This statement is nonsensical - the IRS has no enforcement mandate for theft/fraud, nor does it have any authority to return stolen property. All the IRS would do is say "Hey, I heard you got an extra $NN last year - please pay your taxes on it".
It could even be argued that by reporting people the the IRS, the founder is implicitly admitting that the current possessors actually do own said crypto, otherwise they wouldn't owe any tax on it.
https://www.irs.gov/publications/p17
Illegal activities. Income from illegal activities, such as money from dealing illegal drugs, must be included in your income on Schedule 1 (Form 1040), line 8, or on Schedule C (Form 1040) if from your self-employment activity.
:)
It seems that the only thing you own when you purchase an NFT is the NFT itself. Not a little jpeg that it points to; just the bit of code on the blockchain.
It's kind of tautologically stupid. You buy a receipt that states you own that very receipt.
But if people buy deeds instead of the house itself (i.e. most NFTs) then the link becomes broken and the signifier of “ownership” is less useful.
The deed is only a signifier of ownership, nothing more. If you can prove in court that the possession of the deed itself was improperly transferred, the state will return the deed to the rightful owner. Or annul the old deed and create a new one. (At least in the US.)
As you say, a deed is not a bearer instrument but the concept of home ownership which it symbolizes has legal protection.
And as it is used for digital goods, the signifier of “ownership” is already broken, as multiple people can have a copy of the item without their being any ownership conflict, unlike a house.
This seems wrong. Here's the quote from the founder:
> Otherwise, it's being reported as income to the IRS, and most of you are doxxed.
It seems to be "return it or else it will count as your income," which seems... weird. Do most crypto people just not pay taxes on crypto? How is this a threat?
In fact, that threat almost makes returning it the riskier move. Are they going to report all of these transfers to the IRS? Will the IRS consider it income, and then a gift back to compound if I return it?
[edit] there's even a cottage industry supporting folks who refuse to pay taxes in getting second passports and abandoning their US citizenship. [1]
[1] https://www.cnbc.com/2021/07/11/plan-b-passport-tax-break-bi...
The thought experiment that made this concrete was a sort of reductio ad absurdem:
Let's say for a moment that NFTs win worldwide support and begin to be used as proof of ownership for everything. As part of this movement, the Louvre registers an NFT signature for each item in their collection.
Now, let's say a nefarious actor manages to use social engineering and convince a naive Louvre curator to transfer the NFT ownership of the Mona Lisa.
This bad actor promptly goes to Sotheby's and asks them to list "his" Mona Lisa for sale.
---
Of course, the Mona Lisa would not go anywhere. The French government would never allow it. This is an extreme example but can be walked back to less and less valuable items: would this work for an NFT of a house, a car, a computer, etc?
Unless the state decided to universally and with no exceptions enforce ownership of NFTs, they are ultimately worthless.
Most developed contries have digitized their deed system, so I am not sure how you can con someone out of their deed.
Also, back when we did use physical deeds, there generally was owner’s copy and land office’s copy, and on the back of the deed would be the transfer history.
So to con someone out of their deed, you would not only need to get the owner’s deed, but you would also have to get your name added to the land office’s copy.
Not the US*. I mean I guess they are digitized in the sense that records are typically published online electronically, but it is all still based off these bits of paper going back and forth, there is not like a database of ownership.
*Except for Iowa https://archive.curbed.com/2018/2/26/17017142/title-insuranc...
"Digitizing" something doesn't make it invincible to con artists - there's really no difference between me conning you into signing over a deed if it's paper or digital.
Therefore I have to conclude that NFT usage is an extremely radical act against state power, because what it says is that the state doesn't matter, this blockchain(the one you are using at that moment) does. And you are accepting that your rights end where it does, too, so you had better trust the community.
https://mobile.twitter.com/moo9000/status/144389383001774899...
And that is one of the biggest misconceptions of crypto stuff.
Law and contracts (1) determine who owns what, not who happens to currently hold it.
That's why the founder can threaten them with the IRS, because they (likely(1)) do not rightfully (as defined per law) own it.
This is also why NFTs are kinds stupid, because you totally can sell someone a NFT which "claims ownership rights" without selling them any ownership rights legally seen. Sure it's most likely fraud as you deceived people, but only if. So telling people you sell them the NFT but not the think behind the NFT would make that pretty legal. Like you can sell a certificate about the correctness/quality of a picture without selling (or even having) that picture.
(1): Smart contracts are not contracts, they are computer programs. They might also contain contracts, but that doesn't mean that just because something is done in a certain way in a smart contract it is legally binding, legal, or anything (Well, that's also true for contracts themself).