News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by Enginerrrd on Monday August 30, 2021 @09:36AM (#28355504)
Let me just say that the Remarkable also runs linux.

Not only that, but I've been blown away by the ongoing results from the team at Remarkable. I only have the Remarkable 1 but they continue to ship updates for it, and these updates are often really substantive with sometimes profound new features. Their cloud service is free, no aggravating subscription stuff and even though they have the remarkable 2 now, they continue to kill it with the updates to improve my experience with the remarkable 1. They, as of right now, have my undying loyalty and appear to be a truly customer focused company. I'd love to buy their entire team a couple beers.

Don't get me wrong, I love pine64 too, but they're way more oriented to us hacker types than ordinary people and I don't want to have to hack together a functioning device with everything I own, though I think they're doong good work none-the-less.

Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by eloeffler on Monday August 30, 2021 @09:58AM (#28355711)
And they give root access to the device along with GPL compliance statements, allowing for a flourishing developer community that creates tons of useful programs that can run on the embedded device. See for example https://github.com/reHackable/awesome-reMarkable for a list.

There is also an opkg-based package manager and repo with many packages: https://toltec-dev.org/

Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by Buttons840 on Monday August 30, 2021 @10:08AM (#28355794)
I'm scared by that link warning about how easy it is to brick your device. Should I be?
Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by eloeffler on Monday August 30, 2021 @11:03AM (#28356314)
Especially: Write down your root password and DO NOT factory reset the device if you want to go back to the original state.

If you follow these steps and you know a bit about linux you'll be fine.

Factory reset on the rM2 will mess with the community framebuffer service and reset your root password, effectively locking you out unless you go the fiddly way over the external port.

The rM1 is very resilient as you can directly access the internal storage without special tools.

Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by Buttons840 on Monday August 30, 2021 @11:40AM (#28356763)
So they provide a factory reset feature, and what that feature does is brick your device? (Or nearly so.)

Why do you say connecting over the external port is "finicky"?

Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by kayodelycaon on Monday August 30, 2021 @12:10PM (#28357153)
The factory reset feature clears personal data off the device and resets the root password. So... it's not a factory reset.
Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by eloeffler on Monday August 30, 2021 @12:12PM (#28357182)
I thought this means something else :D I wanted to say "fiddly", correcting it...
Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by p_l on Monday August 30, 2021 @10:30AM (#28356027)
Remarkable 1 is recoverable without many tricks.

Remarkable 2 requires a bit of parts and possibly soldering (but not required, just might make things easier if you don't have pogo pins with handles available).

Both are fully recoverable unless you do something really impressive.

Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by lovelyviking on Monday August 30, 2021 @11:11AM (#28356376)
>Both are fully recoverable unless you do something really impressive.

really impressive like what?

Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by p_l on Monday August 30, 2021 @02:07PM (#28358856)
Physically breaking the hardware through software, for example. I believe there's some fun possible in most embedded designs like the one used in RM1/RM2. Like manipulating power management circuitry, or maybe forcing overheat with disabled throttling, and the like.
Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by codezero on Monday August 30, 2021 @11:54AM (#28356929)
I rooted my 2 and not my 1 without knowing the risk! Turned out fine but I wasn’t too adventurous.
Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by cies on Monday August 30, 2021 @10:46AM (#28356181)
If this e-ink device is usable as a secondary display for my laptop, I'm in.

I'd love to get work done in sunny locations, like gardens. But these LCD screens make me squint. e-ink would be THE solution to this, but the e-ink displays are too expensive, to well supported and not very big.

Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by eloeffler on Monday August 30, 2021 @11:05AM (#28356325)
There is a community VNC client for it. If you're on Windows you'll need a HDMI dummy plug to simulate a second screen with the proper dimensions.

But yes, it works as an external screen. Check out VNSee for this https://github.com/matteodelabre/vnsee

Maybe the rM1 might be the best choice for this. I'm not sure...

Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by sharikone on Monday August 30, 2021 @05:31PM (#28361105)
In the rM1 you just write to a framebuffer device in /dev/fb0 to write on the screen. It's so easy you could probably write an application that does that, compile it for ARM, load it via scp and run it. All in 15 minutes even if you know nothing about the Remarkable itself.

The rM2 is a lot trickier. A full reverse engineering of the drawing routines is still unfinished, as far as I know. So you either manipulate the memory of their closed source application or reuse big binary chunks of it. There are of course abstraction layers built over that by the community but as of today I believe it's much less refreshing than the rM1.

The rM1 used the chip electrophoretic display controller directly , while the rM2 has a software controller which is closed source. Hence much of the complications

Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by AshamedCaptain on Monday August 30, 2021 @10:22AM (#28355953)
Do note that Remarkable is not as rosy as it looks like. Due to the fact that most of the builtin software is proprietary, actually modifying it to run anything other than the stock features requires binary monkey patching the main executable. It's as fragile as it sounds.

If they were to add a simple plugin system, that would take them 0 effort with Qml, it would be significantly better.

Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by eloeffler on Monday August 30, 2021 @11:10AM (#28356372)
Actually, it's better than you describe it, I think. Most components are FOSS. The default GUI and the framebuffer driver are proprietary closed source. However, the framebuffer driver has been extracted from the GUI service by github user ddvk and faciliates the development of independent interfaces (look for "launchers") that can launch further independent programs, e.g. harmony https://rmkit.dev/apps/harmony

There is also an opkg-based package manager and repo with many packages: https://toltec-dev.org/

The binary patching that you talk about is only one mod that can be installed to improve the functionality of the original GUI. It is true that it would be awesome if that had plugin support, as you stated, though.

Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by AshamedCaptain on Monday August 30, 2021 @11:47AM (#28356855)
> However, the framebuffer driver has been extracted from the GUI service

Extracted? Last time I look at it, they were inserting a patch in the main (and only) binary of the proprietary GUI via LD_PRELOAD, and then all other programs which wanted to draw _anything_ to the screen would basically _directly alter the memory_ of the proprietary GUI binary in order to modify its internal framebuffer. You have to do that whether you want to integrate with the main GUI or not -- since you need this hack to draw anything to the screen.

Literally every other Remarkable update so far has killed all of this.

> Most components are FOSS.

The usual thing: most 3rd party components which they are forced to open anyway are FOSS. Anything that may even be remotely interesting is NOT FOSS. I do not understand why people try to claim this as a positive, cause it isn't.

Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by sharikone on Monday August 30, 2021 @05:46PM (#28361264)
I wouldn't look at the mouth of a gifted horse. Their closed source binary is not huge.

Also I don't worry about updates. Why would I connect my notebook to the Internet anyway? I just don't install them.

I guess it's a matter of time before fully open source display drivers are available and I can do my part too to make it happen.

When it happens I will have an ownable very nice, thin and responsible e-notebook. It will never be connected to the Internet and I will patch it myself if I will happen to want a new feature.

Maybe you are right and it could be more FOSS than it is, but in a world where you don't really own anything valuable anymore I am so elated about the hackability of this device that I'll take a bit of tinkering with binary files.

Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by eloeffler on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @03:06AM (#28364786)
You can disable automatic updates, too. This way you can still connect.
Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by eloeffler on Monday August 30, 2021 @12:10PM (#28357161)
xochitl (the rM GUI) doesn't need to be run when other GUI programs are running. I don't fully understand the way this works but for anyone interested, here is the link for the framebuffer workaround: https://github.com/ddvk/remarkable2-framebuffer

On rM1 it was possible to write to the framebuffer directly, on rM2 it is not exposed as a device file directly.

Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by AshamedCaptain on Monday August 30, 2021 @02:30PM (#28359167)
The link you are sharing explicitly mentions you need xochitl running with the LD_PRELOAD hack, which is what becomes "the framebuffer server". In fact,

> To do their job, both the client and the server need to know the address at which a number of functions reside in the Xochitl binary. These addresses change from one release to the next.

