News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by x86_64Ubuntu on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @10:17PM (#28547162)
Doesn't matter though. The web property was taken down, and safer-ish sex work suffered a set back. Sex trafficking is the new "terrorism" whereby the government or other organizations can allege it, and the targeted entity is pretty much SOL.
Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by throwaway91321 on Thursday September 16, 2021 @01:35AM (#28548422)
To add to this, "sex trafficking" to most people means "sex slavery," but if you look at the definition it's a broad term that includes things like helping a prostitute immigrate illegally. And then law enforcement takes things a step further, often referring to any form of prostitution as "sex trafficking" because they know that if they simply call it prostitution, most people won't see the big problem.

It's gotten to the point where I'm skeptical of any news stories I read where authorities are claiming "sex trafficking." It's simply astounding how many of those, if you follow-up on them, end up being simple prostitution cases in the end, with the supposed victims being charged by authorities for engaging in prostitution.

The Robert Kraft case is a good recent example. Authorities made a big announcement of saying Kraft and other men were involved in a sex trafficking ring, and the media uncritically spread their claims. If you look at online comments from the time, most people assume that Kraft and others were taking advantage of unwilling sex slaves. But months later the charges against the men were dropped, and the only people that ended up being punished were the women themselves, for prostitution. Authorities have a habit of making a big deceitful announcement that they're saving these women, then when the public and media attention goes elsewhere, the women are the ones the authorities end up punishing.

Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by nullifidian on Thursday September 16, 2021 @03:14AM (#28548991)
"But anti-prostitution activists like Hughes often use “sexual exploitation” to include any kind of prostitution or sex work—in fact, Hughes insists in her article that "trafficking occurs even if the woman consents.” "

https://newrepublic.com/article/123302/human-trafficking-has...

Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by MomoXenosaga on Thursday September 16, 2021 @05:56AM (#28549799)
The fact is that people are desperate for money. And when you're a 20 year old you have something that you can sell that earns money.

Prostitution is the oldest job in the world as they say. Only a Star Trek post scarcity economic miracle will eradicate it.

Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by CryptoPunk on Thursday September 16, 2021 @06:11AM (#28549875)
Yes, when a desperately poor person accepts a bad job, the problem is not the availability of the bad job. It's them being desperately poor. And eliminating that bad job will likely harm them more than it helps them in their effort to improve their situation.
Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by JackFr on Thursday September 16, 2021 @09:53AM (#28551800)
> And eliminating that bad job will likely harm them more than it helps them in their effort to improve their situation.

That's not always true. Illegal sex work undertaken out of desperation is destructive to the person. It is not the same as an Amazon warehouse job.

Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by gizmo686 on Thursday September 16, 2021 @12:48PM (#28554107)
There's some health and safety risks associated with sex work, but we have a good understanding of how to mitigate them. Shutting down the safer oprions does not do that. Sex work also come with the risk of arrest and a criminal record; which is entirely the fault of current laws and law enforcement.

Amazon warehouse work is highly destructive. In 2019, they had an 8.8% injury rate, with 90% severe enough to interfere with work duties. The working conditions at amazon warehouses have been a national scandal for years.

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/amazon-injury-rate-highest-amon...

Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by CryptoPunk on Thursday September 16, 2021 @11:49AM (#28553336)
If they are willing to do illegal sex work out of desperation, their inability to earn that income could be far more destructive to the individual than the sex work. That's an uncomfortable truth, and avoiding it leads to a host of harmful prohibitions, whether it's on sex work, work for under minimum wage, micro-housing units that are under minimum floor space ordinances, or buildings that are over maximum density caps, etc.
Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by MomoXenosaga on Thursday September 16, 2021 @11:15AM (#28552876)
An Amazon worker earns minimum wage. When you are 50k in debt that's not gonna help much is it?
Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by hn_throwaway_99 on Thursday September 16, 2021 @12:55AM (#28548182)
2 weeks ago, it became a felony in Texas to pay for sex. Unlike most of the other batshit laws passed in Texas this year, this one had wide bipartisan support.

As a gay man, while this is just anecdotal, it seems to me that the dynamics of gay prostitution are very different from most straight prostitution. I used to think it quite sad to hear about gay men paying for sex. I mean, these days, it is extremely easy for gay men to find other gay men to have sex with, for free, as long as you're willing to have sex with guys who generally look like you do.

Then I had some friends who had escorted at some point, and they explained the dynamic. Quite simply, many of the "johns" were older, and they basically wanted a hot, younger guy to have sex with them (of course there were other types, for example closeted men).

