News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Misinformation on Facebook got 6x more clicks than factua... by chuckee on Friday September 03, 2021 @11:05AM (#28405163)
While the article is easy to believe, I'd prefer it was phrased more precisely. For example:

> news publishers known for putting out misinformation got six times the amount of likes, shares, and interactions on the platform as did trustworthy news sources

If a publisher is known for putting out misinformation (and what is the threshold?), that does not mean all their stories are false. To make the claim in the title, the shared articles would have to be individually evaluated for truthfulness.

The second thing that stuck out to me (emphasis mine):

> The researchers also found that the statistically significant misinformation boost is politically neutral — misinformation-trafficking pages on both the far left and the far right generated much more engagement from Facebook users than factual pages of any political slant. But publishers on the right have a much higher propensity to share misleading information than publishers in other political categories, the study found.

The paragraph switches from talking about misinformation (which I understand to be information that is false), to misleading information, which is a far more vague categorization. Notably, any kind of disfavored statistic, that is grudgingly conceded to be factual, tends to be called "misleading", either for failing to adjust for enough factors, or for implying some cause or conspiracy, or for measuring something you shouldn't care about in the first place.

Re:Misinformation on Facebook got 6x more clicks than factua... by suifbwish on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:22PM (#28407560)
Even though I know it is the case it never fails to shock me how naive and unquestioning people are when they read something. It’s like they feel the act of them reading it makes it likely to be true.

If people then question or doubt it when the person just repeats it they get angry when it’s they that should have done that

Re:Misinformation on Facebook got 6x more clicks than factua... by mikece on Friday September 03, 2021 @08:19AM (#28403176)
We all want to be privy to knowledge that is not widely known, even hidden. It should come as no surprise that info that carries an air of "you're not going to see this on the mainstream!" will have an appeal. Heck, that's why I read HN first thing in the morning is because I'm going to see new here long before it shows up elsewhere, along with links to stories/tech you're just not going to find anywhere else. If Facebook it making people believe they have the Forbidden Fruit there's going to be a line of people demanding to have a bite.
Re:Misinformation on Facebook got 6x more clicks than factua... by mensetmanusman on Friday September 03, 2021 @09:40AM (#28404071)
This reminds me of the Gladiator movie scene after the first death in the colosseum “Are you not entertained!!”

The grotesque disinformation internet is a mirror of our humanity.

