News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mixed views on new DNS top level domains by robert_tweed on Saturday August 07, 2021 @10:42AM (#28098924)
I registered my own name under one of the new gTLDs because it was $10 for a year and I thought, "why not?". I didn't do anything with it, partly because I remained sceptical of the new gTLDs so didn't want to switch anything critical over to it, like my email address.

That is probably just as well, because a year later, it had been reclassified as a "premium" name. The renewal fee was over $400,000.

The fact that the owners of gTLDs can set pricing arbitrarily is the biggest problem in all this. A given domain name usually has no intrinsic value. What gives it value is the effort someone puts into marketing it.

With the new gTLDs, the domain operators are free to offer useful names that aren't trademarks, but are unavailable as .com or similar. Then should anyone build a successful business on that name, they are free to seek arbitrarily high rents.

There is no sense in which you can buy a domain name outright. Nor do the new gTLDs have any form of rent control. That is a fundamental problem with the system as it stands.

Re:Mixed views on new DNS top level domains by throw0101a on Saturday August 07, 2021 @12:52PM (#28099997)
> That is probably just as well, because a year later, it had been reclassified as a "premium" name. The renewal fee was over $400,000.

At that price it may be cheaper to simply create your own TLD.

Re:Mixed views on new DNS top level domains by moonchild on Saturday August 07, 2021 @09:49PM (#28103565)
Indeed; registration fees are about $100k, and infrastructure costs a similar amount.
Re:Mixed views on new DNS top level domains by judge2020 on Saturday August 07, 2021 @10:35PM (#28103790)
Specifically this link shows $185,000 and $6,250 per calendar quarter: https://newgtlds.icann.org/en/applicants/global-support/faqs...

For infrastructure, I can imagine this being a case a single colocated server rack would work great, especially if you don't expect your TLD to be super popular among other people (SaaS likely wouldn't be suitable due to the high industry bandwidth costs).

Re:Mixed views on new DNS top level domains by sneak on Sunday August 08, 2021 @03:55AM (#28104972)
DNS doesn't use a lot of bandwidth, and has built-in caching.
Re:Mixed views on new DNS top level domains by throw0101a on Sunday August 08, 2021 @12:41PM (#28108016)
The bandwidth usage is low unless you're DDoSed.

It may be prudent to have some of your own distributed servers act as hidden masters, and then use a DNS anycast service for the publicly listed servers.

Re:Mixed views on new DNS top level domains by ziml77 on Saturday August 07, 2021 @11:09AM (#28099120)
I was looking at gTLDs when getting my own domain. I think I got lucky with the timing because all the desirable ones had already classified the name I wanted as being premium. Around the same price you're saying your renewal would have been. I ended up going with firstnamelastname.net.

I don't thing it's a good idea for anyone to use a gTLD for anything serious. Even without the prices being uncapped, there's no guarantee that a gTLD will stick around. Would be crappy to lose a domain because the company who owns the gTLD went out of business or just didn't want to deal with handling domains anymore.

Re:Mixed views on new DNS top level domains by CydeWeys on Saturday August 07, 2021 @11:25AM (#28099256)
> Even without the prices being uncapped, there's no guarantee that a gTLD will stick around.

Actually, there is a guarantee that a gTLD will stick around. ICANN correctly determined that this would be ruinous to the health of the Internet as a whole if entire TLD's worth of domains could simply disappear, hence they set up procedures to guard against it, including a required daily data escrow deposit from all TLD operators that can be used to spin up the TLD by another registry operator if the worst catastrophe were to happen (which, it should be pointed out, has never happened). For more info see:

https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/ebero-2013-04-02-en https://newgtlds.icann.org/en/applicants/data-escrow

The only TLDs that have ever ceased operation entirely, like .xperia in the linked articles, are closed brand TLDs that were never used for anything, were never available for external registration, and that the company in question (Sony here) simply got tired of paying the annual fees on given their lack of use of it. These TLD discontinuations don't threaten anything.

Re:Mixed views on new DNS top level domains by ziml77 on Saturday August 07, 2021 @11:48AM (#28099483)
That's good to know! Still worried about the prices getting out of control if someone thinks you have a valuable name, but at least it's not too easy to nuke an entire TLD.
Re:Mixed views on new DNS top level domains by RegnisGnaw on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:57AM (#28104757)
Actually that’s not true. In 2017 .wed (with real customers) gTLD ceased operation and was taken over by ICANN under the EBERO program. http://domainincite.com/22372-as-wed-goes-ebero-did-the-firs...
Re:Mixed views on new DNS top level domains by CydeWeys on Sunday August 08, 2021 @09:50AM (#28106682)
Ah interesting, I'd forgotten about that. A grand total of 40 domains were transferred through the EBERO process (note: they didn't experience interruption).