None of the guys I knew who escorted ever felt coerced into doing it, beyond the fact that they needed money, and to them it was an easy way to get money.

Of course, I'm sure there are guys who did feel pressured into doing it, and sex trafficking does occur.

But there are still many, perfectly consenting adults who pay for sex as part of "the world's oldest profession". We should stop this moral panic and focus laws to help actual victims of sex trafficking.

Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by voltaireodactyl on Thursday September 16, 2021 @01:15AM (#28548300)
Just for the record, all the specifics you've listed with regard to gay prostitution also apply to heterosexual prostitution, to my best understanding.

That is to say, much of the clientele are older men who just want a hot, younger woman to have sex with them. There are also other types.

Some female escorts do not feel coerced, while another significant percentage certainly do. I would imagine that's the same on both front as well.

While I totally recognize that male prostitutes are perhaps more likely to be able to resist physical aggression, and therefore have a bit more agency (which I think may have been the point you were leading toward), I think the moral panic crosses all borders, and I agree that once (if) we take that out of the equation, the rest of the conversation becomes much easier.

Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by bongoman37 on Thursday September 16, 2021 @01:19AM (#28548326)
Did they also outlaw taking a woman out on an expensive date?
Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by MomoXenosaga on Thursday September 16, 2021 @06:04AM (#28549843)
I imagine you can still give a woman a gift. Or pay the rent for their apartment- this is how French politicians did it for their mistresses.
Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by onion2k on Thursday September 16, 2021 @01:37AM (#28548436)
If you think that's the same as paying for sex then you need to grow up, and have a think about how you regard other people. Believing that you're entitled to sex because you spent money on a date is a super creepy attitude.
Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by rjzzleep on Thursday September 16, 2021 @01:43AM (#28548459)
In a lot of places of the world that's literally how prostitution works. Since you aren't allowed to pay for sex, they have tea and coffee houses where people pay for very expensive drinks and other things.

Then the women "decides" whether they have sex. At least I'm not so clear on how the second part of that secret handshake works. But it's very much a concept of paying a lot for things that are not technically sex because that would be illegal.

A lot of escorts will also take perfume, jewellery or other expensive gifts instead of money.

Just a quick google search yields this:

"It came to my attention on a recent trip to China that teahouses are now becoming the new center for scandal and prostitution. In fact, teahouses have had a mix meaning in China for centuries. Dating back as far as the Tang Dynasty teahouses were places to relax, play games and take in a traditional Chinese opera show. They were also a place where the equivalent of a geisha would cater to men by accompanying them with drinks, laughter and often-touchy behavior. Although this was seen as more of a custom to enhance customer service, it also gave customers negotiating room to ask the women for other services such as sex. Brothels were very common across China during this time and teahouses happened to be an outlet where prostitutes could also be ordered."

http://qifullife.com/tea-house-meanings/

Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by ultrarunner on Thursday September 16, 2021 @02:05AM (#28548589)
I believe they are just referencing a possible way around the law, implying that prohibition doesn’t have a great track record.
Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by JohnWhigham on Thursday September 16, 2021 @11:16AM (#28552889)
You realize there's multiple online "sugar daddy" services that provide just that, right?
Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by bongoman37 on Thursday September 16, 2021 @04:48AM (#28549462)
If you go to places like Thailand, you can buy 'bargirl drinks' or similar. These are expensive drinks that entitle you to a bargirl spending some time with you. There's also a 'bargirl fine' if the bargirl decides to go out with you. These are listed items on the menu. If you think this is a thinly veiled front for prostitution you'd be right.
Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by dkdk8283 on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @10:30PM (#28547236)
I have personal experience with Backpage. They had a team of 70 analysts on staff to review all ads and were the #1 source of trafficking tips.

I believe the bp owner got into a pissing match with the AZ DA and eventually lost. Many people who hide behind the US government are scumbags.

Fuck FOSTA/SESTA too.

Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by seneca on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @10:34PM (#28547264)
Strongly agree with the sentiment of your post. I'm curious how you came about the information that they were the #1 source of trafficking tips. That seems like the government killing a golden goose (not that that is surprising in any way).
Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by jrnichols on Thursday September 16, 2021 @03:40AM (#28549129)
Kamala Harris had a lot to do with it.

https://reason.com/video/2020/08/20/kamala-harris-dishonest-...

