News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Half of American kids have lead in their blood, doctors say by nate_meurer on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @02:17PM (#28685790)
A lady named Tamara Rubin has spent years testing household products and other commonly handled objects for lead. She uses an XRF tester, which is the gold standard for high accuracy lead testing. She has thousands of items listed, from dishes to door hardware to childrens toys, and a lot of these will put a family at high risk of lead poisoning. There's some woo-y stuff on her website, but her XRF data is a gold mine:

https://tamararubin.com/

I personally have used both XRF and swabs on various objects around by home, and I found some really scary shit. The scariest were the older Lenox dishes we used for years; the decorative glaze on the eating surface tested high in lead via XRF, and the swab lit up bright red which means that lead was also coming off in our food.

I threw away all our dishes and bought new Corelle.

Other problems I found include old electrical cords and things made out of brass, including all plumbing fittings made before about 2012. These will also turn a swab red, especially if there's any corrosion, which means the lead is mobile.

Re:Half of American kids have lead in their blood, doctors say by sayhar on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @03:57PM (#28686785)
So I went into a big rabbithole of writing up a long email to my family warning them about specific plates and so on. Then I paused -- was any of this real?

I looked up on Snopes -- they didn't seem to be too convinced that she's legit[0]. Some more googling didn't seem to show any reputable site repeating her claims.

It's hard to tell if any of this is true or not. (Especially since there's a difference between a _cracked_ or chipped plate vs a normal one)

[0] https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/vintage-pyrex-contains-uns...

Re:Half of American kids have lead in their blood, doctors say by nate_meurer on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @04:51PM (#28687341)
That snopes article is one of the worst ones I've ever read. Snopes does some good work, but they also do some really terrible work, and this is a good example. The writer, Kim LaCapria, is clearly way out of her depth on technical topics.

Notice that the article doesn't provide one single piece of evidence of its own. Kim offers only a contorted narrative about FDA regulations and manufacturer denials, and complains about being unable to find "alternative sources". But the widespread use of lead pigments in ceramic glazes and paints is so well known, and so easily verified, that this is a bit like complaining about alternative sources for the color of the sky.

Tamara's XRF results can be easily verified by anyone with access to an XRF machine. You can take your dishes to any county health department and have them tested by XRF, and you'll see similar numbers. This is what I did with my old Lenox dishes, and the XRF revealed over 5000 ppm lead in the surface glaze. I've had dozens of pieces tested this way, including pyrex, corningware, radom kids cups, etc, and the numbers I get match Tamara's. And of course they do. It would be stupid for anyone to fabrinate this data, because it's so easy to verify.

Anyone can buy a LeadCheck swab for a buck or two and test for mobile lead at the surface. This is mostly how I test the stuff in my house, and it's how I know that my contaminated dishes were an actual poisoning hazard. If the lead comes off on a swab, then it will come off on your hands, in your food, and in your baby's mouth.

It's a similar story with cords and brass plumbing fittings. The facts of lead-based heat stabilizers used in PVC cable jackets, and the high lead content of traditional water works brass, are as incontrovertable as the sky is blue.

Kim LaCapria at Snopes doesn't seem to understand any of this. There's no indication that she even knows what XRF is, or how widely available these devices are.

Re:Half of American kids have lead in their blood, doctors say by fighterpilot on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @06:32PM (#28688263)
If I want to test things in my household should I even bother with XRF testing or do you think LeadCheck is sufficient?
Re:Half of American kids have lead in their blood, doctors say by nate_meurer on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @06:58PM (#28688444)
I rely almost entirely on the swabs for testing things around the house, because they're what I have, and they tell you whether lead is actually transferable from a surface, versus being merely present in the material.

But if I had an XRF tester I would use it all the time. The swabs are relatively slow, especially the way I use them, and they don't work at all for some things. For example, a swab won't tell you if there's lead paint under a layer of safe paint. This is important because that lead paint is just as much of a hazard when it chips or when you do any remodelling. You can scrape away paint a layer at a time to swab it, but you'll never get a whole house tested this way, whereas an XRF could do it in an hour or two.

