News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by oars on Friday July 30, 2021 @03:33AM (#28005386)
170 cases in one day and the army is deployed to enforce lockdowns.

In my country we had over 10,000 cases yesterday and I will be going out for after work drinks at the end of this week to socialise.

Does Australia just overspend on its military budget or am I misunderstanding why Australia is going to these extremes?

Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by pacificmint on Friday July 30, 2021 @03:41AM (#28005455)
> am I misunderstanding why Australia is going to these extremes?

Australia had 923 COVID deaths total, for a population of 25 million. That’s 36 cases per million.

For comparison, the US has 1,887 deaths per million. Most European states aren’t much better, or even worse, per capita.

Now, you can argue if these extremes are worth it, or not, but it seems clear that what they are doing is saving lives.

Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by rglullis on Friday July 30, 2021 @03:55AM (#28005568)
You are comparing an island with low-density population with huge continents, one of them with poorly enforced border control. The amount of confounding here makes it impossible to attribute Australia's success to its policies.
Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by Youden on Friday July 30, 2021 @04:22AM (#28005722)
The very topic of this thread is about how Australia is quarantining a _city_ from the rest of the country.

Australia quarantines internally, which is comparable, if not more difficult, than countries that close their international borders. Imagine if LA was quarantined from the rest of California. That's the closest analogy I can make to the subject of this thread.

And yes Australia is a large island but if you take the briefest glance at a population density map, you'll see that the vast majority of the population is concentrated in a few coastal regions and particularly around Sydney and Melbourne.

Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by rglullis on Friday July 30, 2021 @04:42AM (#28005825)
I'd say it is the other way around. Trying to quarantine a city / aim for zero cases only make sense because the larger area it's easy to shut itself out at the country level.

Lockdowns are not 100% effective, but just an attempt to slow down the transmission rate. Think of it as a type of defense-in-depth. Australia (and New Zealand's) true advantage is their natural isolation from the rest of the world and their ability to control/track who is coming into the country.

Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by Uberphallus on Friday July 30, 2021 @04:41AM (#28005824)
While population density in Australia is low, the population is very concentrated. Half of the population lives in only 3 cities (Melbourne, Sydney, Brisbane).

Arguably the US would have it easier to control, since half its population is in low density rural and suburban environments that significantly reduce social contact.

Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by bananapub on Friday July 30, 2021 @07:37AM (#28006846)
these sort of clueless comments come up in every single thread. approximately everyone in australia lives in six fairly dense cities.
Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by jbsimpson on Friday July 30, 2021 @04:39AM (#28005814)
40% of Australia's population lives in just 2 cities.
Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by rglullis on Friday July 30, 2021 @04:45AM (#28005847)
Still an island, and that alone is the source of confounding.
Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by glenngillen on Friday July 30, 2021 @07:12AM (#28006710)
So is the UK
Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by Aeolun on Friday July 30, 2021 @03:45AM (#28005492)
Saving lives maybe, but how many people have basically lost 2 years of their lives by now?
Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by 2muchcoffeeman on Friday July 30, 2021 @03:51AM (#28005544)
Up until June this year almost everything was back to normal. Even the economy was back on track. The government basically squandered a 12 month head start.
Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by easygenes on Friday July 30, 2021 @03:49AM (#28005527)
The lockdowns have been relatively short-lived and only in the city metros which were then or are currently experiencing outbreaks. So most people have only been in lock down for a few months, if at all.
Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by nmcveity on Friday July 30, 2021 @04:05AM (#28005626)
As a Melbourne resident I really want a citation for this. Maybe the whole thing has been a nightmare and I will wake up shortly, who knows?
Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by pjc50 on Friday July 30, 2021 @03:49AM (#28005529)
Australian lockdowns have been much more intermittent because of their effectiveness; there have been some periods of no restrictions.

(Would be good if someone had a calendar recording this)

Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by jackvalentine on Friday July 30, 2021 @03:49AM (#28005524)
It’s been a bit inconvenient but quite a stretch to say anyone “lost two years”. Life was basically back to normal in Australia until June. In my city we’ve had practically no restrictions for over a year.
Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by bananapub on Friday July 30, 2021 @07:38AM (#28006857)
why do people with no idea about what's happening bother to comment at all?

australia's use of a few lockdowns and draconian border resitrictions eliminated covid within the country and meant there's been little restrictions for anyone for most of the pandemic.

Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by Untit1ed on Friday July 30, 2021 @03:50AM (#28005532)
I think the big difference is that Australia has managed to have zero cases for most of the last 18 months, which has allowed it to go on pretty much as normal for much of that time.

Although 170 cases is a lot less than 10,000 when you view it as a pure number, from an economic and lifestyle perspective the difference between 0 cases and 1 case is effectively more significant than 1 case and any number of cases greater than that - zero cases means that you can not only end restrictions, but also that people who normally wouldn't leave the house as long as there was any danger at all can go out and spend money without any fear of the virus.

So that's why there's so much emphasis on locking down even with only 170 cases - it's about trying to get back to zero ASAP.

There is an argument to be made for the fact that we'll have to live with covid eventually, but: 1. Vaccine numbers remain low 2. Given that people have seen lockdowns succeed in essentially ending covid before, and blame the government for both not locking down quickly enough in this outbreak and for the vaccination rollout, committing to living with covid now would be political suicide

Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by quicklime on Friday July 30, 2021 @03:51AM (#28005541)
There's a big difference between zero cases and one. When there are zero cases, you can (assuming a tight border and quarantine) act more-or-less as you did pre-pandemic. This is what most of Australia has been like, and what Sydney was like before this lockdown.

When you have a small number of cases, you still have to take precautions to keep the reproduction rate below 1.0.

It's up to each society to decide which strategy it wants to take. Australia has chosen eradication (zero cases) over suppression (a low and flat number of cases). The former lets you have periods of pre-pandemic behavior punctuated by short but extreme lockdowns, the latter means you get a constant set of restrictions until enough people are vaccinated.

Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by tomjen3 on Friday July 30, 2021 @06:55AM (#28006626)
Australia did well with this strategy initially, then returned to normal months before the rest of the world and with really low deaths to show of.

So they went ahead and used the strategy again, but this time (because delta is much worse) it didn't work, but they can't stop because the politicians who back this would take a hit if they admitted it. So they do the only thing they can, which is go at it, but harder.

This is basically the US Vietnam war situation.

Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by GuB-42 on Friday July 30, 2021 @03:44AM (#28005489)
Different strategies. Australia wants to completely eliminate covid from the country, it means going all out when even a single case is detected, and no restriction otherwise. It is a strategy well adapted to a large, low density island country.

Your country has decided to live with covid and adjust its response gradually.

Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by 2muchcoffeeman on Friday July 30, 2021 @05:33AM (#28006158)
I don’t think any reasonable person ever thought that was a viable long term strategy. We’ve detected all the variants of concern here. So eventually one was going to get past quarantine.
Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by pjc50 on Friday July 30, 2021 @03:48AM (#28005513)
Australia and NZ are going for "zero covid"; the suppression of general community transmission when it appears, rather than letting it become endemic or having runaway caseloads.

I've not seen this explicitly articulated but I think it may be linked to their long-standing onerous biosecurity rules for plants and animals, e.g. https://www.agriculture.gov.au/import/arrival/pests/plant_di... . If Australia can be free of certain plant diseases, why not of human diseases? The result is a low death toll and really heavy lockdowns.

Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by bo0tzz on Friday July 30, 2021 @03:39AM (#28005438)
Just because most countries are being exceedingly lax in their covid response, does not make Australia trying to actually contain it "extreme".
Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by ThomPete on Friday July 30, 2021 @03:41AM (#28005462)
If you have to deploy your military on your citizens you have in fact ventured way beyond into the extreme.
Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by waste_monk on Friday July 30, 2021 @03:59AM (#28005602)
They're being used to supplement the police force during a state of emergency. It's absolutely an appropriate use of the ADF.
Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by ThomPete on Friday July 30, 2021 @04:56AM (#28005911)
they are being used to enforce something you might think is appropriate, but something huge parts of the world including many Australians don’t think there is a moral basis for which is in part why they have to use the military. So you and i just have different moral compasses it seems. Enforcing your will by boots on the neck is a sign you are doing something wrong.
Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by nmcveity on Friday July 30, 2021 @05:12AM (#28006022)
Why would the rest of the world get a say in what the ADF is used for? isn't that precisely the point of a military?
Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by ThomPete on Friday July 30, 2021 @07:58AM (#28007003)
The rest of the world is entitled to opinions about what the ADF is being used for.

