News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by xqcgrek2 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @12:36PM (#28471583)
Why does YouTube or Instagram tolerate sponsored content?

They don't get a cut from a sponsored video or product placement, and their dominance in the advertising space means this is also cutting into their ad revenue.

Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by ajhurliman on Thursday September 09, 2021 @12:43PM (#28471676)
Sponsored content is the main income for creators, so if a platform banned it there would be a mass exodus and they'd lose their dominance.
Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by xqcgrek2 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @12:47PM (#28471725)
But they would earn more money from regular ad revenue, presumably.

You're painting a rather bleak picture -- that the majority of creators/influencers' content is advertising. If that's the case, I'm not sure why Youtube/Instagram should also tolerate that -- it's basically spam on their platform they haven't curated through their ad network.

Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by djur on Thursday September 09, 2021 @01:02PM (#28471887)
The platform is essentially getting a cut -- their own ad revenue -- from content producers who are financially supported via sponsorship/paid content. Right now it's just economically not feasible for the platforms to force themselves into that sponsorship relationship without risking an exodus of their most profitable users. And Google doesn't really want to be in the business of individually managing influencers' relationships with brands, anyway.
Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by ajhurliman on Thursday September 09, 2021 @01:49PM (#28472509)
Brand deals are the majority of their income, but not the majority of their content. This just means the platforms aren't paying very much, since the platforms are advertising on _all_ their content and yet creators are managing to earn ~80% of their income through brand deals on a tiny fraction of their content. 58% of creators post 16 or less sponsored posts a year, and those with more followers post even less[0], while the majority of creators post significantly more content than that.

Creators are very careful not to overwhelm their audience with ads; their audience (and their portability to new platforms/ channels) is their number one asset since they may need to jump to new platforms in the future as their channels can get demonetized/ banned for frivolous reasons.

[0] https://influencermarketinghub.com/creator-earnings-benchmar...

Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by dathinab on Thursday September 09, 2021 @02:26PM (#28472946)
> _all_ their content

Except if they believe you are not advertisement friendly content.

Like any discussion or educational material about any touchy topic gets not ads (and there are a lot of such thinks).

YT accidentally mistaking a think you sayd as a black listed swear word (even if you didn't say it and are not even speaking in the language its from and it just sound similar) => No Ad Money.

Politics => No Ad Money.

Covering Covid related thinks => No Ad Money.

Covering local news including violence => No Ad Money.

etc...

Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by Cederfjard on Thursday September 09, 2021 @12:55PM (#28471826)
> But they would earn more money from regular ad revenue, presumably.

I’m not sure why you would presume that. Also, product placement has been a standard feature of entertainment for a long time. I don’t see why you’d expect Google and Facebook to be the ones to take a stand on this, after all this time.

Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by asdff on Thursday September 09, 2021 @01:57PM (#28472610)
Youtube et al tolerate it because these influencers posts ultimately mean more eyes are fixed on the platform to watch the actual first party advertisements. Having these influencers rely on third party sponsored posts for their funding means that youtube doesn't have to pay them very much at all.
Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by cma on Thursday September 09, 2021 @02:23PM (#28472907)
And they can eventually change terms to charge a percentage, maybe only on the biggest channels for ease of enforcement, like record labels eventually started doing with concert tickets and merch.
Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by asdff on Thursday September 09, 2021 @06:41PM (#28475528)
How would they even do that? Music artists are free to make their own endorsements without having to pay their label.
Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by pbhjpbhj on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:30PM (#28475968)
Surely just by contract when they get a 'record deal', and practically by hiring the accountant who does the artists books to make sure they don't try and earn without paying the masters?
Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by erosenbe0 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @06:32PM (#28475444)
A lot of content contains or is funded by a product placement but is otherwise not advertising.

For example, a guy is teaching me to fix a generic, unbranded toilet issue but stops to mention a particular widget or toolbelt he is being paid to use.

Next video he is teaching me to fix a sump pump and there again he mentions his sponsored plumbing gear.

This is fine by me. I learn how to fix things and some plumbing widget company pays the bill.

Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by hutzlibu on Thursday September 09, 2021 @01:03PM (#28471907)
Spam is something nobody wants. The influencers videos quite some people want to see despite their sneaky ads. So youtube gets views, too.
Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by katbyte on Thursday September 09, 2021 @01:28PM (#28472246)
Not all sponsored ads are sneaky, a number of YouTube channels I watch do hilarious skits for each one at the end of their videos which I think is a win for everyone involved.
Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by djur on Thursday September 09, 2021 @02:07PM (#28472732)
At this point I don't think there's a single channel I watch that produces original content for YouTube (as opposed to, say, speedruns of video games or stream recordings) that is not sponsored. The last few holdouts gave in just a year or two ago. Just like podcasts, they'll do an ad read before, in the middle of, or after the video. I've gotten very used to skipping them.
Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by slapfrog on Thursday September 09, 2021 @02:21PM (#28472885)
> Spam is something nobody wants.

