News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by NKosmatos on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @07:52AM (#28537904)
Very typical of Apple, using opaque approval procedures. They're acting like bullies because they didn't get what they wanted and because they have the money/power to do so. Apple wanted to buy FlickType but they didn't agree on the price or Eleftheriou didn't want to sell (I doubt it), and so from then onwards started the downhill ride. I fully support Eleftheriou on this just for the principle, but if I were in his place I would have agreed at a very large sum from Apple (even lower from what I had in mind) just so that we could all be happy right now ;-)
Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by windexh8er on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @08:51AM (#28538450)
> I fully support Eleftheriou on this just for the principle, but if I were in his place I would have agreed at a very large sum from Apple (even lower from what I had in mind) just so that we could all be happy right now ;-)

Seems like Apple has a very anti-competitive position, no?

To me this goes all the way back to the walled garden argument. Apple sat on, what some may consider, a straw man arguing that they couldn't deliver security to their customers without it. Fast forward all these years and Apple's walled garden seems to be failing rather regularly for the trifecta of their: users, developers and the system in general. Users get less choice in the app store when Apple wants to compete directly, developers with good ideas who aren't willing to sell out to Apple will pay the price of their livelihood drying up over night if you don't give Apple what they want and finally we get things like no-click zero days on a routine basis these days.

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by Terretta on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @09:30AM (#28538809)
> walled garden argument

A watch is now a walled garden? Does Casio have to open its OS?

Either these are not general computing devices or there's no line, a fridge or microwave or a console are general computing as well -- and device makers have no rights to make a product from digital parts as well as mechanical parts without having to make it open to digital fiddling, and secure it dragging in that new threat model.

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by jacquesm on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @09:32AM (#28538826)
If you gatekeep applications on your device then it's a walled garden. Simple, no?
Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by Terretta on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @09:52AM (#28539035)
No.

Half Life was not a walled garden before opening up to modders, and was not a walled garden after. It was just a game opened to modders.

If we get over ourselves, and allow that there's new category of thing, devices made of mechanical and digital parts both, that the maker may or may not selectively open for mods as a legitimate part of their business model they're within their rights to choose, then we'd be less religiously militant in ways that harm innovation and consumers.

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by jacquesm on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @09:56AM (#28539075)
Half Life is not a device, modders are not application programmers targeting that device.
Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by Terretta on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @10:34AM (#28539592)
> [Software] is not a device.

Then what are you engineering?

---

Edit to elaborate:

I'm convinced this is the essence of the debate that has intensified as parts that move at the speed of light are devouring physical parts.

Switch, transistor, if statement -- a maker should be able to convert one type of part to another type of part without losing their rights, or accidentally triggering a "oh, look, general computing, therefore it's no longer up to you to decide!" flag of some sort.

Ease of reconfiguring electrons shouldn't change right to design and distribute a product with whatever blend of physical and digital one wants, facilitating whatever purpose one wants, and not being forced to facilitate other purposes.

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by jacquesm on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @11:24AM (#28540317)
Sorry, but you really can't just define some arbitrary alternative universe and then expect the debate to take place on your terms.
Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by Terretta on Saturday September 18, 2021 @01:30PM (#28577822)
I think your universe is the alternate, clinging to the antiquated notion a device can’t be digital or a blend of mechanical and digital widgetry.

That’s so last century. :-)

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by OneTimePetes on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @10:06AM (#28539205)
No, a device is more stable when it comes to APIs and Configurations.
Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by Razengan on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @09:39AM (#28538889)
So why has there never been a horde of torches and pitchforks outside Castle Xbox, PlayStation and Nintendo yet?

And don’t squeeze out that “cOnSoLeS aReNt cOmPuTeRs” bullshit. They’re closer to computers than a goddamn wristwatch.

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by sircastor on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @09:51AM (#28539019)
Arguably, there has been. It’s harder to see because the interface is different in those cases. It’s not as public. Developers have been trying to get around game console lock out for as long as it’s existed. Nintendo’s licensing was very restricted with the NES, and it really annoyed a lot of software developers.

