News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by 88913527 on Sunday September 26, 2021 @01:38AM (#28658679)
You can give your heart, but if your significant other doesn't speak your love language, no matter how much you give, it may not be right for you. If you're focused exclusively on giving, are you considering your own needs as a person? Granted, if both people are focused on giving, hopefully they can figure it out among one another.
Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by nsomaru on Sunday September 26, 2021 @02:49AM (#28658932)
The way my guru would respond to question like “how do I avoid giving too much” type questions was to retort with a question…

“If you’re a giver, what are you looking for?”

…

“Takers!”

That is, if you’re giving with an expectation of something in return, you’re not looking to give, you’re looking for a transaction. True giving, then, does not carry with it the weight of any expectation or fruit. The joy is in the act of giving itself, the sacrifice, as a candle sacrifices itself to give light.

He elaborated further to say that if one person is giving oriented in a relationship, it would be stable. If both, it would be heaven. To come back to the point of the OP, it’s the focus on “me, me, me” that’s the issue.

Abraham Lincoln said (paraphrase) “there is one way to bring up your children, and that is to walk that way yourself.” I feel in relationships it’s similar. Less sermons, more leading by example without expectations.

Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by dr_dshiv on Sunday September 26, 2021 @03:26AM (#28659075)
I don't disagree, because there is a lot of wisdom in what you say. But...

1. If kids see the example of a marital power dynamic of taking and giving, it's not that they will necessarily learn to be selfless givers!

2. I like the F Scott Peck definition of love, which is to extend ones self to support the spiritual growth of another. And, often the growth that a taker needs is to learn to be giving. Often, takers take because they view themselves as a victim.

For a giver, it can be really difficult to go outside of one's normal giving mode without being sucked into a mode of anger or resentment.

3."Being married" is not an ultimate value—it can hurt all the people involved. Complicated! Sometimes I feel I could be a much better, more giving person in a healthier relationship because I could be helping many more people. If i take your example of the candle—it may be great to sacrifice yourself to create light, but is it worth the sacrifice if you aren't producing light?

Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by nsomaru on Sunday September 26, 2021 @06:49AM (#28659847)
The way I interpret what he said is, “if the sacrifice is genuine, light is the necessary result”

I like it because it puts the ball back in my court and forces me to take responsibility without judging the other.

Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by treis on Sunday September 26, 2021 @11:22AM (#28661559)
>you’re looking for a transaction

And what is wrong with that? I help you with your shit and you help me with mine.

It's not at the level of transactional quid pro quos. But at a basic level you can't have one giver and one taker. Eventually that breaks down into resentment.

Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by watwut on Sunday September 26, 2021 @07:17AM (#28659953)
There is such a thing as one sided relationship where one person gives and other don't. And the giver is not happy in the long term.

There is value in being able to ask for what you need and being able to realize when giving is not reciprocated.

Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by akomtu on Sunday September 26, 2021 @10:34AM (#28661184)
That's because the giver secretly expected something in return.
Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by PeterisP on Sunday September 26, 2021 @11:37AM (#28661736)
And that's okay and expected - it would be unrealistic to expect people to be 100% ideal givers.

In the parent post's quote "If you’re a giver, what are you looking for?" the "If" is doing a lot of heavy lifting.

Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by watwut on Sunday September 26, 2021 @12:08PM (#28662045)
No. Prior expectations are not the only way how one gets resentful. Being tired is another. Realizing you have not done something you like for long time is yet another.

And all of it is healthy. Being submissive doormat and not having boundaries is not healthy.

Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by kweinber on Sunday September 26, 2021 @11:32AM (#28661678)
You might be a giver looking for another giver to build something bigger together. It isn’t correct that givers only want takers. Think of it like cofounders.
Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by jazzabeanie on Sunday September 26, 2021 @03:39AM (#28659125)
Who is your guru?
Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by nsomaru on Sunday September 26, 2021 @06:45AM (#28659830)
A Parthasarathy — www.vedantaworld.org
Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by wetpaws on Sunday September 26, 2021 @03:01AM (#28658984)
>if your significant other doesn't speak your love language, no matter how much you give, it may not be right for you

Thats why people communicate.

Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by agumonkey on Sunday September 26, 2021 @05:10AM (#28659467)
That is true, personal experience showed me that what I took as love wasn't seen as such by the other one. Absolute crash ensued. Wisdom makes you pick the people that you feel compatible, or at least make you able to communicate in finer ways to make sure both are aiming at the same ballpark.
Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by manmal on Sunday September 26, 2021 @02:30AM (#28658847)
Languages can and have to be learned. This is also true for love language.
Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by fastball on Sunday September 26, 2021 @02:56AM (#28658967)
I'd go one step further and assert that "love languages" are mostly bunk, in the same way that "learning styles" are not really a thing.

Meyers-briggs, zodiac, learning styles, love languages, etc. are all self-fulfilling prophecies that are sold as empowering but are mostly just traps which limit your potential.

Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by tailspin2019 on Sunday September 26, 2021 @09:20AM (#28660651)
I would argue that they're all different forms of "maps" and have their uses, but they are not the territory.

If you start to confuse the map for the territory then yes they can be limiting in some ways, because you no longer see any features that are not included on the map. And the features that have been included seem more prominent.

All we can create as humans are maps for things. Different types of abstractions. And refine them over time as we gain better understanding. But when using these maps it's important to keep in mind that they're just one of many ways of describing the thing you're trying to understand.

Myers-Briggs for me was very enlightening, and started me on a journey of understanding how people can be different (led to greater empathy and awareness on my part). I don't walk around classifying people's MBTI type though.

Zodiac... not so much. That map is a bit old now!

Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by fastball on Sunday September 26, 2021 @10:50PM (#28666606)
This is a fair point, though I'd say my main concern is that "confusing the map for the territory" seems to be the status quo with these types of things.

As an example of this with Myers-Briggs: I think your MBTI can be helpful if you think of it as "these are the patterns of behavior I naturally fall into, I should try harder to be aware of and use patterns outside my comfort zone in situations where that might be more productive than my default".

However, 9 times out of 10 when I actually meet someone who brings up their MBTI in conversation, the way they think about it is more like "I'm an INTJ, X just isn't something I do", where X is something they probably should do but are avoiding because their MBTI is giving them a pass (in their mind).

So on balance I feel that "maps" like this do more harm than good, because our human instinct when given such a map is to point to it and say "this bit of territory looks scary so I'm gonna avoid it".

Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by tailspin2019 on Monday September 27, 2021 @09:53AM (#28670638)
Good counterargument to my counterargument :)

I think you're right that confusing the map for the territory is by far the default. So in that sense I do agree with the downsides that you're bringing attention to. And as always, it's not so much about the tool but how you use it.

If you give a power saw to someone who hasn't used it before and hasn't been remotely trained on how to, then they'll probably end up chopping off a limb. But that's not to say the power saw isn't an incredibly effective tool for achieving a very specific task in the right context.

So I can't agree that these maps do more harm than good. It's not as binary as that in my view.

Even if maps like MBTI are wrong - there is a lot of meta-understanding that can come from just going through the exercise. Most people go through life not really understanding that other people don't see the world exactly the same way as they do. And we judge people on their external actions alone with, most of the time, very little understanding or empathy as to what beliefs, traits and preferences might exist below the surface that drives their behaviour.

The bar is very low even for the best of us in our ability to really understand ourselves and others. So just the process of discovering a map that shows you a different view of the world can be very powerful - even if ultimately the map itself isn't quite right.

Without the use of external maps, we create our own internal maps by default anyway - this is just how the brain works. And those maps can have the exact same effect that you're describing. "I believe that I am X and so this is why I can't do Y". But often those maps aren't created with intention, nor are they based on information that is up-to-date and relevant (eg. our limbic system by default wants to pull our default behaviours/actions back towards surviving tiger attacks and hunting for food - this is out of date information encoded in an out of date map).