"She would go on to spread misinformation about the site and its co-founders, Michael Lacey and James Larkin, and she co-filed criminal charges that were quickly dismissed but succeeded at garnering headlines and photo ops that raised her political profile. In reality, Backpage.com had become a powerful tool for law enforcement to help catch sex traffickers because of the cooperation and commitment of the site's founders to that cause, whom Harris and many other states' attorneys general had painted as villains."

Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by MattGaiser on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @10:56PM (#28547403)
It depends.

If they thought that backpage enabled/induced trafficking, then them being a top source of tips isn’t that valuable.

Would you let a drug dealer run a meth lab if he reported his customers for prosecution?

You can argue with my analogy, and I don’t quite agree with it myself, but I can see the government seeing it that way.

Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by setr on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @11:26PM (#28547613)
Doesn’t the three-letters do that like… all the time? That’s basically the definition of honeypotting

As I recall, the FBI did exactly that fairly recently, when they pwned some credit card trading site and ran it themselves for years.

Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by bigiain on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @11:50PM (#28547761)
They ran a child porn dark web site for two weeks:

"Playpen was a notorious darknet child pornography website that operated from August 2014 to March 2015.[1][2] The website operated through a hidden service through the Tor network which allowed users to use the website anonymously. After running the website for 6 months, the website owner Steven W. Chase was captured by the FBI. After his capture, the FBI continued to run the website for another 13 days as part of Operation Pacifier." -- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Playpen_(website)

Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by stephen_g on Thursday September 16, 2021 @12:36AM (#28548075)
Australian police did the same thing with another captured site, for more than six months if I recall correctly. They actually even posted material to it themselves in status updates impersonating the admins, because the admins who set up the site had established that protocol because they believed police would never do that…
Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by esyir on Thursday September 16, 2021 @01:29AM (#28548388)
Seems reasonable to me. Limited timespan to gather information with potentially large payoff.

I don't agree with "entrapment" arguments and "faciliting spread" here. The site was already up, and the users were going to go there regardless. Running it for a week or two more is at worst marginal harm, considering it was already there for a good 6 months.

Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by efnx on Thursday September 16, 2021 @04:37AM (#28549405)
I don't think entrapment is the problem here - it's that the government is distributing child porn. It's still wrong even if the government is doing it. The ends don't justify the means.
Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by dkdk8283 on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @11:27PM (#28547620)
The real tragedy is it had a massive chilling effect on other sites.

A major escort site (not BP) was ethically ran by a retired sex worker. The site sold out of fear of prosecution and the new owner is a horrible person in my opinion.

Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by lamontcg on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @11:29PM (#28547634)
"the government" isn't a single person with consistent motives.

half the government wants to keep sex work illegal and doesn't really want to stop trafficking that much.

Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by thaumasiotes on Thursday September 16, 2021 @01:13AM (#28548290)
> half the government wants to keep sex work illegal and doesn't really want to stop trafficking that much.

This reads oddly, since in the government context "sex trafficking" is synonymous with "prostitution".

Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by a1369209993 on Thursday September 16, 2021 @05:36AM (#28549687)
They want it illegal but widespread, so they can jail people arbitrarily. (Though I'm not sure that's what the GP meant.)
Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by lamontcg on Thursday September 16, 2021 @12:37PM (#28553945)
Yes, and at least a few of them want it still available for them.
Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by BizarroLand on Thursday September 16, 2021 @04:55PM (#28557463)
I thought the issue with backpage was that they were actively editing / editorializing prostitution ads to increase traffic. Even if they were helping the government they crossed the line from being a neutral carrier to actively aiding prostitution.
Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by jfrunyon on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @11:35PM (#28547667)
A better analogy would be overlooking the weed in your CI's yard because he turns in meth cookers.

The only reason for the government to see it that way is because someone powerful wanted them to.

Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by dkdk8283 on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @11:13PM (#28547527)
I didn’t work for BP but I worked in the industry for over 10 years.
Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by bongoman37 on Thursday September 16, 2021 @01:17AM (#28548312)
Also, once you drive the good people out of business, not only whatever is left over much worse, but it attracts the people who are outright sociopaths and want to push the boundaries just because they like to see people burn. Since the demand doesn't go away, it just goes underground. If tomorrow all legitimate painkillers were outlawed, drug trafficking would become a much worse problem with a lot more deaths.
Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by WoahNoun on Thursday September 16, 2021 @12:12AM (#28547911)
Why do you think it is they were the number one source of tips?
Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by ryanlol on Thursday September 16, 2021 @12:50AM (#28548163)
Basically only sex trade related platforms can be big sources of such tips, Backpage was the biggest sex trade platform.
Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by rhizome on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @10:22PM (#28547195)
It's definitely "other organizations" that are the engine of this stuff.
Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by commoner on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @10:30PM (#28547230)
One of those "other organizations" is the NCMEC, which was established by[1] and heavily funded by[2] the U.S. Congress.

