just cost-per-click. Then company B would offer another product better than company A, and so on. Google is like a person that owns the only road between two towns. You have to pay them until other people can build ferries or airports or trains. At which point you can exit the mentality of "we have to take this road and pay per drive"
Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by jsnell on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @06:55PM (#29007442)
Sorry, that still makes no sense to me. Why would company B have to make a better product in reaction? They're not being impacted at all. Company A having more and cheaper ads certainly won't make any users switch from B to A. It also won't make any existing advertisers stop spending on ads on B and run more ads on A, since the ads on B must have been profitable at the current price, and those ads are reaching a different set of users than the ads on A.

Is it possible that those cheaper ads could create more demand for ads somehow? It seems hard to believe it could. Either it's a search term that people were already willing to buy more expensive ads for, and are now just happy to pay less, or it's a search term that nobody was willing to bid even minimum price for.

What's actually going to happen in your scenario is that company A loses 90% of their revenue, goes bankrupt, and their domain is sold for a fair price to Company B or one of the other 98 remaining competitors.

Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by dragonwriter on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @05:50PM (#29006777)
> If there were 100 good search engines the price for advertising would be 90% lower

If there were 100 good search engines for end users, but opinions of different users on quality were highly correlated, the traffic would be very disproportionately on the one that was perceived as even very slightly better.

And they’d make the bulk of the advertising dollars.

And they’d have the bulk of the money to throw at improvements.

And the next year, unless some competitor got more access to outside investment to make up for that, the gap would be bigger, they’d have even more of the search audience, and even more of the advertising money, etc.

Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by gitfan86 on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @06:23PM (#29007130)
You are describing 99 shitty search engines and 1 good one.
Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by dragonwriter on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @06:28PM (#29007185)
Sure, if “slighty worse that good” is “shitty”.

When you can’t sell your slightly-less-good product for a lower price to make it value-competitive to slightly-more-good one, there’s very little reason for all the users not to go to the slightly-more-good one. With free services given away to get an advertising audience, that makes slight advantages very prone to positive feedback loops.

Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by bduerst on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @05:18PM (#29006396)
>If there were 100 good search engines the price for advertising would be 90% lower

Would it really be that much though?

I thought search ads were auctions - i.e. competition for impressions/clicks directly correlates to the price of advertising.

If you have search users distributed across 100 platforms, the competition for impressions/clicks is going to be super low on all platforms, but you'd have to advertise on 100 platforms to get the same level of engagement, adding it all back up but with 100 middle men this time.

Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by candiodari on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @05:26PM (#29006493)
> If there were 100 good search engines the price for advertising would be 90% lower

And the number of ads and hidden ads would be like Cable.

Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by whimsicalism on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @05:17PM (#29006374)
> I'd bet that Google & Facebook's current run-up is largely driven by inflation and higher ad prices.

What does this mean? The dollar didn't inflate 68%.

If you mean that companies are investing more capital into advertising because capital markets are looser, sure, but why is that a bad thing again?

Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by nostrademons on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @07:31PM (#29007761)
Inflation is uneven, and it tends to pool in markets that are:

a.) close to the point where the money is injected

b.) have quick-adapting prices, ideally ones where competitors bid against each other

c.) are dominated by 1-2 firms with little competition, so they have pricing power.

Google and Facebook tick all the boxes. In COVID money was injected directly to the consumers (thanks to stimulus payments) and to small or mid-size business (PPP loans). Google and Facebook run up-to-the-minute ad auctions, so prices adapt immediately to additional money becoming available. And they have little real competition, so it's not like they can be undercut by competitors.

By contrast, wages (for example) a.) require that your employer have more money, which generally requires that it have trickled down through the whole value chain b.) get updated usually once per year and c.) generally require that your competition also decide they're going to ask for more money too, less your employer just decide to employ someone else. That's why wages are often the last and stickiest place that inflation shows up.

The general phenomena of certain businesses being able to raise prices earlier, faster, and more than others in response to rising money supply is called the Cantillon Effect, and is a pretty fertile ground for making lots of money in an inflationary environment.

Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by whimsicalism on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @07:48PM (#29007918)
2 -> This is the only part of the comment I agree with, inflation is slower to show up in sticky prices.

The rest is wrong - you can look to an economist https://www.themoneyillusion.com/it-really-really-really-doe... if you want an explanation.

I'll not there is a tension between 2 and 3 as highly competitive markets tend to not have sticky prices.

tl;dr You advance a claim of strong monetary non-neutrality. I think that outside of sticky prices, your claim is overstated.

Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by DenseComet on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @04:53PM (#29006110)
Thats an insane conclusion imo. Weekend work being normalized leads to unhappier employees. Working longer also doesn't just mean more productivity, there's been many cases of four day work weeks causing no change.

Employees are a company's most valuable resource. A company looking to grow and innovate must take care of its employees and part of it is respecting their time.

Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by b9a2cab5 on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @06:22PM (#29007127)
Try working 30 hours a week in a top research lab and then come back and say that. Research is one of the least code monkey things you can do (requires the most creativity) yet everyone is working 80-100 hour weeks.

4 day work weeks causing no change means those engineers weren't productive in the first place. Which, in my experience, is the case in a lot of FAANGMULA teams.

Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by buryat on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @04:50PM (#29006086)
> empty parking lots

people working remote

Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by cornstalks on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @04:59PM (#29006187)
During the Google Plus days? Not so much.
Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by azinman2 on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @05:05PM (#29006250)
And indeed FB did eat their lunch in social.
Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by lostdog on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @05:08PM (#29006279)
Because they worked more hours, or because they chose to build something less stupid?
Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by azinman2 on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @07:40PM (#29007861)
Because FB took it extremely seriously and iterated like crazy, where as Google never really did. It was a mindset issue in addition to product taste.
Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by dekhn on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @06:06PM (#29006959)
and in doing so, set themselves up for much larger failure. Google instead pivoted that energy into cloud, which is now broken out in their earnings.

