News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by bin_bash on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @07:50AM (#28838614)
I'm sure living in Japan comes with its own set of problems, but whenever I learn about something like this it makes it sound like such a paradise. I can't imagine how great it would be to live in a small, affordable community where I walk my daughter to school every day and can take care of most errands without using my car.

It seems in America you can pick 2 from safe, affordable, and walkable.

Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by freetime2 on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @08:18AM (#28838788)
> where I walk my daughter to school every day

From first grade onwards kids actually walk to school in groups, without adult supervision (except for the occasional crossing guard). So while you wouldn’t be able to walk with your daughter, I think it actually says even more about the safety and walkability of Japanese neighborhoods that 6 year olds are able to get to and from school safely without adult supervision.

Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by tkgally on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @09:11AM (#28839200)
My two daughters went through elementary schools in Tokyo and Yokohama, and they walked to school in groups—called tōkōhan—that were arranged by the schools. In Tokyo, their tōkōhan met each morning in front of our apartment complex; in Yokohama, it met a block away from our house. There were about ten to fifteen kids in each group.

The children were taught at school how to behave safely in the tōkōhan, and older kids were assigned to walk at the front and rear of each group and to keep tabs on the younger ones. In the afternoons, though, the kids came home on their own, as different grades finished at different times.

In Yokohama, parents shared the crossing guard duties. For a week or so every couple of months, I would have to stand with a flag at a nearby corner for fifteen minutes every morning and wave each tōkōhan by. (I was working from home then and was available to do it.)

The streets in the area where we lived in Tokyo had sidewalks, but in our Yokohama neighborhood the narrow streets are used by both pedestrians and vehicles. That has always made me a little nervous, but fortunately there’s not a lot of traffic in our neighborhood; most of the people living nearby do not have cars, and those who do seem to do most of their commuting and errands on foot or bicycle. I feel less safe in rural areas of Japan, where pedestrians often have to walk along narrow, sidewalk-less roads with cars and trucks whizzing by.

Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by hnlmorg on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @08:53AM (#28839043)
Europe is like this too. I find America's implementation of zoning to be very weird. Maybe there are some upsides to it that I'm not aware of, I'd be interested to hear some opinions of the American system from those who favour it.
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by toyg on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @09:38AM (#28839495)
Eh, some of Europe. Yes, we are nowhere as obsessed as the Americans with suburban life and car-based commuting, because of 2000 years of urbanization (one of those things "the Romans did for us"), but in the last 20-40 years there has been a real shift towards similar models. Suburban hypermarkets, IKEA, entertainment centres, and the pursuit of "Wysteria Lane" habitats, have become commonplace for families across the continent.

Some of it is driven by economic growth (city centres have become increasingly unaffordable, particularly in capital cities), some by population growth (you can only scale up a residential block so much before it becomes a mess from a social perspective), some by fashion (hello Hollywood), some by speculation (it's easy to bootstrap a shopless residential suburb), some by urban planners simply failing in the attempts to create new urban centres.

Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by hnlmorg on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @02:04PM (#28842965)
You're still a short walk from the nearest primary school, shop and pub though. Granted lots of local pubs are going under these days and local shops don't have a massive selection. But it still beats having to drive for every little thing.
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by lbriner on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @09:22AM (#28839312)
There is some "zoning" in the UK too, it is just not so set in stone. Most councils have areas that are pre-approved for new housing, any other areas would require planning permission.

Building in a conservation area (not necessarily rural!), on a listed building or in a "greenbelt" area require special permission, which is not always easy or obvious.

I think the theory must be that people want some assurances. If somewhere is zoned for housing, I don't have to do pointless paperwork to build houses. It also keeps commercial areas away from residential which might or might not be a good idea although I suspect most residents prefer it that way.

Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by xboxnolifes on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @10:52AM (#28840481)
There are upsides, but only relative to the issues it solved decades ago. We stopped (drastically) improving our zoning from the original changes and now we're stuck with the consequences.
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by sho_hn on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @10:08AM (#28839841)
See https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ORzNZUeUHAM for one of the major reasons.
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by hnlmorg on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @04:55PM (#28844958)
I don't follow. That video, while interesting, seems to be complimenting European city planning and critical of American city planning. I don't see how it's making a case for American zoning.
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by sho_hn on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @05:35PM (#28937020)
I may have learned something new from you, thanks! For me this was related to what I conceived of as zoning, but it appears that has a narrower definition.
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by japanftw on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @10:22AM (#28840033)
Europe is far, far, behind japan in pretty much every aspect. Paris, London or Berlin are basically dumps compared to Japan’s cities.
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by JohnJamesRambo on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @08:50AM (#28839016)
You can get all three, you just have to live somewhere outside the two coasts I think. I’ve got all three in a small town in the middle. I walk on the sidewalk in front of my house to the library that is a few doors down from my incredibly affordable house. It feels like a Norman Rockwell painting.

