News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Shareholder Value Myth (2013) by amin on Monday September 06, 2021 @08:39AM (#28433095)
Nearly every long term shareholder understands that, in order to create shareholder value, the company needs to prioritize delighting customers over and over again first and foremost.
Re:The Shareholder Value Myth (2013) by simonh on Monday September 06, 2021 @08:59AM (#28433220)
Kind of. I wouldn't describe Ryanair as having ever delighted me as a customer. They offer fantastic value, so I suppose you could say I was 'delighted' at not having to pay more, but that comes with a significant dose of resignation at the stress I'm going to go through.
Re:The Shareholder Value Myth (2013) by Filligree on Monday September 06, 2021 @09:03AM (#28433252)
I fully refuse to fly with them, no matter what. Once was enough.

I wouldn’t say they’ve delighted, but they certainly impressed.

Re:The Shareholder Value Myth (2013) by heavenlyblue on Monday September 06, 2021 @10:48AM (#28434201)
Uhm.

I come from a pretty poor country. When I was a student I would fly Ryanair because otherwise I would just not fly. Ryanair provided me with a service that would otherwise be not available to me at all if it was not making be nervous.

So it provides services to a bunch of poor people who are probably _used_ to being nervous anyway in other situations.

"Refuse to fly with them". Would you refuse to fly at all if you could not afford alternatives?

Re:The Shareholder Value Myth (2013) by Ma8ee on Monday September 06, 2021 @11:14AM (#28434490)
I refuse to fly at all nowadays. Even on a relatively short flight, I would be responsible for more greenhouse gases than all my other consumption and transports for several months give rise to.
Re:The Shareholder Value Myth (2013) by lotsofpulp on Monday September 06, 2021 @11:23AM (#28434578)
In case you live in an US style suburb detached single family home lifestyle, I feel like suburb living contributes far more greenhouse gases than a short flight, since living in dense communities reduces how far all mass has to move, and suburb living increases how far all mass has to move.
Re:The Shareholder Value Myth (2013) by Aloha on Monday September 06, 2021 @12:24PM (#28435271)
As an American not flying simply means not traveling anywhere further than 500 miles from home, or it means an extra 2-3 days to get there. It means never really leaving North America, heck, parts of North America are not accessible but by air.

I don't have high speed rail options, I can either, take the (slow) train (if it goes there), take the bus, drive or fly. Removing flying also removed the ability for the poor to travel. That doesn't strike me as fair or reasonable either.

I do try to minimize my flying time, but, none? That's not a reasonable option for me.

Re:The Shareholder Value Myth (2013) by Ma8ee on Monday September 06, 2021 @04:40PM (#28437839)
Train connections between countries are quite miserable in big parts of Europe too, but with increased demand, they are quite rapidly improving. Maybe that would happen in the US too if people used the trains more.

For many relative short distance flights, you don't lose that much time taking the train. If you take into account that most airports are far from the city centers, and you have to be there early to check in luggage, go through security, spend 20 minutes boarding the plane and then wait to get of, wait for luggage and then take the time to get to your final destination from the airport, total travel time by train is often faster than by plane when the flight time is an hour or less. The train usually go from city center to city center, you can show up as late before departure as you dare, no security on no luggage check. The leg room is better and nowadays all trains I have been traveling in Europe have had decent wifi so you can use the time for work or entertaining yourself.

And that poor people fly is usually not the problem. They don't go to Hawaii or Singapore or Rome just for fun.

I understand that flying is important for some people, in particular when you have family in the other of the country or even on another continent. But we, as a world, certainly can't afford to fly just for pleasure.

Re:The Shareholder Value Myth (2013) by Aloha on Monday September 06, 2021 @11:01PM (#28440453)
It's rare that I'm getting on a flight that lasts less that 3 hours, unless I really need to be there right now, or it's a connecting flight.

There however is functionally no passenger rail network in the United States, outside of the northeast corridor, trains are at most at a daily headway. It's not practical for me (or most people) to spend five days on the train to get from Seattle to Dallas, because I need to go to either Chicago or Los Angeles first.

FWIW, The distance between Hawaii and Los Angeles is roughly comparable to that of Los Angeles and Newark, so you're also telling some kid in California that they can't visit their grandparents in New Jersey too.

I think taxing non-connecting travel on short hop (sub 90 min) flights is a way to offset this. But even that is with controversy.

So while I conceptually agree with you, your flight-free lifestyle ignores the reality of life (and geography) in North America.

Re:The Shareholder Value Myth (2013) by Ma8ee on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @02:52AM (#28441749)
The problem is of course that the world can't afford the current life style, or as you call it, reality of life, of the people of North America. So the question really is, how important is that trip between Seattle and Dallas in the first place?

Less than a month ago I spent 23 hours on different trains and an overnight ferry to let my children visit their grandparents that live in a different country. And since we do, rail connections are rapidly improving since there is a demand for them. And I know that isn't possible everywhere in the world. But if you really want your kids to spend time with their grandparents several times a year, then you better live closer to them. Even if it means a less interesting and well paying job. In our case, my wife and I are of different nationalities (and we are certainly not unique in this regard), so we can only live close to one set of grandparents. But that means that they kids only get to see the other pair of grandparents once, maybe twice a year, and we spend quite a bit of time on travel for that.

If people and politicians would have taken the climate threat seriously a few decades ago, when scientists started to tell us that this is real and dire, then you would already drive around in an electric car, you would already have fast coast to coast high speed trains, and maybe even something like hydrogen fuelled airplanes. We already have all the money and technology to solve this. Unfortunately the most important ingredient is missing, and that is political will.

