News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Air Force Has Been Trying to Kill the A-10 Warthog fo... by atonse on Saturday September 18, 2021 @08:32AM (#28575710)
No good replacement. The military bet everything on the F35 which ended up being a pile of rubbish.

The A10 can fly low enough and slow enough to do close air support for ground troop, with that incredibly powerful Gatling gun.

What I’m not sure about is why aren’t they using Apaches, Comanches, Scorpions (all helicopters) etc instead for close air support?

Must be the power of the A10’s Gatling gun.

Re:The Air Force Has Been Trying to Kill the A-10 Warthog fo... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday September 18, 2021 @08:34AM (#28575723)
> A10 can fly low enough and slow enough to do close air support for ground troop

Against a an adversary with no anti-air capabilities. Like the Taliban. Whom we are no longer fighting. For the nation-state level conflicts we're gearing up for, the A-10 is a waddling duck.

> why aren’t they using Apaches, Comanches, Scorpions (all helicopters) etc instead for close air support?

The AH-64 Apache has a top speed of 184 mph [1]; the A-10 439 mph [2]. The A-10 is also more-heavily armored, and can carry more ordinance.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_AH-64_Apache

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fairchild_Republic_A-10_Thunde...

Re:The Air Force Has Been Trying to Kill the A-10 Warthog fo... by masklinn on Saturday September 18, 2021 @08:55AM (#28575850)
> Against a an adversary with no anti-air capabilities. Like the Taliban. Whom we are no longer fighting. For the nation-state level conflicts we're gearing up for, the A-10 is a waddling duck.

The US has been gearing up for nation-state level conflicts and only fighting asymmetric guerrilla ones since 1945. And the AF is the one branch which most refuses to fight the wars the US are actually fighting.

Re:The Air Force Has Been Trying to Kill the A-10 Warthog fo... by twic on Saturday September 18, 2021 @08:42AM (#28575769)
The US may be winding down against the Taliban, but there are plenty more farmers with AKs around the world to fight. The US is not done with that kind of conflict by a very long chalk.
Re:The Air Force Has Been Trying to Kill the A-10 Warthog fo... by ianhawes on Saturday September 18, 2021 @08:50AM (#28575813)
For the most part they _are_ done with that kind of conflict. And in situations where they do need to engage an adversary like that, it is far easier to use drones.

I love the A-10, but it's effectiveness as CAS for adversaries with even low-level AA is decreased to a point that its less effective than the F-35.

Re:The Air Force Has Been Trying to Kill the A-10 Warthog fo... by dragontamer on Saturday September 18, 2021 @01:23PM (#28577786)
Are there any drone platforms that have a gun on them?

Bullets are a lot cheaper than missiles. Predator drones get the job done when you just need a one-and-done missile shot. But a loitering gun in the sky is a fundamentally different weapon.

------

I think the issue is that the primary role of the A10, which was to destroy tanks, has basically disappeared. Tank armor has increased to the point where an A10's gun may not be reliable enough.

The A10 exists as a cheap CAS role that it wasn't ever really designed for. A10 has a loiter time of 90 minutes, while AC-130 has a loiter time of 4.5 hours. The air-force would rather be sending in AC 130.

-------

That being said: if the Army wants the A10, they should get the A10. Air Force's main job is air-superiority, ensuring the skys are clear for other operations.

Re:The Air Force Has Been Trying to Kill the A-10 Warthog fo... by Maursault on Saturday September 18, 2021 @12:47PM (#28577531)
> and can carry more ordinance

I think one of the reasons it is easy to make this mistake is that most seem to mispronounce ordnance in that they add a superfluous syllable. Ordinance has three syllables, while ordnance only has two. Hope that helps.

Re:The Air Force Has Been Trying to Kill the A-10 Warthog fo... by masklinn on Saturday September 18, 2021 @09:10AM (#28575966)
> Must be the power of the A10’s Gatling gun.

It's also the carrying capacity, the speed to get on target, the ability to loiter (and take punishment), and that helos try to kill themselves as part of normal operations. One of the large initial motivations for the V-22 was how helos compromised operation eagle claw (the iran hostage rescue), and that was neither the first nor last high-stake op compromised by helos shitting the bed.