Every so often I gather up some particular things and take them to the tri-county health department here in south Denver for XRF testing. The last batch I took included some old red-painted hand tools, a chip of red paint from a yard decoration, a set of chinese-made pastel crayons that my kids got for christmas, and a bag of dust I collected from the HVAC in our house. These things aren't testable with swabs; the dust isn't swabable, and the red tools and pastels colored the swab regardless of lead content.

The people there are friendly and eager to help. I made an appointment, and the lady actually drove in for it from a different department. She tested all my stuff in about 15 minutes, and everything came back negative except for one of the red tools. Even the chinese-made pastels were completely clean, which surprised me.

Fun bonus: she told me a story about how the county health department updated their standard household lead testing protocol twelve years ago after some guy brought in a bunch of dishes that tested shockingly high. Guess who that guy was? :)

Re:Half of American kids have lead in their blood, doctors say by iaw on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @08:52PM (#28689169)
Was his first name Nate?
Re:Half of American kids have lead in their blood, doctors say by nate_meurer on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @09:06PM (#28689239)
Yes! It was actually the lady's former supervisor who tested my dishes back then. She's since moved on, but the new lady told me that neither her boss nor anyone else in the health department had thought to look at dishes. I remember her being shocked and somewhat confused when she saw the XRF reading, and when the swab turned bright red she said, "oh my".

I felt like I was going to throw up, knowing that I'd been feeding my kids off those dishes for years. I've had to really work at putting that burden down and moving on. I never had my kids blood tested, and they seem fine, but I've love it if my experience helps someone else avoid the danger.

Re:Half of American kids have lead in their blood, doctors say by fighterpilot on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @09:23PM (#28689314)
Looks like we either need some new regulations or some better enforcement because that's just disgusting. Glassware for everything it is, I guess.
Re:Half of American kids have lead in their blood, doctors say by colpabar on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @05:11PM (#28687576)
If you're worried about misinformation online, snopes should absolutely not be the first place you look.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28169681

Re:Half of American kids have lead in their blood, doctors say by giantg2 on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @08:04PM (#28688886)
Don't forget to warn them about the uranium plates
Re:Half of American kids have lead in their blood, doctors say by raxxorrax on Wednesday September 29, 2021 @03:27AM (#28691151)
I would prefer uranium plates to lead plates. Long term I would use the good stuff like plastics though.
Re:Half of American kids have lead in their blood, doctors say by reducesuffering on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @03:12PM (#28686285)
Yes, great callout. Relevant to many of us, is that many ceramic coffee and tea mugs also leech lead, especially if they have the colored glaze. I'm using specifically lead-free glass now.
Re:Half of American kids have lead in their blood, doctors say by effingwewt on Wednesday September 29, 2021 @01:48AM (#28690663)
Also, cheap glaze rubs off with the softest of scrubbing.

I remember begging my grandmother to stop using her cheap boil-in coffee pot. Cheap glaze wore down, then the paint, then the metal of the pot. Aluminum just leeching into all the coffee.

Didn't matter, she loved the flavor. The replacements I got her were used once because she loved me, then relegated to the cupboard.

She had really bad alzheimer's by the end. I'll never know if any of the cheap dishes and pits/pans('teflon' coatings etc), but it's always made me super paranoid about this stuff, I bought some testing kits tonight after reading all this.

Re:Half of American kids have lead in their blood, doctors say by fighterpilot on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @04:25PM (#28687071)
"lead-free glass"

I assume glass is just lead-free by default and I don't need to go out looking for a special lead-free version of glassware, right?

Re:Half of American kids have lead in their blood, doctors say by edwcross on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @05:04PM (#28687508)
Crystal (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lead_glass) does contain lead, but apparently "crystal glass" does not.

So, by default, "glass" is indeed lead-free, unless you're talking about some fancy older glassware.

