News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by BitwiseFool on Thursday September 23, 2021 @04:40PM (#28635040)
I know this is nowadays seen as a naive or counter-productive, but I like Unix Philosophy ideal of do one thing, and do it well. I want a business to focus on their business, not on social change or influencing policy. I'm weary of how all these corporate giants are coming together and trying to influence state laws after they've been passed. For two main reasons, one, I would like these companies to focus on what they actually provide, rather than this modern progressive 'everything is political, all the time' mindset. Two, Apple isn't democratically elected and I don't know if any accountability structures exist for such activism. What gives Apple more of a right to counter what the duly elected representatives of a state government have enacted, than the voters of that state themselves?

For all it's horrible flaws, this was something passed by the Texas government. I can at least understand the structural justification for the law. People voted for a state representative, state senator, and a governor who signed the bill. The authority and responsibility is clear. The feedback mechanism is also clear - vote. And, I do hope a lot of them lose their seats as a result of the backlash. But again, I think the power to address this Texas-Sized problem should primarily be in the hands of Texans, rather than giant multinationals like Apple.

Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by nostrademons on Thursday September 23, 2021 @04:48PM (#28635140)
The thing is that this isn't companies influencing state law. This is companies deciding who and where they do business. In many cases valued employees are going to quit and join a company not in Texas if their employer does not give them the option of transferring to a non-Texas office, so the company has a vested economic interest in retaining them and locating their offices in some place where this will not be an issue.

You have every right to be an asshole, but you don't have a right to make other people put up with it. If you're going to enact something that a large swath of your population finds deeply offensive, don't be surprised if they leave, and don't be surprised if the economic activity they generate leaves with them.

Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by in_cahoots on Thursday September 23, 2021 @05:06PM (#28635385)
Is this actually true though? Nobody currently living in Texas just woke up and realized that they live in a deeply conservative state. Even Austin is much more conservative than Seattle or SF.

I have coworkers living in Texas and while they’re disappointed in the ruling, I haven’t heard of a single person planning on moving because of it. Most people I know moved there because of the land, property taxes, climate, etc. The politics situation is unfortunate to them, but not a defining problem. And considering these same people have the resources to get abortions no matter what (not to mention the fact that most abortions happen in low-income, marginalized communities), I don’t foresee many people leaving because of this.

Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by nostrademons on Thursday September 23, 2021 @05:49PM (#28635994)
My sister's thinking of moving out of the state after living there for 18 years.

The actual nail-in-the-coffin for her is the school board situation, although she's pretty furious about the abortion law, the way they've handled COVID, the power utility situation, etc.

For most of the last couple decades you could be liberal in most of the big cities and basically just go about your business. Texas was pretty big on "live and let live", after all. Apparently it's not like that anymore, and the more conservative factions are very in-your-face about owning the libs now.

Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by quantified on Thursday September 23, 2021 @05:42PM (#28635896)
Apple employees who don’t like Texas law or culture can work for Apple in California, and employees who don’t like California culture or law can work in Texas, yes?

Seems like Apple supports their employees by maintaining offices in different places.

Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by nostrademons on Thursday September 23, 2021 @05:56PM (#28636083)
That's what this memo is clarifying, that Apple will support employees who want to transfer because of state politics or who need to seek an abortion out of state.

It's not a given that you can transfer between offices for personal (or political) reasons; normally there are requirements based on team & organizational needs.

Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by karmajunkie on Thursday September 23, 2021 @05:10PM (#28635458)
Austinite here, currently considering whether, when, and how to move to another state. I’m not alone.
Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by thoughtstheseus on Thursday September 23, 2021 @05:23PM (#28635628)
Stay where you are. Texas is almost purple. One of the knock on impacts of this law is to make you move.
Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by taylodl on Thursday September 23, 2021 @05:34PM (#28635789)
The Texas population is almost purple, but the Texas legislature isn't close to purple. Thanks to the legislature's ability to choose their voters (gerrymandering) that's not a situation that's going to change any time soon. Add in the voter suppression laws they've also recently passed and you can be sure Texas is going to be Red for a good long time.

On another note, I know people who were thinking about moving to Texas. They're not now. On the flip side I know people who moved to Austin in the past two years. They're now looking at leaving. One has already done so. This is where renting and working from home is a blessing - you can quickly change residence.

Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by karmajunkie on Thursday September 23, 2021 @05:58PM (#28636117)
yeah, this is one of our considerations. right now my wife and i are planning on sticking around through the election next year and helping out with some campaigns. if dems in this state can’t pull off some Georgia-style turnout in the next election, we’re almost certainly leaving before the next one.
Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by jleyank on Thursday September 23, 2021 @05:12PM (#28635485)
In the chemical modeling/ML field it's an excellent time to find work in N America and Europe. Yeah, it's harder to move as a pair than solo, but one has to be able to look in the mirror.
Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by VictorPath on Thursday September 23, 2021 @04:52PM (#28635208)
> I want a business to focus on their business, not on social change or influencing policy.

Well you're a little late on that, business has been influencing policy since the East India company was chartered in 1600.

I'm perplexed how people don't perceive business has been influencing policy for centuries until they start intervening recently for employees who are women and what have you.

Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by jakelazaroff on Thursday September 23, 2021 @04:56PM (#28635269)
Okay, but where is this energy when companies donate to politicians? Or spend millions lobbying for specific policies? Or contract with the police or military?

Why does the issue begin and end here for so many people?

Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by tablespoon on Thursday September 23, 2021 @05:36PM (#28635818)
>> Two, Apple isn't democratically elected and I don't know if any accountability structures exist for such activism. What gives Apple more of a right to counter what the duly elected representatives of a state government have enacted, than the voters of that state themselves?

> Okay, but where is this energy when companies donate to politicians? Or spend millions lobbying for specific policies?

What do you mean? Isn't there a huge amount of energy in those areas?

> Or contract with the police or military?

That's not at all like the first two things you listed. Refusing to contract with the police or military (because they're the police or military) is probably a greater interference with democratic government than not siting an office in an area because you don't like the laws the legislature passed.

Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by mattmoose21 on Thursday September 23, 2021 @05:05PM (#28635379)
In a world of ideals, I agree with this. Just like I agree that waiters should earn a living wage and I shouldn't have to tip them. But we don't live in that world. Corporations have a ton of influence on governments and I think that singling out instances where a company is considering doing something that supports women's rights is a bit silly.
Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by gifnamething on Thursday September 23, 2021 @05:36PM (#28635810)
It wasn't an issue when the social change was about slavery, or money laundering, or privacy, or monopoly, or copyright, or tax, or employment, or environment, or immigration, or healthcare, or housing, or zoning, or transport, or energy, or manufacturing, or mining, or fiscal policy, or monetary policy, or elections, or trade, or education, or subsidies?

Sorry, yes, I do think it's naive to think a business - particularly a trillion dollar omninational - can operate in ignorance of the laws and politics that their staff experience. A business is a construct of between some and a lot of individuals, not an entry in the NASDAQ.

>What gives Apple more of a right to counter what the duly elected representatives of a state government have enacted, than the voters of that state themselves?

It's a false premise, since there is no additional right, but the employees are voters.

Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by monkeyfacebag on Thursday September 23, 2021 @05:09PM (#28635448)
Apple is the football here, not the quarterback. If Apple does anything, it will be because they are succumbing to pressure from customers, investors and employees. Corporate activism is not orchestrated by cloaked figures in board rooms; it's orchestrated by regular people who have found a more efficient lever than the legislative process. It's the ultimate expression of capitalism!
Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by torstenvl on Thursday September 23, 2021 @11:10PM (#28638199)
Apple has a market cap of 2.4 trillion dollars. I don't think they're a football.
Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by monkeyfacebag on Thursday September 23, 2021 @11:42PM (#28638394)
Ok, so what's bigger than a football? A basketball? I don't really play sports.
Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by jeromenerf on Thursday September 23, 2021 @04:54PM (#28635234)
> this modern progressive 'everything is political, all the time' mindset

Seeing things as not being political is political unfortunately.

After a war ends, companies can be judged for collaboration with the enemy. Until then, it’s all grey area.

Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by amelius on Thursday September 23, 2021 @05:06PM (#28635388)
> I like Unix Philosophy ideal of do one thing, and do it well

Apple's secret power is that they integrate everything really really well. So your laptop works seamlessly with your phone, your watch, and soon Texas too.

Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by pvg on Thursday September 23, 2021 @05:01PM (#28635317)
I know this is nowadays seen as a naive or counter-productive

Apple and many other US employers extended health and other benefits to LGBTQ partners of employees for a couple of decades before Obergefell. Do you think they shouldn't have?

Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by BitwiseFool on Thursday September 23, 2021 @05:14PM (#28635512)
Truthfully I can't give you a satisfactory answer because I see the situation as just too different. They decided to give additional internal employee benefits and they weren't directly going against any state laws to do this. To me at least, the situation feels different.
Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by pvg on Thursday September 23, 2021 @05:28PM (#28635702)
they weren't directly going against any state laws to do this

They very much were

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lawrence_v._Texas

Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by karmajunkie on Thursday September 23, 2021 @05:13PM (#28635488)
> … rather than this modern progressive 'everything is political, all the time' mindset.

I hate to break it to you, but everything IS political, all the time. If you don’t believe that, it’s likely because nobody’s coming for your rights in particular.

Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by BitwiseFool on Thursday September 23, 2021 @05:33PM (#28635784)
I take offense to this, and the assumption that I hold this view because "because nobody’s coming for your rights in particular." How do you know that? To what "rights" do you refer?

I, like you, am a resident of Texas. I think for Apple to do what the article is suggesting is taking away my right as a Texan to have my representatives craft laws. Politicians need the consent of the governed, and now apparently, the consent of Bay Area corporations who are decidedly progressive.

Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by Hermitian909 on Thursday September 23, 2021 @06:01PM (#28636147)
Politics is fundamentally about how groups make decisions. Anything that influences group decision making has a political aspect to it. The status quo implicitly carries a set of norms that will impact group decision making and are thus political, this is hopefully apparent just looking at the differences between countries and their political norms.

Indeed, it's hard to find anything that does not somehow touch on group decision making because so little is truly private e.g. want to have a loud party in your apartment? Whether societal norms approve or not will determine you can do that or whether you're forbidden to do that or allowed to potentially bother your neighbors; part of the group.

Once properly framed, the idea is practically tautological. But even without that framing it's usually much more obvious for people for whom the status quo is a rough deal.

Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by dctoedt on Thursday September 23, 2021 @05:46PM (#28635957)
> taking away my right as a Texan to have my representatives craft laws

In other words, your right to have your representatives restrict the liberty of the rest of us Texans for no good reason.

Sadly, the motto of the Texas Legislature seems to be "Local control!" when it comes to national policy — at least if the federal government is controlled by Democrats — but just the opposite when it comes to blue cities' enactment of progressive local ordinances that offend rural conservatives and/or their corporate donors.

(Houstonian here, formerly a lifelong, pretty-conservative Republican.)

Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by BitwiseFool on Thursday September 23, 2021 @06:09PM (#28636230)
>"your right to have your representatives"

Yes. That is at the heart of my belief in representative government. And it wasn't my representative alone who voted for this, it was enough of them to get it passed.

I've already stated many times that I think this is an atrocious bill and I hope it gets overturned. But at the very least, it was passed by duly elected representatives and it appears to have withstood the courts (for now).

Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by dctoedt on Thursday September 23, 2021 @06:18PM (#28636314)
OK, I take your point. But actions have consequences; if Apple or whoever wants to take their business elsewhere as a result, then that's their right — right?
Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by somuchsothat on Thursday September 23, 2021 @05:58PM (#28636116)
That's exactly right. That's what 'democracy' means...you vote, and sometimes you lose, but you still have to abide by the will of the voting mass that wins.

There's something very entitled to the idea that "I support democracy as long as it advances my agenda. Otherwise (if I'm economically privileged), I'll move to California >>> Canada >>> Overseas somewhere more aligned with me."

Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by belltaco on Thursday September 23, 2021 @08:07PM (#28637162)
>That's exactly right. That's what 'democracy' means...you vote, and sometimes you lose, but you still have to abide by the will of the voting mass that wins.

Let the large cities in Texas decide if abortion should be allowed within city limits. That's totally possible if the state govt delegates powers to counties/cities. Oh wait, that's small govt but goes against the agenda so it will never happen.

>There's something very entitled to the idea that "I support democracy as long as it advances my agenda. Otherwise (if I'm economically privileged), I'll move to California >>> Canada >>> Overseas somewhere more aligned with me."

Not allowing this sounds like an abusive relationship, like a dictatorship like North Korea where people seeking to leave are killed. Just like the Taliban stopping people in Afghanistan from leaving. The new law also comes from an extremist view of a world religion so the argument has a parallel in that they take a dim view of people trying to leave the extremist religion adherence imposed on others.

Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by dctoedt on Thursday September 23, 2021 @06:05PM (#28636192)
You created your account literally ten minutes ago, champ.

Please re-read what I said: I was calling out the hypocrisy of the Texas GOP: Local control for me but not for thee.

And "democracy" does not mean "democratic authoritarianism." (Or as the sour joke went about hard-line Islamist parties during the Arab Spring: One man, one vote, one time.)

Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by detaro on Thursday September 23, 2021 @06:11PM (#28636241)
In what way are your representatives limited in crafting laws by Apple? Should people and companies be forbidden to leave a state just because doing so could have consequences your representatives don't like?
Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by locopati on Thursday September 23, 2021 @05:49PM (#28635996)
The state legislature can craft all the laws they want and businesses can decide they don't want to associate with those states in order to protect their employees. Actions have consequences.
Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by dmd on Thursday September 23, 2021 @04:49PM (#28635161)
The “vote” system has been broken badly, which is why the “free market” system needs to be used instead until it’s fixed - and to help fix it. And if you don’t like a company acting on some social value, don’t buy their products.
Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by BitwiseFool on Thursday September 23, 2021 @04:58PM (#28635291)
Sadly, I think the "free market" system of voting with your wallet is also broken, if not moreso. Everyone hates Nestle, yet they're doing better than ever.

If I don't like what Amazon is doing, how can I possibly boycott a company that has meshed itself into the backbone of the internet at almost every level? As a Texan, at least I can vote in the next election. I have virtually no power over these big companies.

Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by rsj_hn on Thursday September 23, 2021 @06:57PM (#28636634)
Very few people hate Nestle. I certainly don't. Nestle is the fifth most loved brand in the world (whatever that means): https://www.nestleusa.com/media/news-and-features/nestle-5th...

This idea that you can put yourself into an ideological bubble and just assume that the world outside the bubble is the same as the world inside the bubble is a form of self-deception.

Most people don't hate Amazon, Apple, Facebook, Microsoft, etc. All these companies have huge user/customer bases. Even when the whole Microsoft is Evil thing was going on, most people were sufficiently self-aware to understand that this was a niche view. For some reason, that connection with reality became unhinged and many people really think they are in the majority now, and that's when they experience these types of coginitive shocks such as realizing that most people in Texas are pro-life or that most Brits voted for Brexit. For some, the shock of reality is so devastating that it deeply wounds them and they start massively freaking out when they see a tear in the fabric of their self-constructed reality.

Note that I am not arguing against self-constructed realities. It's necessary, but you have to keep in mind that

1) odds are most people don't share your views

2) odds are that you yourself will change your mind later in life as you become wiser.

3) odds are very good that your grandchildren will repudiate your views.

The number of views that we have that we can think are truly universal and will stand the test of time is very small, and almost all of them already have existed for a very long time.

Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by tablespoon on Thursday September 23, 2021 @05:42PM (#28635894)
>> The “vote” system has been broken badly, which is why the “free market” system needs to be used instead until it’s fixed - and to help fix it. And if you don’t like a company acting on some social value, don’t buy their products.

> Sadly, I think the "free market" system of voting with your wallet is also broken, if not moreso.

It's definitely more broken, at least from a democratic perspective. In the free market, you vote with your dollars and shares, and those with more money have more votes (sometimes many orders of magnitude more). One man one vote it ain't.

Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by dmitriid on Thursday September 23, 2021 @05:04PM (#28635371)
> I want a business to focus on their business, not on social change or influencing policy

What if a law is being drafted that directly affects their business? Should they still be quiet? Or is there a list of issues that can be vocal about, and a a list of issues they should be quiet about?

Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by dayyan on Thursday September 23, 2021 @04:41PM (#28635058)
Agree.
Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by 8note on Thursday September 23, 2021 @04:48PM (#28635136)
Lobbying the government of Texas to get rid of bad policy is part of doing their one thing well, convincing people all over the palace to but iPhones.

Mind you, representatives choose their voters to ensure that they will win elections. The power has been removed from voters hands via gerrymandering

Re:Apple's Texas-Sized Problem by BitwiseFool on Thursday September 23, 2021 @04:55PM (#28635252)
As a point of order I don't think this article is advocating for lobbying as much as it is advocating a boycott slash pseudo-embargo of the State itself. To me, at least, that feels very different.