I guess another way to put it, is we're always following a map of some sort. Our default maps (our beliefs about ourselves) aren't as a rule known to be the most accurate either!

Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by xyzelement on Sunday September 26, 2021 @09:19AM (#28660649)
> mostly bunk

Does this style of post ever work? You are dismissive of all these things but you lack a single reason/argument. Is there a chain of logic that leads you to this conclusion?

It's a bit fascinating to me. I imagine the purpose of a post is to share ideas, to give people a chance to think more like you and that takes a persuasive argument.

Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by moogly on Sunday September 26, 2021 @12:35PM (#28662267)
I think the poster anchored their argument better than what the post they replied to did, by comparison to other things. The post they replied to stated something to be an absolute truth without any support whatsoever.
Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by fastball on Sunday September 26, 2021 @12:19PM (#28662138)
Not sure why the burden of proof is on me to demonstrate that they are bunk. Seems like the burden of proof is on anyone who asserts they exist in the first place, since "love languages" are not an objective thing.
Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by xyzelement on Sunday September 26, 2021 @12:29PM (#28662216)
> Not sure why the burden of proof is on me

There's no burden of proof here, the question is: what is the point of the post? I assume the goal is to help someone change their mind - to think more like you. And my observation is that you are not providing anything in your comment that would enable someone to follow a logical thread to reach the same conclusion as you.

So the net effect is, whoever already agreed with you continues to agree with you, and anyone who doesn't already agree with you isn't given a reason to change their mind.

In my mind that's a lost opportunity to persuade people, in which case what's the point of the comment?

Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by fastball on Sunday September 26, 2021 @10:07PM (#28666405)
Well first off it is entirely possible that there are people who have been introduced to the concept of love languages in a way where they never questioned them critically, and merely pointing out that I think they are "bunk" might start someone down that path of questioning.

On top of that, however, I specifically compared love languages to other things which people might have already examined critically. Since this is HN, probably the most cogent item from my list is zodiac/horoscope, as techies tend to be fairly dismissive of it already, and therefore might have the realization (after reading my comment): "oh wow, I've been believing in love languages this whole time but been dismissive of zodiac, even though both have the same amount of evidentiary backing (~ 0)". However, I actually think "learning styles" is a better example because it is something a lot of people believe in (something like 90% from the surveys I've seen), even though in reality there is almost zero experimental evidence for them as well, despite many biased attempts to do so. My opinion is that love languages are very similar – people believe strongly that there are certain actions/behaviors that they are most receptive to when it comes to romance, but that fundamentally people just want to be loved in a much more generic way and that if the particular way in which love is expressed matters that much to you, you are probably focused on the wrong thing (missing the forest for the trees).

To really spell out why this is bad, let's look back at learning styles: someone believes in learning styles, which don't exist[1]. Specifically, they believe they are a "visual learner". As soon as this belief forms, it almost instantly becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy – they think they are a visual learner, so whenever they are faced with learning something in a non-visual way they don't try as hard, and therefore do not learn the material as well. They are effectively self-sabotaging by having this constrained picture of themselves in their head. There is no reason to believe that people who take love languages seriously will not suffer a similar fate. Imagine someone who thinks of themself as a lover whose primary love language is "physical touch", so when someone demonstrates love in a way that is not touch, they say to themselves (maybe not in an explicitly conscious way): "hmm, this isn't as compelling as it could be because I'm a physical touch lover – I wish my partner demonstrated their love with more touch".

In essence, I feel that all of these things, love languages included, are artificial and mostly arbitrary labels (some more arbitrary than others) which only serve to constrain your breadth of experience and openness to new things, resulting in unfortunate self-fulfilling downsides with no clear upside.

