News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by trutannus on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:18AM (#28760619)
> Require ID verification

I'll pass on putting my personal ID in the hands of an organization that sells data as a business. No matter how many flimsy laws they put in place to ban selling my PII, you'd have to be born yesterday to think that won't just delay the sale this new treasure-trove of information.

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by aeturnum on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @12:14PM (#28761446)
I think this just goes to show how useful some kind of digital identity verification service would be. Giving your ID to a third party isn't that risky (as I hand it over to grocery cashiers all the time) but we certainly have the tech to do better.

It would be great to have a system with a municipal agency where you sign up for an account at the DMV and then they will sign low-info attestations of identity ("this person is over 18", "this person resides in California", etc) in response to queries from orgs.

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by gretch on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:59PM (#28763084)
We have a lot of evidence that local/municipal agencies are a huge attack vector for hackers. You have the resources and talent pool of a small city who now has to defend against attacks from all over the planet. Consider the ransomware attacks against the city of Baltimore: https://www.govtech.com/security/for-second-time-in-a-year-b...

I'd much rather my sensitive digital information be stored with FB (knowing how much they spend on cyber security) than the CA DMV.

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by aeturnum on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @05:56PM (#28766187)
> I'd much rather my sensitive digital information be stored with FB (knowing how much they spend on cyber security) than the CA DMV.

I know what you mean and also my information is stored at the DMV if I want a drivers' liscence - we have no choice in the matter. I think we must improve public systems.

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by trutannus on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @02:14PM (#28763317)
Where on earth (quite literally) do you live where you give your ID to cashiers in the grocery stores? Even in alcohol sales, these ID records are not kept. The clerks just look at the ID.
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by aeturnum on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @06:02PM (#28766248)
It's quite common to scan IDs in California to verify age (I assume to guard against fakes). I believe it's also common in other parts of the US.
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by code_checker4 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @12:32PM (#28761714)
This. Society evolving to require a service like this sounds great to me.
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by zxcvbn4038 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:30AM (#28760802)
They probably already have all your data, from Equifax or T-Mobile or whomever else is selling.
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by apozem on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @12:35PM (#28761751)
I’m not a Facebook fan, but it is incorrect to say they sell data. They collect data, build a profile of you and your interests and sell access to your eyeballs to advertisers.
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by spywaregorilla on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @12:12PM (#28761416)
They generally don't really sell data, they use your data to sell your eyeballs. The PII you're referring to is a drop in the bucket compared to the content most users are willingly sharing on their own. Yes, they will immediately monetize this information. But if that really bothers you, I'd have to ask if you're actually at all interested in being in the platform at all. The marginal privacy invasion going on here is so tiny compared to the product itself. It doesn't seem like a reasonable counterargument to implementing this as a safeguard.
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by chrononaut on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @12:36PM (#28761768)
Perhaps there are ways to do it indirectly?

Require a credit card associated with the account that matches the name of the account? (IIRC, you need to be 18+ to get a credit card)

(I recognize this goes outside the scope of GP, and this example may not be viable as I'm sure I am forgetting something here.)

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by nonameiguess on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @12:12PM (#28761419)
Not sure all states do this, but the Texas DMV already sells the information on your driver's license to marketers. Not much you can do when the agency that issues identification also sells your data, aside from totally withdraw and don't participate in modern life.
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by trutannus on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @06:25PM (#28766514)
The world isn't Texas. I'd rather not give Facebook extra data to play with because "well, Texas already sells Texan's data".
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by fighterpilot on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @07:04PM (#28766864)
What if the government gives each valid person a unique token that they can use to register once per social media site?
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by Bhilai on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:29AM (#28760790)
Have you ever provided your SSN to use a bank or applied for a car loan or mortgage? In all cases you are probably dealing with an entity that would sell your data or atleast share with "affiliates and partners."
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by trutannus on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:31AM (#28760824)
Your argument is "well the cat is out of the bag already, so let's make it worse by giving Facebook this sort of data too". We're talking about Facebook here.
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by SavantIdiot on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:50AM (#28761114)
Your personal ID contains public information.
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by Steltek on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @12:05PM (#28761318)
My public information is not tied intimately to my behavior and social circles.
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by SavantIdiot on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @12:52PM (#28762039)
Unless you live in a shed in the Rockies, I got bad news for you.
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by Steltek on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:03PM (#28762182)
Skip the trite cliches, what are you talking about? My driver's license, passport, whatever does not directly encode my relationships other than simple demographics.