Re:Misinformation on Facebook got 6x more clicks than factua... by egberts1 on Friday September 03, 2021 @11:40AM (#28405631)
I gravitate toward news articles with meaningful citation hyperlink(s) and not links that points to just its definition, or worse points to similarly but not related articles within their own web site.
Re:Misinformation on Facebook got 6x more clicks than factua... by krsdcbl on Friday September 03, 2021 @05:47PM (#28409790)
So basically facebook is saying it's bo biggie that people mostly click & watch disinformation because they do scroll past a lot more memes ...
Re:Misinformation on Facebook got 6x more clicks than factua... by hoppyhoppy2 on Friday September 03, 2021 @07:52AM (#28402954)
Re:Misinformation on Facebook got 6x more clicks than factua... by glanard_frugner on Friday September 03, 2021 @12:21PM (#28406205)
“misinformation”
Re:Misinformation on Facebook got 6x more clicks than factua... by ratsmack on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:15PM (#28407467)
As defined by the ministry of truth, I presume.
Re:Misinformation on Facebook got 6x more clicks than factua... by rezbull on Friday September 03, 2021 @12:28PM (#28406286)
Seems like misinformation pays
Re:Misinformation on Facebook got 6x more clicks than factua... by zadokshi on Friday September 03, 2021 @08:36AM (#28403315)
Isn't it already common knowledge that Right leaning readers are moving away from mainstream left wing leaning news sources. The rise of Brietbart, and similar sites that fact checkers dislike is hardly a surprise is it not? (Or is it? seriously, I would like to know, are people surprised that right wing sources are increasing in the wake of Trump?)
Re:Misinformation on Facebook got 6x more clicks than factua... by smolder on Friday September 03, 2021 @11:51AM (#28405776)
The surprising part is the extent to which right wing news like what comes out of Murdoch's companies has become a vehicle for dissemination of obvious falsehoods --paranoid nonsense inconsistent with any evidence. Long ago, I used to think right wing politics were fundamentally rational and just carried a different view on how best to govern versus the left's. Nowadays I see little appeal to rationality, and a great deal of trust-destroying, desperately contrarian fiction masquerading as insight. Left wing sources have gotten worse, too, but don't seem as keen on making things up.
Re:Misinformation on Facebook got 6x more clicks than factua... by glanard_frugner on Friday September 03, 2021 @12:15PM (#28406134)
examples?
Re:Misinformation on Facebook got 6x more clicks than factua... by smolder on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:06PM (#28407379)
An easy example is the idea that the 2020 US presidential election was stolen. There's Obama birtherism, the Seth Rich thing, attributing all sorts of nonsense to Antifa. Coverage of COVID has been awful and very misleading from the start.
Re:Misinformation on Facebook got 6x more clicks than factua... by glanard_frugner on Friday September 03, 2021 @03:19PM (#28408221)
i don’t think you can conclusively say there wasn’t something fishy about the 2020 election. the 2016 election was considered “stolen” or “hacked” by the losing party that year too
Re:Misinformation on Facebook got 6x more clicks than factua... by spaceisballer on Saturday September 04, 2021 @12:48PM (#28416652)
If there was something fishy there would be evidence wouldn’t there? The DOJ said there was no rampant voter fraud. Every election will have some votes that are off, but when it’s not enough to sway the election (by even a close margin) then I don’t think it rises to the bar of suspicious. In 2016 there was not any coverage about the election being stolen, nor people attacking congress to try and overturn an election. There was a large discussion about polling and how they were so off. Also outrage about how the electoral college works (same thing in 2020). Maybe if you look at the media on the extreme sides you have a different picture, but I would say the sentiment after 2016 was more shock (once again because of polling).
Re:Misinformation on Facebook got 6x more clicks than factua... by smolder on Friday September 03, 2021 @05:44PM (#28409771)
I think every election is going to be fishy in the sense that the biased media outlets break stories in ways to manipulate voters towards one outcome or the other. Making voting more accessible to people with mail-in ballots will have had some affect, too, and most likely helped the democrats, just like closing polling stations and under-serving voters has helped the republicans in some cases. But was it cheating, or stealing? I don't think that qualifies at all. I definitely don't think the pandemic response and mail-in ballot measures were primarily some scheme to get more D votes. I wouldn't call Trumps 2016 win illegitimate either, but all the fake news coming from russian owned blogs and sockpuppets and targeting vulnerable voters was still something we needed to make a stink about and work to mitigate.
[dead]
Re:Misinformation on Facebook got 6x more clicks than factua... by scarmig on Friday September 03, 2021 @10:19AM (#28404553)
There's also a fair bit of circular reasoning going on. Take the lab leak "conspiracy theory." Some organizations were dinged by the media raters (relied upon for this study) for being ahead of the curve on that, while organizations like CNN and the WHO weren't dinged despite being very wrong on an important topic. So people want to share articles that accurately point out that the lab leak hypothesis is plausible, which gets marked up as sharing information from organizations known for sharing disinformation (like the lab leak hypothesis), while people don't really care to share whatever CCP-apologetics the WHO is spouting today because it has no credibility, which gets marked up as not wanting to share True Information.
Re:Misinformation on Facebook got 6x more clicks than factua... by frzj on Friday September 03, 2021 @09:59AM (#28404326)
While they indeed wrote "last year", this is purely semantic because democrats indeed started to say lab origin was unlikely at that time. The new information is by definition new. Sure they could have said that, up until last week they still thought so, but it's implicated. The article says that virologists still think that it is natural. The very job of intelligence agencies is to control information. Sometimes they say stuff that makes them look incompetent, like the WMD in Iraq or that the Taliban wouldn't take Kabul this soon. While their service protects "our" interests in the end, they are no reliable source for anything. Scientists at least have some incentive to state the truth. But I have to agree that news outlets like CNN are politicizing information, but an educated reader can still extract what is important. The alternative is no alternative.
Re:Misinformation on Facebook got 6x more clicks than factua... by dntrkv on Friday September 03, 2021 @09:44AM (#28404146)
I don’t see how those articles are an example of what you’re stating. The 3rd article you posted specifically points out the Democrat’s reversal in their stance from a year ago.

Now, if they pretended the democrats were always skeptical of the natural source of the virus, I would agree.

Though, I still haven’t seen anything but circumstantial evidence to support the lab leak hypothesis. Not saying it isn’t possible, but just because China can’t be trusted with these sorts of things, does not mean they’re lying. Most experts still lean heavily on the side of the natural explanation.

Re:Misinformation on Facebook got 6x more clicks than factua... by amanaplanacanal on Friday September 03, 2021 @09:34AM (#28403983)
I think you don't understand how reporting works. Those last two arricles are reporting what other people are saying. Neither one is CNN making a claim.

You may think CNN is not a trustworthy news source, but both of those articles look fine to me.

Re:Misinformation on Facebook got 6x more clicks than factua... by 1MachineElf on Friday September 03, 2021 @11:13AM (#28405291)
>Those last two arricles are reporting what other people are saying. Neither one is CNN making a claim.

That is CNN's proven strategy for pushing baseless narratives with plausible deniability.

Re:Misinformation on Facebook got 6x more clicks than factua... by torstenvl on Friday September 03, 2021 @11:56AM (#28405856)
I understand your position. My response comes in two parts:

First, I don't think it was necessary to make an ad hominem comment about me personally. What you think I "understand" is irrelevant and the comment was inflammatory.

Second, if "almost certainly" is really "what other people are saying," can you direct me to the quote from one of those other people? It seems to me that this is indeed CNN's conclusion rather than someone else's actual words.

Re:Misinformation on Facebook got 6x more clicks than factua... by helen___keller on Friday September 03, 2021 @09:35AM (#28404006)
Maybe we should be using different words when talking about this subject to clarify, but in my head there's a big difference between CNN being untrustworthy because it's got an awful, inconsistent, and partisan editorial slant, versus say GNews or the Bannon Pandemic War Room being untrustworthy because they literally push falsified and highly damaging information for months, like that the fake news vaccine is designed by the CCP and will result in infertility for the sake of the Great Reset genocide (real talking points).