News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sid Meier and the meaning of ‘Civilization’ by toyg on Thursday September 23, 2021 @02:43AM (#28625890)
I think that's just like the fact that John Lennon did his best work in The Beatles, or that George Lucas's best films are the ones where he was challenged by collaborators. Once art requires a certain amount of diverse techniques in order to be produced, the chances that a single individual will excel in all of them fall dramatically.
Re:Sid Meier and the meaning of ‘Civilization’ by TeMPOraL on Thursday September 23, 2021 @04:17AM (#28626531)
Makes me think about Gene Roddenberry, too. The more I learn about history of Star Trek, the more it seems that Roddenberry was a bit over-the-top with his ideas. If he got his way with everything, the show would be quite cheesy (the way Andromeda is). Star Trek's golden era (TNG/DS9/VOY/ENT) is the result of other producers pushing back on Roddenberry's influence, and after his death, increasingly subverting some of his ideas.

(Of course over time things strayed too far from the original vision, and the result is the post-ENT crapfest that carries the official "Star Trek" name, but is otherwise a generic action movie franchise. A strange situation, in which the only work still sticking to the deep and hopeful vision of the future is the little animated show that everyone thought will be a joke.)

Re:Sid Meier and the meaning of ‘Civilization’ by hef19898 on Thursday September 23, 2021 @06:42AM (#28627446)
Lower Decks is good, it is done by people that really liked the old ST series. Sometimes, I am not sure if it is mocking some of the ST tropes, like the two-hand punch, space anomalies and so on. Still light years better then Discovery (which is totally not cannon in my mind).
Re:Sid Meier and the meaning of ‘Civilization’ by TeMPOraL on Thursday September 23, 2021 @07:06AM (#28627601)
I love Lower Decks. It's definitely mocking and lampshading plenty of Star Trek tropes, but it does that in a playful and positive way. It laughs, but doesn't trivialize - and unlike the other new shows (Discovery, Picard), it doesn't paint the future as grimdark and everyone as untrustworthy and bloodthirsty.
Re:Sid Meier and the meaning of ‘Civilization’ by hef19898 on Thursday September 23, 2021 @08:08AM (#28628026)
Picard wasn't too bad actually, I think. Maybe a tad to gritty / realistic when compared to TNG. It did offer a plausible universe development so, incl. Picard sacrificing his career for principle.
Re:Sid Meier and the meaning of ‘Civilization’ by TeMPOraL on Thursday September 23, 2021 @10:36AM (#28629756)
I feel DS9 pulled off realism better - Picard seems to me to fly past realism and straight into dystopian stereotypes. And there was too much meaningless killing.

I'm also pissed about the Borg subplot - in the trailer and initial episodes, they set up the scene for some amazing drama and deep storytelling, and then they just literally crashed it into a planet and discarded like space trash. It was a huge letdown to me.

Re:Sid Meier and the meaning of ‘Civilization’ by hef19898 on Thursday September 23, 2021 @10:49AM (#28629954)
I honestly believed that the AI-gods were the creators / origin if the Borg. DS9 is quite a high bar to be measured against, so. Just shy of Babylon 5 for that period in my mind.
Re:Sid Meier and the meaning of ‘Civilization’ by TeMPOraL on Thursday September 23, 2021 @10:52AM (#28630014)
Right. B5 is a masterpiece.
Re:Sid Meier and the meaning of ‘Civilization’ by dragonwriter on Thursday September 23, 2021 @12:34PM (#28631500)
> Picard seems to me to fly past realism and straight into dystopian stereotypes

The “dystopian stereotypes” in Picard seem to me to be classic Trek with a very slight change of focus (largely in dwelling in aspects of the setting and social contexts which were indicated in other parts of the franchise but only briefly or tangentially interacted with.)

Kind of like what Lower Decks does, but in a different direction (and played for drama rather than laughs.)