I'm not under an illusion that I myself am personally anonymous. I'm sure I leave enough breadcrumbs around the Internet but that's my (dubious) choice. However, force me to verify my identity, use my real name, or enter a phone number and I lose that opportunity.

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by SavantIdiot on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:29PM (#28762596)
Every time I swipe my credit card, an intimate profile of who I am and what I do is updated. I don't see the difference between verifying my identity to use a service, and the thousands of other electronic activities I perform on a daily basis that succinctly outline what I do.

This nonsense that one more organization asking for ID is somehow the straw the broke the camels back is decades too late.

You say you are under no illusions, and then you demonstrate with words that you are under illusions.

You don't see it? It is clear as a bell to me.

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by trutannus on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @02:24PM (#28763471)
I still fail to see how this makes the idea of trusting Facebook or any other social media company with my ID any better. What's clear as a bell to me is that, given how Facebook is known to behave reprehensibly, giving them more data is not something we should even be considering.

It's a lot like saying "well now, this boat is full of holes, so rather than start patching them, let's just open several new ones".

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by SavantIdiot on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @02:47PM (#28763808)
> let's just open several new ones

I see it as the exact opposite: the gambler's fallacy. "This time we'll protect our privacy! I got a lucky feeling!!"

Doors open. Horse is gone. ID is actually smarter in this case because it will prevent fake accounts, which is a huge problem given their failures at policing the horrible things being done behind anonymity.

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by trutannus on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @03:12PM (#28764192)
This isn't even remotely close to the gambler's fallacy. This isn't an issue of statistics, or probabilities being skewed 'this time'. Really what the question being asked is if you want to force people by law to hand more information over to organizations like Facebook. Legislation or not, Facebook and their ilk will abuse this data. Give it time, and so will any government. Your argument is basically "yeah, well it's so bad at this point we might as well not even try to stop it".

In addition:

> policing the horrible things being done behind anonymity

Anonymity isn't something you can just do away with and have a happy ending. In some parts of the world, anonymity is the only thing standing between people and their government. That's not something I'd like to see done away with. The Afghan people need anonymity now more than nearly anyone else in the world. As do the Chinese, the Turkmens, Eritreans, domestic violence victims, and anyone who lives in a world where being identified could lead to a swift, brutal death. What are these folks to do? Hide forever? If that's the result, then we are not just seeing social cooling, we're looking at a social ice age.

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by jokowueu on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:26AM (#28760735)
HIPAA isn't a flimsy law and works quite well . Something similar can be used
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by trutannus on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:30AM (#28760801)
Right, the difference is medical records don't have a track record of being bought and sold with zero consequence. We're looking to take businesses that operate from the paradigm of "sell first, deal with the fallout later". Not organization that from day one have had a gun to their head if they so much as give the data a sideways look like those under HIPAA.
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by eh9 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:29AM (#28760783)
Sounds like a big ask porting something like that over to a widely public industry
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by ben-gy on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:35AM (#28760882)
HIPAA is PHI - wouldn’t apply in this example
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by barbazoo on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @12:16PM (#28761476)
> Something similar can be used
Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by ChuckNorris89 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:21AM (#28760662)
>I'll pass on putting my personal ID in the hands of an organization that sells data as a business.

I see this as a win for society. The more friction we insert and the more people are discouraged to join these ad-ware social networks the better.

Re:Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids an... by trutannus on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:23AM (#28760696)
I don't think the average person cares enough, or knows enough about how these organizations operate to actually think past putting their ID in whatever state approved portal you need to use. If people do it willingly, it does not reduce the cost to society of millions personal ID documents leaking or being sold to the highest bidder.