News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple explicitly asks employees to merge their personal a... by hanniabu on Thursday August 19, 2021 @11:40PM (#28242295)
> I’m slowly getting the impression that either there’s been a policy change at Apple in terms of customer privacy

More likely that they never were for privacy and injury used it as a marketing ploy, putting on the mirage of being pro-privacy.

Re:Apple explicitly asks employees to merge their personal a... by azinman2 on Friday August 20, 2021 @01:31AM (#28242961)
I work for Apple. It’s not just marketing. It’s in every discussion in every feature. Even the current CSAM implementation is actually all about privacy if you read the details on how it’s implemented.

The real question and concern is what happens once laws start getting passed that run counter to this. And that then won’t be just Apple’s problem at that point.

Re:Apple explicitly asks employees to merge their personal a... by brokenmachine on Friday August 20, 2021 @01:41AM (#28243024)
>Even the current CSAM implementation is actually all about privacy if you read the details on how it’s implemented.

Lol, no.

Re:Apple explicitly asks employees to merge their personal a... by azinman2 on Friday August 20, 2021 @01:45AM (#28243040)
Read this: https://www.apple.com/child-safety/pdf/CSAM_Detection_Techni...

and tell me what's not about privacy with this? The alternative is upload everything unencrypted to providers who then scan there, which is how everything else works.

Re:Apple explicitly asks employees to merge their personal a... by d110af5ccf on Friday August 20, 2021 @02:55AM (#28243379)
> The alternative is upload everything unencrypted to providers who then scan there

That's exactly how it should be. If a service provider wants to scan unencrypted documents for legal or PR reasons that's completely understandable. If instead they want to provide true E2EE and risk ending up in court with the regulators, that's also fine.

E2EE with black box on device scanning, however, is an absolutely terrible idea. It misleads regular people who almost certainly won't understand what's really going on. It's easily subverted by various governments as a condition of doing business. It blurs the line regarding ownership and unlawful search, thereby eroding future expectations of civil rights.

Apple should just be honest about the fact that they aren't comfortable providing a full E2EE solution for various regulatory or political reasons.

Re:Apple explicitly asks employees to merge their personal a... by brokenmachine on Friday August 20, 2021 @05:44AM (#28244340)
There's no proper encryption though. In my mind, it's just like having everything unencrypted but using TLS to get it to Apple central. Apple employees can still access it.

This is just ever so slightly better than the worst of everything.

No real encryption, on-device scanning and scanning on Apple servers. "For privacy", WTF!!

Re:Apple explicitly asks employees to merge their personal a... by d110af5ccf on Friday August 20, 2021 @05:57AM (#28244406)
No client side encryption yet.

I can't see any reason to implement a scanner in this way other than at least having E2EE as a possibility under consideration. They knew there was the possibility for PR backlash. Doing it on device also adds significant complexity. Meanwhile scanning on upload is a very common and well accepted (both legally and socially) practice.

On its own the current approach is all downsides and no upsides so there has to be something else going on here. Wanting to market iCloud as providing full E2EE is obvious and fits perfectly.

Re:Apple explicitly asks employees to merge their personal a... by brokenmachine on Friday August 20, 2021 @10:50AM (#28246693)
Nitpick: What I think you're talking about is not E2E because there is no recipient (ie in this scenario Apple is not able to decrypt your data). It's just bog-standard encryption so your files are private or only shared with people you choose.

We can only recognize the current situation, not a hypothetical future one.

I for one think it is unlikely that Apple will willingly lock themselves out of that mountain of intoxicating user data.

I believe their privacy stance is just marketing. There's countless examples of them not caring about real security issues, eg https://sneak.berlin/20201112/your-computer-isnt-yours/

Even if they do ever implement true encryption - not E2E between customer and Apple - personally I wouldn't trust it because of the unauditable on-device scanning/snitching.

Re:Apple explicitly asks employees to merge their personal a... by brokenmachine on Friday August 20, 2021 @02:48AM (#28243344)
This is a ridiculous redefinition of the word, "privacy".

I don't need to read your marketing manual when there's no getting around the fact you are normalizing on-device scanning on personal devices and automated secret reporting to the authorities, which means iphones have now become adversarial.

Used to be that there was a clear delineation between a customer's device and a cloud server. Not anymore with Apple "privacy".

At least with Google I know that if I don't upload the photos to them, they're not scanning my device.

Just as a point of fact, there is zero point to encryption if Apple is able to access everything on icloud, which they can, because Apple doesn't allow you to do backups using a key that only you know.

That's just another one of Apple's penny-pinching scams so they can upsell customers on extra icloud space for backups which are also "encrypted", yet Apple can read everything.

Real privacy would mean real encryption, but then Apple couldn't do their upselling scam and also couldn't secretly scan all your personal stuff.

Re:Apple explicitly asks employees to merge their personal a... by qot on Friday August 20, 2021 @03:12AM (#28243481)
You are missing the forest for the trees. This entire feature is a privacy violation.

> The alternative is upload everything unencrypted to providers who then scan there

No, the alternative is to not do any scanning.

Re:Apple explicitly asks employees to merge their personal a... by encryptluks2 on Thursday August 19, 2021 @11:59PM (#28242417)
100% this. If you had said this a month ago you'd get viciously downvoted. People are finally waking up though.