News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Canyon.mid by littlebentoo on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @09:10PM (#28780533)
> listening to this song

Song? It’s just music there’s no singing in it. Midi is an instrumental only declarative format.

Re:Canyon.mid by underwater on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @09:17PM (#28780590)
How am I only just learning that a a piece of music is only a song if it has vocals? Even the name makes that obvious.
Re:Canyon.mid by frogulis on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @10:05PM (#28780961)
Calling instrumental pieces "songs" does exist in real-life common usage even if it's not "technically" correct. After all, the ancestor post did just that.

Depends how prescriptive you want to be.

Re:Canyon.mid by mkl on Thursday October 07, 2021 @05:24AM (#28784023)
A classical music lecture series I listened to [1] claimed this came about because that's what iTunes calls all tracks/pieces/songs. Seems plausible, but probably other MP3 players did the same thing too.

[1] Sorry, no link, don't remember what exactly it was.

Re:Canyon.mid by markshead on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @10:11PM (#28781001)
Felix Mendelssohn wrote a collection of pieces called Songs without Words for the piano. This might suggest that the term "song" can be more nuanced than simply whether or not there are vocals.
Re:Canyon.mid by rob74 on Thursday October 07, 2021 @09:48AM (#28786208)
The original German title is "Lieder ohne Worte" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Songs_Without_Words), and there is AFAIK no strict requirement for lyrics to count as a "Lied" (or at least "Lied" is not connected to "singen" the way "song" is connected to "sing").
Re:Canyon.mid by jrootabega on Friday October 08, 2021 @08:03AM (#28798251)
No no no, the second letter functions like a power button. i means on, and o means off. "Song" means the vocals are off.
Re:Canyon.mid by GaylordTuring on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @09:24PM (#28780664)
> Midi is an instrumental only declarative format.

There's nothing stopping you from using midi data to generate singing: https://youtu.be/Ab4zUFKxVpk?t=87

Re:Canyon.mid by mrblampo on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @09:59PM (#28780918)
Here's a much weirder example of using midi data to generate singing: https://youtu.be/ZY6h3pKqYI0
Re:Canyon.mid by TheOtherHobbes on Thursday October 07, 2021 @07:25AM (#28784850)
Re:Canyon.mid by BoxOfRain on Thursday October 07, 2021 @07:19AM (#28784805)
This is absolutely terrifying and I hate it. Congratulations to the author, it's very interesting!
Re:Canyon.mid by smcl on Thursday October 07, 2021 @06:29AM (#28784482)
Here's another nice example of this - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eRlhKaxcKpA
Re:Canyon.mid by bartvk on Thursday October 07, 2021 @02:52AM (#28783049)
That is low-key terrifying. And amazing, too.
Re:Canyon.mid by pjbeam on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @10:05PM (#28780963)
Since when does a song require singing..?
Re:Canyon.mid by Biganon on Thursday October 07, 2021 @02:45AM (#28783017)
It's literally in the name
Re:Canyon.mid by mekkkkkk on Thursday October 07, 2021 @03:53AM (#28783408)
Words can expand from their original meanings, you know. Look at any music player or just everyday speech, you'll see "song" being used to refer to a discrete unit of music in the same way you could use "track" or "tune".
Re:Canyon.mid by Biganon on Thursday October 07, 2021 @05:54AM (#28784259)
Maybe, but we can still protest against changes when they are silly. Nobody in French would call Debussy's Clair de Lune "une chanson", why should the English language be oversimplified? Also, good music players use the word "track", and one song (or other musical piece) can span over multiple tracks, e.g. Pink Floyd's Atom Heart Mother.
Re:Canyon.mid by mekkkkkk on Thursday October 07, 2021 @07:21AM (#28784823)
It's not about simplification, it's just the way language works and evolves. Like how "track" originally referred to the literal engraved track on a phonograph record, yet you claim that that's obviously the correct term for a musical piece. At one point someone argued like you do now about that word.
Re:Canyon.mid by jay-anderson on Thursday October 07, 2021 @12:02AM (#28781687)
I've sung or hummed along to canyon.mid a time or two. We're good. The meaning of the word 'song' has expanded in popular usage. I play the horn (french horn) and I smile an nod when someone calls a clarinet a horn.
Re:Canyon.mid by mrblampo on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @09:33PM (#28780723)
Boooo.
Re:Canyon.mid by littlebentoo on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @09:38PM (#28780757)
What does that mean?
Re:Canyon.mid by mrblampo on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @09:53PM (#28780873)
Sorry, I may have been making unfair assumptions about your intent with your comment about the definition of "song." Let's assume that you are just eager to help me understand proper usage of the term. Thank you for pointing this out. I'm aware of the distinction, but was making a choice to ignore it, because I think most people ignore it. And when I was a kid playing around with Windows 3.1 I definitely would have called it a song.