[1] https://www.apa.org/pubs/journals/features/edu-a0037478.pdf

Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by asdfasgasdgasdg on Sunday September 26, 2021 @09:23AM (#28660684)
Don't forget enneagrams. These things are all based on very shaky research at best. I would argue that love languages of all of these are probably the best supported, or at least the most plausible a priori. After all they mostly boil down to, "I especially like {touch, gifts, service, ...}." But even then I think that for most people you need a mix of all of these things in a romantic relationship. Getting great gifts from a spouse is not going to save the relationship if they won't touch you, nine times out of ten.
Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by xivzgrev on Sunday September 26, 2021 @03:46AM (#28659151)
I disagree. Love language improved my relationship for the better. It gives us language and priority to things that felt important but were difficult to describe and help the other understand.

To your point tho we use all the languages, and many other things beyond the languages. I think it’s important to not get too fixated on them. It’s just one piece of the puzzle. There’s many other things required besides speaking someone’s love language, but it helps!

Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by unyttigfjelltol on Sunday September 26, 2021 @07:13AM (#28659941)
Individual people can be radically different in what makes them feel loved, satisfied and connected. If the OP never has to understand this, he/she is fortunate. More likely, there is someone in that person's life who would appreciate some directed curiosity.
Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by golemotron on Sunday September 26, 2021 @02:53AM (#28658953)
Love languages were invented to sell a book in 1992.
Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by feanaro on Sunday September 26, 2021 @04:06AM (#28659216)
Is this an American thing? I had no idea the OP was talking about an actual thing until now and understood the phrase "love language" as figurative.
Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by sammalloy on Sunday September 26, 2021 @06:08AM (#28659677)
"Love language" is a hugely popular, but pseudoscientific concept in the relationship community in the US. It's BS, just like astrology, the law of attraction, and all that jazz. But people swear by it, and they won't back down from it if it works for them.
Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by giantg2 on Sunday September 26, 2021 @07:42AM (#28660074)
I mean, if you consider psychology psuedoscience, I suppose that could be true. It has numerous articles written about it in psychology publications.
Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by asdfasgasdgasdg on Sunday September 26, 2021 @09:27AM (#28660708)
Would you be so kind as to point out some well executed research on the love languages? I had been under the impression that they are pop-psychology.

https://www.mic.com/p/do-love-languages-actually-matter-psyc...

“I don’t consider it to be an evidence-based practice, but I do find it to be a very useful tool and use it in all of my work with couples,” says Stefani Goerlich, a Detroit-based psychotherapist.

research conducted in 2017 suggests that the five love languages only work when “both spouses exhibit appropriate self-regulatory behaviors.”

Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by giantg2 on Sunday September 26, 2021 @10:06AM (#28660999)
From that same article, it says that it's a communication technique/framework that is used in therapy. That it's a useful tool. I don't consider useful tools to be "BS".

Also, just because something only works within specific parameters (spouses with self-regulating behaviors), doesn't mean it doesn't work. It just isn't a cure-all. It would be like saying antibiotics are BS just because they only work on a subset of bacterial infections.

https://www.jhseonline.com/article/view/788

Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by asdfasgasdgasdg on Sunday September 26, 2021 @10:55AM (#28661346)
Hard to tell if a tool is useful if there is not high quality research backing up the claim. That a tool is used, especially in psychology, does not mean that it is useful or a good model of actual human psychology. Freud's stuff is a great example of this. None of it has any basis in reality or formal research, but it was still widely used for many years.
Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by giantg2 on Sunday September 26, 2021 @11:07AM (#28661437)
Hence my qualifier of if you think psychology is psuedoscience. There is some research on ths subject, but most psychology research uses self reporting or self evaluation. If this is psuedoscience, then we should also be talking about how psychology in general is psuedoscience. Let's not forget, psychologist are used in court and even for things like psychological evaluations for employment. If they really are using psuedoscience, this presents a threat to the rights and freedoms of many individuals.

Another study: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/233241159_Speaking_...

Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by asdfasgasdgasdg on Sunday September 26, 2021 @11:15AM (#28661507)
I think self-reporting can provide some evidence, but of course it's much weaker than many other study methods. But even within survey studies, there are degrees of quality. And studies that sample undergrads in psychology classes (like the one you linked) are of particularly poor quality and generalizability. To me, that only barely counts as research at all.

That doesn't mean psychology in general is pseudoscience. But it does mean this is a bad study that tells us almost nothing, and if this is representative of the quality of studies on the love languages overall, then we basically have no evidence one way or another about them.

Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by giantg2 on Sunday September 26, 2021 @11:23AM (#28661564)
What evidence do you have that the two studies are bad? Just claiming that a study using undergrads is bad sounds like terrible evidence.
Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by asdfasgasdgasdg on Sunday September 26, 2021 @11:30AM (#28661641)
Small, non-representative subsets of the population are inherently bad as study targets from the perspective of epistemological power. Results derived from such sample sets often do not generalize. If you combine this weakness with a weak investigative methods like survey, the problem compounds. My definition of a good study is one that gives us strong evidence about the world, and a bad study is one that doesn't. What else can you call a study like this one but bad?

> What evidence do you have that the two studies are bad?

The study indicts itself (i.e. it describes its methods, and the methods are not ones that lead to strong evidence).

Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by giantg2 on Sunday September 26, 2021 @11:50AM (#28661858)
I asked for evidence and you are essentially saying "cause I say so". Explain why the methods are wrong. Show some evidence.

The study population is only non-representative if applying it to populations that don't match. For example, this study supports the results for university students 18-22. Again, we come back to the point that just because it only applies for a subset does not make it "BS".

So what's wrong with the other study? Or will it be more of the same generalized claims about poor methods without any specific details from the study being given, nor any supporting facts to back up your determination?

Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by asdfasgasdgasdg on Sunday September 26, 2021 @12:09PM (#28662062)
> Explain why the methods are wrong. Show some evidence.

When you sample a non-representative subset, you often get different results from the population at large. For example, you might get a different answer if you ask the Porsche enthusiasts club what the best car is, compared to if you ask random people in the population.

Undergrads are the same way. Asking a group of people, almost half of whom are virgins, questions about romantic relationships . . . well let's just say it might not generalize to the adult population.

This is covered in detail in any intro stats course or textbook. You may also be able to Google something like "unrepresentative subset psychology" to get an explainer. I can't do the issue complete justice in a comment here.

> So what's wrong with the other study?

I'm sorry, I did not sign up for reviewing every study you link me to. I reviewed the one, and explained my perception that it is a good example of the overall quality of the research on this topic. If you want an assessment of the other study, you'll need to look elsewhere.

Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by giantg2 on Sunday September 26, 2021 @12:28PM (#28662211)
The point of this site is to have discussion. If you dont want to discuss things, then maybe you shouldn't be commenting.

It sounds a bit like trolling when you call something BS, then the source you give shows evidence that it does work in some populations. Then there are two other supportive studies. Yet you want to give non-sensical and non-applicable examples of asking Porche owners questions.

Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by tablespoon on Sunday September 26, 2021 @01:20PM (#28662640)
> Hard to tell if a tool is useful if there is not high quality research backing up the claim.

That's obviously not true. Show me the high quality research studies backing up the idea that a hammer is useful for hammering nails or that a flat-head screwdriver is useful as a improvised chisel. The way to tell if a tool is useful is if you use it and it works for your application.

Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by tablespoon on Sunday September 26, 2021 @04:39AM (#28659339)
>> Languages can and have to be learned. This is also true for love language.

> Love languages were invented to sell a book in 1992.

Can you clarify? Are you saying that someone first decided they were going to sell a book in 1992, and "invented" love languages to "fill in the blank" in order to do so? Or are you just talking about the normal situation of someone introducing a new idea of theirs (or in this case, schema) in the form of a book?

I get the impression that you're objecting to the concept as not really a thing because it doesn't have a deep history. However, not all real things have names, or always had names.

Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by MillenialMan on Sunday September 26, 2021 @07:17AM (#28659951)
"The Five Love Languages" is literally trademarked. It's a framework that's designed to sound plausible, like a horoscope. It's not designed to be accurate, it's designed to make you go, "oooooh" and repeat the trademark. "Having relationship issues? Oh, have you heard of the Love Languages®? I read about it the other day..."

If your partner doesn't want to touch you, what's the most likely explanation? That they "don't speak your love language", or that they aren't attracted to you?

Ok, and if you are that partner, but you don't want to lose the relationship, what's an easy response? "I don't want to touch you because I don't find you attractive," or "I'm sorry babe, I do love you, but we just don't speak the same love language"?

The whole thing is very Cosmo. It's designed to sell in the same way as Cosmo.

Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by tablespoon on Sunday September 26, 2021 @01:08PM (#28662534)
> "The Five Love Languages" is literally trademarked.

So?

> It's a framework that's designed to sound plausible, like a horoscope. It's not designed to be accurate, it's designed to make you go, "oooooh" and repeat the trademark. "Having relationship issues? Oh, have you heard of the Love Languages®? I read about it the other day..."

That sounds like you think it was constructed in bad faith. Do you have any evidence for that?

A model that's simplified can still have value even if it doesn't perfectly fit every situation.

> If your partner doesn't want to touch you, what's the most likely explanation? That they "don't speak your love language", or that they aren't attracted to you?

I'm only passingly familiar with the love languages thing, but I think it does have a point, and I've experienced some of the differences in relationships that is schematizes. Reducing it to sexual attraction is kinda missing the point.

Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by MillenialMan on Sunday September 26, 2021 @04:35PM (#28664432)
Plenty of it has a point - so does Cosmo. The problem is that it's a psychological model written primarily to be sold. You're welcome to put your trust in that, but I think that's a mistake, and the way that type of stuff usually hurts people is that the model being peddled cuts off deeper understanding of human relationships.
Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by hallway_monitor on Sunday September 26, 2021 @10:02AM (#28660973)
You're probably right but does that mean it can't also contain some useful truths? Personally, these types of frameworks do help me break out of my own self centered paradigm and appreciate differences in friends, coworkers and partners. For work teams I highly recommend the DISC survey.

I do agree with the part about not touching though. It seems like a lot of problems are invented in marriages because people are unwilling or unable to say or even think the ugly truth that they simply don't want to have sex with their partner anymore.

Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by MillenialMan on Sunday September 26, 2021 @10:37AM (#28661204)
In my opinion the issue with pop-psych marketing constructs is that there are kernels of truth embedded within a misleading superstructure. They tend to leave you worse off because the structure (which is wrong, incomplete, misleading) is bundled with the kernels of truth. They also usually purport to be rosetta stones. There are exactly five love languages, and humans happen to each speak a different variety of them? Hmmmmm.

Another example: what if someone feels "loved" when they're bought gifts, but that's because they're materialistic, a gold digger? Likewise if someone wants to be touched because they're more interested in sex than a relationship, and they derive validation from your sexual interest. "It's just their Love Language" is technically correct, but it's the wrong lens to apply to those situations.

Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by PeterisP on Sunday September 26, 2021 @11:49AM (#28661848)
One thing is that those aspects map to quite real needs, and the book does provide a set of reasonable metaphors to talk about those needs between partners in a way that gets the point across where previous attempts didn't succeed. It's genuinely hard for many people to define and communicate their own feelings and expectations, and even more so for someone else's feelings and expectations, complicated by the natural tendency to presume that other's preferences work similarly to yours, so a framework that helps this communication is really useful in those cases where relationship problems involve a misunderstanding about those expectations; which is not all relationship problems but certainly a meaningful part of them.

