News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by blub on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @05:33AM (#2890510)
I have been using GIMP for 9 months and the UI is exasperating.

It's not just multi-window mode, things like the way the windows are rendered and designed, focus issues, shortcuts, missing features and a lot of other annoyances.

The most disappointing thing is that I'm not even doing intensive graphical work, just retouching some photos, moving things around, resizing, etc.

Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by gst on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @05:48AM (#2890542)
The UI works quite well with a focus-follows-mouse policy - as it has been standard in Unix for decades. With today's click-to-focus window managers the UI is just horrible (but that's not Gimp's fault).
Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by LawnGnome on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @06:21AM (#2890613)
To an extent it is Gimp's fault, though. It's not as though click-to-focus is a new fad that's sprung up and surprised everyone -- it's been the default way focus has worked in GNOME and KDE for as long as I can remember, and I've been using it for the best part of fifteen years on Linux.

The fact that such a common use case (almost certainly the most common use case, not to mention Gimp-related irritation, for at least the past decade) has been ignored for so long is disappointing.

Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by thristian on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @07:35AM (#2890738)
The most common use case... except among the kind of people whose idea of a fun evening is developing a Free image editor on a Free operating system.

I'm not one of those people, but I have a similar background, and GIMP has suited me pretty well for the photo-retouching and website-graphics work I've done.

Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by pwg on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @08:44AM (#2890916)
> almost certainly the most common use case [click-to-focus]

Most common only if you are coming from a ms-windows background. Click-to-focus is only a relatively recent newcomer to the Unix/X-Windows system in the scheme of how long X-Windows has existed.

And if you ever break out of your ms-windows mindset and actually give focus follows mouse a try, focus follows mouse is actually the more powerful method.

Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by eropple on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @10:50AM (#2891361)
And if you ever break out of your ms-windows mindset and actually give focus follows mouse a try, focus follows mouse is actually the more powerful method.

Not this again. Focus-follows-mouse is different, not more powerful. It provides a different way of working that not everyone agrees with and not everyone wants to use.

Seriously, get over yourself.

Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by pwg on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @12:30PM (#2891797)
Yes, it is different.

But it is that very difference that makes it much more powerful of a UI convention.

If you had ever experienced it, you'd understand.

Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by eropple on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @01:32PM (#2892090)
I've used both. I have no preference and can work in either; it doesn't affect me either way. Your argument is to false authority.
Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by drivingmenuts on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @11:17PM (#2893921)
All the power in the world doesn't matter if it's not what the user wants or expects.

Which gets right to the core of GIMP's marketing problems. For years, users wanted a cheap Photoshop clone ... they got GIMP. Because it's not a near-clone of PS, it hasn't caught on as well outside a small group.

Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by 5l on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @09:03AM (#2890959)
Just as an FYI, Windows actually supports focus follows mouse with a registry hack [0]. There are a couple of quirks mostly to do with things like tooltips, but I've found it usable.

[0] http://sinewalker.wordpress.com/2010/03/10/ms-windows-focus-...

Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by seabee on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @11:24AM (#2891494)
I remember getting a Windows 95 PowerToy for it; I didn't see the point of it, previously being an Amiga user which had click-to-focus also.
Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by windsurfer on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @10:05AM (#2891166)
The new window managers are a hybrid. Mouse events are focus follows mouse, while keyboard events are focus follows click. This allows you to highlight a bit of text and middle click on another window to paste, but leave the focus on the first window and continue typing, for instance. It also allows you to code in an editor while scrolling a documentation window.

MS Windows is only focus follows mouse.

Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by bronson on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @01:58PM (#2892198)
Citation please. I love focus-follows-mouse but this sounds downright confusing. Do windows have different highlights to show where mouse and keyboard events will go?
Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by windsurfer on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @09:53PM (#2893695)
Citation? Sorry, but it's been in Ubuntu for ages, and that's what I use.

As for the visual cues, it looks a lot like OS X. Currently focused windows has a highlighted top bar and pronounced shadows and is in front of other windows. As for where the keyboard and mouse events... keyboarrd goes to focused window, mouse goes to where you click. It makes sense.

Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by bronson on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @11:35PM (#2893972)
I'm using FFM in Ubuntu classic (non-Unity) right now. Mouse and keyboard events go to the highlighted window and the highlight follows the mouse (with a few minor exceptions which is why some people call it sloppy focus). Clicking doesn't affect where the events go.

Not sure what you're talking about...? Maybe plain old click-to-raise like Mac and Windows?

Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by jholman on Wednesday August 17, 2011 @02:56AM (#2894412)
I'm using default Ubuntu classic behaviour currently, and I almost agree with windsurfer's description. (I'm currently using 11.04, dist-upgraded from a 10.10 clean install, but it's been this way in every Ubuntu I've used over the past four years.)