Same case with XBox and PS. You can’t willy nilly write a game for either platform.

For some reason the unlicensed cartridge that always comes to mind for me is the powder blue Bible stories game.

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by salamandersauce on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @11:12AM (#28540153)
I feel like it was far more fair pre-OTA updates. EA for example famously strong armed Sega when they reverse engineered the Genesis allowing them the right to make their own cartridges (which is why EA games look different) and better terms than what they otherwise would have gotten.

These days if a company tried that Sony/Nintendo/Microsoft would just laugh and issue a firmware update "improving system stability" three weeks later bricking any unlicensed games in the process.

There was even a handful of unlicensed titles for PS2/GC.

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by jacquesm on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @11:26AM (#28540336)
And this is now also brought to vehicles, TVs and many other devices, more often than not to fix broken business models or extract more revenue or spy on users instead of to fix bugs.
Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by windexh8er on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @09:45AM (#28538950)
It's a good point, but consoles were single purpose computers. They exist to play games. Now, I'll agree that the line is blurred these days, but they're still generally gaming machines. Nobody is buying an XBox to stream Netflix solely.

I think the difference is that Apple wants people to buy these devices as your primary computing device. Are you OK when Apple locks down the Mac line? What if you couldn't use Brew to install open source software? For a not insignificant portion of their buyers that may be OK.

I agree that consoles have their own anti-competitive issues, but they're not the same. Copy-cat games have always existed. The difference is that Sony's not going to pull a Rockstar game exclusively built for their platform to directly compete. So while I'm trying to see the parallel, it's not quite the same in my opinion.

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by nextaccountic on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @01:13PM (#28541730)
> Nobody is buying an XBox to stream Netflix solely.

What if I want to? I don't particularly care what the manufacturer thinks, I bought the machine. Why does Microsoft gets a pass to dictate what I can do with the hardware I bought?

See for example people that bought PS3s for operating distributed clusters (because at the time the console WAS open) and then Sony locked down other OSes with an update. Why is this fair?

https://www.itwriting.com/blog/2394-sony-locks-down-the-ps3-...

> I think the difference is that Apple wants people to buy these devices as your primary computing device.

How can a wristwatch be a primary computing device?

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by windexh8er on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @09:02AM (#28682250)
> How can a wristwatch be a primary computing device?

Oh it's not. But you don't have a choice. Last I checked Apple Watch required being locked into the walled garden [0] via ownership of an iPhone. Apple Watch is a feature, not a standalone product as it stands today.

[0] https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT204505

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by jacquesm on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @10:03AM (#28539156)
It's not so much about copycat games per-se but about the ability to run whatever software you want on a device that you own, and in that respect those games consoles are quite good representations of the walled garden concept.

In fact, the 'general purpose computer' will historically be seen as some kind of very stupid aberration, who ever thought that giving end users that kind of power was a good idea? /s

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by Terretta on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @10:33AM (#28539571)
Software is not different from hardware. Digital parts aren't magic, bring no magic rights, it's still just boring old parts someone invested in engineering into a product.

Even in digital, beige box server, IaaS, PaaS, SaaS, FaaS, applications, devices, apps, screens... different waterlines, none of them magic. Which waterline do you have the right to "run whatever you want"? Which waterline is a business ok to say, from here down, it's my product?

Anti-circumvention laws saying DRM means hands off altogether are different from saying a maker must take extra steps to make it easier for you to mod the device they invested R&D in, must allow your mod at potential harm to other mods on the device, or a maker must change their business model to facilitate malware and benevolent app devs alike.

There's a market segment for beige boxes and Raspberry PIs. Not every device with digital parts supporting digital mods, plug-ins, add-ons, cartridges, apps, whatever you call them, has to be forced to be a Raspberry Pi.

You have a right to remove the warning label from your mattress, or root your phone, but Sealy doesn't have to perforate the tag and Samsung doesn't have to give you a toggle.