Spam is something the recipient doesn't want. What is or isn't spam is subjectively determined by each individual recipient. If spam were strictly determined by what nobody wants, requiring complete consensus, then nothing would be spam because in a world of 7 billion people there will always be one nut who welcomes the unrequested solicitation.

Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by dathinab on Thursday September 09, 2021 @02:21PM (#28472890)
> that the majority of creators/influencers' content is advertising.

Advertising embedded in the content as sponsor callouts and similar (often paying way better then YT ad sense), this includes showcases of sponsored content and similar.

Which if it's properly labeled is not a problem.

But as far as I know many big YT channels can NOT live from YT ad sense/network money. Some won't even get any at all due to YouTubes (IMHO overreaching) classification of content into advertisement friendly or not.

Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by cwkoss on Thursday September 09, 2021 @12:54PM (#28471805)
I don't think most influencers can make a living with just ad content. Many are using sponsorships and ada and barely getting by.
Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by onlyrealcuzzo on Thursday September 09, 2021 @01:13PM (#28472050)
And make money how? Creators are dependent on platforms to get and monetize attention. People aren't going to stop using Instagram and YouTube because a few superstars only post content on TikTok.
Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by jollybean on Thursday September 09, 2021 @02:03PM (#28472683)
Content is King.

TikTok has a fund to pay people to make content to get them up off the ground.

Insta, despite it's growth, has a decay problem in that it's out of the zeitgeist of the key demos. it's growing in developing markets and maybe might have some incidental sign ups, but people are not flocking to it.

And TikTok - depsite it's popularity, has a very 'fad' feel to it. While FB has a bit of the 'e-mail' incumbency in that it's how people communicate with family and user groups, TikTok is a bit more fleeting.

These platforms would get hurt badly without a lot of those middle and upper tier content makers.

The current situation is a rational entente actually: Insta makes ads, influencers can make a buck however. The more popular YouTubers will monetize with ads anyhow.

Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by space_fountain on Thursday September 09, 2021 @01:35PM (#28472343)
Even moderately successful YouTubers rely on sponsorship and because there's competition for creators between platforms it would take illegal coordination to present a united front and ban it
Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by slapfrog on Thursday September 09, 2021 @02:48PM (#28473161)
> Even moderately successful YouTubers rely on sponsorship and because there's competition for creators between platforms

The fact that you call them "Youtubers", identifying them using the trademark of one particular platform rather than a generic descriptor like "video content creator", suggests that there is not quite as much healthy competition as you claim. Most video companies other than youtube only compete with youtube in a narrow sense; a great deal of the content on youtube does not fit on tiktok's platform, which is only good for short-form content. Netflix only hosts movies or TV shows. Twitch is for livestreaming; other kinds of content don't fit into the paradigm of twitch. Vimeo has never been a good place for off-the-cuff home movies, they too try to compete with youtube only in a narrow domain, not across the board. The few generalist video hosting companies other than youtube are all jokes that are faaar behind youtube in viewer counts.

Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by space_fountain on Thursday September 09, 2021 @02:55PM (#28473240)
I guess the point is that Youtube has a powerful market position but not an unassailable one. They can lose market share and pissing off a large percent of there content creators seems like a good way of doing that
Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by onlyrealcuzzo on Thursday September 09, 2021 @01:56PM (#28472598)
Right... Like how Google and Apple and Steam and Microsoft and Playstation compete on transaction fees for their stores?

If the platforms wanted to come after the money, they could. I suspect they're still in the growing phase. But I imagine in the near future, they'll start demanding all ads go through their platforms.

Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by space_fountain on Thursday September 09, 2021 @02:44PM (#28473127)
Ignoring the ongoing court cases around that it's very different when you have huge barriers to entry and thus only a few companies especially when they just have to follow the existing norms vs imposing a new norm. Like starting up a video sharing site is hard, but we've seen a number of examples over the past 5 years who have gained traction where we've seen no examples of new successful app stores in that time
Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by not2b on Thursday September 09, 2021 @02:35PM (#28473041)
Only if they aren't worried about antitrust enforcement against their advertising monopolies. Probably safer for them to let it go.
Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by jdavis703 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @12:51PM (#28471784)
Digital ad campaigns are all about advanced targeting that influencers can’t really do. Influencers are more like traditional media that can describe their general demographics, but can’t precisely deliver ad dollars.

