Re:DeFi bug accidentally gives $90M to users
by tylerhou on Friday October 01, 2021 @02:48PM
(#28722093)
It’s more like a deed. Even if you possess the deed, someone can still take you to court because they actually own the property. But a deed can still be a useful tool if most of the time whoever possesses a deed owns the house.
But if people buy deeds instead of the house itself (i.e. most NFTs) then the link becomes broken and the signifier of “ownership” is less useful.
Re:DeFi bug accidentally gives $90M to users
by arcticbull on Friday October 01, 2021 @02:56PM
(#28722162)
Deeds are legally binding, NFTs are nothing at all. You can make as many or as few as you want, and they come with anywhere from 0 to full rights to the underlying. Also the "underlying" is literally just a URL with no restrictions. What it points to could just disappear one day and SFYL. Should have checked the JSON blob you were buying to make sure it pointed at IPFS or something.
Re:DeFi bug accidentally gives $90M to users
by tylerhou on Friday October 01, 2021 @08:59PM
(#28725052)
Possession of a deed is not legally binding — if someone robbed your house and took your deed, clearly they don’t own your house.
The deed is only a signifier of ownership, nothing more. If you can prove in court that the possession of the deed itself was improperly transferred, the state will return the deed to the rightful owner. Or annul the old deed and create a new one. (At least in the US.)
Re:DeFi bug accidentally gives $90M to users
by arcticbull on Saturday October 02, 2021 @10:17PM
(#28733975)
Sorry for the delay, what I meant is that the concept of NFT has no protection under law whatsoever. It means literally nothing. It's a bearer instrument for nothing.
As you say, a deed is not a bearer instrument but the concept of home ownership which it symbolizes has legal protection.
Re:DeFi bug accidentally gives $90M to users
by mrgordon on Friday October 01, 2021 @07:55PM
(#28724701)
I believe even a lot of the IPFS NFTs have gone missing already
Re:DeFi bug accidentally gives $90M to users
by humaniania on Friday October 01, 2021 @03:02PM
(#28722207)
A deed only has value because there is a government that enforces what it represents.
Re:DeFi bug accidentally gives $90M to users
by tylerhou on Friday October 01, 2021 @09:00PM
(#28725057)
That is true of all property, so I don’t understand the relevance.
Re:DeFi bug accidentally gives $90M to users
by recursive on Friday October 01, 2021 @05:11PM
(#28723417)
You seem like a smart guy, so you'll probably recognize a bargain when you see one. I've got a deed available for disney.com, for today only.
Re:DeFi bug accidentally gives $90M to users
by sorbits on Friday October 01, 2021 @03:00PM
(#28722196)
> But if people buy deeds instead of the house itself (i.e. most NFTs) then the link becomes broken and the signifier of “ownership” is less useful.
And as it is used for digital goods, the signifier of “ownership” is already broken, as multiple people can have a copy of the item without their being any ownership conflict, unlike a house.
Re:DeFi bug accidentally gives $90M to users
by colechristensen on Friday October 01, 2021 @02:42PM
(#28722041)
NFTs could be used for the sale of various kinds of intellectual property, I’m not aware of any that actually are doing so.
It seems that the only thing you own when you purchase an NFT is the NFT itself. Not a little jpeg that it points to; just the bit of code on the blockchain.
It's kind of tautologically stupid. You buy a receipt that states you own that very receipt.