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by jacquesm on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @10:40AM (#28539707)
> Software is not different from hardware.

I'm sorry but this is where I'm going to have to bow out of the conversation.

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by EMIRELADERO on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @12:24PM (#28541103)
I don't see this as a "features" problem. I think the correct way to approach this is in terms of "control". By designing their devices that way (non-unlockable bootloaders, signature verification on every app or executable with hardcoded public keys etc) companies have essentially introduced a new paradigm in which the legal owner of the device has less control over it than its manufacturer. That is the issue here.
Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by jrockway on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @12:56PM (#28541509)
Yeah. What people are complaining about is cryptography to prevent them from using their thing as they wish. Nobody is demanding API documentation from Sony, people are happy to reverse engineer that. But it doesn't matter because you can't give the machine valid code and have it execute, for no good reason other than that you don't know a magic number.

The problem is that building platforms is expensive and if people can use your thing for whatever they want, that thing that they want is often not giving you money. My conclusion is that there shouldn't even be game consoles. They're just a tax on everyone that wants to play games.

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by sircastor on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @10:05AM (#28539179)
> Are you OK when Apple locks down the Mac line? What if you couldn't use Brew to install open source software?

I’ve wondered about this for a while. After about 2015 when the MBP was steadily losing features and gaining problems I was certain that my next machine couldn’t be a Mac. I was certain that the Mac would be rapidly becoming a glorified iPhone.

The trick is, I don’t know where to draw that line. One thought about jumping ship to Linux full time, but I haven’t been able to trust the setup. I’ve heard Windows with WLS is good, but haven’t tried it.

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by jacquesm on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @10:08AM (#28539215)
I've been using Linux as my daily driver since 2004 or so and I haven't looked back. And the only reason I used windows as long as I did was because I had a business that depended on our ability develop a particular windows binary as well as some bookkeeping software. But bookkeeping can be outsourced and that windows application is long gone.
Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by pwinnski on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @09:53AM (#28539043)
You're talking about Macs. This thread is about watches.

I'm struggling to see any argument about watches that doesn't apply at least as much to game consoles.

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by Terretta on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @10:06AM (#28539200)
"these devices" was a watch
Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by CRConrad on Friday September 17, 2021 @01:55AM (#28561769)
> "these devices" was a watch

If you don't allow any third-party developers to make apps for your device, you have a closed garden and no anti-competitive conflict. If you allow all third-party developers to make apps for your device, you have an open garden and no anti-competitive conflict. If you allow some third-party developers, but not some others, to make apps for your device, you have a walled garden and a potential anti-competitive conflict.

As long as some developers are allowed to make apps for this device -- be it a watch, a safety needle, or a 60,000 sq ft rack-server center -- barring others is anti-competitive. And barring them just to launch a clone of their product yourself is an anti-competitive super dick move.

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by dding on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @01:40PM (#28542068)
It's not about if devices are general computing devices or if the device maker can moderate third-party apps on its platform. Apple invited other developers to sell apps on a market it created and regulates. It also competes with those developers in this market. And in this case, it used its power as the market's regulator to remove a competitor and promote its own app.

Nintendo, Sony, etc also allow other developers to sell apps on markets they created, and they also compete with those developers. If Nintendo ever removes a platforming game for competing with the Mario series, we should also raise our pitchforks and protest against unfair abuse of power.

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by JohnTHaller on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @09:44AM (#28538941)
I'd wager a lot of it has to do with history. Gaming consoles were always proprietary hardware that could only do things approved by the manufacturer, and were purchased with that understanding, unless you did some hacking. Computers were always open platforms that you purchased and then could do what you wanted with, no hacking required. iOS was the first major market computing platform that broke this general understanding.
Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by rasz on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @09:36PM (#28546886)
Consoles were pretty open at the beginning. 2600 had plenty of third party games https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Activision#Early_years_(1980%E... and even crazy futuristic peripherals like modem (online game renting service) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GameLine. Same for Genesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sega_v._Accolade. Atari f** up on NES by committing blatant copyright infringement and scamming Patent Office <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atari_Games_Corp._v._Nintendo_...> if not for the method they used it would of been fine too.
Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by sircastor on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @10:14AM (#28539290)
> iOS was the first major market computing platform that broke this general understanding.