For example say I follow a lot of architecture / interior design / construction accounts. A company that pays a construction influencer is going to waste their money on my impression — I’m never going to buy professional-grade construction equipment.

On the other side Instagram or whomever already knows I’m a white collar worker and just sends me ads for ring lights and laptop stands.

So influencers and platforms are essentially going after different sets of ad dollars.

Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by asdff on Thursday September 09, 2021 @01:54PM (#28472587)
Youtube and instagram still place their own ads on sponsored content. I see it as youtube and instagram saving on labor costs since the sponsored posts are paying the influencer who ultimately drives engagement to the actual first party advertisements that make these platforms their real money. Just look at what gets posted as a sponsored post vs a first party advertisement and you can see its an entirely different ballgame being played and orders of magnitude different levels of ad spend. Sponsored posts might have some weird energy drink you've never heard of with vague promises of virility or other typical snakeoil features. The first party ad on the other hand will be from coca cola.
Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by lostlogin on Thursday September 09, 2021 @02:12PM (#28472789)
> Youtube and instagram still place their own ads on sponsored content

The ‘skip advert’ button… should it skip the YouTube inserted sponsored content, or move to the end of the video entirely?

Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by corobo on Thursday September 09, 2021 @12:41PM (#28471646)
Sponsored content isn't locked in to YouTube

The second they ban it all the creators that can afford to will jump ship. YouTube knows the creators that can afford to jump ship are also the ones keeping their lights on

I have no idea the legal situation but I'd also imagine there'd be a safe harbour challenge in there somewhere too

Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by Jerry2 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @06:08PM (#28475225)
>The second they ban it all the creators that can afford to will jump ship.

Jump to where though? No other video platform is even close to the number of visitors.

We really need a credible YT alternative :(

Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by corobo on Friday September 10, 2021 @08:40AM (#28480683)
Probably Vimeo plus their remaining socials at first to satisfy outstanding contracts and then I'm not sure unfortunately

Depends on their access to tech knowledge whether they go distributed (peertube) or find another YouTube. Wherever they go would become the new YouTube over time

Oddly enough it seems all content creators quickly attract a tech person that they later rely on and make their first hire when successful. I doubt it'd be the issue, depends what exists at the time

Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by lampe3 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @12:49PM (#28471762)
because if you would only get money from youtube ads then you could not survive on it.

Maybe if you are on of the 0.1% creaters but then you would miss out on a lot of smaller channels.

Sure you have things like Patreon but its not that easy to get people to pay for your stuff.

So in the end you will take sponsorship deals because you either do that or do something else.

Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by Bayart on Thursday September 09, 2021 @01:04PM (#28471924)
Their dominance in the ad space means content creators aren't able to make a living without sponsorships and other sources of revenue (merch, patreon).

Sponsorships on Youtube exploded when ad revenue cratered.

Cut sponsorships away and you're basically killing the ecosystem.

Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by manigandham on Thursday September 09, 2021 @01:32PM (#28472302)
It's not really the same ad revenue. Sponsorships are completely different campaigns and budgets from typical programmatic video or companion ads run on Youtube.

As far as YT is concerned, their ads pay for the hosting and delivery of the content, but it's the creators who actually create the content and they can include whatever they want (as long as its legal, etc) with their audience deciding if they want to deal with it or not.

Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by kentosi on Thursday September 09, 2021 @12:44PM (#28471684)
True, but banning it would mean a drop in engagement with the platform, which would in turn hurt YouTube/Instagram's profits.

That's my guess.

Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by that_guy_iain on Thursday September 09, 2021 @01:21PM (#28472164)
Instagram actually force themselves into the value chain. Also, if all your content creators leave then you have no content. If you see the "sponsored" field on Instagram then it's part of Facebook forcing itself into the value chain.

I also suspect it's againist anti-trust to force yourself into that value chain and to prevent others from marketing.

Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by heavyset_go on Thursday September 09, 2021 @01:30PM (#28472272)
Because without sponsored content, they'd have to give content creators a bigger cut of their own revenue.
Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by joshl325369 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @01:06PM (#28471953)
Why wouldn't they? It doesn't really hurt them.

When viewers see Youtube ads, they'll be annoyed with Youtube. But when viewers see sponsored content, they'd be annoyed with the content creator. So Youtube won't get the extra flak.

Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by paxys on Thursday September 09, 2021 @01:03PM (#28471918)
Because then they would have to pay content creators themselves.
Re:Paid influencers must label some posts as ads, German cou... by mhh__ on Thursday September 09, 2021 @02:37PM (#28473065)
Better the devil you know?