News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google digital advertising antitrust litigation [pdf] by mathnmusic on Sunday October 24, 2021 @02:12AM (#28975360)
Google should be broken up into 5 parts: Search/Adwords/Mail/Drive, Android, Chrome, Maps & GCP.
Re:Google digital advertising antitrust litigation [pdf] by vgel on Sunday October 24, 2021 @03:24AM (#28975631)
Ads would need to be split up further, as well. It's ridiculous that Google controls the marketplace, buying of ads on that marketplace, and selling ad placements.
Re:Google digital advertising antitrust litigation [pdf] by solidangle on Sunday October 24, 2021 @03:57AM (#28975764)
Agreed! GCP should be broken up as well. It is incredibly unfair to third party services that Google is both supplying the platform and the competing services. This is probably a bigger problem on AWS though.
Re:Google digital advertising antitrust litigation [pdf] by lettergram on Sunday October 24, 2021 @02:13AM (#28975364)
No ads should be separate from everything imo. Drive and mail can each make money on their own.

Search and AdWords are too tied however.

Re:Google digital advertising antitrust litigation [pdf] by weird-eye-issue on Sunday October 24, 2021 @02:20AM (#28975391)
You mean Google Ads - and no they don't have to be too tied together. What is so special about Google Search that Google Ads has to be owned by the same entity? I have websites with ads on them and I don't own the ad network either like 99.99999% of every other publisher out there
Re:Google digital advertising antitrust litigation [pdf] by easrng on Sunday October 24, 2021 @01:48PM (#28980254)
Because they sell specially-formatted ad spots that are supposed to look like results, not generic display ads.
Re:Google digital advertising antitrust litigation [pdf] by weird-eye-issue on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:51PM (#28983728)
They can continue to do that and it doesn't need to be part of the broader Google Ads entity that places ads on other websites and operates an even broader ad exchange

Think about Pinterest, Quora, or FB, for example, they have "native ads" but they don't operate Internet-wide ad exchanges

Re:Google digital advertising antitrust litigation [pdf] by easrng on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @03:48PM (#29005365)
Wasn't that what lettergram was saying? They specifically were talking about AdWords (regardless of whether that's the current name), which is Google's search ads system, not all of Google Ads.
Re:Google digital advertising antitrust litigation [pdf] by weird-eye-issue on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @09:20AM (#29012941)
Google Ads is a single entity that does both and AdWords is now known as Google Ads. So what he was actually referring to is ambiguous...
Re:Google digital advertising antitrust litigation [pdf] by DeathArrow on Sunday October 24, 2021 @02:40AM (#28975463)
That would mean 5 monopolies. I would split them in 5 parts, each owning 20% of all current businesses.
Re:Google digital advertising antitrust litigation [pdf] by seanhunter on Sunday October 24, 2021 @03:10AM (#28975571)
There's a very clear conflict of interest between ads and everything else google does, and the documents alledge some abuses of the monopoly position around that conflict. So any kind of antitrust breakup is very likely to start there. Personally, I think it would be quite interesting to split ads from everything else and then split ads itself into a few competing entities.

I'm not sure you get a benefit to the consumer from having multiple entities who can all still do search and manipulate ads, keyword sales and search rankings for example.

Re:Google digital advertising antitrust litigation [pdf] by willis936 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @05:18AM (#28976179)
But the ads are how google exists. They keep the lights on and the campus hedges trimmed. If you spin off a google without ads then would it even succeed or would the google with ads just take its old monopolistic position as soon as society allowed (forgot) it?
Re:Google digital advertising antitrust litigation [pdf] by makeitdouble on Sunday October 24, 2021 @04:14AM (#28975854)
A monopoly is fine if it doesn’t hamper competition and doesn’t use its position to impact unrelated markets.

Shimano has a near monopoly on bike parts, and it’s mostly fine. DJI dominates the pro drone market, and it’s fine. All monopolies aren’t evil.

Re:Google digital advertising antitrust litigation [pdf] by robbedpeter on Sunday October 24, 2021 @06:00AM (#28976397)
Context matters. With the intellectual property situation as bad as it is right now, the monopolies those companies hold give them a nearly unbeatable advantage in squashing competition. Their IP holdings let them immediately tangle up any new businesses with massive legal hurdles, regardless of the merits of their claims.