I think the reason this worked, and the reason it’s still sort of confusing to people, is that the iPhone is a phone, and showed up at phone stores. People viewed as a super-powered iPod, not a computer.

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by JohnTHaller on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @01:34PM (#28541994)
The phone computers that came before it didn't have walled gardens either. Palm, for instance.
Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by fsociety on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @10:16AM (#28539309)
Huh? Most console games today aren’t exclusives, developers have the freedom to release them on any platform they want with little restriction, and there is no risk in a console maker refusing to let you sell a game and then they go back and make the game themselves.

Consoles are very different from Apple’s walled garden.

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by HelixEndeavor on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @11:27AM (#28540343)
1. Consoles are just as much computers as smart watches.

2. There isn't a horde of pitchforks because instead people's efforts with those consoles are focused towards jailbreaking them to run their arbitrary code instead of begging the company to do it - and Microsoft's Developer Mode on Xbox allows running of arbitrary code anyways, so the problems is basically solved there.

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by jacquesm on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @09:42AM (#28538921)
I honestly could not tell you, but that's a 'whataboutism' argument, we are not talking about Xbox, PlayStation or Nintendo here. But to the extent that they determine what can and can not be shipped on their platform they are - to me - just as much a walled garden.
Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by shawnz on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @10:56AM (#28539951)
Why was AT&T forced to allow third party landline telephones on their network? Those aren't general purpose computing devices either, right?
Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by kurikuri on Thursday September 16, 2021 @03:21AM (#28549030)
The line might be able to be drawn between devices which have support, or intend to have support and will accept applications/plans, for 3rd party software and those who don’t. By accepting third party software, the third party now becomes dependent upon (and in this case: a customer to) Apple. In these situations, the device producer has knowledge about and leverage over on-device application competitors which other third parties would not.
Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by atatatat on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @09:41AM (#28538910)
I'd agree with you 100% conceptually, if not for the fact I've been personally left to improve the security on every phone and computer I've been offered by the market since my birth.
Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by defaultname on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @09:52AM (#28539029)
The original issues with the app weren't opaque at all: Keyboard utilities can't have network access. Then he noted that it can operate without it, but the entitlement can't even exist for any users, even optionally. That is very clearcut.

At least without the App Store reviewers crawling all over everything you do, putting an enormous level of scrutiny over everything you do. And the functionality has to justify it (not that it should operate without it, but with it has to validate why -- is it using some massive cloud resource to guess your next word, etc?)

That he ever got away with it was during confusion over keyboards on the watch where they weren't officially sanctioned and thus policed.

But otherwise he's engaged in building features for someone else's platform. Eventually those features get first party inclusion. This is the surest thing in this industry, and people comparing it to sherlock, etc -- ridiculous. Apple made a larger Apple watch so they decided it's time for a keyboard. That this guy is trying to claim some sort of moral/intellectual ownership over keyboards and/or swype typing is ridiculous, and it's the sort of overreach that is usually criticized viciously on HN.

And if Apple truly made an offer to "buy" his keyboard, it was certainly just to settle bad blood. The likely outcome would have been that they toss his solution and then do exactly what they did, which is build their own.

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by danShumway on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @10:59AM (#28539991)
> The original issues with the app weren't opaque at all: Keyboard utilities can't have network access. Then he noted that it can operate without it, but the entitlement can't even exist for any users, even optionally. That is very clearcut.

