News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by benzible on Saturday October 09, 2021 @01:28AM (#28807288)
Per the Washington Post [1]

> "The uber-rich in the United States tend to pay such low tax rates that they have less incentive to seek offshore havens. But their absence from the files also may mean that very wealthy Americans turn to different offshore jurisdictions."

[1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/interactive/2021/pan...

Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by taurath on Saturday October 09, 2021 @02:10AM (#28807459)
Its pretty well known by now that billionaires pay an effective single digit tax rate in the US.

https://www.propublica.org/article/the-secret-irs-files-trov...

Hell, the person who used to be president was paying that or less. They have at least 60% of congress paid for in order to not raise taxes or close loopholes as well. Then you have so many otherwise smart people believing that taxation is theft, when they're just not rich enough to pay the good rates.

Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by feelandcoffee on Saturday October 09, 2021 @02:34AM (#28807578)
This is the case of "Buy, Borrow, Die" or "kick the can". The top 0.01% paying a lower percentage of taxes than even the lower tax bracket worker class.

If you are a wharever-ionaire you could put your gains in index S&P 500 shares, then use them as collateral, paying everything you need with credit and having a $1 annual salary. So technically, that $1 it's their only income to the IRS. But what about interest? with that collateral, you have a special rate close to (or even lower than) inflation. Then you die, the bank takes your shares to pay your debt, and that's it.

https://www.wsj.com/articles/buy-borrow-die-how-rich-america...

Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by GDC7 on Saturday October 09, 2021 @06:15AM (#28808496)
but that isn't very smart strategy because it prevents you from spending every dollar that you have ever earned.

At some point you want to open the floodgates so you don't leave any quality of life on the table.

You can't do that on margin loans, whereas you can if you are able to engineer a tax efficient way to cashout without paying capital gain tax

Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by nikitaga on Saturday October 09, 2021 @06:40AM (#28808642)
Nobody who uses this strategy will come even close to spending every dollar that they earned, they spend all they want yet still end up leaving all their wealth to their kids when they die.
Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by GDC7 on Saturday October 09, 2021 @06:45AM (#28808672)
> Nobody who uses this strategy will come even close to spending every dollar that they earned

But why? It's a lot of quality of life left on the table.

Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by yifanl on Saturday October 09, 2021 @07:03AM (#28808763)
After the first hundred million dollars spent on personal expenditures, what material gains to quality of life are there?
Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by GDC7 on Saturday October 09, 2021 @07:09AM (#28808801)
However small, isn't it better than losing them? I think yes.

Because you can't bring that "quality of life potential" in the grave

Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by Jasper_ on Saturday October 09, 2021 @12:46PM (#28811335)
The FT runs a magazine called "How To Spend It" with ideas for what cheeky stylish thing to buy this month after you already spent it on what you want to. That this is apparently a lucrative business possibly tells you that you can max out your quality of life and still have money leftover.

https://www.ft.com/htsi

Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by kadoban on Saturday October 09, 2021 @07:59AM (#28809083)
It's not small, it's zero or even negative. If you already have everything you want, buying more is just extra crap you have to deal with.
Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by Spooky23 on Saturday October 09, 2021 @09:24AM (#28809645)
Many people with money like this flip; preserving capital and reducing risk becomes the destination, not the journey.

It’s the way humans are wired, and there’s a whole industry of lawyers, accountants and others to support it.

Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by gabrielhidasy on Saturday October 09, 2021 @10:54AM (#28810399)
Really depends, I can see a lot of quality of life on leaving family set for the next few centuries. And a lot of headache on managing the next personal island.
Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by AmericanChopper on Saturday October 09, 2021 @07:56AM (#28809070)
You missed a couple of steps.

> Then you die

> The bank takes your shares to pay your debt

> The IRS taxes this against your estate as income

> The entire value of your estate is taxed for any capital gains at the “fair market value” of all your assets at the time of your death

> and then that's it.

Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by rapind on Saturday October 09, 2021 @09:10AM (#28809542)
And of course it's more nuanced than that, with stuff like accelerated depreciation, preferential tax rates on investment income, charitable lead annuity trusts, etc. ad infinitum.
Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by naasking on Saturday October 09, 2021 @10:12AM (#28810010)
No, they give their wealth to their family as gifts, and they have no capital gains because they were living like a royalty off of loans leveraged against their assets and so their effective gains are zero, among other tricks. It's easy for the rich to avoid taxes.
Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by azth on Saturday October 09, 2021 @11:05AM (#28810472)
> living like a royalty off of loans leveraged against their assets

Maybe we should ban interest instead, just like how we were told thousands of years ago. See: Islam, Judaism, and Christianity.

Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by hairofadog on Saturday October 09, 2021 @11:20AM (#28810604)
This isn’t a criticism of your comment, but I have always thought it was funny that devout practitioners of those religions seem to find ways of technically adhering to those rules while at the same time completely flouting the spirit of them. See “Heter Iska and other evasions” here

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loans_and_interest_in_Judaism

…or “sabbath mode” on many appliances on the market.

The funny part to me is believing in an all-powerful and omnipotent god whom you can nonetheless fool with semantics and shuffling papers.

Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by dragonwriter on Sunday October 10, 2021 @10:37PM (#28824046)
> The funny part to me is believing in an all-powerful and omnipotent god whom you can nonetheless fool with semantics and shuffling papers.

There's no fooling going on. There's just faith traditions that believe God, either generally or for specific subsets of the overall rule set, is extremely concerned with the letter of the rules and not what humans might infer the spirit to be from the letter. That is, the rules are the rules, not an imperfect approximation serving some higher but difficult to express set of rules.

Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by azth on Sunday October 10, 2021 @10:34PM (#28824027)
> but I have always thought it was funny that devout practitioners of those religions seem to find ways of technically adhering to those rules while at the same time completely flouting the spirit of them.

We don't do that in Islam.

Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by hairofadog on Monday October 11, 2021 @12:03AM (#28824529)
I would be interested in hearing more if you feel like elaborating.
Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by azth on Monday October 11, 2021 @12:45PM (#28830259)
For example, the Quran explicitly calls out the behavior of a tribe of Jews who, to tried to avoid the prohibition of fishing on the Sabbath: https://quran.com/7/163

We also have explicit texts in Hadith that call out and reprimand attempts to bypass usury by buying an item in installments, then selling it back to the original seller for a lower cash price. The effective transaction being a money for money contract with a disposable item in the middle. All this is prohibited.

You will not find a single Muslim scholar say that it is ok for a woman to wear a wig instead of a headscarf, even though technically she is still covering her hair.

Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by MomoXenosaga on Saturday October 09, 2021 @11:46AM (#28810846)
There was a discussion about this in the Netherlands. Ultimately it was concluded that Jesus was less important than the future of the nation. And these people were 100% orthodox protestants. Quantitative easing is just too good like that.
Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by azth on Sunday October 10, 2021 @10:35PM (#28824035)
And now people cry about financial inequality. Sometimes the easy things out have long term consequences. We've living those consequences today across the globe.
Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by Aerroon on Saturday October 09, 2021 @08:23AM (#28809243)
Doesn't this mean that it all still gets taxed, but if nothing goes wrong, then it's paid after you die?
Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by kyteland on Saturday October 09, 2021 @10:16AM (#28810048)
You should read about the step up in basis loophole that happens when you die. That's the biggest one I'm aware of where your estate doesn't pay taxes after death that you would have owed in life. I'm sure there are many others I'm not aware of, but this is one everyone should know about.

> https://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/stepupinbasis.asp

Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by AmericanChopper on Saturday October 09, 2021 @08:28AM (#28809274)
Yes, every single piece of it is taxed. But a lot of people really don’t want you to think it is. Apparently a couple of articles about the calendar years in which some billionaire didn’t pay very much tax did the trick on the parent commenter.
Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by Spooky23 on Saturday October 09, 2021 @09:15AM (#28809579)
That’s what the talk radio shills and similar right wing folks tell you.

The reality is that when you have enough cash to justify, you roll your assets into a series of South Dakota trusts and that money is perpetually tax-free.

Another tactic is to use Nevada and Delaware corporations to buy real property everywhere, and use that to avoid most taxation.

Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by AmericanChopper on Saturday October 09, 2021 @09:25AM (#28809653)
I see. Estate tax is a right wing radio conspiracy theory…
Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by Spooky23 on Saturday October 09, 2021 @11:35PM (#28815532)
For most people, there’s little to no exposure.

The exotic trust structures talked about here are money laundering structures, which exist because gullible voters are duped with tales of widows losing houses and farm families losing the mythical family farm. There’s a reason why the home base for this is a state with weird banking laws where there’s more cattle than people.

Mitt Romney’s (I point him out because of his fame in this regard, he’s not unique or alone) great-great-grandchildren will be living off some untaxed trust 150 years from now when we’re all dead.

Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by JetSpiegel on Monday October 18, 2021 @06:17PM (#28912523)
Corporations are people, my friend.

-- Mitt Romney

Not sure if worse than his descendants living tax free hundreds of years for now, is having his image whitewashed for his "bullwark against Trump" that weirdly only manifested in the latter part of his term.

Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by roenxi on Saturday October 09, 2021 @03:05AM (#28807692)
That article is misleading - there are no scenarios where a billionaire is going to withdraw their wealth as income where it might be subject to an income tax. Of course the amount of income tax they pay is tiny and comparable to a multi-millionaire. That is the level of income where all their material wants are met.

Even ignoring taxes why would anyone ever want to get paid billions dollars in a direct cash transfusion? Nothing they would be buying regularly costs that much!

They should be leading with how much of the tax burden the billionaires are responsible for shouldering, not how much they are shouldering via one specific tax that isn't there to tax them. Income tax isn't for business owners, it is for people who earn an income!

Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by taurath on Saturday October 09, 2021 @05:22AM (#28808269)
Sure, but then all their real estate, cars, etc is also there and tied to a business. They never have to take money out for any reason, and if they do it’s just forever rolling over low interest loans. Besides, the money amount never goes down unless there’s a big crash.
Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by moonchrome on Saturday October 09, 2021 @05:31AM (#28808298)
Don't know how it works in the US but here if you own property or cars etc. through business you can't use them for personal reasons and if you get audited this is considered tax evasion. I would be surprised if the US is any different.
Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by GDC7 on Saturday October 09, 2021 @06:20AM (#28808525)
This is very much like the speed limit on highways.

You can't put a private investigator on the tail of every business owner.

Personal expenses will be justified as business expenses, it's a matter of catching the very big and obvious cases, doing it so very publicly with the help of the press and try to scare all the other business owners in order to scale down the amount of personal expenses that they claim as business expenses

Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by Aerroon on Saturday October 09, 2021 @08:30AM (#28809284)
But the non-obvious cases will also be the one where only a fraction of the assets in personal use will be owned by the business. Depending on the size of the fraction it might very well be not much different than what regular people do (eg using a company laptop to watch YouTube at home).
Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by bojangleslover on Saturday October 09, 2021 @07:28AM (#28808919)
They don't pay tax because they don't earn any money. When they sell assets they pay capital gains like everyone else. Then it's taxed when they die at a hell of a lot higher than single digits.

Not saying system is perfect but exaggerating the problem is definitely not the best way to fix it.

Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by chockablock on Saturday October 09, 2021 @08:00AM (#28809097)
Not true in the US where asset values are ‘stepped-up’ when passing to heirs avoiding all tax on gains.
Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by djbebs on Saturday October 09, 2021 @09:51AM (#28809821)
That step up is pointless since upon death you pay estate tax which is significantly higher
Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by naasking on Saturday October 09, 2021 @10:15AM (#28810033)
> Then it's taxed when they die at a hell of a lot higher than single digits.

It's not an exaggeration to say the rich rarely actually pay these taxes you describe. There are innumerable ways around it.

Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by thatswrong0 on Saturday October 09, 2021 @02:35AM (#28807582)
I genuinely wonder what would be the best way to deal with the unrealized gains + taking out loans as untaxable income loophole. It seems like the current Democratic party strategy would be taxing unrealized gains over a certain amount but that still doesn't quite feel right..
Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by nmfisher on Saturday October 09, 2021 @03:02AM (#28807682)
I’ve said this a number of times before, but I still can’t see why loans > $1m against share-based collateral shouldn’t be taxed as income.
Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by 1123581321 on Saturday October 09, 2021 @04:00AM (#28807912)
It’s because loans must be repaid. Perhaps there could be a fee on the collateral process itself.
Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by dredmorbius on Saturday October 09, 2021 @06:08AM (#28808453)
Possibly: tax the interest on those loans at the bank. Possibly count such loans against assets (reducing banks' lending capability).

I'm not positive this works out, but:

- Banks tend to be well-established, identifiable entities.

- They are highly regulated and audited.

The question I'm not certain of the answer is what the result of such a tax would be. I suspect such loans would tend to be crowded out or inerest rates increased (raising costs to the billionaire utilising this cash-out option).

This seems to me along the lines of an HFT transaction tax, possibly operating similarly.

Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by 3finmunchousen on Saturday October 09, 2021 @05:44AM (#28808340)
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guillotine

Alternatively, tax consumption over a certain threshold as though spending is income. Effectively instate a federal sales tax after one has spent $X dollars.

Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by roenxi on Saturday October 09, 2021 @09:02AM (#28809499)
There is a section on that page titled "Reign of Terror" talking about how eventually the revolutionaries were also guillotined.

Although violence can resolve a situation, negotiation with only the threat of violence gets much better results.

Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by refurb on Saturday October 09, 2021 @04:03AM (#28807926)
Loophole? How is it a loophole? It’s just kicking the can down the road. The equity gets sold and taxed eventually.

The only “loophole” is inheritance with a stepped up basis, which every American gets.

I’d be happy to get rid of that rule. No need for inheritance taxes, just make the estate pay all capital gains up death.

Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by thatswrong0 on Saturday October 09, 2021 @10:58AM (#28810425)
> Amazon founder and CEO Jeff Bezos paid a true tax rate of 0.98% as his wealth grew by a staggering $99 billion between 2014 and 2018; he reported just $4.22 billion in reported income during the same period.

I'm curious how I should rationalize that this is not in fact a giant loophole for billionaires. Bezos' wealth increased immensely such that he is now one of the richest people in the world, and yet his effective tax rate is far lower than anything you or I will ever see. If he needs "income", he can simply take out a low interest loan with his stock as collateral to pay for whatever he needs (yachts, spurious lawsuits against NASA, etc.). His stock is effectively cash, loans effectively "realize" his gains, and yet we don't treat any of it as income.

There's a vast difference between the unrealized gains of not-filthy-rich people with 401ks / middling stock portfolios and the unrealized gains of filthy rich people who primarily take stock as income (which they do for the exact purpose of paying lower taxes).

[0] https://www.forbes.com/sites/sarahhansen/2021/06/08/richest-...

Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by tbihl on Saturday October 09, 2021 @02:28PM (#28812048)
First, you can look at "true tax rate", which has nothing to do with how taxes are calculated (as described in your linked article).

.98% sounds like he paid just under 1 billion on 4.22 billion of reported income (or just under 25%). I guess it sucks to be Bezos, because he spent more in one year on taxes than I'll have to pay in my life.. I'm going to go out on a limb and suspect that figure is not AGI, but total income. I suspect he had many deductible expenses like donations to charity, though 25% isn't that low since the top marginal bracket for capital gains is 20%.

I guess I'm curious how he paid so much in taxes...

Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by thatswrong0 on Saturday October 09, 2021 @02:40PM (#28812155)
I mean I don't know what to say here - the whole entire point here is that he makes a fuck ton more than his reported income and should (probably somehow) pay taxes on that. This graph IMO shows pretty clearly how not optimal the current tax system is: https://i.imgur.com/jcO8KgO.png
Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by occamrazor on Saturday October 09, 2021 @03:18AM (#28807738)
Taxing capital gains at nark-to-market values, with a flat rate (maybe 20-25%) and without exemptions or deductibles would go a long way towards fiscal equity.
Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by watertom on Saturday October 09, 2021 @05:31AM (#28808301)
The concept of “capital gains” in the U.S. is a joke, unless you buy stock directly from the company, or buy when the company goes public, there is no capital investment. Once the company sells stock to the public, further purchase or sale of stock is nothing more than buying/selling goods. When I buy stock on the stock market the company doesn’t get the money, the person who sells me the stock gets the money, and that’s not capital investment.

