News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:El Salvador adopts Bitcoin as official currency, first co... by aazaa on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @12:20PM (#28446591)
> To warm up a skeptical public, Bukele has promised every citizen $30 in bitcoin if they sign up for a government digital wallet. Ahead of the launch, El Salvador bought 400 bitcoins, Bukele said, helping drive the currency price above $52,000 for the first time since May.

> In the early hours of Tuesday the wallet had not appeared on Apple Inc., Google and Huawei’s app download platforms, however, prompting a series of tweets from Bukele, including one with a red-faced “angry” emoticon.

The involvement of a government-issued wallet gives this story an even stranger dimension. First, it's not clear how the government will identify those eligible to receive the $30 bitcoin deposit. Second, why would the government be involved at all in developing a wallet? There are plenty to choose from now, so what features exactly were missing in those? Finally, what government in its right mind would hitch its fortunes to the vagaries of a walled-garden App Store based in the US, a country clearly hostile to the Salvadoran experiment?

Re:El Salvador adopts Bitcoin as official currency, first co... by Godel_unicode on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @12:56PM (#28447040)
The government is going to have to make an official recommendation for which wallet to use, and from their perspective the risk of promoting an existing wallet whose provenance they don't know is pretty high.
Re:El Salvador adopts Bitcoin as official currency, first co... by nomoreplease on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @01:09PM (#28447197)
The most logical reason is that they want to connect the human identity to the wallet/address, thereby easily removing anonymity and ensuring the government can monitor their population effectively
Re:El Salvador adopts Bitcoin as official currency, first co... by ClumsyPilot on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @01:41PM (#28447562)
Normal banks already do that
Re:El Salvador adopts Bitcoin as official currency, first co... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @01:57PM (#28447752)
> Normal banks already do that

70% of El Salvadorians don't have a bank account [1].

[1] https://datacatalog.worldbank.org/dataset/el-salvador-global...

Re:El Salvador adopts Bitcoin as official currency, first co... by q-rews on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @02:26PM (#28448110)
What you said does not contradict the parent comment. Just because Bitcoin is now a thing in El Salvador it doesn't mean that that missing 70% will now starting using it.
Re:El Salvador adopts Bitcoin as official currency, first co... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @02:31PM (#28448195)
> What you said does not contradict the parent comment. Just because Bitcoin is now a thing in El Salvador it doesn't mean that that missing 70% will now starting using it.

It was alleged this move would let percent "removing anonymity and ensur[e] the government can monitor their population effectively" [1]. Counterargument was that "normal banks already do that" [2].

That is true. But 70% of El Salvadorians don't use "normal banks." They use cash. Cash does not "ensur[e] the government can monitor its population." This Bitcoin rollout does.

So yes, an El Salvadorean using a bank to do business and switching to Bitcoin gives up no privacy. But one using cash does.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28447197

[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28447562

Re:El Salvador adopts Bitcoin as official currency, first co... by HWR_14 on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @01:56PM (#28447736)
> There are plenty to choose from now, so what features exactly were missing in those?

IIRC, people using that wallet can opt into a government backed BTC to fiat conversion rate that allows all shopkeepers to cash out in fiat. It's to make people feel comfortable being forced to accept bitcoin. For obvious reasons, governments don't want to subsidize non-citizens or risk alternative wallet lending themselves to arbitrage.

Re:El Salvador adopts Bitcoin as official currency, first co... by rgrieselhuber on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @12:22PM (#28446610)
I’d be skeptical about using a government wallet as well, though it could potentially make initial disbursements easier.
Re:El Salvador adopts Bitcoin as official currency, first co... by ridethebike on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @12:56PM (#28447034)
This probably eliminates this whole "bitcoin is privacy and independence from government" thing but I think for majority of bitcoin buyers it was not more than just a nice talking point anyway.
Re:El Salvador adopts Bitcoin as official currency, first co... by danlugo92 on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @01:42PM (#28447567)
> privacy

From the original bitcoin white paper:

> The traditional banking model achieves a level of privacy by limiting access to information to the parties involved and the trusted third party. The necessity to announce all transactions publicly precludes this method, but privacy can still be maintained by breaking the flow of information in another place: by keeping public keys anonymous.

Salvadorians can transfer their BTC to a tumbling service then to a an anonymous public key.

> independence from government

As soon as you transfer the BTC out of the wallet, you'll be independent from the government.

You are not required to use the government provided wallet if you don't need the $30 handout.