Completely wrong. I assume you saw some source online saying that network access was banned across the board for keyboard apps, maybe someone looked at the default restrictions and extrapolated from there. Easy mistake to make. Anyway, see below:

----

> To be clear, Apple’s own developer guidelines specify that “full access” isn’t a problem: the only dispute here is whether the app continues to work if a user turns it off — which it does, says Eleftheriou, if you turn VoiceOver on. “They’d have to try it as a VoiceOver user, something that they don’t seem to bother doing. I’ve had several rejections in the past because the reviewer didn’t know anything about VoiceOver,” Eleftheriou says.[0]

And from Apple's (as far as I can tell, still current) developer documentation:

> By default, a keyboard has no network access and cannot share a container with its containing app. To enable these things, set the value of the RequestsOpenAccess Boolean key in the Info.plist file to YES. Doing this expands the keyboard’s sandbox, as described in Designing for User Trust.[1]

Which then goes on to extensively document how network access can be added to a keyboard utility. Pretty far away from a utility-wide ban.

[0]: https://www.theverge.com/2021/8/16/22627515/flicktype-ios-ke...

[1]: https://developer.apple.com/library/archive/documentation/Ge...

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by jjcon on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @12:47PM (#28541397)
> Keyboard utilities can't have network access

This is 100% false. Both the apple keyboard and gboard from google require network access for gif, search support etc

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by sva_ on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @08:51AM (#28538444)
> just so that we could all be happy right now

To be honest, I'm quite happy about big companies revealing their ugly real face. And some people might benefit from such a reality-check.

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by yummypaint on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @09:18AM (#28538702)
I wish the plaintiffs luck in court. I remember apples courtroom privateering where they persuaded the justice system they invented rounded corners and got their competitors phones pulled from the market. If only the same standards and rigor of enforcement could actually apply to them.

Once all is said and done I suspect whatever apple has to pay will not meaningfully impact their profitability, and will be seen as a cost of doing business. This is a core reason these companies are so caustic. Penalties need to be harsh enough to make this behavior unprofitable. The board needs to be pissed at their executives.

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by rjzzleep on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @09:43AM (#28538932)
For reference[1].

Apple also managed to cause lasting damage to HTC as a brand when they ventured into the US. I don't HTC ever recovered from that, although it might not have been the only problem they had.

[1] https://morningconsult.com/opinions/apple-v-samsung-scotus-s...

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by lotsofpulp on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @09:59AM (#28539099)
Seems like small pickles compared to Android brands damaging themselves by not supporting their own devices with software updates after 18 months.

That is what drove me away. I assume this is still true, and my iOS devices will receive software updates for longer than Android devices.

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by Sunspark on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @10:37AM (#28539639)
I would rather use an unsupported device that has the ability to do a variety of things than a supported device that doesn't allow various features which is the case with iOS for me. With Apple, it's their way or the highway.
Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by lotsofpulp on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @10:57AM (#28539964)
I understand, but in terms of mass market appeal, most people just want to be able to safely take pics and share them and participate in group chats and browse the web and play some games.

Granted, most people would not be able to discern security updates and software updates or maybe even care about them nowadays, but back when the ecosystems and reputations were being established in early 2010s, Android vendors really dropped the ball. Everyone could see their relatives continuing to use iPhone 4 and iPhone 5 a couple more years and getting visibly updated for a couple more years than competing Androids (even from Google themselves!).

The resell value of iPhones was more as well, and I assume many or most people figured out that the probability of iOS devices outlasting competing Android devices was high.

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by Damogran6 on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @10:52AM (#28539895)
So do the hackers and Zero Day Exploit day traders.
Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by nisegami on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @11:30AM (#28540389)
This is so pointless, but I feel like 0-day exploit sellers benefit if everyone is up to date, as it means you need a 0-day to exploit those devices (making those exploits more valuable). But if everyone is running out of date software, who cares if it's a 0-day?
Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by lenkite on Thursday September 16, 2021 @05:29PM (#28557909)
Zero-day's are more expensive for Android nowadays https://www.wired.com/story/android-zero-day-more-than-ios-z...
Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by atatatat on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @09:42AM (#28538928)
Larger discussion:

Is this what being a hacker is now?

