News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The FDA wants you to be able to buy a hearing aid without... by slownews45 on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @04:19PM (#28923228)
Fantastic news.

If you can afford the $5,000 - great! The current system works for you. 80% of people cannot and so are stuck.

For folks with mild/moderate loss (where a LOT of people don't get help) something as simple as letting Apple tweak noise cancellation to be voice enhancing and providing a tuning and hearing test app in the iphone would be a godsend.

The elderly miss out on a lot of family life because of hearing issues - people stop talking to them even if they are fully sound of mind because of this issue. I've seen this personally.

And for all those who say apple is just a consumer products company and there is no way their $180 - $250 airpods can provide any benefit I think you might be surprised.

Re:The FDA wants you to be able to buy a hearing aid without... by ddlutz on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @04:45PM (#28923524)
This is me. 28, had mild hearing loss for about 3 years now in one ear due to a bad ear infection. I can get by fine, however I'm definitely missing out on a lot of "richness" of sound. I can't hear high pitched noises, or subtle differences between noises in my left ear at all. And everything in general is a little muted. Since I can hear perfectly find out of my right ear I'm not convinced spending thousands of dollars is worth it.

I would spend $10,000+ if my tinnitus could be cured permanently though.

Re:The FDA wants you to be able to buy a hearing aid without... by dfinninger on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @08:05PM (#28925290)
I'd take that tinnitus treatment in a heartbeat.

The drumming-on-the-back-of-the-skull trick lasts just long enough for me to realize what the world could sound like. (I tend to not do it anymore due to the mild depression I get realizing how fleeting the relief is)

Re:The FDA wants you to be able to buy a hearing aid without... by babarganesh on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @08:50PM (#28925557)
i'd pay way more than 100k for a tinnitus cure. it would be worth significantly delaying retirement for. but there's nothing on the horizon. and yes, i have adapted to it well enough that it doesn't cause me anxiety and don't notice it 98% of the time. i just miss pure hearing.
Re:The FDA wants you to be able to buy a hearing aid without... by falcolas on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @04:42PM (#28923487)
FWIW, there is a nuanced difference between hearing aids and iPods. Hearing aids basically apply a hearing-capability matched EQ to the incoming sound.

Why this matters: Hearing loss is not uniform across frequencies, and we use huge portions of the spectrum for different functions (truck backup beepers vs. car engine noises, both used to identify what's coming your way).

Re:The FDA wants you to be able to buy a hearing aid without... by slownews45 on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @04:46PM (#28923542)
And you are CERTAIN that the iphone could not

a) conduct a hearing test

b) do a hearing based EQ on incoming sound?

c) do sound profiles (ie, optimize for speech?)

Realize that calling already may use some of this - using microphones to pick out speech from background noise etc.

For folks who have hearing issues you could have one device that would cover your movie watching, your phone calls, and hearing enhancement. For $180.

Re:The FDA wants you to be able to buy a hearing aid without... by falcolas on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @04:50PM (#28923585)
> conduct a hearing test

It could not. A hearing test requires an environment with exceptional isolation and flat-response drivers (iPods are not remotely flat) to be done properly.

> do a hearing based EQ on incoming sound

It could, given a proper prescription for the EQ, and an understanding of the response curve of the iPods' mic and drivers.

> do sound profiles

Not required, the EQ is tied to your hearing damage, not your environment.

Re:The FDA wants you to be able to buy a hearing aid without... by slownews45 on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @05:36PM (#28924083)
I've got a higher end audio setup, I can put the sound calibration mic in the listening position etc (think YPAO / Audyssey etc). But you get little weird sync issues at times between sources / displays etc.

On a whim I tried Apple's wireless sync. It's end to end, and works as well as I could with manual tuning (which I would do by filming at high speed a time audio sync track)

https://www.reddit.com/r/appletv/comments/itm711/psa_wireles...

