News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by thepangolino on Sunday September 05, 2021 @06:38AM (#28423137)
Wouldn't a land value tax encourage urban sprawling ?

Current ubran policies in the western world, coupled with the normalization of remote working already do this to some extent.

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by taffer on Sunday September 05, 2021 @07:07AM (#28423314)
On the contrary, a land value tax is often proposed to discourage sprawl. Since a land value tax is the same whether you leave a lot vacant or build a single family home or a multi family home, it encourages density and leads to less sprawl.
Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by Lammy on Sunday September 05, 2021 @07:31AM (#28423458)
Sprawling to where? It’s an island
Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by pydry on Sunday September 05, 2021 @06:57AM (#28423261)
It would probably encourage less urban sprawl by driving more efficient use of city center land and housing.
Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by R0b0t1 on Sunday September 05, 2021 @07:09AM (#28423333)
It depends. If owned land is converted for rent then the LVT is passed on to the tenant. To avoid paying the LVT tenants are incentivized to own, which may imply buying new construction.

As population density increases, desirability increases, and people may try investing with the goal of renting, which with an LVT will more sharply decrease the desirability of population density.

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by taffer on Sunday September 05, 2021 @08:02AM (#28423660)
> To avoid paying the LVT tenants are incentivized to own

LVT is paid by the owner of the land. That is the whole point of a LVT, that you cannot avoid it.

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by R0b0t1 on Sunday September 05, 2021 @08:59AM (#28424010)
On paper, yes, but it'll just get passed on to the renter.
Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by imtringued on Sunday September 05, 2021 @11:29AM (#28425045)
On paper it will be passed to the renter. The owner of the land obtains returns through rent seeking.

If he raises his rents to the maximum that renters are willing to pay then the value of the land grows and he has to pay more land value taxes. He actually cannot make land more expensive. He can only make the land as expensive as it already is.

Of course, it is entirely possible that the effective tax burden on the tenant has risen in the process. For that reason I would encourage the government to reduce income taxes.

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by pydry on Sunday September 05, 2021 @09:52AM (#28424353)
Renters would pay the same rents they do now.

For some landlords that would cover their tax bill. Others not so much.

It would precipitate a collapse in property values, but not a rise in rents.

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by R0b0t1 on Sunday September 05, 2021 @11:03AM (#28424852)
I must sincerely ask you if you read my original comment and the person I am replying to:

As population density increases, desirability increases, and people may try investing with the goal of renting, which with an LVT will more sharply decrease the desirability of population density.

An LVT can incentivize sprawl because all else equal the LVT would ultimately be passed on to renters.

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by systoll on Sunday September 05, 2021 @11:35PM (#28429977)
But all else isn’t equal – denser places have less land per house.

With a property tax, the total tax bill increases when you build upward and make the apartment block. If you take a lot with a single home on it, and then stack 9 identical homes on top, the resulting property might be worth 9x as much. That’d mean the renters of that bottom home still have to pay 90% of their old property tax.

With LVT, the tax bill is based on whether you could build up productively, whether or not you actually choose to do so. So if you stack 10 family homes on top of one another, the renters of those homes would pay 1/10th the land tax.

This shifts the relative tax burden toward lots which are less dense than their surroundings. Encouraging infill and discouraging sprawl. If it pushes some to build their single family home in the exurbs so that an apartment block can be built in the suburbs, that’s a net win.

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by R0b0t1 on Monday September 06, 2021 @04:16PM (#28437581)
Overly optimistic. If you stack 10 family homes the land is now 10x more valuable and gets taxed accordingly.
Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by systoll on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @08:20PM (#28451446)
If you bring more families into an area, the land around them may become more valuable, but there’s no reason that effect would be localised to the apartment block.

This is the core distinction between LVT and property tax.

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by R0b0t1 on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @08:51AM (#28456259)
That makes no sense. If land affects the value of the land around it then it had to have gone up.

If you put 10 family dwellings on land, then its value is at least that of 10 family dwellings. So each individual renter is somehow paying 1/10th the 10x greater cost. You haven't reduced the LVT by sharing it between the LVT between the renters, they're all paying the same or more.

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by systoll on Friday September 10, 2021 @01:58AM (#28478268)
If you buy a block of land with 10 filled apartments on it, and then you demolish it and leave it vacant, the land still has value.