If you think this is the point of the military then we just have two very different opinions about what it says about a governments ability to manage the mess they made themselves.

The use of coercion is a sign you've failed regardless of the outcome.

Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by waste_monk on Friday July 30, 2021 @08:44AM (#28007334)
>If you think this is the point of the military then we just have two very different opinions about what it says about a governments ability to manage the mess they made themselves.

The ADF's stated mission is "to defend Australia and its national interests in order to advance Australia's security and prosperity.", and further goes on to state one of it's purposes is to "defend Australia and its national interests through the conduct of operations and provision of support for the Australian community and civilian authorities in accordance with Government direction."

Supporting state government and local police during a time of declared emergency is clearly within that scope.

Further, the ADF personnel deployed to assist with the lockdown will not be armed and will not have law enforcement powers - each ADF member will be paired with a regular police officer, and the police will be performing checks as they have for the last however many months [2]. This is simply to alleviate staffing and logistical issues, and is entirely ordinary. No one's getting a rifle squad kicking down their door because they didn't wear a mask.

>The use of coercion is a sign you've failed regardless of the outcome.

There is no coercion, and the whole point of the lockdowns are to prevent failure (that is, uncontrolled community transmission of COVID).

[1] https://www1.defence.gov.au/about/at-a-glance

[2] https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-07-30/adf-soldiers-to-arriv... - quote extract from NSW Police Commissioner Mick Fuller

Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by ThomPete on Friday July 30, 2021 @09:16AM (#28007602)
If you are so successful why did you have to use military to coerce people into doing it? That's not success thats failure. If we can't agree on that I guess we just have to agree to disagree.
Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by waste_monk on Friday July 30, 2021 @09:49AM (#28007927)
The failure belongs to the selfish individuals who are ignoring the lockdown because it offends their personal convenience. If everyone did the right thing by isolating, engaging with contact tracing and getting tested for possible exposures, etc. voluntarily then there would be no need for enforcement.

Given that we know people are ignoring lockdown, it would be a failing of the government NOT to do something about it given the grave consequences to both individuals and the security of the nation as a whole.

>why did you have to use military to coerce people

The ADF are not there in a military capacity. They are assisting regular law enforcement with a labor shortage due to the scale of the outbreak.

And again, it is not coercive for police officers to enforce the law, including public health directives. Unless you consider all law enforcement to be coercive, in which case I no longer have any time for your opinions and would encourage you to expatriate yourself to a country with a more "relaxed" legal system as soon as you can. I hear Mogadishu is nice this time of year.

Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by ThomPete on Friday July 30, 2021 @10:03AM (#28008072)
You are assuming that you are on the right side of this.

If you can't at least understand why people are opposed to the lockdown of course you think "boots on the neck" is a justified response.

Most people luckily do know the nuances and do understand the consequences of lockdown taken to the extreme of what we see in Australia.

That's why as I said we should probably just agree to disagree, I am not convinced about your justification for coercion no matter what semantic and rhetorical games you throw at it.

Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by Barrin92 on Friday July 30, 2021 @03:47AM (#28005500)
in many countries the military has a role to play during states of emergency or disasters or otherwise unusual situations like this, not every country is the US with its hyperbolic aversion to government or the state. The same bad takes keep happening every time an Anglosphere journalist sees the Gendarmerie on a French street.
Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by vladvasiliu on Friday July 30, 2021 @03:59AM (#28005601)
> The same bad takes keep happening every time an Anglosphere journalist sees the Gendarmerie on a French street.

I'm not familiar with the "bad takes" happening in the Anglosphere, but it should be noted that the French Gendarmerie is not exactly the same thing as "the military".

Until recently they were, technically, military, as in they were attached to the Defense Ministry. This has changed a few years ago, and are now attached to the Interior (Home) Ministry, like the "regular" Police. But this isn't what I'm arguing.

Even before the change, the Gendarmerie was intended to police the citizens, even though they would sometime take part in external operations. They are basically "the police outside of cities". This is in contrast to the "regular military" whose goal is to operate outside of France.