Knowing your project is going to get stomped out with uncompetitive practices from day 1,

still doing and carrying it all the the way through to court with a big player?

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by smoldesu on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @09:51AM (#28539020)
25 years ago, that was still the hacker ethos. Linux stood no chance against the commercial operating systems of the day, and Microsoft was in the process of accretion to a similar position Apple is in today. Yet, against all odds, David sprouted wings and Goliath kneeled.
Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by andrekandre on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @11:18AM (#28540240)
how much of this was initially enabled by the anti-trust settlement and subsequent restrictions on microsofts behavior?
Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by FireBeyond on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @12:42PM (#28541343)
The sad thing is that I've seen numerous comments here saying (of this and other situations), "Well, Apple offered him/them some money for it. They should have just taken the money", and that, to them, completely justifies it.

"A gift he couldn't refuse", indeed.

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by NKosmatos on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @03:39PM (#28543434)
When you're facing big tech giants it's very difficult to judge the best course of actions. They have the advantage, money, influence and usually the advantage in similar situations. I'm not saying the sell out (especially at a ridiculous price) is ok and should always be accepted, but most of the times it's the wiser thing to do. Anyhow, isn't this one of the purposes of most app developers/startups, to have a software/service that one of the big companies out there will want to acquire and give you cash and time to work on your "brain child" the way you want it?
Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by woko on Thursday September 16, 2021 @05:02AM (#28549532)
It depends on the offer. Remember that recent piece of news?

> Newly-released emails reveal how Google hoped to pay $50 million for YouTube in 2006, and why it ended up paying $1.65 billion

> https://www.businessinsider.com/email-reveal-google-hoped-bu...

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by piokoch on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @11:43AM (#28540537)
That's not only Apple, other companies (like Microsoft) were eating their customers, who were providing service that followed their business line.

On the one hand, this is not pretty, on the other hand, this was happening, happens and will happen, so anyone starting business should think of this - that's one more risk to take into account. I think there was a good post on this by Joel Spolsky - if you create app that improves someone else product, the owner of the product soon or later will come after you.

Apple probably is not going to extend iOS with capabilities useful for plumbers, so one is safe building app for plumbers, however I would hesitate to build app for runners, as Apple is clearly looking on the health & sports sector.

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by VortexDream on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @11:36AM (#28540455)
It's because of this kind of stuff that I wanted the Epic case about anticompetitive behavior to be successful. Unfortunately, they blew past this whole issue and focused solely on the issue of the store tax and payment processing. So we're stuck with crap like this.
Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by sushicat on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @04:03PM (#28543686)
Personally, I doubt the blocking of app updates is due to failed acquisition. Yes, let’s admit the facts are Apple tried to buy FlickType, the attempt failed, FlickType is blocked from issuing updates, and Apple released keyboard for Watch 7. But let’s think from a different angle, Apple is a large corporation, all these steps were performed by different teams under different organizations.

I can image when acquisition happens, the keyboard team under software org will need to have some sort of requests to M&A(?) org, and then let them negotiate the details like price and make decisions. And app store review team is not involved in this discussion process.

For the M&A (I don’t know the actual name) org, IMO there is no incentive to block an app update due to a failed acquisition, they handle acquisitions every day and turned down offers are normal to them.

For the keyboard team, do they really want to block the app updates for a revenge? It’s possible but I think unlikely, they’re not competing with FlickType. Yes, they sherlocked the FlickType, but they don’t have the pressure to increase adoption because the native keyboard will have better experience (may not fair to developers if no API provided), and only available on watch 7.

Let’s say the keyboard team do want a revenge. Then some manager under keyboard team, which is a few levels down the tree of software org, needs to talk with another manager in app review team, which is also a few levels down of marketing org, for the blocking of updates for a specific app. Why would the manger of app review team accept such request? Imaging you’re that app store review manager, someone down the line of another org ask you to do something not only hurt the reputation of the company, but also yourself either externally or internally. Will you accept that request?