I was one of those googlers who, when Plus was announced, wondered "why aren't we announcing an AWS competitor?"

Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by azinman2 on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @07:46PM (#29007908)
What makes you think it was the same people inside Google that did social instead of cloud computing, and that was the choice going through leadership?

Google can walk and chew gum at the same time.

Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by dekhn on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @07:55PM (#29007980)
Well, I worked there at the time and had significant insight into the cloud leadership (and some into the social leadership), it wasn't the same people at all. Basically, Eric Schmidt wanted Google to make an enterprise cloud product years before it did, and saw no point in social, while Larry somehow got conned by Vic Gundotra and a few good PM decks that social was Google's future. Larry never had any interest in cloud computing and even the cloud leadership was skeptical that it could ever present an opportunity worth the small profit margins.
Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by sangnoir on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @10:35PM (#29008974)
> Google can walk and chew gum at the same time.

As I recall from my outside/user perspective: Google Plus pretty much co-opted the entire organization in an supposed "all hands on deck, existential fight" against Facebook. Every product and feature had to have a "social" layer (including GMail!); YouTube even adopted a "Real Name" policy but still amazingly managed to worsen the comment system.

Can you imagine what a similar level of effort on the cloud would have produced? Maybe they wouldn't be a distant #3 in that space today.

Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by jeffbee on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @05:08PM (#29006275)
At the same time Facebook tried and failed to take on Gmail.
Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by azinman2 on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @07:45PM (#29007898)
I would not argue they failed. Young people don't email their friends.
Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by jeffbee on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @10:25AM (#29013680)
They don't Facebook their friends either, and email is now integrated into schools. Every kid I know has Gmail and none of them have Facebook (although, many do use Instagram).
Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by azinman2 on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @01:10PM (#29016075)
Instagram and WhatsApp are Facebook.
Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by dragonwriter on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @05:55PM (#29006837)
But not “not only in social mindshare, but in ad revenue”.

Social is just (fom a business perspective) a tool for getting an audience. The thing both Google and Facebook are selling is advertisement placement. Winning in one area of free “services” to build an audience to deliver ads to but not winning in actually selling ads…isn’t winning.

Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by kansface on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @04:41PM (#29005991)
More like the pandemic is good for pushing activities onto the internet of which Google takes its slice.
Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by TrainedMonkey on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @04:54PM (#29006123)
And $2T dumped into stock market, portion of which companies have used on online ads to compete for increased revenue.
Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by mrep on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @05:01PM (#29006209)
Where are you getting your $2T number from?
Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by TrainedMonkey on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @05:12PM (#29006315)
Looking at https://www.investopedia.com/government-stimulus-efforts-to-... and roughly guesstimating $1.5T from direct loans / PPP and additional $0.5T from the knock off stimulus and inflation effects.
Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by mrep on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @05:18PM (#29006394)
That's money given to people and businesses. Secondary effects could go into the stock market but not directly and I definitely would not call that dumping into the stock market considering most was probably used to keep business and people afloat.
Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by harmmonica on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @06:41PM (#29007302)
This squarely falls into the anecdotal camp, but my understanding based on online commentary and more specifically the actual experiences of four of my friends who run businesses ranging from a two-employee, furniture-building firm that probably generates $300-$500k in annual revenue all the way up to a major concrete contractor with a thousand employees and hundreds of millions in revenue applied for and were granted government funds and not a single one of those companies needed the money to keep staff on the payroll because their businesses continued to operate as normal for the extent of the pandemic. At least one of those folks fully admitted to putting their entire $80k+ "loan" into the stock market (the cruise lines in particular when they were getting beat up early on). It's appalling. And yes I said friends. I'm not condoning it, but business people will justify by saying "that's why I pay taxes."

I can't prove the scale, but I believe the op (or was it gp?) is right and those funds, to some extent, went directly into stocks, real estate, luxury automobiles, luxury watches, artwork and other assets, and a large percentage of the remainder found its way to those same places indirectly.

I have no concrete evidence or source for this, but I don't think my friends are unique here. For as many businesses as you heard were struggling there were countless others doing ok or even well during the pandemic.

Just trying to offer a different perspective on your comment.

Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by Jensson on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @06:29PM (#29007196)
In a trickle up economy it doesn't matter where you drop it, it will go into the stock market.
Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by deadmutex on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @04:56PM (#29006144)
Umm, a pandemic is not good for business. Many of the ads are bought by real businesses.

"Alphabet has been viewed as a key beneficiary of the **reopening trade**, given it stands to gain from a pick-up in travel-related searches and advertising on Google Search." (** emphasis mine **)

Source: https://finance.yahoo.com/news/alphabet-google-reports-q3-20...

Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by sangnoir on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @10:43PM (#29009019)
A lot of "real businesses" are online and saw a massive boom of people searching for, and buying products online. Additionally, a lot of marketing campaigns on TV/radio were stopped when the lock-downs started, and the budgets were shifted online. Same real businesses (think fast-fashion retailer), simply shifting more money to Google while they figured out if, and how to shoot new ads to replace those that depicted happy people at crowded parties.
Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by Factorium on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @06:04PM (#29006934)
Lockdowns and money printing are great for business. No wonder Google is deplatforming scientists and engaging in mass censorship.
[dead]
Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] by sidibe on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @05:22PM (#29006439)
Don't see anything in there about government paying