Re:The Shareholder Value Myth (2013) by Aloha on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @05:15PM (#28450050)
I would rather invest money in technologies that allows us to make flying carbon neutral than move backwards in time.

24 hours of time is no big deal, moving back to 1925 travel times, is.

Re:The Shareholder Value Myth (2013) by Ma8ee on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @05:31PM (#28450212)
In a decade or so, I’m sure we all can fly climate neutral. But we don’t have that time. We must drastically reduce greenhouse gases now! We already squandered the time we could have used to do this the simple way without too much personal inconveniences.

It is astonishing that people just don’t get how grave the situation is, even when towns are burning to the ground. This is not something that will happen decades from now, it has already started and it will become much worse.

Re:The Shareholder Value Myth (2013) by Aloha on Thursday September 16, 2021 @12:10PM (#28553589)
Towns are burning to the ground, because we built them in places where there never should have been towns. Furthermore, those western megafires while probably made worse by climate change are mostly the result of 120 years of poor forrest management policy.

The drought that California and the West is seeing right now is within historical norms for the West, we just tended to ignore those norms when building population centers and developed our water expectations around the wet years.

Re:The Shareholder Value Myth (2013) by kinj28 on Monday September 06, 2021 @10:28PM (#28440198)
Poor countries would have rich people too!
Re:The Shareholder Value Myth (2013) by pixelrevision on Monday September 06, 2021 @10:03AM (#28433723)
A lot of large problems tend to stem from picking short term strategies. A relentless focus on quarterly profits likely causes more issues than prioritizing investors though the two are related.
Re:The Shareholder Value Myth (2013) by Ericson2314 on Monday September 06, 2021 @10:58AM (#28434303)
Moreover, it is quite unclear whether capitalism is capable of optimizing over the long term at all.

Suppose we had two planets. Then if global warming got really bad on one, the other would charge crazy fees to refugees --- turn them into indentured servants to the 5th generation or something, and all the investments on the hot planet would loose their value relative the good planet. Clearly, the hot planet's rich people would not want to become indentured servants like everyone else -- for they have little to offer to the cold planet, and so global warming would be prevented.

(Aside, I suppose this is/once was Musk's plan, but his timing is off.)

Without the other planet, civilization can mostly collapse, but not ones investments go to shit relative and advanced society elsewhere. I suppose there can be an small states in the far north, but the rich people will get priority to move there and could sill own everything. All our standards of living go down, but they get to keep their relative position in society, which is mostly what they care about anyways (at least as long as the standard of living declines slow enough to not be too salient.

Of course, the rich people could still do that if there are two planets, but the cold planet elite will mock and scorn the rich planet elite for being so much poorer holed up in Siberia/Canada.

---

We see a similar problem with this chip shortage / lack of inventories. Everyone else did, so no one is loosing market share. The widgets you can sell command a high price, too. What are the consequences? Only when demand crashes do firms suffer.

Re:The Shareholder Value Myth (2013) by anchpop on Monday September 06, 2021 @11:03AM (#28434355)
> Aside, I suppose this is Musk's plan, but his timing is off.

I see people say things like this often but it doesn’t make sense. No matter how bad global warming gets, earth will always be more habitable than mars.

Re:The Shareholder Value Myth (2013) by Ericson2314 on Monday September 06, 2021 @12:10PM (#28435123)
Well yes, he can't be so dumb as not have not realized this. I also it doesn't make sense, and the more benign reasons (more planets derisk) are related. I am just sure it came up at some point in discussion, and is still useful as a family of tall-tale narratives.
Re:The Shareholder Value Myth (2013) by WalterBright on Monday September 06, 2021 @12:10PM (#28435127)
> it is quite unclear whether capitalism is capable of optimizing over the long term at all.

Do you have evidence that socialism/communism is better at it?

Politicians, for example, infamously "kick the can down the road" for the costs of their decisions. They don't care about consequences after the next election.

Re:The Shareholder Value Myth (2013) by Ericson2314 on Monday September 06, 2021 @12:25PM (#28435280)
Well, for starters, I did not claim other things were better at this than Capitalism :).

I don't know of a silver bullet. Planning can probably do it some times, and probably not do it other times.

What I do know is that poverty traps are sort of a curse of short term optimization. So it's imperative to make people feel less precarious or they will not care about these things as much as the elites who like to sit around and mull about abstract world-historic issues.

Re:The Shareholder Value Myth (2013) by fuzzfactor on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @06:36AM (#28443114)
One of the things to think about is that shareholder value really is supposed to amount to what the company as a whole is fundamentally worth.

Maybe about what the company would sell for if it was for sale, or what a comparable company would cost to build. Seems most realistic and still quite difficult to pinpoint a total value. But this is where most private small companies are with an intimate group of partners holding illiquid shares having no market effect. Company growth and building shareholder value are synonymous with each other. Delighting customers has one of the strongest effects.

Anything less realistic is going to be an even less accurate estimate and this can happen with highly liquid shares where the market itself has inflated their recognized value well beyond the underlying assets. These certificates can be more like fiat currency, many companies went public so they can print more according to retail demand.

And fiat currency has an incredible advantage in its ability to be manipulated. Backed by the full faith & credit of a company believed to be strong.

Are all of these people so faithful or creditworthy?

Or is their company really that strong after they kick out half the people and sell off the crown jewels and it makes the share price go up?

Delighting customers at this point may already be out-of-reach.

Re:The Shareholder Value Myth (2013) by NicoJuicy on Monday September 06, 2021 @11:45AM (#28434827)
Stock based compensation to an extreme like Palantir does, is not that.