So they demonstrated a consumer device could, in a few seconds, generate a fantastic sync solution across my entire input -> output -> room stack. Or I could spend an hour fiddling around in settings.

Airpod pro's provide a some level of isolation already especially if you run the fit check. airpods are also not that bad.

You could do a calibration curve at factory if needed for drivers. You could run a very user friendly process to fine tune, in the comfort of your own home, a profile of your hearing loss. You could update this anytime.

You could then also obviously offer some presets to amplify things in a targeted way. At the dinner table? Focus on voices. At a concert, do a music preset.

We've heard all this before with camera's by the way. The iphone doesn't have a "real camera". Yes, I used to shoot full frame. Yes, the iphone's cameras are "crap". But for many people they are "good enough", and they have other benefits, ease of use, easy to learn, not a big extra expense etc.

Let the market decide, apple can provide a warning -> if you want to wait for insurance to approve a hearing test, then schedule one, then wait for a device to be ordered and ship, then go back, then be dependent on an audiologist to tune things for you etc you should do so, but if you want, try out little app here to see if it helps.

Re:The FDA wants you to be able to buy a hearing aid without... by falcolas on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @07:39PM (#28925111)
> Let the market decide

I really hate it when people say "let the market decide" when it comes to health care. It's how we get $10,000 suppositories (a story earlier this week).

It appears you really like Apple's audio hardware (whereas I think it's middling crap), know little about hearing loss, and I don't feel like arguing the points.

Congratulations, you win.

Re:The FDA wants you to be able to buy a hearing aid without... by onphonenow on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @07:43AM (#28929511)
That’s not the market - if one person is paying and another consuming you get crazy distortions.

As to whether AirPods etc are crap - I’ll let you have you opinion- I like them and they seem to sell well

Re:The FDA wants you to be able to buy a hearing aid without... by sgent on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @08:10PM (#28925316)
The real issue is that an iphone cannot check for conductive or mixed hearing loss.
Re:The FDA wants you to be able to buy a hearing aid without... by jrace on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @04:50PM (#28923586)
They would need a properly calibrated set of headphones/microphones and environment to conduct a proper hearing test.
Re:The FDA wants you to be able to buy a hearing aid without... by mnemotronic on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @05:17PM (#28923876)
<i>It could not. A hearing test requires an environment with exceptional isolation</i> Don't be so picky. Or don't let the perfect be the enemy of the good enough.
Re:The FDA wants you to be able to buy a hearing aid without... by falcolas on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @07:27PM (#28925009)
An improper hearing test can result in an improper amplification curve, which can lead to further hearing loss.

Perfect is perfectly acceptable to aim for, when it comes to your hearing for life.

Re:The FDA wants you to be able to buy a hearing aid without... by jrace on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @03:02PM (#28934697)
A hearing test is done to compare your thresholds to what is considered "normal".

Without controlled test environment you cannot compare as your test environment will change your thresholds, and therefore make the test invalid.

Re:The FDA wants you to be able to buy a hearing aid without... by RHSeeger on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @04:48PM (#28923557)
I had some trauma induced hearing loss recently and cannot hear certain frequencies at all with my left ear. When I stand outside next to the (small) waterfall with it on my left size, I can hear "part" of it from my left ear... and the other part as if it was coming from the woods on the right side. It passes right by my left ear w/o me hearing it, bounces off the woods, and comes back to me. It sounds like there's 2 different waterfalls, one on each side of me.
Re:The FDA wants you to be able to buy a hearing aid without... by falcolas on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @04:52PM (#28923614)
Trippy, isn't it? A similar phenomenon can occur without hearing damage, where the reflection to the right ear is at the right phase to cause wave-interference with the source waveform that reaches the right ear.
Re:The FDA wants you to be able to buy a hearing aid without... by eurleif on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @04:46PM (#28923530)
Samsung phones have a feature that tests your hearing at different frequencies, creates a personalized EQ profile, and applies it to your earbuds: https://www.samsung.com/au/support/mobile-devices/customise-...
Re:The FDA wants you to be able to buy a hearing aid without... by falcolas on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @04:54PM (#28923629)
Cool. But without properly flat headphones and sufficient sound isolation, I wouldn't put a ton of trust into it.

