I feel there's a lot of people who are absolutists about privacy without realising the legal and technical realities of that absolutism. I don't agree for one minute with governments and corporations compromising people's privacy, but whatever we like to tell ourselves about liberal democracy all authority amounts to "might makes right" in the end, and ProtonMail doesn't have the mightiest club to swing around in this situation.
- a service which would blindly accept money/crypto-money,
- in exchange of a worldwide legal shield which would take all of the heat resulting from the user's anonymous actions.
This service is not going to exist for $100/year. It would not even be safe to offer such a service for a million dollars per year, because the responsibility could be huge (terrorist attacks, human trafficking, etc.). Nobody in their right mind would be ready to bear this kind of legal responsibility without trusting (and thus knowing) their customers.
Nobody is. But if you buy a trailer every week, it wouldn’t be unreasonable for law enforcement to ask Walmart to let them organise a sting outside or even just leave a video camera on premises. They could do that without a warrant in the U.S., Walmart willing, something that is illegal with ProtonMail in Switzerland.
There is also another viewpoint. Since ProtonMail is non-USA company, any internet activity associated with non-US citizens isn't protected by the US Constitution when CIA et al. are in action. They can do whatever they please.
Also, the background of the ProtonMail is not so clear. Many might not know as they have tried to hide it, but MIT guys have been in big part of originally writing the ProtonMail, which can be linked to CIA/NSA oversight[1].
Also, major part from the equity ownership belongs to U.S (Charles River Ventures was one of the first big funders, and this naturally happens)
I also leave this interesting link here[2] (The Truth About Protonmail).
[1]: https://web.archive.org/web/20210226014214/https://privacy-w...
[2]: https://web.archive.org/web/20210220023958/https://privacy-w...
First, Charles River Ventures is no longer a shareholder: https://protonmail.com/blog/crv-investment-other-news/
Second, all of ProtonMail's code that runs on your device is open source and independently audited. It would be nearly impossible to hide a backdoor in there.
When will you support reproducible builds, or are you supporting it already? Because only then we can be 100% that same code is actually running in there without reverse-engineering between every update.
This gets at the key tech question: what's the most they could do? (either in response to a legal order or for any other reason)
ProtonMails answer here is "not much"; they can log IPs and access times. Signal has a great write up about how they respond to warrants, and it's similar: just IP and last access time.
But is that really all?
Protonmail has a web app. This time, a court said "you must add server side logging for these specific accounts". Could a court also say "you must add client side logging for this specific account"? If so, could that come w a gag order such that only that one user gets served different code, almost impossible to detect?
That would let a user read their mail.
I am very curious whether the App Stores have ever served modified versions of apps to specific users in order to, for example, extract Signal messages.
Software update is a key problem, closely related to the Ken Thompson "Reflections on Trusting Trust" thought experiment. I'm using a tool: how can I know for sure that I'm using the same copy everyone else has, not one that's been compromised?
They do if they're asked to and you're not using their custom e2e thing (e.g. you're using the imap gateway).
ProtonMail is effective at thwarting the first. It sees headers and IP addresses, so the risk is theoretically there. But their technology, policies and the strength of Swiss privacy law [1] make them a less-ideal coöperator for the NSA than e.g. Google or Comcast.
With respect to the second, I feel like ProtonMail went out of their way to communicate their limits. They will comply with Swiss warrants. These are signed off on by a Swiss court and made pursuant to Swiss law. (They still don’t get to hand over your emails, which is an improvement over most other providers.)
Disclaimer: I used to use ProtonMail. I switched to Microsoft 365 because I need integrated calendaring and delegation.
[1] Third-partly doctrine doesn’t exist for e-mails in Switzerland. If the FBI asks ProtonMail for information, ProtonMail would be breaking Swiss law if they handed it over without a Swiss court signing a warrant.