I do like this quote from the article:

> In this case, ICANN said that Atgron had failed to provide Whois services as required by contract. The threshold for Whois triggering EBERO is 24 hours downtime over a week.

> However, the situation looks to me a lot more like a business failure than a technical failure.

> Multiple sources with knowledge of the transition tell me that the Whois was turned off deliberately, purely to provide a triggering event for the EBERO failover system, after Atgron’s back-end contract with CoCCA expired.

> The logic was that turning off Whois would be far less disruptive for registrants and internet users than losing DNS resolution, DNSSEC, data escrow or EPP.

It sounds like they creatively used EBERO as the most expedient method to be able to cease hosting .wed, which they had been unprofitable to them owing to the mere 40 total registrations that they had. And they did so in a way that would minimally disrupt their users.

Overall, seeing that EBERO was successfully used strengthens my confidence in the overall safety of new gTLDs. There's way too many of them out there, and they're way too important now as a whole, for anyone to simply just let them vanish out from underneath their users.

Re:Mixed views on new DNS top level domains by oauea on Saturday August 07, 2021 @12:22PM (#28099759)
Oh good, it will remain available at the low, low price of half a million per year. That soothes my worries entirely.
Re:Mixed views on new DNS top level domains by CydeWeys on Saturday August 07, 2021 @01:20PM (#28100201)
You're painting a very broad brush with that one extreme outlier. Most registries don't operate like that; stay away from the few that do.
Re:Mixed views on new DNS top level domains by lbotos on Saturday August 07, 2021 @11:20PM (#28103961)
How does one know if they are picking a registry that doesn't operate like that?

I have a benign gTLD that went from $10 -> $30 next year... I shudder to think what it will be in 5.

EDIT: Also I just looked, and most are doing a thing were the y will let you get the first year for $12 or so, and then every year after is $25+.

Re:Mixed views on new DNS top level domains by CydeWeys on Saturday August 07, 2021 @11:51PM (#28104074)
I'm still waiting on them to say which TLD this was. The big operators don't randomly make drastic price changes like that. This bizarre incident is getting outsized attention that I don't think it merits. Frankly, a premium price of hundreds of thousands per year sounds like an out-and-out mistake somewhere; no one is paying that, certainly not on a random first name on a random nTLD. That's simply not a successful business strategy; you'd lose all your registrations by doing it.

Which TLD went from $10 to $30/yr? There's a lot of missing info in these comments!

On the other hand, first year discounting is (as you're seeing) quite common. So just treat the 2nd year price as the actual price for the purpose of deciding whether you're willing to pay it. The key difference here is that you know the price schedule up front.

Re:Mixed views on new DNS top level domains by josephcsible on Saturday August 07, 2021 @11:17PM (#28103947)
Isn't the problem that there's nothing preventing all of the registries of new gTLDs from suddenly starting to operate like that tomorrow?
Re:Mixed views on new DNS top level domains by ryan29 on Saturday August 07, 2021 @06:58PM (#28102628)
Which TLD was it? I’ve been trying to find an example of a domain being reclassified as premium while registered for almost two years. Are you sure you didn’t let it expire?

That violates the registry agreement AFAIK. They’re not allowed to arbitrarily change the price for a registered domain. Can you give more detail?

Re:Mixed views on new DNS top level domains by iomcr on Saturday August 07, 2021 @11:10PM (#28103926)
My first thought, while I don't know the exact rights of the parties involved, they should have filed a complaint with ICANN regardless.
Re:Mixed views on new DNS top level domains by CydeWeys on Saturday August 07, 2021 @01:21PM (#28100207)
What was the TLD with the huge price hike?
Re:Mixed views on new DNS top level domains by billpg on Saturday August 07, 2021 @09:15PM (#28103365)
Which TLD is that? Because I never want to use that domain and I'm thinking about hacking my DNS to fake-NXDOMAIN it entirely.
Re:Mixed views on new DNS top level domains by iomcr on Saturday August 07, 2021 @10:58AM (#28099035)
Was it {firstname}{lastname}.gtld or only one of those?
Re:Mixed views on new DNS top level domains by robert_tweed on Saturday August 07, 2021 @11:15AM (#28099163)
It was just my last name. So in a way surprising it wasn't classified as premium to begin with. But the fact such a concept exists at all, and the goalposts can move at any time, is the troubling part.
Re:Mixed views on new DNS top level domains by cpach on Saturday August 07, 2021 @03:53PM (#28101313)
Yikes. That’s very lousy behaviour of them.

Thanks for the warning.

Re:Mixed views on new DNS top level domains by devwastaken on Saturday August 07, 2021 @11:26AM (#28099262)
.coms are cheaper now anyways with cloudflare. 8 years pre-purchased for $60.