It's probably good enough for an temporary situation, but I wouldn't trust it long term. Improper amplification can damage your hearing further.

Re:The FDA wants you to be able to buy a hearing aid without... by eurleif on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @05:10PM (#28923810)
I don't know much about this topic, so interpret these as questions, not as arguments that I have particular confidence in:

* If the earbuds you use to perform the hearing test are the same ones you use with the resulting EQ profile, why does it matter whether the earbuds are flat or not? If you're taking measurements in a transformed coordinate space, and applying those measurements in the same transformed coordinate space, shouldn't that be equivalent to taking measurements in the original coordinate space and applying them in the original coordinate space?

* Why isn't active noise cancellation a good enough form of noise isolation?

* If using an EQ profile that only matches your hearing loss imperfectly can damage your hearing, wouldn't the same thing apply to EQ profiles that aren't intended to correct hearing, like the media player presets "classical music", "rock music", etc.? For that matter, wouldn't it apply to a flat EQ profile? Is there something special about an imperfect hearing correction EQ profile, compared to other EQ profiles?

Re:The FDA wants you to be able to buy a hearing aid without... by falcolas on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @07:36PM (#28925088)
> If the earbuds you use to perform the hearing test are the same ones you use with the resulting EQ profile

You also have to account for the microphone, which can (and will) have its own bias. Measuring from a flat response source, and producing for a flat response mic/speaker combination will produce the most accurate results.

> active noise cancellation

ANC creates sound artifacts at low volumes. It also provides, in ideal circumstances, around 25Db of noise reduction. You probably want between 40 and 80Db (or more) of noise reduction, depending on the ambient noise level around you. The threshold of hearing hovers around 10Db for healthy ears. Healthy ears can hearing your own heartbeat in an anechoic chamber (as close to 0Db as we can get).

> wouldn't the same thing apply to EQ profiles that aren't intended to correct hearing

If you're correcting for a 40Db loss at one frequency (taken randomly from the surrounding threads), applying it to a frequency where you have only 20Db loss can result in an extra 20Db of sound at that frequency. 20Db is 4x louder by perception, and over 6x higher pressure.

For a point of reference, Apple music's EQ curves are 12Db, 24Db if you set the extremes. So yes, they could damage your hearing, but that will depend more on the volume than the EQ.

Re:The FDA wants you to be able to buy a hearing aid without... by mnemotronic on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @05:15PM (#28923860)
I'll bet most earbuds with active noise reduction and equalization could be tweaked to provide augmentation similar to a hearing aid. The current algorithms for active noise reduction are designed to suppress external sounds -- all they have to do is invert the logic and amplify external sounds. Just add EQ to make my wife's voice come in better.
Re:The FDA wants you to be able to buy a hearing aid without... by dominotw on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @01:48AM (#28927205)
My dad has mild hearing loss and recent 'conversation boost' in airpods works like magic for him.

Most ppl don't know that this even exists in their airpods because the settings are hidden deep inside hearing accessiblity .

Re:The FDA wants you to be able to buy a hearing aid without... by kristofferR on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @04:26PM (#28923324)
Yeah, the AirPods Pro's are amazing as hearing aids.

The only issue is that they are very visible and only last 4 hours each charge (I suppose you could get two pairs and switch between them every four hours).

Re:The FDA wants you to be able to buy a hearing aid without... by slownews45 on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @04:40PM (#28923471)
Airpods 3's should be 6 hours without spatial audio. And yes, I do use one at a time! The charge time is pretty quick.
Re:The FDA wants you to be able to buy a hearing aid without... by kristofferR on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @07:57PM (#28925241)
The things that makes it work good as a hearing aid are the microphones and other Pro-only features though, so the non-Pro can't be used.