In the examples you provide, I would say that it's exactly the right lens to apply to those situations - it's imperative for both parties to understand that those are the factors that matter instead of trying to work out a relationship around them, ignoring those core issues; and this lens allows to understand/specify/communicate it better.

Like, if someone does derive validation from your sexual interest, then that's a quite important thing to understand for the partner (even if for them personally the concept of needing such validation is a bit alien, because their self-worth is filled differently), because that's not going to change easily and is going to be a big factor in making the relationship work. And if someone is materialistic, pretending otherwise won't be helpful and neither will trying to change someone's values, that generally takes huge time and effort and/or crisis events. Of course, obtaining a proper understanding may also mean understanding that the relationship should not continue, but for such relationships that's also a beneficial result.

There may be more effective ways of facilitating this communication and common understanding of the partner's inner needs, e.g. perhaps couple's therapy can do it faster, but that's a quite expensive process and a simplified set of metaphors can be a cheap and useful approach ("A change in perspective is worth 80 IQ points") if there's sufficient material to ensure that both partners, likely coming from very different perspectives given that they have this communications problem, get a common understanding of how they understand them.

Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by MillenialMan on Sunday September 26, 2021 @04:42PM (#28664498)
I don't mean this disrespectfully, but your comment is a perfect example of someone falling into the trap I was describing. If someone's using you, they don't love you. They won't love you. It doesn't matter what their "love language" is - giving them the thing they're looking to extract isn't going to help, it's just going to get you exploited.
Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by hallway_monitor on Sunday September 26, 2021 @05:11PM (#28664705)
That case doesn't apply because it's not love and that partner is not committed to the relationship. In fact I would go so far to say it's pathological.

I think GP would agree that this type of self help book is not a Rosetta Stone and its core truth may be somewhat banal ie think about what makes your partner feel special not only what makes you feel special. Maybe part of the success formula for these pop psyc books is that we need these truths to be wrapped in a story and labeled so we can remember them more easily.

Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by MillenialMan on Monday September 27, 2021 @05:59AM (#28668888)
My point is that he's trying to shoehorn the "Love Languages" framework onto that situation, because the model is designed to encourage you to do that - it's the same thing that makes it sell. You shouldn't dismiss that as a coincidence, it's not as simple as divorcing that from the legitimate insights. The framework is designed to be a brain worm.

Here's a question: you like the framework. Have you ever seen a specific relationship be saved by it?

Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by PeterisP on Monday September 27, 2021 @04:04PM (#28675350)
While it's hard to attribute "saving a relationship" to any one thing, yes, I've seen multiple relationships where this book helped the couple's communication during a crisis in a very long-term relationship; surfacing some things that (with hindsight) could and needed to be communicated and fixed many years ago but which simply were not; because they lacked "skill"(? or had ingrained/cultural barriers?) to meaningfully talk with their partner about the specific issues and unmet needs they had.

However, your objections seem to be about something other than what I'm talking about - what I hear in your responses is something like equivocating "Understand that it's their love language" with "you should accept it unconditionally", especially in the context of abusive relationships, which is definitely not what I'm arguing about. The decision whether a particular relationship is good for both people involved and whether should continue is orthogonal to that aspect, and "love languages" don't/shouldn't affect that decision; But in the context of various one-sided and possibly relationships, however, understanding that (for example) one partner really only cares about sex in this relationship and doesn't care about the other aspects - well, that's useful information to make the decision whether to move on away from the relationship.

I see it's use solely as a means of improving communication, and it's scope limited for couples which have a problem with that communication (which is common) and also a mutual desire to improve it (which is not that common, and already excludes many destined-to-fail relationships), in this regard, it's useful only if applied by the couple, not by one of them. It's definitely not an universal solution - it solves a particular type (though IMHO popular) of miscommunication, and if the couple has fixed those, this book will be useless for any other types of problems in their relationship.

Re:The Problem of Marital Loneliness by bluedino on Sunday September 26, 2021 @08:04AM (#28660197)
Some people need to read a book to realize or justify their incompatibility