NCMEC has consistently tried to impede the implementation of end-to-end encryption. Even before the Apple/iCloud debacle, the NCMEC pushed tech companies to prohibit users under 18 from using end-to-end encryption:[3]

> On February 20, 2020, NCMEC released an open letter to the technology industry outlining five Principles to Safeguard Children in End-to-End Encrypted Environments.

> - Do not implement end-to-end encrypted communications for accounts where a user has indicated they are under 18 years old.

Restricting children from secure communications is an especially user-hostile way to advocate against child abuse.

[1] https://web.archive.org/web/20121029010231/http://www.missin...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Missing_Children%27s_Assistanc...

[3] https://www.missingkids.org/e2ee

Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by ethanbond on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @10:54PM (#28547393)
Given that children have attenuated rights in basically every society, restricting access to E2EE seems like an imperfect but deeply net positive way to reduce child harm. What “savory” actions for which a minor would use E2EE are you concerned are jeopardized by such a proposal?

(Particularly interested in what actions or content is jeopardized, not the ideal of privacy, which I agree is important even for minors)

Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by commoner on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @11:10PM (#28547506)
Preventing children from using E2EE is not a "net positive" just as preventing adults from using E2EE is also not a "net positive". Privacy is a human right, not a right that should be made exclusive to adults. Just because children are restricted from other activities does not make it justified to restrict their rights further.

End-to-end encryption helps prevent messages from being intercepted by intermediaries, such as companies and governments. For example, an advocate (for human rights, environment, or any other cause) who is under 18 may wish to coordinate a protest or some other activity while minimizing exposure to surveillance from potential adversaries. Or in a more ordinary example, children may want to communicate with others without being profiled by advertisers or government agencies through the content of their messages. Secure communications are as valuable to children as they are to adults.

Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by ethanbond on Thursday September 16, 2021 @07:20AM (#28550312)
So your answers are children organizing protests and children not being targeted by advertisers. Personally unconvinced by these since neither is actually guaranteed by E2EE nor is E2EE required for either. A functioning society can (and should) protect both of those things, and a non-functioning one doesn’t need to ban E2EE to attack them.

I appreciate the response in any case.

Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by commoner on Thursday September 16, 2021 @10:29AM (#28552285)
I'll try to express my point from a different angle. If E2EE were unavailable for adults, it would probably be easier for law enforcement to investigate sexual abuse cases in which adults are the victims. But, it would also prevent adults from enjoying the security and privacy benefits of E2EE and the protection E2EE affords against having their messages intercepted (which is something advertisers, hostile governments, and other adverse intermediaries regularly do). Many adults would not trade away the ability to use E2EE in exchange for a more empowered law enforcement.

Child sex abuse may be a more severe crime than adult sex abuse, but aside from how certain crimes are sentenced, E2EE benefits children just as much as it benefits adults. Before arguing that E2EE should be unavailable for children, I would consider whether the argument holds up if E2EE were revoked for adults as well.

Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by pyuser583 on Thursday September 16, 2021 @12:05AM (#28547868)
I review my daughters devices regularly. She has encounters extremely predatory content - basically groomers reaching out to see who will bite.

As a parent, I have a right to review my childs communications.

If she had been using end to end crypto, it’s likely these communications would have auto deleted.

That’s the thing about end to end: it isn’t just about a stopping surveillance in real time. It auto destructs the message.

That’s makes parental oversight extremely difficult.

Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by commoner on Thursday September 16, 2021 @12:48AM (#28548144)
Prohibiting minors from using end-to-end encryption would not prevent them from using self-destructing messages, since they are completely different features. There are messaging solutions with end-to-end encryption that do not have self-destructing messages (e.g. E2EE email, Apple iMessages) and vice versa (e.g. Snapchat).

As a parent, you have the option to use parental controls to block apps with the self-destructing messages feature. However, other parents may have different parenting situations and styles that do not need this feature to be restricted from their children. Pushing for a feature to be unavailable for all children would infringe on other children's rights and their parents' rights.

Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by bildung on Thursday September 16, 2021 @03:37AM (#28549112)
> If she had been using end to end crypto, it’s likely these communications would have auto deleted.