I’m hoping remote work can allow more people to experience this.

Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by thethethethe on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @09:35AM (#28839470)
Edit: modified the list of cities based on comments

Is your neighborhood truly walkable though? Do you walk to the grocery store? What about the hospital? dentist? Physical therapist? Pet store? Restaurants? Is there transit nearby?

Afaik, there are only a few cities in the US (all costal) which are truly walkable in the traditional sense, SF, NYC, Boston, DC and maybe Philadelphia and only limited parts of the cities are actually walkable. These are the only cities with limited single family zoning and didn't boldoze their city centers to build parking lots and freeways in the 50s like the rest of NA cities (see https://www.vox.com/2014/12/29/7460557/urban-freeway-slider-...)

Many cities and small towns in the US and Canada may have walkable elements in limited areas, but they are still very car dependent in most cases

Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by cnntth on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @10:41AM (#28840291)
Boston is /very/ walkable, the whole city can be walked end to end in a few hours and Somerville is one of the densest neighborhoods in the U.S.

I'll also say D.C. (and to some extent Northern Virginia and select parts of Maryland) makes car ownership optional, the transit system does a good job of covering a lot of neighborhoods.

I've been to a few college towns that also, by necessity, are dense and are walkable or at least bikeable oasis in otherwise rural areas.

Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by ghaff on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @10:56AM (#28840526)
The thing with college towns is that you tend to have the campus and, if it's in a rural area, generally a few streets of associated town. Technically walkable but, once you're not a student any longer, the campus is less interesting/useful and there probably isn't a whole lot in the ten or so blocks of the town that you can walk to. You can doubtless survive but the options are probably limited without a car (and most of your non-student friends in the area probably have one).
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by thethethethe on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @10:52AM (#28840475)
Thanks for the info, I added an edit to my comment
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by ghaff on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @11:00AM (#28840579)
BTW, Boston did pretty much bulldoze the center of the city (the West End) for a freeway but spent some $10 billion (much of it federal money) to rectify the problem with the Big Dig. It was walkable before the freeway was dismantled but less so in Boston proper. (As with other US cities, it was also less safe in general a few decades ago.)
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by lolpython on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @12:53PM (#28842012)
Just providing a non-coastal example - Pittsburgh is pretty decent for walkability and transit. It is a dense, small (in area) city. Trips by bus are often comparable to the same trip by car. I would say that most neighborhoods in Pittsburgh are walkable, but getting between neighborhoods is best done by bus, due to the big hills.

Some figures:

- 10 percent of Pittsburgh residents commute by walking [0]. 17 percent commute by public transit [1].

- "According to the U.S. Census Bureau, public transportation commuters in Pittsburgh spend an average of 32 minutes traveling to work, the 11th-fastest transit commute time of the 136 cities in our analysis. That is also just nine minutes slower that the average commute time for drivers, the fifth-smallest difference." [2]

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._cities_with_most_... [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._cities_with_high_... [2]: https://smartasset.com/mortgage/best-cities-for-public-trans...

edit: formatting

Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by ghaff on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @10:34AM (#28840204)
The core of Boston is more walkable than SF is. Especially if by "walkable," you really mean walkable and with easy access to expansive public transit to easily get to all the other things you won't have in a small town center or otherwise within a 30 minute or so walk.

To the sibling comment, walkable means different things to different people.

Walk to a hospital or a grocery store that isn't a small market/convenience store? You're already talking a city at that point. And, in the hospital case, probably not all the medical professionals you might conceivably want to see are likely to be within a one mile or so radius.

A ton of places are walkable in the sense that you can buy a house/condo and walk to a restaurant or two and pick up a few groceries. But, as you say, very few cities in the US are walkable in the sense that you really don't need a car without a lot of compromises/depending on others/using personal transportation services a lot.

Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by thethethethe on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @10:53AM (#28840482)
Added an edit to the comment based on your info, thanks
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by helen___keller on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @09:29AM (#28839399)
FWIW you can have all of these on the coasts as well. For example, if you can afford a suburban Boston house, you can find any number of small towns in New England where you can afford to live and have a small walkable community (that is to say, in absolute terms these communities are expensive but in relative terms for New England they are not).