DJI being in China means they will lie, cheat, and steal from competitors such that meaningful competition becomes impossible.

Innovation and consumer value suffer. Monopolies automatically and unavoidably hamper competition and have secondary impacts on unrelated products through inflation of pricing, e.g. if a cog is overpriced it's taking spending away from other markets.

Corporations are not people, they are constructs that act toward to goal of self preservation at any cost. Once they exceed a certain size, individual humans in the loop lose meaningful control over the behavior of the company as a whole.

The international legal situation we find ourselves in automatically places Chinese companies outside the reach of accountability to any rules by which most of the rest of the world have to abide.

By themselves, monopolies could be functional participants in a healthy economy, but there are too many factors making that position completely untenable right now.

Re:Google digital advertising antitrust litigation [pdf] by accountofme on Sunday October 24, 2021 @02:47AM (#28975486)
So you are saying that no one entity could own more than 20% of alphabet? And it would retain all of its monopoly power?
Re:Google digital advertising antitrust litigation [pdf] by axiosgunnar on Sunday October 24, 2021 @02:44AM (#28975476)
How would this help?
Re:Google digital advertising antitrust litigation [pdf] by gonzo41 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @03:40AM (#28975691)
You'd need to control the flow of people between those companies for this to work well. It'd be a challenge with us Labor law
Re:Google digital advertising antitrust litigation [pdf] by oscargrouch on Sunday October 24, 2021 @05:03PM (#28981891)
Sovereign states are anemic by now and i'm skeptical that they would want to fight where the money and (real) power is, and if they grow some balls, or stop being so corrupt, even than, i'm skeptical that they will manage to win this fight.

We are entering into a new era where big techs are so massive they can fight sovereign states and win, heading us into a new era of neo-feudalism were "civil rights" are only granted if they are not in the middle of our new digital lords lust for profit and power.

So people might think this is unlikely and conspiratory, but its just natural human nature, social dynamics and following the political vectors by the aggregation of the past events.

If they are willing, they know the secrets of everyone, and its just a matter of pressing the right people to bow to their will and that's it, we become the fools of Weimar republic that were not aware of the dangers ahead of us, because there were no historical precedent to make us vigilant and aware, and all the signs were well aligned to a hostile takeover.

Re:Google digital advertising antitrust litigation [pdf] by onion2k on Sunday October 24, 2021 @04:47AM (#28976014)
Only the ads part needs to be broken up. It funds all the other parts, so they'd break up or shut down on their own.
Re:Google digital advertising antitrust litigation [pdf] by throwaway4good on Sunday October 24, 2021 @03:28AM (#28975644)
Problem is only one of those things make money.
Re:Google digital advertising antitrust litigation [pdf] by mathnmusic on Sunday October 24, 2021 @04:21AM (#28975881)
Android's Play stores makes a lot of money. So much so that it's quite comfortable reducing its fees from 30% to 15% for some developers.

Maps already charges fees for all location-based apps (cabs, deliveries, fleet tracking etc) like Uber. It may have to tweak its pricing, that's all.

GCP has a revenue model as strong as AWS. There's a reason why Google is pumping money into it.

Chrome is the only one that could be called a loss leader but given its dominance, it can figure out a model. If Adobe photoshop can survive as a paid software, so can Chrome and its Developer Tools.

Re:Google digital advertising antitrust litigation [pdf] by otabdeveloper4 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:43AM (#28977013)
That's not a problem, that's an opportunity.

Don't we all love "disrupting" things?

Re:Google digital advertising antitrust litigation [pdf] by djrockstar1 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @03:54AM (#28975746)
I'd say 3 of those make money. The first one, Android with the Play Store, and GCP with Firebase gaining popularity, should all be bringing in enough money to be self-sustaining.
Re:Google digital advertising antitrust litigation [pdf] by stonogo on Sunday October 24, 2021 @04:51AM (#28976029)
Google has a TON of retired properties that were profit-makers, but not unicorns. Smaller Baby Googles would likely find solid revenue bringing some of them back.
Re:Google digital advertising antitrust litigation [pdf] by libertine on Sunday October 24, 2021 @06:18AM (#28976519)
Youtube man!

Youtube must be split from Google ASAP!