What is unusual is the "Operation Sentinelle", where actual soldiers are patrolling the streets of French cities in an effort to fight terrorism.

But note that pretty much every action by the actual military inside of France is seen as exceptional, and there really aren't that many.

For example, during the height of the Covid crisis last year, when hospitals were overflowing with the sick, the military transported some people from one hospital to another. This was considered fairly out of the ordinary, much more so than the national rail company preparing special TGVs (high-speed trains) for the same.

Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by ThomPete on Friday July 30, 2021 @03:53AM (#28005550)
Of course the military is used for other means. This time just isn't one of them and thus my point still stands.

When you have to use military to enforce your policies you've lost the plot it's really that simple.

Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by tomjen3 on Friday July 30, 2021 @06:58AM (#28006643)
To quote the dictionary:

extreme | ɪkˈstriːm, ɛkˈstriːm | adjective

1 reaching a high or the highest degree; very great: extreme cold.

• not usual; exceptional: in extreme cases the soldier may be discharged.

• very severe or serious: expulsion is an extreme sanction.

• (of a person or their opinions) far from moderate, especially politically: groups of his more extreme supporters rioted in front of parliament.

• denoting or relating to a sport performed in a hazardous environment and involving great risk: extreme sports like snowboarding.

2 [attributive] furthest from the centre or a given point: the extreme north-west of Scotland.

It fits every option, other than the extreme sports.

Edit: formatting.

Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by SpicyLemonZest on Friday July 30, 2021 @03:42AM (#28005472)
I would respectfully suggest that you've lost perspective if you don't see military deployments to keep people in their homes as extreme. Maybe it's justified - I'm certainly not gonna go around telling other countries how they ought to handle a pandemic - but this is not just your normal every day decision.
Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by rdiddly on Friday July 30, 2021 @01:53PM (#28010515)
They don't have their rifles with them. So arguably the words "force" and "army" don't even apply. (An 'army' generally has 'arms' or at least 'armor'.) It's just more bodies, more personnel. Cheaper than hiring a bunch of temps.
Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by jimmy2020 on Friday July 30, 2021 @03:35AM (#28005403)
Yes, they withdrew from Afghanistan there's money to be spent domestically or internationally.
Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by oars on Friday July 30, 2021 @03:38AM (#28005434)
Thank you, this makes more sense now.

It seems that it is normal for Australian soldiers to be deployed in Australia as they are not in Afghanistan. This article has just taken advantage of it for the headline and news content.

Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by switch007 on Friday July 30, 2021 @03:43AM (#28005474)
Normal for Australian soldiers to police the streets to keep people locked in their homes?

When has this happened before 2020?

Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by waste_monk on Friday July 30, 2021 @04:21AM (#28005715)
Not specifically to enforce a lockdown (and to clarify they are assisting police, it's not the ADF doing this by itself), but it's routine for the ADF to assist with disasters.

Surely you remember the ADF helping out with the bushfires not too long ago? There were the big news items like civilians trapped by bushfires being evacuated by the RAN off of Mallacoota beach, but the ADF also provided an incredible amount of assistance with logistics, engineering, and so on... it is deeply unfair to assume the worst of them just because it's enforcing a lockdown.

Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by mimentum on Friday July 30, 2021 @03:42AM (#28005468)
The deployment isn't a standard practice. Just something that has been enforced as of late.
Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by skhr0680 on Friday July 30, 2021 @03:41AM (#28005463)
There's a difference between being deployed sitting around at your base doing Really Important Stuff and

> Australian Defence Force soldiers will undergo training on the weekend before beginning unarmed patrols on Monday.

Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by easygenes on Friday July 30, 2021 @03:55AM (#28005572)
Parent is missing <sarcasm> tag, I think.
Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by jimmy2020 on Friday July 30, 2021 @03:58AM (#28005592)
Yes.
Re:Covid in Sydney: Military deployed to help enforce lockdown by __alias on Friday July 30, 2021 @03:46AM (#28005498)
Before the 170 daily case 'outbreak' we were able to go a fairly long time without any community transmissions. The point of military involvement is to try enforce an effective lockdown so people take lockdown seriously and we stop the spread as fast as possible while we finally start rolling out vaccines.