Re:El Salvador adopts Bitcoin as official currency, first co... by ridethebike on Thursday September 09, 2021 @02:23AM (#28466898)
Ok, good points
Re:El Salvador adopts Bitcoin as official currency, first co... by FroshKiller on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @01:40PM (#28447542)
The majority of Bitcoin buyers don’t appear to be interested in its use as currency at all from what I’ve seen.
Re:El Salvador adopts Bitcoin as official currency, first co... by de_keyboard on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @01:40PM (#28447548)
Only when using the government wallet though. I imagine people will have multiple, just like how we already have multiple debit cards, credit cards, online payment apps...
Re:El Salvador adopts Bitcoin as official currency, first co... by rgrieselhuber on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @01:19PM (#28447298)
The best argument for Bitcoin is that it’s not created out of thin air and then lent to people with interest, IMO.
Re:El Salvador adopts Bitcoin as official currency, first co... by okl on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @01:36PM (#28447507)
Sure, it's created out of hot air and instead of interest you have crazy transaction fees.
Re:El Salvador adopts Bitcoin as official currency, first co... by rgrieselhuber on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @01:45PM (#28447611)
Paid to whom? If it was created out of hot air, it would be a hell of a lot cheaper than it is now.
Re:El Salvador adopts Bitcoin as official currency, first co... by HWR_14 on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @01:57PM (#28447753)
BTC is quite literally made out of hot air. Burning coal to create hot air to spin turbines is the most common energy source for BTC mining. And "hot air" describes most of it's coals replacements as well.
Re:El Salvador adopts Bitcoin as official currency, first co... by rgrieselhuber on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @02:19PM (#28448017)
And yet it still costs far less energy to mine Bitcoin than it does to sustain Petrodollars.
Re:El Salvador adopts Bitcoin as official currency, first co... by HWR_14 on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @07:27PM (#28451088)
Yes, if in your analysis digging up fossil fuels to power the entire world infrastructure is just a side effect of sustaining the currency's core value. Good thing cars, airplanes and shipping have as much intrinsic value as waste heat.
Re:El Salvador adopts Bitcoin as official currency, first co... by okl on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @02:22PM (#28448065)
Do you have data for that comparison?
Re:El Salvador adopts Bitcoin as official currency, first co... by ryan93 on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @02:35PM (#28448245)
The entire world economy runs on fiat dollars.
Re:El Salvador adopts Bitcoin as official currency, first co... by BTCOG on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @02:12PM (#28447928)
100% BULLSHIT. The fees on Bitcoin, on chain, have been less than 75 cents the entire year of 2021. The average tx on chain the past 9 months has been about 10-15 cents. Unless you stand here trying to tell everyone that 10 cents is a crazy transaction fee. Quit lying, or better yet quit spreading FUD purposely.
Re:El Salvador adopts Bitcoin as official currency, first co... by BTCOG on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @02:57PM (#28448490)
So today, the low priority (and for the past few weeks) has been sitting at 6-7 satoshi per vByte. If you do not understand and watch the blocks to realize you can simply set to around 3-4 sats/vB and get in within 2-3 blocks when a block comes along with merely a few hundred transactions in it, sure you're going to pay about 65-75 cents. But I'll pay 10 cents and still get in, while you pay 75 cents. It's not zealotry to tell the truth about using Bitcoin regularly and those that use Bitcoin all understand the fees have been 10-75 cents max all year long. My own sources don't back me up? Anyone using Bitcoin at least once or twice per week the past solid 9 months can attest that transaction fees have been floating from 3-8 sats/vB and you can comb through ALL the blocks you want to figure it out. Or don't figure it out. You're here to spread FUD quite clearly, anyhow.

The fee was NEVER once $62 per tx in ALL of April, I sent numerous transactions all that month long for mere cents.

Re:El Salvador adopts Bitcoin as official currency, first co... by BTCOG on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @02:44PM (#28448347)
https://mempool.space/ https://bitinfocharts.com/comparison/bitcoin-median_transact...

And considering I use Bitcoin frequently, and I'm constantly, on a weekly basis sending on chain for 5 cents, 10 cents max. I'm in within a couple blocks, every single time. You are straight up spreading FUD.

Re:El Salvador adopts Bitcoin as official currency, first co... by Forbo on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @02:49PM (#28448419)
> 100% BULLSHIT. The fees on Bitcoin, on chain, have been less than 75 cents the entire year of 2021. The average tx on chain the past 9 months has been about 10-15 cents.

By your own sources your original claims don't hold up. So much for "100% BULLSHIT". Please stop with the zealotry, it makes the entire space look foolish.

Re:El Salvador adopts Bitcoin as official currency, first co... by okl on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @02:55PM (#28448474)
Let's look at your claims again:

> The fees on Bitcoin, on chain, have been less than 75 cents the entire year of 2021.

The average transaction fee on April 21st was $62.779. You are wrong.

> The average tx on chain the past 9 months has been about 10-15 cents.

Clearly wrong. The data you cite is the median transaction fee, not the average transaction fee. For the lowest median transaction fee the chart shows 22.9 cents. Even that is above your claimed 10-15 cents.

Good for you that you spent less on your transaction, doesn't change the data though.

Re:El Salvador adopts Bitcoin as official currency, first co... by only_as_i_fall on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @02:31PM (#28448185)
Source?
Re:El Salvador adopts Bitcoin as official currency, first co... by lottin on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @02:25PM (#28448103)
Bitcoin is created out of thin air. Where do you think bitcoins come from?
Re:El Salvador adopts Bitcoin as official currency, first co... by tacostakohashi on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @01:04PM (#28447150)
I'd be even more skeptical about using a government wallet hosted on an Apple / Google app store.
Re:El Salvador adopts Bitcoin as official currency, first co... by kobieyc on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @12:56PM (#28447035)
I've been watching this situation from 50K feet and I think the reason they built their own wallet is for the ability, for merchants, to cash out any bitcoin payment in USD instead of BTC using the government swap system
Re:El Salvador adopts Bitcoin as official currency, first co... by defgeneric on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @01:22PM (#28447338)
You need a DUI (Documento Único de Identidad) or Passport number for the Chivo wallet.
Re:El Salvador adopts Bitcoin as official currency, first co... by val314159 on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @01:48PM (#28447642)
you think the government doesn't have a list of its citizens? I'm sure they have something like a social security number.
Re:El Salvador adopts Bitcoin as official currency, first co... by el-salvador on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @04:51PM (#28449778)
There is a National ID Number for everyone with Salvadoran Nationality 18 and older. And also a Tax ID that anyone can apply for.
Re:El Salvador adopts Bitcoin as official currency, first co... by xtracto on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @12:30AM (#28453046)
As someone from Latin America, it's funny to read about Americans' struggle for a countrywide ID and the sense of government control/ freedom.

Here in Mexico the government has our biometrics, there's a national election ID, SSN and a unique "clave de población " .