To be clear, this is my guess, and I don’t know what’s really going there, I could be wrong, and this is indeed a revenge. But my point is things may not connected as they look like.

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by jb1991 on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @08:03AM (#28537982)
> Apple wanted to buy FlickType but they didn't agree on the price or Eleftheriou didn't want to sell (I doubt it)

Man, these Apple threads are always so full of open speculation.

Edit: I find it very interesting that after multiple downvotes, suddenly I'm getting downvotes on lots of older comments of mine also. Are folks just going into comment histories to go on a downvote rampage?

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by sodality2 on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @08:07AM (#28538007)
> In one blatant example, Eleftheriou said he was approached by Apple’s head of mobile keyboard technology, Randy Marsden. The latter (who created the Swype keyboard) wanted to buy FlickType to add a native QWERTY for the Apple Watch and improve typing on the device. When Eleftheriou rejected Apple, it refused to remove copycat and scam apps from the App Store.

https://hitechglitz.com/the-creator-of-the-previous-highest-...

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by commoner on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @08:15AM (#28538086)
hitechglitz.com is one of those spam blogs that copies articles from other sites and changes a couple of the words around. The original article from PhoneArena also contains the lawsuit filing:

https://www.phonearena.com/news/flicktype-developer-files-su...

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by buran77 on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @08:11AM (#28538048)
Blocking the app was probably just a dick move and revenge in response to the rejection. The two softwares aren't actually competing, one now comes with the OS whether you want it or not.

If Apple now bans the use of an alternative keyboard despite it not breaking the rules then that's the real issue: they'd be arbitrarily choosing when to apply or ignore the stated terms of use of the store. Reinstating the app later on once the damage is done is a small price to pay from Apple's perspective.

On the other hand if your product is actually just a feature for someone else's product you're always exposing yourself to a situation where the product developer just builds that feature in.

Think of other fields where you may offer an aftermarket solution like a car seat heating cover but the market evaporates the moment the manufacturer starts offering that as standard.

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by sodality2 on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @08:43AM (#28538361)
>The two softwares aren't actually competing

Well yeah, duh, they literally cannot compete. They were kicked off. The fact that you defend banning an app from the store as childish retribution for not taking a lowball offer is telling.

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by windexh8er on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @08:44AM (#28538369)
> Blocking the app was probably just a dick move and revenge in response to the rejection. The two softwares aren't actually competing, one now comes with the OS whether you want it or not.

You have to remember that to companies like Apple everything is competition and financially related. Apple sells widgets based on product release cycles. Those cycles generally focus on features, whether those are hardware or software. Keep in mind that not everyone knows about FlickType. So in that case Apple may choose to release a FlickType clone as part of a new Apple Watch series, exclusive to that version and above. This helps sell more product for Apple. More new features that resonate with their buyers == more profit. Also you can't stand on the stage for 10 minutes and talk about a keyboard that your buyers go to the App store to get, now can you?

Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by NKosmatos on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @08:13AM (#28538064)
It's not speculation, Apple for sure wanted to buy and had invited over Kostas to demo FlickType. Kostas for sure wanted to sell, since he went over at Apple to showcase his very good and usable watch keyboard. They didn't agree on a price and thus parted ways.
Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by LeoNatan25 on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @08:07AM (#28538004)
This is not a speculation, it is according to Kosta Eleftheriou, the developer of FlickType.
Re:Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced... by CRConrad on Sunday September 19, 2021 @12:36PM (#28585652)
This took vouching to be able to reply. People, if what the commenter said were all that wrong, it should be pretty fucking easy to post a coherent and convincing rebuttal. Just downvoting in stead shows that it's the downvoter, not the downvoted, who lacks good grounds for their opinion.

And the retroactive downvote sprees of other comments -- which I've also seen before, so don't even try to deny their existence -- are just beyond despicable. Shame, shame on anyone who is enough of an asshole to do shit like that.