News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Home Depot is introducing power tools that won’t work if ... by throwaway0a5e on Monday August 02, 2021 @10:47AM (#28037193)
Tool truck these days are for suckers and everyone under 35-40 knows it (everyone over 40 knows it too but fewer of them will admit it). Back in the day the price differential was less and the quality differential was more and a lot of people are stuck int their ways. People will still pay for tool truck convenience when they need to though. Most people have a mix of everything from Harbor Freight to Craigslist/ebay/pawnshop to tool truck to Home Depot to Amazon. Nobody is really buying expensive tools on the regular because that's a lot of money. People will generally buy expensive power tools when they see a good sale or have a specific job to justify it.

The white collar internet loves to blindly fetishize "quality" tools but professionals are always trying to strike a balance because every buck spent on overhead is a buck you're not getting paid and having breadth of tools is often more important than quantity since having the right tool matters a lot more than having a nice tool and if you don't buy nice tools you can afford to have the right tool more often. For secondary "luxury" tools that just make a job faster (like a ratcheting box wrench) many people buy the cheap stuff whereas tools you only use when you really need them (like flare nut wrenches) tend to be higher quality.

Re:Home Depot is introducing power tools that won’t work if ... by sokoloff on Monday August 02, 2021 @11:01AM (#28037381)
I worked for years with Craftsman and Husky (and some Harbor Freight) hand tools. I later splurged for some secondhand SnapOn ratchets. They are unquestionably better and totally worth the difference in price to me. Similar story with Wera screwdrivers being noticeably better than Craftsman.

I still buy some Harbor Freight tools, especially if I only need it for a one-off job, but the higher-end tool names are often genuinely better, not just higher priced.

Re:Home Depot is introducing power tools that won’t work if ... by throwaway0a5e on Monday August 02, 2021 @11:13AM (#28037619)
You never get more than you pay for but you can always get less.

Whether a fancy ratchet is worth it depends a lot on how much you use your impact wrench. People tend to buy high end versions of the tools they use the most. There's plenty of professional roofers who have a $400 nail guns that weigh nothing and a couple clunky old HF framing guns on the truck. An electrician probably has a pawn shop or harbor freight hammer drill. The plumber probably has a nice hammer drill.

Re:Home Depot is introducing power tools that won’t work if ... by michaelt on Monday August 02, 2021 @01:52PM (#28040150)
Oh, expensive tools are very nice, certainly.

But if you're a young guy just getting started in a trade, and you can choose between a cheap socket set plus two dates with your girlfriend, or a premium socket set? 9/10 guys would choose the former.

Re:Home Depot is introducing power tools that won’t work if ... by kevin_thibedeau on Monday August 02, 2021 @11:56AM (#28038338)
Go watch the Project Farm torque wrench test where the Harbor Freight was more accurate than Snapoff.
Re:Home Depot is introducing power tools that won’t work if ... by rpcope1 on Monday August 02, 2021 @01:17PM (#28039573)
It's not totally inconceivable that there are Harbor Freight torque wrenches that are initially is on par with a CDI, Precision Instruments (both of whom Snap-On rebrand), or the Tech-Angle with regards to torque accuracy, but good luck ever getting a reputable metrology shop to touch a Harbor Freight torque wrench (or one that isn't American made, for that matter) when it inevitably comes time to do a re-calibration.
Re:Home Depot is introducing power tools that won’t work if ... by namibj on Monday August 02, 2021 @02:11PM (#28040465)
Not even like Knipex, Wera, or a similar German tool company?
Re:Home Depot is introducing power tools that won’t work if ... by rpcope1 on Monday August 02, 2021 @05:49PM (#28043128)
If it's manufactured in a western country, it's probably fine, I don't think you see too many like that here in the U.S.

It's usually either American, Taiwanese or Chinese, and a reputable shop like Angle Repair, for example, absolutely will not touch a Chinese torque wrench, and might only ever touch a Taiwanese torque wrench if it's a warrantied item on one of their supported brands, and probably only with some arm twisting on the part of the vendor they're doing warranty work for.

Re:Home Depot is introducing power tools that won’t work if ... by munificent on Monday August 02, 2021 @01:08PM (#28039429)
> The white collar internet loves to blindly fetishize "quality" tools

I don't know how much this is fetishizing versus simply having different priorities.

White collar tech people using tools are more likely to be doing so for hobby or recreation. They have spare money and their goal is a maximally enjoyable experience. With those priorities, it makes sense to buy better tools than you could justify economically.

Re:Home Depot is introducing power tools that won’t work if ... by alistairSH on Monday August 02, 2021 @02:05PM (#28040382)
The white collar internet loves to blindly fetishize "quality" tools but professionals are always trying to strike a balance because every buck spent on overhead is a buck you're not getting paid

That certainly wasn't my intention. My last roommate was an auto mechanic, then later a SnapOn dealer. He and the techs at the shops he serviced had massive rolling carts that cost $20k+ filled with another $30k in tools.

Certainly there were some cheaper tools in those carts, but as far as I could tell, they were mostly SnapOn or Mac.