If I mouse to a different window, focus does not follow (like MS). However... if I use the mousewheel, it applies to whatever window is under the mouse. As windsurfer says, this is cool because I can navigate around in one window while keeping my editor typing in another.

However, in disagreement with windsurfer's claim, my middle-click DOES change focus, as with my left- or right-click.

Anyway, I hate full-on sloppy focus, but I sure love this sloppy-mousewheel-focus.

Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by BDFL_Xenu on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @10:16AM (#2891217)
So that's the justification? That the GIMP expects WM settings that were only the default on TWM and the like over 15 years ago?

Well, I must say that I haven't seen any other application of its size take the "NO WARRANTY" shouting of the GPL so seriously.

   This program is distributed in the hope that it will be useful,
   but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of
   MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. 
But the program did start as a showcase for some graphics manipulation algorithms that the authors made. Maybe the fault is with the people with the high hopes that it was actually meant for them to use and edit their photos.
Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by rat on Wednesday August 17, 2011 @01:29AM (#2894226)
I'm fairly sure most closed source applications also Include something of a "NO Waranty as much to the degree allowed by law".
Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by theBobMcCormick on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @12:30PM (#2891793)
It seems rather inaccurate to claim that focus-follows-mouse is "standard in Unix".

Correct me if I'm wrong, but focus-follows-mouse hasn't been the standard in Unix for quite some time. I don't think it's ever been the default in Gnome or KDE. Is it the default on anything that isn't antiquated and/or super-niche (like FVWM or TWM, etc.)?

Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by yason on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @02:04PM (#2892227)
Haven't seen a default configuration of focus-follows-mouse for quite a while on any "big" Linux desktops. I always turn it on manually the first thing I touch a new system so it's not a big problem. However, a bigger problem is that finding a strict focus-follows-mouse is getting more difficult: for example Metacity can't do it, only sloppy focus-follows-mouse.

But the strict one would be the real focus-follows-mouse: with that you never lose the focus unintentionally since the focus is always under the mouse cursor. With sloppy focus, a newly opened window might of might not steal the focus regardless of the mouse position, and I quite often find myself typing into the wrong window after that.

Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by nimrody on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @05:51AM (#2890549)
I haven't been tracking GIMP development for quite a while and couldn't find the information online.

Does the current version of GIMP finally support non-destructive editing (adjustment layers)?

Is GIMP still too slow for photo retouching?

Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by wcoenen on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @06:48AM (#2890659)
> Does the current version of GIMP finally support non-destructive editing (adjustment layers)?

Layer effects are planned for Gimp 3.2. http://wiki.gimp.org/index.php/Roadmap

It will be achieved by integrating the GEGL library (http://www.gegl.org/) which enables the use of OpenCL acceleration (http://www.khronos.org/opencl/).

Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by blub on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @06:35AM (#2890640)
No, the version that I'm using doesn't seem to support this so I duplicate the layer and work on the copy.

As for slowness, it depends on what kind of retouching you are doing. I'm retouching mobile graphics assets, which are small enough and I haven't seen any lags. I image that things are very different when working with high quality photos...

Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by nodata on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @06:11AM (#2890596)
Can you name some of these things that have been bothering you for the past nine months?
Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by blub on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @07:02AM (#2890684)
The biggest problem I have with GIMP is that it's not intuitive. Every time I open it I have to stop and think how I am supposed to do what I am trying to do, my work never flows. This has such an impact on my productivity that I'm desperately looking for alternatives that don't involve purchasing Photoshop - now looking at Pixelmator. Other members of the team have switched to Paint.NET or other simple editors, but they are too simple for me.

Another problem that I have is with focus - sometimes the picture window loses input focus to one of the tool windows and then the keyboard shortcuts stop working. I have to click on the window and then use the shortcut, but when clicking the current tool will execute its action (such as paint a black blob in the middle of the layer), so I have to click outside the picture area (might be hard to do) or hunt for the title bar. Furthermore, when the tool windows have focus they control some of the widgets in the tool window, popping up subwindows or changing settings by accident.

Yet another issue is text editing and selection. GIMP does not allow me to do live text-editing, instead it pops up a dialog box and I have to adjust the actual text rect in the background. Every time I click the text rect to adjust it the tool windows flicker into view for 0.5 seconds, very annoying. Selections are significantly harder to control compared to Photoshop, where you can do pretty much anything to a selection just by using the mouse and one or two keys.