Re:Half of American kids have lead in their blood, doctors say by giantg2 on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @08:06PM (#28688899)
Some older ceramics have lead too (mugs, crocks). I think some coming from China in more recent years have tested positive (plus toys and more).
Re:Half of American kids have lead in their blood, doctors say by giantg2 on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @02:30PM (#28685911)
I think it can depend on other factors too. For example, lead crystal drinkwater is considered safe as long as you aren't leaving the liquid in there for long periods of time. It's possible that's similar to the dishes.

Stuff like leaded fuel exhaust or paint flakes are more likely to be ingested/absorbed.

Re:Half of American kids have lead in their blood, doctors say by nate_meurer on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @02:38PM (#28685990)
This is why the swabs are an important tool in addition to the XRF. If the swab turns red, then by definition it's wiping mobile lead from the surface of the object you're testing.

Using electrical cords as an example, years ago I went through my house and swabbed all of the cords. If I found a cord that turned a swab red, I either threw the thing away if it was cheap, like an old coffee grinder, or I replaced the cord if I didn't want to replace the whole machine, like the cords on all of our Oreck vacuum cleaners.

A lot of newer cords have lead in the insulation as indicated by XRF, but won't turn a swab pink. These I don't worry about too much, but I still tell the kids to wash their hand after handling them.

EDIT:

The LeadCheck swabs are pretty expensive, and using a whole swab for just one or two objects is ridiculously wasteful, but I have a trick that makes them cheap. I cut the cotton head off of a Q-tip cosmetic swab so that it's just a rolled paper rod. I activate the LeadCheck swab and squeeze out a drop of the liquid onto the upright surface of the swab. I dab the end of the decapitated Q-tip in the liquid, and I use that to swab the surface of whatever I'm testing. If something turns the paper red, I clip the end of the shaft off with nail clippers to get a fresh end, and continue to the next object.

I can get dozens of tests out of a single swab this way. I make a list of things to test in one afternoon, and I can get the whole pile done for the cost of a single swab, instead of spending hundreds of dollars it would take to use a new LeadCheck swab for each object.

Plus, the hard paper Q-tip shaft works better for aggressively rubbing on surfaces.

Re:Half of American kids have lead in their blood, doctors say by Metacelsus on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @03:29PM (#28686476)
You can also make your own with sodium rhodonizate (which you can get at many chemical supply companies)
Re:Half of American kids have lead in their blood, doctors say by nate_meurer on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @03:39PM (#28686568)
The LeadCheck swabs are super nice because they package the reagent in binary form in separate sealed glass capsules. As far as I know, this gives the product an indefinite shelf life. I'm still using a batch of LeadChecks that bought from Ebay fifteen years ago.
Re:Half of American kids have lead in their blood, doctors say by comboy on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @05:16PM (#28687638)
Can anybody explain to me or give me some materials to read? Say toy has 5000ppm Pb, how does that translate to it being dangerous? Child only touches it. Assuming soil have a ballpark of 100ppm Pb and we all love fresh vegetables.. how is this toy or even a dish doing any damage?
Re:Half of American kids have lead in their blood, doctors say by nate_meurer on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @05:24PM (#28687711)
Not sure what you're asking. You want an explanation of how lead pigments chalking off the surface of an old dish get in your mouth? Or how lead paint on a toy gets into a baby's mouth?
Re:Half of American kids have lead in their blood, doctors say by comboy on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @05:44PM (#28687892)
You don't give your kids toys which fall apart and your dish is not losing 1% of its mass with your every meal. So I'm asking how much is it losing? How many grams of your dish may stay on your food? From a quick look carrot has like 0.1mg/kg with up to 10mg/kg of lead [1][2]. We just eat it and give it to babies so they're healthy.

So how much mass does a toy or a dish lose and how much of it ends up in somebody's mouth?

Based on the data above if you ate 10g of your 5000ppm dish that seems equivalent to 5kg of carrots. And I do love to make a carrot juice, that's like a few servings. 10g of dish seems like a lot to swallow.

I'm just trying to explain my lack of understanding here. I have just learned about these measurements and I'm clueless about the topic.