In theory, it still has whatever value the optimal use would provide.

In reality we don’t have an optimal land use oracle, and valuation techniques would take the vacant lot as a data point suggesting that the area is bad. The assessed land value might decrease a tiny bit – along with that of your entire suburb, and similar regions. But it’s not going to zero.

Similarly, if you take a block of land, put 10 apartments on there, and fill them with renters, you’ll create property value where there was none, but the land value isn’t going to go up 10x.

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by pydry on Monday September 06, 2021 @05:42AM (#28432000)
>people may try investing with the goal of renting, which with an LVT will more sharply decrease the desirability of population density.

I dont see how that follows - you stated it but did not explain the mechanism by which it happens.

Population density would flow from the land value as it does now, albeit more efficiently since inefficiently used land would not just mean minimized profits but large losses.

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by coryrc on Sunday September 05, 2021 @12:08PM (#28425359)
Currently, the owner could rent out 2 units on the land and break even. But really there could be 12 units there. LVT raises the taxes as if there were 12 units. This will bring the break-even point to renting out 6 units. The owner has to either build out the property (increasing supply, driving down rental prices), sell to someone who will, or lose money.

That's also why there shouldn't be an exemption for first home.

Obviously made up those numbers but hope you get the idea.

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by zeepthee on Sunday September 05, 2021 @06:44AM (#28423175)
How would it encourage urban sprawling?
Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by ForHackernews on Sunday September 05, 2021 @06:53AM (#28423229)
If you're taxed on the value of the land, rather than the value of the property built on top of that land, it arguably incentivizes buying super-cheap exurban land and planting massive McManisions on it.

Obviously in real life, people care about other things besides just pure acreage, but you can see the argument.

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by taffer on Sunday September 05, 2021 @07:46AM (#28423549)
If people only cared about land area, the distinction between urban and non-urban land wouldn't even exist. What makes urban land special is the infrastructure, schools, workplaces, restaurants, cafés, theaters, libraries. These things make a city a city. These things promote density because people cluster around them.

As I explained in another comment[1], a property tax discourages density and encourages sprawl. A land value tax, on the other hand, does not have these adverse effects on density because it taxes only the fixed supply of land, not the variable supply of buildings.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28423428

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by Pet_Ant on Sunday September 05, 2021 @06:51AM (#28423216)
Preosumably the closer to the city centre the higher the per square fot value so to minimise costs you move to the edge of town, thus sprawl.
Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by pydry on Sunday September 05, 2021 @06:58AM (#28423270)
Or you buy an apartment in a high rise and share the cost with the other residents.

It would certainly discourage the building of houses in the city centre.

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by taffer on Sunday September 05, 2021 @07:27AM (#28423428)
> It would certainly discourage the building of houses in the city centre.

No, that's not how it works. The value of a property is made up of the value of the land and the value of the buildings on it. If one of these two components is taxed, its value is reduced. However, it is important to remember that the supply of land is fixed, but the supply of buildings is not. If one taxes buildings, as is the case with a traditional property tax, construction activity is reduced, but if one taxes only land, as is the case with a land value tax, construction activity is not impeded at all. That's the beauty of a land value tax: it doesn't distort anything.

With a property tax, an undeveloped lot in the center of town is taxed less than a high-rise. With a land value tax, both are taxed at the same rate. Relatively speaking, a property tax promotes sprawl, a land value tax promotes density.

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by pydry on Sunday September 05, 2021 @09:21AM (#28424160)
That's essentially my point. A house in the city center which consumes the same amount of land as an apartment block would face the same tax bill.

Who would want that house with that tax bill?

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by imtringued on Sunday September 05, 2021 @11:38AM (#28425120)
The bill is high because people are willing to pay it. If the neighboring properties are 3 story multifamily buildings then this one will be upgraded to a 3 story building as well.
Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by merrywhether on Sunday September 05, 2021 @10:44AM (#28424687)
Someone who wants to demolish it and turn it into an apartment building! That’s literally the point of LVT: incentivizing increasingly efficient usage of land in high-value areas.
Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by neutronicus on Sunday September 05, 2021 @07:04AM (#28423302)
Aspiring single-family home dwellers will go farther afield in search of less-taxed land
Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by thriftwy on Sunday September 05, 2021 @07:55AM (#28423616)
Maybe they will go to smaller metropolitan area instead?