Sale of stock should be taxed at each states tax rate, because it’s the buying and selling of a good, it’s not capital investment.

Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by lotsofpulp on Saturday October 09, 2021 @05:46AM (#28808353)
Capital gain is defined as an increase in the price of any capital asset, not just publicly traded stocks.

https://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/capitalasset.asp

Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by djbebs on Saturday October 09, 2021 @09:52AM (#28809841)
You know what would go a long way towards fiscal equity? Cutting taxes on the richest to 1/6th of what they currently are.

It's not the rich that arent paying their fair share here.

Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by thatswrong0 on Saturday October 09, 2021 @11:10AM (#28810514)
Yep it's definitely those damn poor people who aren't pulling their weight
Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by refurb on Saturday October 09, 2021 @04:00AM (#28807914)
Your article says Elon paid 33% which was half a billion in taxes on a $1.5B stock sale.

That’s not single digit.

Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by spurgu on Monday October 11, 2021 @10:14PM (#28835332)
> Hell, the person who used to be president was paying that or less.

You need to have income to pay income tax.

Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by zo1 on Saturday October 09, 2021 @02:52AM (#28807656)
I believe "taxation is theft" out of moral and ethical reasons. It's not something I just pulled out of nowhere because I don't like paying taxes.

The problem here is as always the government, which is not doing as much as we'd like and has supposedly gotten captured by bad individuals. We can't have our cake and eat it.

And despite being against taxation I'm all for flat or proportional taxation, while we have it. This whole mess arguably came about because we wanted the ability to make the rich pay more than the rest of us, and then while we were at it decided to use taxation to manipulate the behavior of the public. And look how it turned out, the market spoke and found optimal solutions around taxation, and unfortunately it only works for the wealthy. It's like shaking our fists at the sky because the rain caused a lake and mosquitos bred there.

/rant

Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by SturgeonsLaw on Saturday October 09, 2021 @04:42AM (#28808101)
Would you still think taxation is theft if the government was acting as a responsible steward of tax money, and spending it in ways that improve the lives of the citizenry without running up a huge debt?
Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by maccolgan on Saturday October 09, 2021 @06:56AM (#28808724)
Ideally it would be spending an amount of money that individuals can also afford to spend themselves, that'd be the fairest, but that hardly ever happens...
Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by JetSpiegel on Monday October 18, 2021 @06:24PM (#28912576)
How do you build a railroad as an individual? How do you pay for NASA as an individual?
Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by zo1 on Saturday October 09, 2021 @07:05AM (#28808779)
Like with a lot of things it's more of a spectrum than a binary. Yes it still would be "theft". But if they were responsible with it then I'd definitely be more okay with it(like a lot of libertarians) . It'd be more okay if we all paid proportionally to our earnings. It'd also be more okay if we had more and more granular controls over what it gets spent on (like the humble bundle where I'd pick which ratio of my share of gov spending goes to which department or social good).

The thing that irritates me about it is that none of these intermediate steps seem to get any traction. My pet theory about that is they don't get implemented because they would inevitably lead to full public control over social spending. And when we get there we're essentially doing libertarianism anyways and realise we are responsible for our neighbours and society and have no need for a government that does stuff without our consent.

Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by andrepd on Saturday October 09, 2021 @10:33AM (#28810196)
Taxes are not the evil gobernmint coming to "steal" the money you made alone. It's a price for living in a society that enabled you to make the money in the first place.

By all means, I'm in favour that anyone can voluntarily opt-out of the social contract and go live in a cabin in the woods unmolested. But if you don't, then you need to pay taxes and obey laws.

Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by RNCTX on Saturday October 09, 2021 @02:36AM (#28807591)
You mean the Washington Post owned by one of those people who would be in the data?
Re:Pandora Papers: is the world’s biggest leak the world’s b... by MomoXenosaga on Saturday October 09, 2021 @05:34AM (#28808312)
The American people worship their rich. There would be no outrage no matter what. See Trump.