Re:Sid Meier and the meaning of ‘Civilization’ by toyg on Thursday September 23, 2021 @09:11AM (#28628580)
Picard was aimed at people who were teenagers or twentysomethings at the time of TNG, and 30 years later are now disillusioned adults. It had to be "all grown up and shit". I found it pretty good, if occasionally predictable.
Re:Sid Meier and the meaning of ‘Civilization’ by hef19898 on Thursday September 23, 2021 @09:38AM (#28628934)
So I am the target audiance then. Especially since I consideres TNG to be too optimistic already as a teenager.
Re:Sid Meier and the meaning of ‘Civilization’ by TeMPOraL on Thursday September 23, 2021 @10:28AM (#28629643)
I guess I'm not the target audience then - I was a kid when TNG was created, and on the lower end of teenage years when it aired in my country. I bought the optimism wholesale - hook, line and sinker. It had significant influence on my development as a person. As much as I'm disillusioned about the real world, TNG is in my heart a reminder that we could do better. And I feel the first step to do better is for the idea to be out there.

So here's me hoping that in 5-10 years time, I'll fall into their "target audience" window and they'll make an inspiring, positive show for people like me.

Re:Sid Meier and the meaning of ‘Civilization’ by hef19898 on Thursday September 23, 2021 @10:45AM (#28629888)
I am also a Star Wars fan, and Battletech. Star Wars wise, I loved TIE Fighter. So I guess I always had a leaning towards darker, less otimistic SiFi. Still watch TNG, DS9 and ENT so. Even VOY from time to time. Not sure I'll do that with PIC once I've seen the episodes once. Not sure if that is due to the episodic story telling of the former or nostalgia.
Re:Sid Meier and the meaning of ‘Civilization’ by toyg on Thursday September 23, 2021 @09:50AM (#28629110)
And you didn't hate it, so - job done :)
Re:Sid Meier and the meaning of ‘Civilization’ by hef19898 on Thursday September 23, 2021 @09:52AM (#28629147)
Yeah, funny isn't it? Not that I'll complain, so. Give me more content like that!
Re:Sid Meier and the meaning of ‘Civilization’ by saalweachter on Thursday September 23, 2021 @12:05PM (#28631113)
Orville is also in that vein, IMO.

It tries to be a comedy, a parody, but you can also tell it's a love-letter to old-school Star Trek.

Re:Sid Meier and the meaning of ‘Civilization’ by TeMPOraL on Thursday September 23, 2021 @01:18PM (#28632162)
My pet theory is that they went over the top with comedy aspects in S1 only to establish The Orville as a parody, to avoid being accused of IP misuse/plagiarism. S2 toned down the jokes a lot, and it feels more like a lighter TNG, which I believe was the goal all along.
Re:Sid Meier and the meaning of ‘Civilization’ by saalweachter on Thursday September 23, 2021 @01:23PM (#28632251)
Yeah, I got the same impression -- they really wanted to make Star Trek, and were like, "Exactly how much parody do we need to include to make a lawsuit unprofitable?".
Re:Sid Meier and the meaning of ‘Civilization’ by hef19898 on Thursday September 23, 2021 @12:13PM (#28631213)
And better Star Trek then Discovery.
Re:Sid Meier and the meaning of ‘Civilization’ by mandmandam on Thursday September 23, 2021 @12:59PM (#28631895)
I've pulled Ceti eels from my ear that had parasites who wrote better Star Trek than Discovery.
Re:Sid Meier and the meaning of ‘Civilization’ by sprafa on Thursday September 23, 2021 @05:42AM (#28627083)
Basically it seems like having a strong inventor with a good original idea, then mixing it with other peoples influences even AGAISNT that original inventor’s intent, is a good way to get cool stuff.
Re:Sid Meier and the meaning of ‘Civilization’ by nickik on Thursday September 23, 2021 @01:22PM (#28632231)
This discussion is just silly. Claiming anything about art in general is gone be wrong.

Sometimes a singular vision leads to something great. Something it doesn't. Sometimes a single vision contained by bureaucracy leads to something great. Sometimes a vision helped along by others creates great things. Sometimes nobody has any vision and they somehow end up with something amazing. Sometimes you have a bad vision and others turn the core of your idea into something awesome.

There are literally tons of examples for all of these. We have 10k+ years of human history of art.

Re:Sid Meier and the meaning of ‘Civilization’ by dataduck on Thursday September 23, 2021 @02:57AM (#28625989)
I don't even think there needs to be more than one "technique" - think of all the authors that are worse without an editor. It's about not having any pushback, and missing your blind spots or getting high on your own supply.