General UI problems:

* dialogs that are too small

* dialogs popping up over other dialogs

* many dialogs that cover the image when shown and I have to move them out of the way

* dialogs that sometimes remember their position, sometimes show up at apparently random locations

* tool windows exiting the screen

* tool fields that just look like they were thrown together without any thought to spacing, grouping and alignment (check out the rectangle select or the almost invisible spinner arrows for the layer transparency)

* the layers tool window is especially difficult to use with a mouse (dragging & dropping, ordering, linking)

* tools that reset their settings (e.g: move tool rests to pick a layer to move instead of move active)

* general disregard for UI design that makes the UI look crowded (e.g layers tab icons)

* the design choice of clipping layers to the visible image area, forcing you to resize the canvas and the layers unnecessarily

I could go on and on and on. I can't remember using GIMP even once without being annoyed by something in the UI that breaks my work flow.

The features I miss the most are adjustments layers, layer grouping (this is so painful when working with a lot of layers).

Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by nodata on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @09:18AM (#2891000)
Great! A list of problems with a description of _why_ it's a problem. Can I ask if you have put this list anywhere near the GIMP developers - mailing lists or bugzilla?
Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by windsurfer on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @10:10AM (#2891191)
If you've tried the latest build, litereally every issue he's described has been fixed.
Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by nodata on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @10:30AM (#2891279)
It would be interesting to know if it's because he brought these issues to the attention of the developers.
Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by eropple on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @10:51AM (#2891364)
Given the fairly legendary hostility of GIMP developers, I'd hope he brought an asbestos suit.

(History aside, they're actually acting like they care about their users as of late, and good on them for it. It certainly took long enough.)

Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by windsurfer on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @12:17PM (#2891743)
I doubt it. These changes have been on the roadmap for a long time.
Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by blub on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @10:29AM (#2891277)
I assume windsurfer below is correct and that most of these have been fixed in the latest build (unavailable to me yet).

I will wait for it to become available and then write a small list with the issues and try to send it to the mailing list/bugzilla.

Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by tintin on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @09:45AM (#2891099)
Totally agree. I would like to add one think that is bugging me: layer size. It sucks. Move a layer 50 pix. to the right and suddenly you can't draw in the left 50 pixels because the layer has moved. But perhaps some issues are they because of patents. I can image they cannot copy every part of Photoshop. But infinite layer size would be nice.
Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by jcfrei on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @09:52AM (#2891124)
thanks - I'm glad I'm not the only one who feels that way. GIMP completly breaks your photoshop habits, because it's so similar yet makes tiny little differences along the way. either embrace the photoshop design philosophy fully - or build your own, distinct and intuitive GUI - now it's just confusing to the point of being useless, whenever I have to quickly edit a picture on linux.
Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by SoftwareMaven on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @10:02AM (#2891157)
I understand what you mean, since i feel the same way every time i use gimp. However, I don't think you can blame it for breaking your photoshop habits. It is, after all, not photoshop.

The problem I've had (and the most common one I've seen) is that people use gimp 15% of the time and don't learn it's flow, then get frustrated because it's not photoshop's flow.

I've done full-time in both gimp and photoshop and decided, for now, to stick with photoshop. Too many niggly UI issues (like the GP mentioned) in gimp (not that photoshop is great, but it is at least reasonably consistent). Same reason I'm on a Mac instead of Linux (after doing full-time Linux, too).

Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by struppi on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @05:44AM (#2890533)
Some aspects of Gimp are a little bit annoying (especially on a Mac), but you can do pretty cool things with it once you get used to it. I do some artwork for some web sites I created and Gimp is a good tool for this. Photoshop probably would be better, but for as little as I do me it is way too expensive.
Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by nimrody on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @09:39AM (#2891078)
On OS X, you can try Seashore (http://seashore.sourceforge.net/The_Seashore_Project/About.h...). Based on GIMP code but simplified and emphasizing usability.
Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by tom9729 on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @01:11PM (#2891978)
I like Seashore because it's a real Cocoa app, but I frequently find myself having to fallback to X11 Gimp for little things. YMMV.
Re:GIMP Single-Window Mode Almost Ready, Hardware Accelerati... by watmough on Wednesday August 17, 2011 @10:52AM (#2895511)
If you're on a Mac or Linux, it's easy to switch to a click-through model where you don't have to click a window before selecting a tool. It renders GIMP usable on a Mac if you do this.

Personally, I just haven't managed to get into Pixelmator, I always try, then end up running back to GIMP, and I'm not a heavy user of the program by any means, though I did do all the FemCal art in it.

The biggest fix to GIMP right now should be to get 16-bit color depth working. 12-bit isn't a huge problem for me, but I can understand it holding people back who are doing lots of photo manipulation.