> That’s the thing about end to end: it isn’t just about a stopping surveillance in real time. It auto destructs the message.

Those two things have nothing to do with each other. Encryption neither enables nor prevents auto deletion of content.

Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by okamiueru on Thursday September 16, 2021 @12:30AM (#28548031)
Are you reviewing the messages on their devices, or package sniffing at the gateway? I don't see how E2EE has any effect on whether a device/application retains communications or not.

A separate argument is that kids experiment and do dumb stuff together with other kids. Forcing them to not be able to do so in private without bad actors collecting images seems like a pretty significant sacrifice in human rights. I get the intention, I just think it is very misguided.

Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by pyuser583 on Thursday September 16, 2021 @02:15AM (#28548654)
Lol … a little of both. As I said my daughter came into heavy contact with pedo/grooming material. Nasty stuff.

I’m reviewing her devices manually and monitoring her connections via router logs.

The two work in tandem. When I see an issue with one I check the other.

Once she shows better judgement, I’ll back off and give her more privacy. She’s very young now, and does need the supervision.

Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by pseudalopex on Thursday September 16, 2021 @12:24AM (#28547999)
The only connection between disappearing messages and end to end encryption is they're both privacy features.
Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by withinboredom on Thursday September 16, 2021 @02:22AM (#28548685)
Do wire-tapping laws not apply to children? That’s what you just admitted to.
Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by ryukafalz on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @11:18PM (#28547561)
Having a sexual orientation or gender identity that their parents don't approve of and that they haven't revealed?
Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by ethanbond on Thursday September 16, 2021 @07:13AM (#28550273)
in what world does lack of E2EE mean “parents can read messages?”

They’d still have to hack the services or obtain a warrant, neither of which a parent can do.

Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by ipaddr on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @11:34PM (#28547660)
Wouldn't the concern be that a bad actor could be stalking and listening in on conversations? End to end would remove that man in the middle.
Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by ALittleLight on Thursday September 16, 2021 @01:13AM (#28548291)
Depends on your threat model. Are you more worried about a hacker breaking Instagram chat and reading messages to and from your child or some bad actor grooming them?
Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by ethanbond on Thursday September 16, 2021 @07:09AM (#28550240)
Yeah, this is exactly what I’m getting at. Kids aren’t getting victimized by zero days against online services. They’re getting victimized by predators having private conversations with them.
Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by jfrunyon on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @11:39PM (#28547684)
> Given that children have attenuated rights in basically every society

Just because something is true does not mean that it should be true.

> What “savory” actions for which a minor would use E2EE are you concerned are jeopardized by such a proposal?

Why does it matter whether their actions are savory or not? There are many things that reality tells us children are going to do, whether it's "savory" or not. And a lot of those things probably shouldn't be exposed to interception.

Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by burnished on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @11:48PM (#28547745)
Children aren't responsible enough to.. well.. take responsibility for their actions. That is what you are arguing against.
Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by jfrunyon on Friday September 17, 2021 @08:29AM (#28564661)
Huh?

First off, who are you to tell me what I'm arguing for or against?

Second, "children" covers an EXTREMELY wide range of maturities. Some children are absolutely responsible enough to take responsibility for their actions.

Third, what on earth does that have to do with allowing anyone who feels like it to intercept their conversations?

Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by ummwhat on Thursday September 16, 2021 @12:18AM (#28547954)
When it's inconvenient, "children aren't capable of adult responsibility". When it's inconvenient in the other direction, "this court has decided to have you tried as an adult."
Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by burnished on Thursday September 16, 2021 @01:43PM (#28554740)
Its not clear what your statement is supposed to mean. Are you asking me to take personal responsibility for times where minors are tried as adults and we'd both see it as an injustice? Cause, I got beef with the judiciary, but I don't see how thats germane to the topic right here.
Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by pseudalopex on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @11:25PM (#28547609)
What harm do you think would be reduced? Just what surveillance do you suggest?

How would it be enforced? Could minors just lie about their age? Or would you eliminate anonymity for adults?

Re:Backpage founders get mistrial because US overplayed chil... by trhway on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @11:25PM (#28547612)
when it comes to minors there is a good principle that whatever happened shouldn't cast shadow on adult life, like for example criminal record gets sealed/etc. Absence of E2E makes for higher chances that your communications are going to be out there for the rest of your life, so whatever stupid thing you said at 16 may be a part of your unofficial background check at 30 or even 40 ...