This is absurdly fragile. In fact, it's even worse than I was guessing :/.

Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by eloeffler on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @03:04AM (#28364778)
Huh, I really had the wrong idea... Thanks.

I'm still very happy with the device but I'll keep that in mind when recommending it to others.

Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by salamandersauce on Monday August 30, 2021 @09:58AM (#28355718)
Kobo and Kindle both run Linux too. Kobo still updates every single model they've released except for the first two non-touch models and the 5" mini stretching back a decade. And Amazon is pretty good with updates too.

Kobo is pretty similarly hackable to the Remarkables but they are not nearly as open and free as the Pine stuff. I take a look at what remarkable has updated, and they just still haven't gotten ePub support anywhere close to where it should be. I belive it technically converts ePubs to PDF and displays that?? With large books taking minutes to change font sizes. That to me has completely turned me off their devices. Writing may be better but reading is IMO equally important for devices like these.

Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by someperson on Monday August 30, 2021 @10:09AM (#28355799)
> Kobo still updates every single model they've released except for the first two non-touch models and the 5" mini stretching back a decade.

Wow you're right (at least until this year?): https://wiki.mobileread.com/wiki/Kobo_Firmware_Releases

The Mk3 is the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kobo_Touch released 10 years ago.

Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by bkallus on Monday August 30, 2021 @10:32AM (#28356043)
I have an original Kobo WiFi (no touch) and the internal storage is a microSD card. You can literally just take it apart, remove the SD and stick new programs on it, start an SSH server, etc. I also have the non-WiFi version, and it has eMMC soldered on, so it's more of a pain. There's an exposed UART on the board though, so getting a shell is pretty easy there too.
Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by dreamer7 on Monday August 30, 2021 @11:21AM (#28356499)
I'm not sure I agree about Amazon being good with updates. They removed the ability to change orientation for no good reason!
Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by Youden on Monday August 30, 2021 @10:06AM (#28355776)
I like the idea of Remarkable but the thing that bothers me a lot is that it doesn't have a backlight. I'd really like to use it to read at night and no backlight kinda kills that.

Do you not use it at night or do you use some other solution for nighttime lighting (like bright ceiling lights)?

Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by horsawlarway on Monday August 30, 2021 @10:24AM (#28355968)
I have both the Kindle Oasis and a Remarkable 2.

If the use case is just reading at night, a Kindle with a backlight is probably a better bet.

That said - I like the Remarkable a lot more, and tend to carry it with me more. The kindle has essentially just become my "vacation" reading device since I stopped taking the train for work.

It definitely doesn't need bright lights to read (well, depending on your eyesight). If I want to read/write before bed, I'll keep my side table light on at 25%, and it works fine. If my wife is still watching a show, the tv alone is bright enough I can generally read/write fine.

Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by marcus_holmes on Monday August 30, 2021 @11:05AM (#28356324)
Love my Remarkable 2, it's replaced the endless amount of paper pads I used to have - I even sketch on it, which is taking some adjusting to (it ends up being closer to etching than pencil sketching).

But it hasn't replaced my e-reader. I read myself to sleep every night, and 80% of mornings wake up with the e-reader lying on the pillow next to me. If I tried that with the Remarkable I'd smack myself in the face every night. I have a hand-size e-reader (Tolino, a German brand) with a backlight, which I use in dark mode so less light to keep the gf awake. Works great.

I could see myself reading a technical manual on the Remarkable, but I'd still need the e-reader. Two different use cases.

Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by aidenn0 on Monday August 30, 2021 @11:59AM (#28356999)
I would also already own a remarkable-2 if it had a builtin light. I do about 20% of my reading with the lights off, and while I can (and do) use a booklight, there's considerable light-spillage compared to most builtin lights and the lights I've tried all either have arms so short as to be hard to position right, or arms so long that the weight of the light overcomes the elasticity of the arm.
Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by mbreese on Monday August 30, 2021 @10:09AM (#28355796)
What about a normal book light that you’d use with a traditional book? I find that even the Kindle light can be uncomfortable when in complete darkness, so I try to always keep a little bit of ambient light, which is usually enough to read by.
Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by AlanYx on Monday August 30, 2021 @10:39AM (#28356120)
I use a book light with my Remarkable. It works well, but I'd still prefer an integrated frontlight, as long as it didn't affect the writing experience.
Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by mbreese on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @03:28PM (#28372389)
Ah yes... that's probably why we won't see one then. The frontlight adds some space between the surface and the panel. That would probably be distracting for writing.
Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by zaphar on Monday August 30, 2021 @09:58AM (#28355713)
My Remarkable 2 is the best note taking, writing, sketching device I've ever owned. I appreciate the competition in the space and hope it drives more innovation but I don't want to hack on my Remarkable tablet. I just want to write and sketch on it for the moment.
Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by marcus_holmes on Monday August 30, 2021 @11:12AM (#28356395)
Totally agree. But I've got to the point where I'd like to start hacking on mine.

I have a folder full of startup ideas. I really want a Lean Canvas page template to go with that (and be able to mix page types in a single notebook would be cool, but I'm not sure that's possible yet).

I want to create a "meeting notes" type of notebook, that automatically adds today's date, and lives in a "meeting notes" folder organised by date.

I'd love to be able to sketch in white on a black background.

I keep meaning to get around to learning how to do this stuff... but life has been getting in the way. Doesn't mean I don't want to ;)

Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by kayodelycaon on Monday August 30, 2021 @12:15PM (#28357227)
Not sure if this is stock or provided by https://github.com/ddvk/remarkable-hacks but I can change the template per page.
Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by zaphar on Monday August 30, 2021 @02:14PM (#28358973)
That is stock. It's in the page menu and I don't have any hacks installed.
Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by marcus_holmes on Monday August 30, 2021 @05:07PM (#28360881)
cool :) thanks :)
Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by ocdtrekkie on Monday August 30, 2021 @10:58AM (#28356273)
I got my wife a Remarkable 2, and for as many Pine devices I own, I think she'd make fun of me for struggling with a PineNote. I'm glad there's more open source development going on in the space though.
Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by marvindanig on Monday August 30, 2021 @10:14AM (#28355855)
How is the web browser experience on the ReMarkable? It kinda sucks on the Kindle and forces me to consider an iPad to make up for open access.
Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by horsawlarway on Monday August 30, 2021 @10:32AM (#28356041)
I would say if you want a web browser, it's probably not the right device for your use case.

I have a Remarkable 2, and I really enjoy it, but it's more like an upgraded replacement for the legal pad/notebook I would carry around at work.

It does notes and sketches really well. But there's no browser by default on the device. I appreciate it, since it keeps me focused on what I'm doing without distractions (like HN :D ).

Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by ploek on Monday August 30, 2021 @10:28AM (#28356009)
There is no web browser on the ReMarkable. On purpose. Their mentality is that the device should be a distraction-free note-taking, idea-sketching tool.

source: https://remarkable.com/blog/inside-remarkable-2-chapter-2-th...

Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by e12e on Monday August 30, 2021 @11:48AM (#28356856)
There's no web browser, but in theory there's a "send to remarkable" plug-in for other browsers (basically print to pdf;sync to remarkable). It's not really usable, for various reasons imnho.
Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by pxhb on Monday August 30, 2021 @10:26AM (#28355986)
No web browser on the remarkable (at least stock). Stock it is literally just a note taking device, which I personally find appealing.
Re:The PineNote is an e-ink notebook that runs Linux by jethro_tell on Monday August 30, 2021 @10:32AM (#28356040)
I also like the large sized reader. It's not something I need anyone but when you find a technical manual or text book as a pdf only the remarkable is a pretty good reader. I do like the Kobo for most of my reading but it's nice not for the oddly shaped big stuff.