you know that it's time to either drop the vendor prefix or to hope that there will not be another browser vendor implementing the exact same functionality and again protect it behind a prefix.
I know that technically, the transform specs are not finalized, but considering this kind of consensus (even IE seems to agree), would it even be wise to change the spec again?
Re:The Shapes of CSS
by chriscoyier on Saturday August 13, 2011 @12:25AM
(#2880242)
I think it's nice to see. It means the spec is probably pretty close to being finalized, because in order for that to happen, there needs to be at least two browser implementations.
Re:The Shapes of CSS
by ck2 on Friday August 12, 2011 @07:18AM
(#2876822)
They had me at the heart but then the infinity blew my mind.
For the record it works in what's now the "old" Firefox 3.6 (Firefox 6 final is out in 4 days)
Everything made of triangles works in IE8 (ie. star and pentagon work).
Unfortunately IE6 does not support background:transparent but if you know what solid background color you do want, you can fake it.
If I remember correctly there is also a way to fake the transparency in IE6 with a chromakey and filter. You basically make the parts you want transparent a crazy color like bright pink and then have the filter make that color transparent. Almost not worth the effort anymore though.
Re:The Shapes of CSS
by genieyclo on Friday August 12, 2011 @08:17AM
(#2876949)
How much money would HN save in bandwidth from changing the voting arrow images grayarrow.gif and graydown.gif (both 111b) to two small triangles in CSS as shown in this story? Or would it cost them more to even change to the css-style arrows? Also -- correct me if I'm wrong here -- why doesn't HN use one sprite image instead of serving up the images everytime separately for each story and comment? Probably because it's cached the two small arrows from the beginning so there's very little resources used anyways?
Re:The Shapes of CSS
by nickzoic on Sunday August 14, 2011 @01:43AM
(#2882891)
"data:" URLs are pretty good for this too, no web request needed. See RFC2397.
I've been using these a bit lately for little icons and such, I think its a cleaner approach than spriting in a lot of cases. I put a little script to generate data URLs up at http://nick.zoic.org/art/etc/make-data-url.html
How good is cross-platform Unicode support these days? I do like the idea of just using characters which look like icons, even if it does feel a bit like writing MS-DOS TUIs with box-drawing characters :-).
Re:The Shapes of CSS
by Timothee on Friday August 12, 2011 @05:26PM
(#2879332)
The :before and :after add one element of 60px x 60px on each side of the original element.
"border: 20px solid red;" and "border-radius: 50px 50px 0 50px;" makes these elements' border round on three sides and square on the bottom right. (of bottom left for the :after element)
"transform: rotate(-45deg);" and "transform: rotate(45deg);" turn the two elements so that their square corner meet in the middle, leaving one loop on each side.
Re:The Shapes of CSS
by olavk on Friday August 12, 2011 @09:30AM
(#2877153)
CSS is designed for typography and layout. It was never designed to render arbitrary geometric shapes - something like SVG should be used for that. This is just clever hacks pushing the box model to its limit.
Re:The Shapes of CSS
by dcaylor on Friday August 12, 2011 @12:37PM
(#2877970)
I don't think that "it was never designed to" and what you should do with a technology necessarily go together. A lot of innovation comes from doing things with technology that it was not originally designed to do. You should be aware that you are beyond the intended purpose, but you should not let that stop you.
Re:The Shapes of CSS
by raganwald on Saturday August 13, 2011 @09:31AM
(#2880930)
Yes, a thousand times yes. I assure you that in the 1970s engineers were telling each other that using 8-bit microprocessors to build “toy” computers was outside of their intended purpose.
Basically, the triangle is made of only the bottom border.
The top border is of width 0px so doesn't show. The element itself is 0x0px so doesn't show either. The right and left borders are transparent so you don't see them, but their width of 50px gives the base of the triangle. (which is then 100px) Finally the bottom border is 100px wide which gives the height of the triangle.
Note that the trapezoid further down is the same thing with a width of 100px for the element itself, as if you stretched that triangle in the middle.
Re:The Shapes of CSS
by losvedir on Friday August 12, 2011 @09:29AM
(#2877148)
Wow, offtopic, but you have a beautiful site.
I'm in the midst of reading Robert Bringhurst's Elements of Typographic Style and it's really motivating me to design my blog in a lot neater, cleaner, typographically-aware style. I think you've really nailed that. If you haven't read that book yet, I highly recommend it; I think you'd appreciate it.
Re:The Shapes of CSS
by mortenjorck on Friday August 12, 2011 @06:08PM
(#2879459)
You're absolutely right, visual designers really do need to learn CSS.
But not for this. These examples are as relevant to real-world CSS design as writing a Reddit clone in three lines of Clojure is to real-world web development.
I know that technically, the transform specs are not finalized, but considering this kind of consensus (even IE seems to agree), would it even be wise to change the spec again?
For the record it works in what's now the "old" Firefox 3.6 (Firefox 6 final is out in 4 days)
Everything made of triangles works in IE8 (ie. star and pentagon work).
Unfortunately IE6 does not support background:transparent but if you know what solid background color you do want, you can fake it.
If I remember correctly there is also a way to fake the transparency in IE6 with a chromakey and filter. You basically make the parts you want transparent a crazy color like bright pink and then have the filter make that color transparent. Almost not worth the effort anymore though.
I've been using these a bit lately for little icons and such, I think its a cleaner approach than spriting in a lot of cases. I put a little script to generate data URLs up at http://nick.zoic.org/art/etc/make-data-url.html
How good is cross-platform Unicode support these days? I do like the idea of just using characters which look like icons, even if it does feel a bit like writing MS-DOS TUIs with box-drawing characters :-).
"border: 20px solid red;" and "border-radius: 50px 50px 0 50px;" makes these elements' border round on three sides and square on the bottom right. (of bottom left for the :after element)
"transform: rotate(-45deg);" and "transform: rotate(45deg);" turn the two elements so that their square corner meet in the middle, leaving one loop on each side.
What I'd like to see is proper anti-aliasing. I'm obsessive enough that it prevents me from using CSS in such cases.
I see what their doing, but why does it make the triangle shape? Shouldn't it just render as a square with different sized rectangular borders?
Basically, the triangle is made of only the bottom border.
The top border is of width 0px so doesn't show. The element itself is 0x0px so doesn't show either. The right and left borders are transparent so you don't see them, but their width of 50px gives the base of the triangle. (which is then 100px) Finally the bottom border is 100px wide which gives the height of the triangle.
Note that the trapezoid further down is the same thing with a width of 100px for the element itself, as if you stretched that triangle in the middle.
You just have to look at the code behind this - http://nicolasgallagher.com/pure-css-gui-icons/demo/ - for confirmation that this is not a viable solution for complex shape creation.
I'm in the midst of reading Robert Bringhurst's Elements of Typographic Style and it's really motivating me to design my blog in a lot neater, cleaner, typographically-aware style. I think you've really nailed that. If you haven't read that book yet, I highly recommend it; I think you'd appreciate it.
But not for this. These examples are as relevant to real-world CSS design as writing a Reddit clone in three lines of Clojure is to real-world web development.