Re:YouTube suspends filmmaker Oliver Ressler’s account witho...
by warning26 on Tuesday August 10, 2021 @01:15PM
(#28131499)
Exactly -- I'm not sure why people seem convinced that YouTube should be legally compelled to provide free video hosting for anyone. Surely HN people should be aware how much that costs.
If one feels that YouTube is abusing a monopoly position, then one should be in favor of breaking up YouTube. Period.
Re:YouTube suspends filmmaker Oliver Ressler’s account witho...
by AbrahamParangi on Tuesday August 10, 2021 @01:24PM
(#28131628)
I think in general people believe that freedom of association in business is a much more limited right than the other freedoms enshrined in the first amendment- particularly regarding not associating with people that you find disagreeable.
You cannot deny business to someone because of their race or ethnicity, and generally people think this is a good thing.
Legal theories aside, I think people feel that it is unjust when a monopoly or near-monopoly business acts in a manner discriminatory to one group or another.
Re:YouTube suspends filmmaker Oliver Ressler’s account witho...
by falcolas on Tuesday August 10, 2021 @01:18PM
(#28131547)
The government has more than just 'breaking up a company' in their toolbelt for handling companies with dominant marketshares. It's not a black and white situation.
Re:YouTube suspends filmmaker Oliver Ressler’s account witho...
by MikeUt on Tuesday August 10, 2021 @01:25PM
(#28131640)
People can complain about something, without believing it is illegal, and without already having a legislative or other solution for the problem ready.
If nothing else, it informs others about Youtube censorship - even the most radical libertarians are pro-informed consumers.
Re:YouTube suspends filmmaker Oliver Ressler’s account witho...
by blunte on Tuesday August 10, 2021 @01:15PM
(#28131490)
It may be practical fact, but its is not any sort of wisdom. They claim to have rules and are expected to follow their own rules.
But that's a bit like the legal system. A government or civil case against you may be completely unwarranted, but it likely will cost you time and resources (and connections to powerful people) to fight.
Re:YouTube suspends filmmaker Oliver Ressler’s account witho...
by shadilay on Tuesday August 10, 2021 @01:27PM
(#28131666)
Nowadays we are digital serfs living off the properties owned by megacorporations. They have made it increasingly difficult to live outside their ecosystem and run your own email server (your messages will end up in spam) or host your own website (NAT/Cloudflare DDoS etc).
Re:YouTube suspends filmmaker Oliver Ressler’s account witho...
by blunte on Tuesday August 10, 2021 @01:12PM
(#28131450)
This topic really needs a good documentary. It should scare the hell out of people.
If you build up a library of your creations, your email, your communications, whatever, and the masters can just flip a switch and make it all unavailable to you (and the rest of the world), then you are really putting yourself at risk by using those services.
Often it seems "AI" just makes mistakes. Whether that's the case or not, the dispute "resolution" phase is almost universally a joke - a preprogrammed NO response.
This is not reasonable, and it ultimately should fall under consumer protection or other standards.
Re:YouTube suspends filmmaker Oliver Ressler’s account witho...
by talal7860 on Tuesday August 10, 2021 @01:19PM
(#28131551)
One more reason not to use a single email address for multiple services. Violation of terms of services in one of them can be catastrophic, like in the article, the author's google account gets deleted with just warning.
Inhuman-ops
Governments tend to put additional restrictions on the biggest players, and perhaps YouTube should be the subject of such a restriction.
If one feels that YouTube is abusing a monopoly position, then one should be in favor of breaking up YouTube. Period.
You cannot deny business to someone because of their race or ethnicity, and generally people think this is a good thing.
Legal theories aside, I think people feel that it is unjust when a monopoly or near-monopoly business acts in a manner discriminatory to one group or another.
If nothing else, it informs others about Youtube censorship - even the most radical libertarians are pro-informed consumers.
But that's a bit like the legal system. A government or civil case against you may be completely unwarranted, but it likely will cost you time and resources (and connections to powerful people) to fight.
Do I think that YouTube should be forced to allow content on their platform that they don't want? No.
Do I think the monopoly of cloud providers (AWS, GCP, etc) should be allowed to censor content they don't want? No.
The solution here is finding a hosting provider to host your own content. IPFS is a great alternative, and LBRY has proven to be pretty open-minded.
If you build up a library of your creations, your email, your communications, whatever, and the masters can just flip a switch and make it all unavailable to you (and the rest of the world), then you are really putting yourself at risk by using those services.
Often it seems "AI" just makes mistakes. Whether that's the case or not, the dispute "resolution" phase is almost universally a joke - a preprogrammed NO response.
This is not reasonable, and it ultimately should fall under consumer protection or other standards.