1. https://www.scielo.br/j/hb/a/PSXVNhx63TkLq9rFKVFNfjr/?lang=e...

2. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/016788...

Re:Half of American kids have lead in their blood, doctors say by nate_meurer on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @06:14PM (#28688118)
It sounds like you're overthinking this a bit.

Kids chew on and swallow all kinds of weird shit. I've seen young kids chew the paint off whole sets of pencils. Babies put literally everything they can in their mouth. I've watched children lick window sills for fucks sake.

If there's lead glaze on the eating surface of a plate or bowl, and if you know it's mobile, as it was on my dishes, then it's a safe assumption that it's mostly going in your food.

Someone could spend a ton of time and money studying and quantifying the transfer of lead in all kinds of different scenarios, but what would the purpose be, when it's a relatively simple matter to abate or remove the hazard completely?

Food is a different matter, and I believe tested regulation of heavy metals in foods is sorrowfully lacking.

Re:Half of American kids have lead in their blood, doctors say by comboy on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @06:30PM (#28688250)
I have kids, and I also definitely agree that it's better if lead is not in there at all. The whole lead in gasoline story is ridiculous and traumatizing.

I'm just not sold on the idea of testing/researching products and getting rid of them based on what I've learned these last 10 minutes. It seems to me that it would be multiple orders of magnitude more important to test your vegetables if you are a lead-minimizer?

And what about soil? E.g. in context of playgrounds. Soil is 15-40ppm Pb. Really bad toy from 90s is 5000ppm. Exposure surface * time * ppm. Based on that equation it seems that testing playground soil would be much more important.

Assuming your lead-heavy plate completely disappears after 10 years of every day usage just ponder how much of it ended up in your belly compared to dishwasher cycles. If 1% of it disappeared, and you ate 1% of what dishwasher did, then it's equivalent to eating the dish weight of carrots during these 10 years.

I have no idea why I'm defending leaded dishware here, I do not recommend anybody keep their leaded anything based on erroneous math and data from some random HN comment. I would just like to learn if there is something I'm missing that would change my understanding of the problem.

Re:Half of American kids have lead in their blood, doctors say by nate_meurer on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @07:14PM (#28688563)
Ok, that's reasonable, and I don't have any good answers. I just get rid of things and call it good, but the food is a big question, and it's not fair to the kids to completely forbid playgrounds.

Lead dust in houses is a well studied hazard. The folks at the county department tell me the things they address first are lead paint (interior and exterior house paint and soil around the house), lead in the tap water, and vinyl mini-blinds. Abating those sources almost always drops BLL in the kids. If that isn't enough, they go after toys and dishes. If I remember right, testing of food is not yet in their protocol.

For me the decision to get rid of the dishes was trivially simple. I'd be glad to find out that the food we ate off those dishes miraculously failed to pick up any of the lead that so easily rubbed off on my swabs. I don't think that's likely.

Same with the kids toys and art supplies. Sure, I can tell little kids not to lick their arylics, but why wouldn't I also make sure the yellows are cadmium-free, just in case they forget and eat a sandwich with paint on their fingers?

Re:Half of American kids have lead in their blood, doctors say by giantg2 on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @08:15PM (#28688950)
I generally agree. Anything you are consuming that contains lead is much more concerning than food contacting a dish with a low amount of lead for a short amount of time (implying minimal to negligible transfer).

Honestly, the amount of lead in dishes and crystal (when it even contains it) is low. If you keep the contact time with the food low and there's no cracks/chips/dust, then you're fine. As an example, generally drinking from crystal is fine, but leaving a drink in a crystal decanter is not.

Re:Half of American kids have lead in their blood, doctors say by ramblenode on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @07:29PM (#28688660)
The dish lead is concentrated in the glaze on the surface, not throughout the mass of the dish. That should change your calculations...
Re:Half of American kids have lead in their blood, doctors say by annoyingnoob on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @04:20PM (#28687022)
Its in so many older city water pipes that you cannot see, only to be let out when the water chemistry changes a bit.