Yes, it is just a peace of paper, except that it is also not once it becomes something to fight for and something that people believe in.
The US declared itself independent while British troops were in the country. It asserted rights against somebody else who didn't recognize them.
And that worked well enough that later people would refer to those assertions when debating freeing the slaves, and it was that which MLK was able to refer to in his speech.
I won't live long enough to see international human rights become a norm and neither will anybody else alive right now. But that doesn't mean that it isn't important that we start creating the norm now.
There was a time that all of these were just "nice ideas" in the US
- Same sex marriage
- Women having the right to vote
- People of color having the right to freedom
- And on the list goes
Most of these rights were not enforced, or even recognized until people fought either with pens or with weapons and progress was made.
I linked to the UN's framework for this in my parent comment, and while I agree that this is an incredibly hard problem to address globally, we shouldn't discount the value and power of "nice ideas".
> Whether or not China recognizes human rights doesn’t have any bearing on whether or not they are breaking them.
"Whether or not your country recognizes Sharia doesn't have any bearing on whether or not you are breaking it and you should be prosecuted for breaking it."
See how stupid your logic sounds when it is told from another perspective?
If you want to fight for something at least try to understand what makes you right and the other one wrong.
In US they are written into Constitution which is the law and which is source of these rights and basis for enforcing them.
"Human rights" are part of international law which is an agreement signed by multiple countries -- a form of law.
Not in the American tradition.
"We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights..."
"The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people."
https://www.fff.org/explore-freedom/article/rights-constitut...
Maybe our interest for humanism depleted when we had to get rid of fossil fuels because of climate change; at which point we noticed that humanism was only a pipe dream atop a fossil-dependent society, and coal had made our life much easier for a short period of time, until we fell into hard times again.
If there was a modern day nazi nation, that was genoiciding people en mass, that had nukes, such that invasion was impossible/mutually destructive, the answer would be the same.
Yes, sometimes it is difficult to stop all the bad things that evil people are doing. But that does not change the fact that those actions are still clearly evil and should be opposed where possible.
I'm not saying it's right. I'm saying its inevitable.
This sound like the "trial/judgement by combat", that the Gods will favor the guys with the "right" morals. My hope is that education/information in all camps would slowly but surely increase the global level of empathy,
That specific comment was made in the light of the statement 'even if you make a convincing argument for moral relativism'. At that point there is no longer a right or wrong, there is just "this exists" and "this does not exist".
The difference is that the other perspective is wrong, and ours is much closer to being correct (even if it still has problems).
So that is why your statement is silly.
And before you say it, no, I do not care about any of your arguments about cultural relativism.
I am perfectly happy, saying that people who, for example, want to kill gay people, have morals that are wrong, and that our morals, which are that we shouldn't do that, are correct.
Are you able to do that?
When China says "You know what, China? No. We will not break our own agreement. How could you even suggest that? Hong Kong is sovereign" (as the United States recently did in McGirt v. Oklahoma), then we can talk about whataboutism. Until then, that kind of argument is utterly unconvincing.
Always disappointing to see such vitriolic rebuttals to the mere idea of considering a Chinese perspective.
Whether or not China recognizes human rights doesn’t have any bearing on whether or not they are breaking them.
The international community recognizes human rights at least on some level, and it’s not particularly useful to use China’s perspective as a lens here any more than it would be useful to judge other atrocities throughout history through the eyes of the perpetrators.
Edit: Adding [0] for consideration as some responses seem unaware.
- [0] https://www.un.org/en/about-us/universal-declaration-of-huma...