The problem this is missing is that "walkable" doesn't actually include everything you need to live. Jobs are the most obvious one, for those who don't have remote work or their own business, which is to say for most Americans. You'll also probably end up driving when you need to do serious shopping because your town center's general store isn't a Wal-Mart. Similarly for any number of specialized purchases or services.

In any case, small-town living and city living are very different. What's impressive about Japan is bringing a walkable, livable urban form to a mega city of 30 million people. When American towns start growing into cities (or when they are informally annexed into a larger cities' urban region) they usually do so by converting farmland into car-accessible suburbs, which is the problem.

Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by gremIin on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @08:55AM (#28839057)
What are you job options if you get laid off? How often do you and your spouse spend time with friends? I would hate moving to a small town and being cut off from seeing friends whenever I want to. Not to mention people tend to congregate towards larger cities, so moving to a small town probably means giving up quality food and my favorite events like sports and the symphony.
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by JohnJamesRambo on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @09:03AM (#28839130)
I’m self-employed, so I can’t be laid off!

My gf and I don’t really like to socialize that much and prefer to stay in and play video games and watch tv, so we love it. The ubiquity of the internet has made it possible to live almost anywhere in my opinion. For $25 a month we can see and do pretty much the same thing everyone else is doing every night on the internet. We cook our own meals also. You can always make new friends in a small town.

There are trade-offs to be sure, but if you knew how low my mortgage payment is you might choose like we did. :) All the money I save has allowed me to invest heavily, which will allow me to travel and see the world instead of see a city go by every day on a commute to work until I’m old.

Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by gremIin on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @09:50AM (#28839625)
I see, so your "you can have all three, you just have to..." is actually unrealistic/bad advice to those who are not self-employed, not to mention those who actually enjoy doing things in the city.
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by ghaff on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @11:21AM (#28840824)
How many places is being able to walk to a wide choice of professional jobs a realistic option? (Obviously if you expand the definition to reasonably accessible by public transit, the list gets longer but is still relatively limited given transit options and the fact that many offices are in industrial parks, not cities.) And sports/symphony limit you to a relatively large city or at least a college.
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by ghaff on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @10:37AM (#28840229)
You don't really need to choose.

In many places, you can live in a smaller town and be within an hour or so of a city. It doesn't need to be a choice between living in Manhattan or the middle of nowhere in Wyoming.

Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by skhr0680 on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @08:26AM (#28838840)
If you can find a way to make money without working for a company that demands all of your time for a small wage, Japan is a great place to live. Having schools etc in walking distance means that all of the local people keep an eye out to make sure each other’s kids are safe. It’s really nice.
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by bart_spoon on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @08:11AM (#28838738)
I lived in Japan for a few years, and it basically was paradise. There were virtually no downsides in my opinion.
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by pjc50 on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @08:17AM (#28838779)
It looks from the outside that the downside is "small" living spaces. They look small by UK standards so I imagine that to an American it's like living in a closet.
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by lozenge on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @09:00AM (#28839099)
It's a lifestyle difference. Americans enjoy the convenience of a home gym and paddling pool/real pool (if they can afford it). Japanese might walk to their gym or even prefer the onsen to the shower they have at home. Americans invite guests round, Japanese use cafés and love hotels. Americans stack consoles and gaming PCs, Japanese can also visit arcades. There's an equivalent for most activities, and it has lower CapEx and more variety. Maybe if your hobby is woodworking or car repair, Japan can't serve you for lack of space.

Here in the UK, it really feels like every business is taking my money and spitting me out as fast as possible (except pubs, which... are good if you want to get drunk I guess...). Vs in Japan where services felt cheap, trustworthy, and welcoming (such as clean toilets).

Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by namelessoracle on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @09:39AM (#28839500)
Are you really stating the home gyms and pools are common in the Americans that do buy homes? Huh?
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by helen___keller on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @09:49AM (#28839619)
It depends heavily on region, but in the suburbs most Americans have room for something that wouldn't be easily affordable in an urban Japanese home (or urban anywhere home, i suppose). Maybe a lawn or backyard, maybe a pool, maybe a garage that can fit more than one car, maybe a driveway that can fit your car while your garage is used for something else, a house big enough to have a room that you don't use every day, and so on

I personally would vastly prefer a walkable, affordable, safe, dense urban region over a lawn, a 2 car garage, and a backyard. But not everyone would agree with me, particularly for some who would say that dense and walkable is a negative rather than a positive.

Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by corpdronejuly on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @10:24AM (#28840061)
They are though. This varies regionally, but they're both multimillion dollar industries that push very hard to make their goods affordable to increase their available customer base.

I grew up in a lower middle class neighborhood, and every other house has a bench and some weights. Many of the families saved up for a treadmill or elliptical, and woe betide the child who thought they could use it. Someone on every block(usually more wealthy than the area average) had an above ground pool, and the neighborhood kids would go over and hang out there all summer.

Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by bart_spoon on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @11:30AM (#28840953)
Its not super crazy. When you consider the number of homes that have home gyms, or pools, or basketball hoops, trampolines, or swing sets etc. that people have, its a large number of homes. And even for those who don't, most houses in America are built such that one could buy one if they want.

I grew up in suburban Indiana, and when I went home to visit my parents, I counted it up and literally over 1/3rd of the houses I could see from their front porch had a basketball hoop in the driveway.

Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by liotier on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @08:25AM (#28838833)
Desktop computers with CRT were far less popular in Japan than anywhere else, and compacity is part of the story for the TV/gaming console/computer hybrids that found more traction there than elsewhere. Perfectly usable furniture that lost its purpose are left on the curb for pickup - no space at home to store anything not in production ! The never-used formal dining room found in US homes would look bonkers to a visiting Japanese.
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by skhr0680 on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @08:28AM (#28838856)
I remember people making fun of the Xbox for being too huge and “American”!

> The never-used formal dining room found in US homes would look bonkers to a visiting Japanese.

there’s always the never-used huge tatami room at grandpa’s house in the countryside

Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by ghaff on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @10:44AM (#28840340)
>never-used formal dining room

To be fair, I'm not sure how common this is with new/remodeled construction in the US. Entertainment pattens have changed for the most part and layouts tend to be a lot more open. In particular, you don't see the hard demarkation between dining area and kitchen area which dates to when the "help" worked in the kitchen and served in the dining room.

Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by freetime2 on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @08:25AM (#28838836)
It depends where you’re coming from and where in Japan you choose to live. I moved from a small city with a high cost of living in the US to a small city with a low cost of living in Japan. My home in Japan is twice as big and a quarter of the cost of my former home in the US.
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by rwmj on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @08:49AM (#28839000)
It can be very cheap if you're prepared to put the work in. There's a Youtube series about a guy who is doing up a large (even in UK/US terms) abandoned house which he bought for (IIRC) $40K: https://www.youtube.com/c/TokyoLlama/videos
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by freetime2 on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @10:11AM (#28839879)
Or even if you don’t want to put in any work, it can still be quite affordable.

Here’s a 10 year old, 18,000 sq ft house in Ibaraki prefecture (same prefecture as Tokyo Llama’s house) for about $220k USD. It’s not large by US standards, but definitely sufficient for a family of 4 IMO. And with interest rates in Japan being about 1%, the monthly mortgage payment would be about $625.

https://www.athome.co.jp/kodate/1039825842/

This location looks pretty rural, but similar homes can be found all over Japan.

Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by bart_spoon on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @11:16AM (#28840758)
Sort of, but the reality is that when everything is structured the way it is in Japan, you don't really feel like you need much space in your apartment. That said, I lived there when I was single, and it would be very different living there with my young family. But I knew young family with houses when I was there and it seemed comfortable. I was also in Hokkaido (mostly Sapporo), which is not quite as dense as the Tokyo area (though still very dense compared to most of the US).
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by lozenge on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @08:45AM (#28838973)
Gender norms are pretty stringent especially on mothers.

In general it seems very accepting if you fit in and very hostile if you don't, which is shown in a high suicide rate in school age children.

Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by bart_spoon on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @11:23AM (#28840858)
While true, I was mostly speaking of zoning. I consider things like gender norms as being cultural and not necessarily overlapping with their city zoning. From a pure urban design perspective, its basically perfect in my opinion. (That said, it's not entirely correct that culture and urban design are separate. I'm not sure Japanese cities can be recreated in America, if for no other reason than there is a huge gulf between how individuals view and interact with society in Japan vs. America)

It's also worth noting that while stressors from gender norms exist in Japan, the idea that their suicide rate is extremely high is somewhat outdated. Its been decreasing over the last few decades, while countries like the US and many European countries have increased, to the point where there isn't that much of a difference between the regions.

Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by naomeux on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @09:24AM (#28839336)
I agree with you on this one, but except for one thing. The walls are too thin to have your own space. It's quite uncomfortable that you don't have your privacy even you're at home.
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by bart_spoon on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @11:21AM (#28840821)
If you are talking about walls within your home, that may be true, my living situation was such that I wouldn't know. If you are talking about thin walls between neighboring apartments, I never had much of an issue. Perhaps they are thing, but in general Japanese people are so conscious of others that I never had an issue with loud neighbors.
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by aikinai on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @09:29AM (#28839395)
Japan's not a paradise in every way, but this is exactly why my family has settled here. The lifestyle possible in most of Japan is very difficult to replicate in other countries and invaluable to general quality of life even if you have to compromise in some areas.
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by blacktriangle on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @08:17AM (#28838777)
Being a homogeneous ethnostate does wonders for the social cohesion that allows for a society like Japan to work.
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by llampx on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @08:35AM (#28838900)
Plenty of homogeneous states which don't work. Seems it's not such a great indicator.
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by ethanbond on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @08:46AM (#28838977)
Well GP does say allows for such a state, not guarantees.
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by darksaints on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @08:55AM (#28839060)
Well if that's what they meant, then heterogeneous melting pots also allow for advanced societies to work. And ethnocentricity is a shitty indicator for social cohesion.
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by njharman on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @11:09AM (#28840681)
> Plenty of homogeneous states which don't work.

Plenty? Name five, other than isolated microstate islands. I can think of very few modern homogeneous ethostates.

Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by rataata_jr on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @09:29AM (#28839403)
IQ factor? Japanese are pretty smart.
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by eldaisfish on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @10:00AM (#28839750)
You are being downvoted but this sentiment is not wrong. See also the nordic countries and this Freakonomics podcast that goes into some detail: https://freakonomics.com/podcast/happiness/ In particular, note Denmark's notoriously strict immigration system.

The key point being that ethnically homogenous societies tend to work well. It isn't guaranteed but it does contribute because everyone is the same or similar. Similar ideals, similar goals and so on. The feeling one gets in these societies is stifling. We have nice things but they are for us, not for you.

Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by j-bos on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @08:39AM (#28838930)
Hard to say because while Japan has long been homogenous and had strong social order, the modern level of safety is historically recent.
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by stormdennis on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @08:24AM (#28838829)
Not a popular opinion, it seems.
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by darksaints on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @09:08AM (#28839166)
No, it's not. It's a common opinion among white nationalists, but they are a tiny minority and they don't realize how different white people (or any ethnicity for that matter) actually are. If you put a bunch of British Columbians and Texans in a room, you might have ethnocentricity, but you won't have anything close to social cohesion.
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by eldaisfish on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @09:56AM (#28839690)
This is a bad comparison. "White" is about as informative as "European" or "Indian". It conveys a vague notion of melanin levels and little else. Regions such as Europe or India are so diverse that a Finn and a Spaniard have very little in common. Same goes for a "Country" like India.

Someone from BC and someone from Texas actually have a lot in common - both are from immigrant societies and both speak the same language. Can't say that for someone from Kerala, India and Punjab, also in India.

Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by darksaints on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @11:44AM (#28841139)
Thats all fine, but we're talking about white nationalists...they're not exactly nuanced about culture. To white nationalists, whiteness is all that matters, and if we just kicked out all of the non-white people, we could participate in this enthocentric utopian fantasy that they have. Nevermind the fact that almost every ethnostate that has ever existed has had civil wars and irreconcilable differences. Hell, our own country is the result of some members of a homogenous ethnostate moving to get away from that state, and ultimately waging war against it.
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by corpdronejuly on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @10:29AM (#28840118)
Given the interminable arguments they have about "who counts as white" and their racial anxieties I'm sure they're more aware, on average, of the differences between a Texan, and a Californian, or a Scottsman and A Frenchman than those of us who focus on finding what we have in common and being good neighbors.
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by jgwil2 on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @10:30AM (#28840124)
People are rightly offended by the claim that racial purity is a prerequisite for a cohesive, high-functioning society.
[dead]
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by darksaints on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @09:00AM (#28839101)
Nothing you've said here is incompatible with Japanese zoning. It is American zoning that forces choices on people, not the other way around.
Re:Why Japan Looks the Way It Does: Zoning [video] by temp8964 on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @09:47AM (#28839586)
Your understanding is very strange. I didn't say Japanese zoning is forcing people. Weird.