Re:The Air Force Has Been Trying to Kill the A-10 Warthog fo... by chrisseaton on Saturday September 18, 2021 @08:33AM (#28575718)
> > A10 can fly low enough and slow enough...

...to get annihilated by Russian or Chinese air defences.

> What I’m not sure about is why aren’t they using Apaches, Comanches, Scorpions (all helicopters) etc instead for close air support?

I don't think the USAF operate these platforms do they?

Re:The Air Force Has Been Trying to Kill the A-10 Warthog fo... by imglorp on Saturday September 18, 2021 @08:55AM (#28575841)
Vs helos:

A-10 can carry 16,000 lbs of ordinance alone, including that brrrt stuff and 2000 lb bombs.

AH-64 can carry 8,000 lbs, including fuel.

Re:The Air Force Has Been Trying to Kill the A-10 Warthog fo... by ericmay on Saturday September 18, 2021 @09:27AM (#28576101)
Yea but helicopters have their own advantages. So you’re trading some things like payload for maneuverability. Helicopters also don’t need a runway. Etc.
Re:The Air Force Has Been Trying to Kill the A-10 Warthog fo... by masklinn on Saturday September 18, 2021 @08:57AM (#28575861)
> ...to get annihilated by Russian or Chinese air defences.

Which is a big concern when… not fighting either.

Re:The Air Force Has Been Trying to Kill the A-10 Warthog fo... by chrisseaton on Saturday September 18, 2021 @09:00AM (#28575893)
A lot of military planning is increasingly pivoting towards being prepared for peer or peer+ adversaries.
Re:The Air Force Has Been Trying to Kill the A-10 Warthog fo... by masklinn on Saturday September 18, 2021 @09:04AM (#28575922)
It can't pivot towards that since it hasn't done anything else since 1945. The US has spent 75 years preparing to fight peer adversaries while fighting asymmetric guerillas. Especially the AF.
Re:The Air Force Has Been Trying to Kill the A-10 Warthog fo... by chrisseaton on Saturday September 18, 2021 @09:15AM (#28576001)
But still running the A-10 is a good example of where that’s not true.
Re:The Air Force Has Been Trying to Kill the A-10 Warthog fo... by masklinn on Saturday September 18, 2021 @11:19AM (#28576906)
The A-10 was originally designed as a CAS and tank killer for the invasion of western europe by eastern troops and armor. It was never designed to fight against guerillas.

The AF is still running the A-10 because they've not managed to get rid of it yet — not for lack of trying, but because when they try the army suggests taking it off their hands and if there's one thing the AF likes less than CAS, it's the idea of the Army getting fixed-wing units.

Re:The Air Force Has Been Trying to Kill the A-10 Warthog fo... by chrisseaton on Saturday September 18, 2021 @11:20AM (#28576916)
Right but you get why it's not even remotely suitable for that role now? It's no longer a weapon system that's suitable for use against peer/+. It'd have absolutely no chance of getting that close to an advancing Russian force.
Re:The Air Force Has Been Trying to Kill the A-10 Warthog fo... by masklinn on Saturday September 18, 2021 @11:31AM (#28577007)
> Right but you get why it's not even remotely suitable for that role now?

Which does not matter because it's not a role anyone actually needs.

> It's no longer a weapon system that's suitable for use against peer/+.

Which has not actually been needed in 75 years, unlike a weapon system suitable for use in asymmetric conflicts.

Re:The Air Force Has Been Trying to Kill the A-10 Warthog fo... by chrisseaton on Saturday September 18, 2021 @12:55PM (#28577589)
If you're of the opinion there is absolutely no possibility we'd ever have to fight a peer/+ adversary, then your position makes sense.

But nobody serious responsible for managing our defence thinks that. Hence why the capability needs to be upgraded.

Re:The Air Force Has Been Trying to Kill the A-10 Warthog fo... by geoduck14 on Saturday September 18, 2021 @08:56AM (#28575852)
>What I’m not sure about is why aren’t they using Apaches, Comanches, Scorpions (all helicopters) etc instead for close air support?

What about the Warren: https://www.duffelblog.com/p/army-to-name-new-attack-helicop...

Re:The Air Force Has Been Trying to Kill the A-10 Warthog fo... by samcheng on Sunday September 19, 2021 @01:30PM (#28586151)
IMO this kind of race-baiting, divisive satire doesn't belong on HN.